Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To encourage my friend to have a smear test?

91 replies

ThatIsVerySilly · 18/05/2015 15:05

She is 27 now and was called in for her first smear test at the standard age of 25, so two years ago now. However she refuses to have one.

I have told her than nobody likes smear tests, it doesn't hurt and that it's a couple of seconds of embarrasment but she still refuses to have one. She still refuses to have one and has told me that being scared it will hurt or that it will be embarrasing is not the reason why she won't have one but then won't tell me why she won't have one. But what other reason would a woman not want one if not for embarrassment or fear it will hurt?

She is now very upset as when she went to get a repeat prescription of the pill last week her GP told her that she will not be given any more unless she has a smear test. I think this is a good idea as they really are so important and save lives. My friend has told me her GP has nagged her about it in the past so I think they are doing this to push her to have one. Personally I think it's a good idea and sounds sensible.

My friend is still telling me that she doesn't want one though and is now feeling bullied into having one.

WIBU to tell her to just get it over and done with? I feel kind of bad for thinking this but I can't help but think just suck it up and stop being so irresponsible. Having a smear test is nowhere near as bad as having cancer or dying from it.

OP posts:
RevoltingPeasant · 18/05/2015 17:57

Why the fuckety fuck are people on here so obsessed with whether OTHER WOMEN have smear tests?

Want a smear? Great, have one. But back off other women.

There are many compelling arguments against having smears when no symptoms present. See RTB's excellent post above. Many women in this country get false positives, leading to further treatment which has its own risks.

The top causes of death for women in the UK in 2012 were Alzheimer's and coronary/ cardio diseases ONS link. Even if you look at cancer specifically, cervical cancer deaths don't feature in the top ten causes of death due to cancer.

It is obviously true that the cervical screening programme has been correlated with a decrease in mortality due to that cancer. But the evidence isn't unmixed and the test isn't uncontroversial. Margaret McCartney is a respected GP who argues against blanket smear tests because if the damage they do to women's health due to false positives.

IMO if we really cared about women's health we'd

  • resource midwifery and labour wards a hell of a lot better
  • put more money into researching effective contraception without unacceptable side effects, and pain relief for labour
  • prioritise preventative health checks focussing on diet and lifestyle, as the biggest contributors to what actually kills us

But that would be complex and expensive. Easier to just guilt women into smears Hmm

FatalCabbage · 18/05/2015 17:57

I don't go because I have PTSD from rape. Reading or being told that it doesn't hurt most women and can save however many lives each year doesn't encourage or enable me to go: it just makes me feel worse about my inability to go. I have tried, but the panic attacks despite sedatives meant I can't get through the door. I think my gynaecologist did one while I was under GA for something else (as discussed in advance).

If a friend bugged and bullied me about not going and teased me about being frightened about the pain, I would want to punch her in her ignorant, smug mouth.

WeAreEternal · 18/05/2015 17:45

I'd be encouraging her to complain about her GP actually.

100% this ^

It's her cervix, it is her choice, you should be supporting your friends decision not trying to talk her into something that she obviously does not want to do.

As as for her GP withholding contraception, that is very out of order and needs to be reported.

There are a multitude of reasons women decide not to have smear tests, some like myself even think smear tests can do more harm than good and do not agree with them at all.

SaucyJack · 18/05/2015 17:43

Only 0.067% of women who undergo smear test actually get any health benefits from it. The rest go through it for absolutely nothing.

Perhaps she's just made a rational decision based on the facts.

And it goes without saying that you should mind your own bloody business.

RedToothBrush · 18/05/2015 17:31

She is now very upset as when she went to get a repeat prescription of the pill last week her GP told her that she will not be given any more unless she has a smear test.

Tell her to report her GP to the GMC. The GP is using coercive behaviour to improve their smear test record. They get paid based on the percentage of their patients who have a smear. If they miss the target they don't get paid. Doctors are not allowed to withhold treatment on this basis as it breaks their ethical guidelines. The money they receive in this case illustrates the direct conflict of interest the GP has. If the GP is driving women away from their practice by saying this, its as bad as forcing them to have a smear in order to get the pill. So she shouldn't just change GP.

As for whether she wants to go for a smear. As a grown woman she is able to make informed decisions about her care without someone like you judging her and pressuring her.

There is a very respected doctor by the name of Margaret McCartney who writes about how biased the information about screening we are given is, and how it is presented in a deliberately emotive way to 'encourage' women to attend rather than treating them like adults and presenting figures about false positives and the benefits of screening in a balanced way. She herself makes the point that there is a massive difference in screening and investigative smears and she does not have the former. She stresses the importance of tests if there are symptoms or perhaps a family history but questions the fact that we 'have' to have one. She is very respected and does have a very valid point about how we have made the worried well.

