Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To encourage my friend to have a smear test?

91 replies

ThatIsVerySilly · 18/05/2015 15:05

She is 27 now and was called in for her first smear test at the standard age of 25, so two years ago now. However she refuses to have one.

I have told her than nobody likes smear tests, it doesn't hurt and that it's a couple of seconds of embarrasment but she still refuses to have one. She still refuses to have one and has told me that being scared it will hurt or that it will be embarrasing is not the reason why she won't have one but then won't tell me why she won't have one. But what other reason would a woman not want one if not for embarrassment or fear it will hurt?

She is now very upset as when she went to get a repeat prescription of the pill last week her GP told her that she will not be given any more unless she has a smear test. I think this is a good idea as they really are so important and save lives. My friend has told me her GP has nagged her about it in the past so I think they are doing this to push her to have one. Personally I think it's a good idea and sounds sensible.

My friend is still telling me that she doesn't want one though and is now feeling bullied into having one.

WIBU to tell her to just get it over and done with? I feel kind of bad for thinking this but I can't help but think just suck it up and stop being so irresponsible. Having a smear test is nowhere near as bad as having cancer or dying from it.

OP posts:
Happfeet2911 · 18/05/2015 23:29

It's her choice, I'm well over 50, and have avoided all government recommended health checks my whole life. If I feel the need I will deal with it but I object to being told what to do, naughty children spring to mind! XX

ReallyAmAtBreakingPoint · 18/05/2015 23:03

Excellent post, RedToothbrush.

lunalovegood84 · 18/05/2015 22:49

I think I can contribute the most inappropriate smear test nagging story ever - the midwife while I was in labour. 9cm dilated. Hooked up to syntocinon. She was filling out some part of my notes, but really!

NotOneIota · 18/05/2015 22:44

Im in my 40s,and a couple of years ago I opted out too. OP,be the one person in your friends life who doesn't nag her about this,that's what she needs.

RedToothBrush · 18/05/2015 22:02

Well my rationale for going through a smear is that it is less painful and embarrassing than full blown cancer treatment, even my colposcopy was less painful and embarrassing and I am alive with now a clean smear plate - if she has no previous abuse issues and it is just embarrassment or worry over what discomfort she will experience then Yanbu to try and encourage her to go.

The problem with posts like that are they are a) emotive b) not informative c) don't respect other women's right to choose d) not balanced and reflective of actual risk e) seem to think women need to justify why they don't want a smear to others f) are rather dismissive and patronising of reasons that are given and seem to think its all about embarrassment

Unfortunately there is something of a benefit to those running screening programmes in having a lot of false positives resulting from screening. Every woman who goes through treatment thinks they have 'been cured' but many will have unnecessary treatment and never know it. But the high number of those having treatment inflates the perception of how prevalent cervical cancer actually is. Its almost a vicious circle that prevents screening programmes from being viewed without prejudge and bias.

This is why, posts like this are generally unhelpful in letting women make an informed decision, because the poster is usually too emotionally involved to give information about actual risk.

Doctor patient relationships rely on informed choice and consent given without duress and unfortunately the aggressive hard sell of screening programmes combined with payment structures greatly undermines this.

Strangely if I read threads about pregnancy women want things backed up with studies but when it comes to cervical screening, the tend to be lost in a culture of fear. It speaks volumes about the way screening has been promoted and doesn't reflect well on the NHS.

If screening programmes are that important then the figures should speak for themselves without the need for emotive or emotionally blackmailing language. This is what women need to hear, not anecdotal scaremongering comments.

Gabilan · 18/05/2015 21:55

"She still refuses to have one and has told me that being scared it will hurt or that it will be embarrassing is not the reason why she won't have one but then won't tell me why she won't have one"

2nd paragraph in the OP makes it clear that it isn't fear of pain or embarrassment but something else that the friend isn't willing to talk about. Frankly that's fair enough, under the circumstances it's likely to be something very personal.

MrsGentlyBenevolent · 18/05/2015 21:53

It's not just abuse, although I can't imagine how awful that must be, a smear can be so invasive. A friend of mine was born a female, has gender dysphoria and lives as a male. They already hate their own body. I cannot imagine suggesting to him to go for a smear, as he still has full female parts. 'Hi, I know you are livable s a man, but don't forget, take good care of those girl parts you still have'. It's beyond rude and inconsiderate. I would think at best his response would be to tell me to mind my own, at worse stop talking to me or give me a smack for being such a smug arse.

ToadsJustFellFromTheSky · 18/05/2015 21:33

if she has no previous abuse issues and it is just embarrassment or worry over what discomfort she will experience then Yanbu to try and encourage her to go.

The thing is though, how would you know what the reason is if she hasn't told you?

The OP's friend may want a smear test but might just be embarrassed about having one and in that case maybe a bit of encouragement would work.

However if she's been the victim of abuse in the past then encouraging her may be very distressing to her. I know if someone kept encouraging me to have one even after I decided not to I would find it very upsetting.

maddening · 18/05/2015 21:25

Well my rationale for going through a smear is that it is less painful and embarrassing than full blown cancer treatment, even my colposcopy was less painful and embarrassing and I am alive with now a clean smear plate - if she has no previous abuse issues and it is just embarrassment or worry over what discomfort she will experience then Yanbu to try and encourage her to go.

PeppermintCrayon · 18/05/2015 21:15

YABVU.

Abuse survivor here. Smears hurt me every time and cause flashbacks. This kind of smug pushiness would not help me.

makeminea6x · 18/05/2015 20:29

Just to be clear. No one should be bullied into doing anything they don't want to.

