Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or was this man really rude?

110 replies

DextersMistress · 14/05/2015 12:16

I'm at dm's with dc. DM had a man come to cut the grass and dc were on the step watching him. When he finished, he had a little chat with them (and DM)
He asked their age and remarked that ds2 is big for his age (true)
DM said yes, and they're like chalk and cheese aren't they (also true)
He said what? They're brothers?
DM laughed and said yes.
what, like proper brothers or is one the milkman's?

Shock

DM seems to think it wasn't rude and just an observation. I think it's a horrible comment. Aibu?

OP posts:
BitOutOfPractice · 14/05/2015 13:04

Surly really. I don't even know where to start with how utterly silly that sounds

BitOutOfPractice · 14/05/2015 13:03

I don't think he was implying that they might have different fathers in some sort of Carry on style nudge nudge fasion - I think he was asking if they were even related as they are so different

Really, OP, unclench

Jackie0 · 14/05/2015 13:01

It's an old fashioned comment from a time when blended families were unusual.
It sounds very rude to our modern ears.
What age was the gardener?

SurlyCue · 14/05/2015 13:00

Surly I'm sure he didn't say it in a serious questioning way, but in a laughing joking way.
To an adult that would be fine, we have fine tuned our ability to read and interpret tone and implication/intent. Children havent got that nailed yet and they can take things quite literally. They dont always see the wink or smirk to indicate a joke, they dont know that "the milkmans" is an age old joke not to be taken seriously. It is insensitive and careless at best to say that about a child, right infront of the child.

MammaTJ · 14/05/2015 12:58

Yup, just a joke, not a very funny one but a joke all the same.

Really funny is my female friend, who is mixed race (father Jamaican, mother English) who has three children. Her husband is white and quite fair. Two of the DC are quite dark, one of them fair, almost with blonde hair. A 'friend' questioned whether they all had the same father! Hmm

sebsmummy1 · 14/05/2015 12:57

He was basically asking if they have the same father -in a jokey way.

To be honest I probably would have laughed along but been pretty pissed off if the happened not to have the same father and assume he might have been passing judgement on it.

TwoAndTwoEqualsChaos · 14/05/2015 12:55

It's joke but, IMO, it has never been funny and is grossly offensive, for all the reasons mentioned above.

balletnotlacrosse · 14/05/2015 12:52

Surly I'm sure he didn't say it in a serious questioning way, but in a laughing joking way. Really, I think people overanalyse everything to do with children nowadays. I don't know how some of them are going to function when they have to move away and join the real world.

SurlyCue · 14/05/2015 12:49

Is everyone who thinks Op needs to 'lighten up' missing the fact that this was said infront of the children? For all he knew they were adopted or didnt share the same mother/father, for all he knew they could actually be blatantly aware of how different they look an be really sensitive about it because thats the billionth time someone has suggested they arent "proper" brothers? Or they could actuay have just found out that they dont share a parent and are having difficulty processing that. Not sure how thats at all funny or that they should just lighten up.

AGirlCalledBoB · 14/05/2015 12:45

Of course it's just a joke, I would not take a offence to that whatsoever. It's a old joke so admitally not so funny now but nothing to get worked up about.

I agree with TurnOverTheTV some people do take offence at the slightest thing.

Chipshopninja · 14/05/2015 12:43

Wow yabu

It was a joke you need to lighten up OP

Here have a BrewBiscuit and calm down dear

gaggiagirl · 14/05/2015 12:43

Its just a joke. Our little family get it all the time. Only I did ride the milkman and now DH is getting suspect Grin

TurnOverTheTv · 14/05/2015 12:40

Some people take offence to the tiniest things these days.

BitOutOfPractice · 14/05/2015 12:39

It's just a throwaway comment. Lighthearted.

YABU

CaTsMaMmA · 14/05/2015 12:39

is it specifically milk men you find offensive? Or all delivery type employees?

balletnotlacrosse · 14/05/2015 12:35

It's a very old joke. I can't believe anyone would take offence (unless, of course, they had been having it away with the milkman).

crymeariverwoo · 14/05/2015 12:34

YABU. I don't think it has anything to do with a woman sleeping around haha just that they are so different! We say my brother is the milk man's because he is normal unlike the rest of us ;)

SurlyCue · 14/05/2015 12:34

Yes its rude and a sign of his ignorance. Brothers dont even have to be blood relate to be brothers FFS! Who questions a child's parentage right there in front of them? Especially someone who it has fuck all to do with.

firesidechat · 14/05/2015 12:32

That one is as old as the hills and almost guaranteed to be trotted out in the conversation you describe. It's tired, unoriginal and nothing to be offended about at all.

ThreeQuartersEmpty · 14/05/2015 12:32

YABU. its just a joke, a bit of something to say.

PuppyMonkey · 14/05/2015 12:32

It's just a joke but your mum should have played along and said "yes actually you're right - it's our dark family secret." And pretended to cry. Grin

maz210 · 14/05/2015 12:32

I use this joke myself, my husband, myself and our daughter all have dark brown hair and brown or greeny brown eyes. Our son is blond haired and blue eyed Grin

It's honestly not meant nastily, I'd hardly be calling my own fidelity into question!

budgiegirl · 14/05/2015 12:31

YABU - its just a joke !

I've used it about myself, my children all look very like my DH, and if anyone comments, I have said 'You can certainly tell they're not the milkman's"

I think you being a touch oversensitive, and it's definitely not offensive.

ludmiliana · 14/05/2015 12:30

It's a joke, but it's a bit of a tactless one to be cracking these days, when lots of families are blended, and might have different fathers!

Allinson2014 · 14/05/2015 12:28

It's a joke, just not a very funny one. I get asked it all the time as myself and exDP have blue eyes same as DC2, but DC1 has brown eyes!

Swipe left for the next trending thread