You need to back the hell off your friend and give her some good advice about her doctor being completely unethical. If you respect your friend, you should treat her with some intelligence rather than trying to bully her in the same way as her unscrupulous GP.

specialsubject · 18/05/2015 17:13

for many people, me included, it doesn't hurt. And of course it is 'invasive' given where your cervix is. For me it takes 5 minutes; not the most fun five minutes I ever spend but part of the deal.

this does NOT belittle the OP's problem, or that the test is painful for some. But I'd hate anyone to read this and refuse a possibly life-saving test because it is being presented as an agonising and blood-soaked experience for all.

checked NICE guidelines and contraceptive prescription is not conditional on smear tests. However the UK also now think that hormonal contraceptives give an increased risk of cervical cancer; it isn't just due to increased sexual activity.

be informed of the FACTS and then make a choice.

zen1 · 18/05/2015 17:00

If I was your friend, I'd be changing my GP. He / she is completely in the wrong to try and bribe her into it. Also, don't GPs get funding for every smear done at the surgery? So it may not just be her wellbeing that's motivating the GP. As long as she's aware of the facts etc, she has made an informed choice. I wouldn't be very pleased if one of my friends tried to talk me into a medical procedure I had already made up my mind about.

Pippioddstocking · 18/05/2015 16:51

It's really difficult . I would leave it and hope that she finds a sensitive HCP to discuss it with one day .
It's difficult , and I say this as a HCP and someone who has had stage 3 changes ( with no symptoms ) found on a routine smear . I consider myself lucky to be here to bring up my children thanks to that screening programme.
When I come across patients who haven't had a smear I try to be sensitive in discussing it with them but it is ultimately their choice . I would never force them nor withold prescriptions .

lunalovegood84 · 18/05/2015 16:50

I opt out as well due to being at negligible risk of exposure to HPV and alarmed at the over treatment that is carried out following cervical screening. None of my friends seem the slightest bit interested in the state of my cervix, thankfully, as it's none of their business!

FaFoutis · 18/05/2015 16:44

It is not your business, you can't judge other people on the basis of your experience.
And she needs to complain about the GP.

PatricianOfAnkhMorpork · 18/05/2015 16:43

I'm in my 40s and have now opted out of the screening programme. I've done the research and there are way too many false positives leading to unnecessary treatment in comparison to the actual risks of it being a true positive. I believe they've now found similar issues with the prostate screening too.

If the OPs friend has decided against it then that's her choice as long as she is doing so with all the facts.

AFAIK the GP can't withhold hormone contraception for not having a smear test given you can opt out of the programme. They do need to do a general health review on a yearly basis for other issues (blood pressure, changes to migraines, etc) but that's standard with any drug treatment.

AwakeCantSleep · 18/05/2015 16:39

Sorry, forgot to say this was commenting on some people saying smear tests don't hurt.

It's a very invasive and awkward procedure and I have full sympathy with women who refuse to undergo this test.

ScorpioMermaid · 18/05/2015 16:38

I was also touched very inappropriately by a male GP when I was 5 or 6 - as was my mother, an Aunt, possibly my Gran and many others, by the same GP (thankfully he was struck off etc and I believe he is now dead) this is why I have anxiety issues about things like this.

kimistayingalive · 18/05/2015 16:38

I got hounded by my old gp surgery as I hadn't had one. I found it extremely upsetting as they kept reminding me despite I politely told them I didn't require one and if they read my notes they'd understand. I even told the receptionists outright the issue.
A few months later I got a letter to remind me to get the smear. Hubby got on the phone to them and gave them a right earful for causing upset.
I don't need a smear as I lack the cervix which is the whole point of the test and it was extremely upsetting due to the fact it was related to the whole reason why I couldn't have kids and was suffering depression due to it.
Terribly insensitive I felt but never had a letter since. Moved surgery due to moving and wonder if we will have the same rigamole here too.

AwakeCantSleep · 18/05/2015 16:36

I've had smear tests from a young age (20 I think) as in my home country women tend to have regular gyn checks (with gynaecologist not nurse) once a year anyhow. When I had them with the gynaecologist, in a gyn chair, I never felt a thing. In this country however, a nurse unceremoniously scratched my cervix out while I was lying flat on a trolley, and it hurt like hell.

I now tend to go back to home country and privately pay for a full gyn check every now and again.

ScorpioMermaid · 18/05/2015 16:29

I'm 30 and haven't had one. I will be later this year though after I've had this baby and my postnatal. etc. (I have anxiety issues about things like that, makes me sick thinking about it buy I know I should)

my SIL is 37 and has cerebal palsy her doctors keep hounding MIL to book her in for one. MIL refuses, says it's completely unnecessary as she's never even kissed a bloke let alone done anything else.