Your GP is not PAID EXTRA to meet qof targets (which are being phased out anyway). It is part of there basic wages. They must meet the targets, or they won't get half their pay. Every year the targets become more strict, or are changed, so your GP must do more work to receive the same wages.

I don't know why this GP in the OP refused to prescribe more contraception until the OPs friend had her smear. On the face of it, it doesn't seem reasonable but of course we don't have all the information. I do know that I spend a significant proportion of my time, as a HCP, chasing people to have the basic checks that make it safe for them to continue taking their medication. I write note after note on prescriptions and they are just ignored. It would actually be negligible for a GP to continue prescribing in some circumstances.

Please try not to assume that GPs are living their lives focused on earning as much money as possible while fucking over the general public. Most GPs are doing more work for less pay year on year and as a result are leaving the profession in droves.

Oldsu · 18/05/2015 19:58

I wonder if GPs only refuse to give repeat prescriptions for someone that requires a patient to have a test that they get PAID EXTRA to perform like smears, would they be have the same attitude towards a patient who wanted a repeat prescription but needed a test that is not covered by their QOF payments

EnlightenedOwl · 18/05/2015 19:51

completely out of order for you to badger her and for GPs to do this and yes they do put pressure on you - I went for a blood test last week and the nurse was pestering me but I won't have one done for reasons that I am not going to disclose to her or here.

MrsGentlyBenevolent · 18/05/2015 19:46

I knew you were being unreasonable without even reading your post op. No one has the right to pester or bully/blackmail a woman into a smear. She doesn't have to explain her reasons either. I've had one, will again, but that's my choice. I'm not a special flower for doing so. I certainly don't go on to my friends and family to do the same (and I know of at least two who chose not to).

PatsyNoPasta · 18/05/2015 19:27

YABU. The GP should be struck off for blackmailing your friend by holding her birth control hostage. Shocking and unethical behaviour.

morage · 18/05/2015 19:13

That is appalling peasant. My GP surgery accepts if you don't want one. Everyone should have the right to refuse medical treatment, even if others think they are wrong.

RevoltingPeasant · 18/05/2015 19:11

Quite! My last GP practice threatened me with de registration for refusing smears which is when I got so hot under the collar about it! Informed consent is key and a big part of that is respect people who say NO.

Signlake · 18/05/2015 19:09

I'm certainly not denying that the program saves lives, which is does, which is wonderful. But patients have a right to informed consent which is sometimes lacking. If a women decides for whatever reason she doesn't wish to take part, that decision should be respected and she should not be intimidated or bullied as described in the OP by medical professionals and other women who do wish to take part

RevoltingPeasant · 18/05/2015 18:44

Well tbf cervical cancer deaths have declined by about one-fifth in the period covered by the screening programme (introduced 1988 in the NHS).

But as with all risks, it's about presenting them fairly!

In 2012 there were 919 deaths nationally from cervical cancer, according to Cancer Research. So you can see that the original number if deaths prior to the programme, whilst greater, cannot have been that big.

I am not against the screening prog per se, but I do feel there is a lot of misinformation.

And that is not fair on women, as follow up treatments for abnormal cells can make it harder to carry a pregnancy to term or cause infection. These risks should be set out more clearly instead of relying on guilt inducing ads and bully tactics.

Signlake · 18/05/2015 18:31

Fantastic post RevoltingPeasant

I agree with everything you said. When I did research of my own, I was astounded with how uncommon cervical cancer actually is. Everyone I have spoken to seems to believe it's at epidemic levels and I honestly don't understand why

Extra funding for GP practices should be abolished if it is encouraging doctors to blackmail patients into unwanted procedures

dailyfix · 18/05/2015 18:21

I'm a HCP & very pro cervical screening, however as long as she makes an informed choice she can opt out. She should let her GP practice know that she wishes to be taken off the register.
I'm sure you're trying to be a helpful friend but her medical history is private.

RevoltingPeasant · 18/05/2015 18:21

*HPV

RevoltingPeasant · 18/05/2015 18:21

Special agreed they can't win! But if I ruled the NHS Grin people would have access to qualified dietitians to help sort health conditions.

I have no idea about contraception but it can't hurt to try - women are expected to put up with all kinds of rubbish!

Personally, as someone in a low risk group for HPG infection, I opt for minimal medical interference and smears only if symptomatic. This makes sense to me as a balance of risk. I would be beyond fucked off if some "friend" took it upon herself to bully me into changing my mind.

makeminea6x · 18/05/2015 18:15

I think you should respect your friends right to choose. If she has asked for your opinion, maybe encourage her to go and have a chat with her GP/a GP at the practice that seems approachable and explain to them that she wants to opt out. She could ask them for the reason for their policy.

This may not completely resolve the issue, as pp, but may help.

GPs in the main are motivated by wanting to help people be healthy. They may worry too much about the missing diagnoses, and not enough about over screening and intervention. It's a tough balance.

You will find many threads where people complain that they haven't had various tests, or that something was missed. Others where people feel they have been over investigated. It is a hard line to find. Tell your GPs how you feel and hopefully that will help them to personalise your healthcare better.

specialsubject · 18/05/2015 18:06

trouble is that those preventative health checks - don't eat too much and move around more - seem to result in people on here complaining that 'GP said I was too fat'. Doctors really can't win.

glad to hear the incidence of cervical cancer is so low.

I suspect that there is no such thing as 'effective contraception without unacceptable side effects', although the condom plus spermicide and very careful use is pretty near.

Swipe left for the next trending thread