Signlake · 18/05/2015 16:24

Sorry YABU. At 27 your friend is an adult and is old enough to make her own decisions. If she understands the risks of not attending (which I imagine she does if the GP has nagged her - which is totally unreasonable in my opinion) then it's completely her choice!

I find it completely disgusting that contraception is being withheld because she refuses to take part in a VOLUNTARY screening program. I would complain to the practice manager. Absolutely shocking that anyone would agree this is a good idea

FiveExclamations · 18/05/2015 16:21

Gabilan I'm basing my it's not unreasonable of the GP on the fact that our (and thought all) GP(s) will not allow repeat prescriptions for hormonal contraception, Asthma meds and I would imagine other things without a yearly review where they require a blood pressure check/peak flow and listen to the chest respectively. Whether they would actually refuse to give the medication in the end to someone who refuses I don't know.

I appreciate that to most minds a smear is different because it is so invasive, so from that perspective I agree with you, I just don't know whether the Op's friend can force the issue and get her pills without one.

UmiSays · 18/05/2015 15:56

You can't force her to have one, but if she were my good friend, I would be gently trying to coax out why she is so set against having one. If its fear, embarrassment, an issue from past abuse etc...it can be overcome with the right support.

I wouldn't be forcing the issue on her, obviously, but I would let her know that if she wanted to talk about it at any point in the future, she could always turn to me and we could look at ways of helping her feel better about the test. Its such a quick and straightforward test and could be a life saver.

I say this having just buried a good friend at 35 yrs old. Mother of four, never had a smear, was taken to hospital with a urinary infection that wouldn't go away last September, no other symptoms. She was diagnosed with stage 4 (terminal) cancer and died eight months later.

I wish to God I had said something Sad.

Gabilan · 18/05/2015 15:45

"A quick google suggests that hormonal contraception can increase the risk of cervical cancer (US site) so based on that I don't think the GP is unreasonable."

The GP is refusing to write a prescription for contraception without her having an invasive medical procedure. S/he is being entirely unreasonable. The effects of an unwanted pregnancy far outweigh the risks of her getting cervical cancer. The risks to her from not wanting to go to the GP because she is being bullied also far outweigh the risks of her getting cervical cancer. Having sex increases the risk quite drastically, is the GP saying she should stop that too?

NB I'm not in anyway belittling the problem but it is her body and her decision. If she goes into the situation informed about the risks and still decides she doesn't want the smear then that is entirely up to her. Anyone else can think she's an idiot and can disagree with her, but it's still her body.

Given time, sympathy and understanding she might change her mind, especially as she gets older and the risk increases.

specialsubject · 18/05/2015 15:27

tell your friend that it is her body and her choice, that you respect that she understands the risks of not having one and that if she wants to talk more, you are there.

and leave it at that.

Mamus · 18/05/2015 15:26

I'm torn between thinking she's an effing idiot who should just get over herself and respecting her complete right to bodily autonomy. The latter wins, because it is her body and she does get to choose, and because I know my first reaction is utterly unreasonable and entirely down to being the niece of three sisters who all had cervical cancer. I think I'd have to say to her that it isn't a subject we could discuss on the grounds that I don't think I could be supportive of her choices.

Elsashmelsa · 18/05/2015 15:25

YABU OP.

Firstly for telling your friend that it doesn't hurt and it isn't embarrassing!! Your experience may not be the same as hers or anyone else's.

It took me 3 years to pluck up the courage to go after all the ones I had to have repeated when I was younger because I bled too much during the procedure, having my DD was less painful than having a smear (and that was pretty horrendous too).

It's a horrible experience for me with loads of bleeding and I always cry during it. So don't assume that your experience will be hers. Obviously she hasn't had her first one yet so she won't know whether it will hurt or not, but clearly she has her own reasons for not going.

FiveExclamations · 18/05/2015 15:25

A quick google suggests that hormonal contraception can increase the risk of cervical cancer (US site) so based on that I don't think the GP is unreasonable.

Did she ask your opinion? How did you originally find out she doesn't go? I'm generally of the view that adult's medical decisions are between themselves and their Doctor and everyone else should mind their own business but if she keeps bringing it up and asking you to agree with her that's different.

Incidentally my last smear, which came back clear, did hurt, not enough to be an issue but definite ouch at the time and some soreness for a few hours afterwards. Won't stop me getting another one though.

Iggi999 · 18/05/2015 15:20

You could ask her, is there anything that could be done to make it easier for her? Maybe she would have an answer to do with who performs it, or who goes with her, or speaking to the nurse in advance or whatever. Or maybe if she reflects on it she might wish to disclose something to an appropriate helpline, for example.
Although the OP sounds like she's adding to the bullying, the friend has brought it up with her so must want to discuss it to some extent - I have no idea whether friends have smears or not as we would never chat about it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread