Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Couples with children are more important" - Radio 5 this morning

56 replies

DrSethHazlittMD · 27/04/2015 09:10

There was an interview on the breakfast show this morning catching up with some mums who they apparently followed through pregnancy a couple of years ago. They were discussing assorted topics concerning the election and assorted pledged from the parties about improving things for working families and the one mum was very much in agreement that more needed doing for families.

The presenter posed the idea that the parties always promise things to "hard working families" and that single people (11 million) and those without children might feel a bit hard done by. Presenter asked the mum if she could relate to that?

Mum said she didn't agree that couples without children were hard done by (she avoided anything about single people altogether), that even more needed to be done for families, that the recent cuts had hit families most of all and that, in her opinion, couples with children are more important than those without.

AIBU to think that she's wrong in that:
a) the cuts have probably hit the disabled/permanently ill far most of all
b) couples with children are no more important than other couples, nor single people?

OP posts:
DrSethHazlittMD · 27/04/2015 09:23

Breadrocks - is a 13-year old child more vulnerable than someone with profound disabilities who can do nothing for themselves? I'm not sure I agree with that.

Yellow - already on this thread we have someone who thinks children are more important than other people.

Young - those were her exact words. While I do agree with Yellow that you can easily misword things on live radio, the tone and vehemence with which this mum spoke said it suggested to me she definitely meant it the way I heard it.

OP posts:
YoungGirlGrowingOld · 27/04/2015 09:17

YANBU - if that is indeed what she said then she sounds like a self important arsehole.

I have heard less "hard working families" BS in this election, thank goodness!

yellowdaisies · 27/04/2015 09:16

I suspect she didn't word it very well (it's very hard when under pressure of live radio I imagine) She probably meant that couples with children were more in need of state support, than couples without children - which is fair enough really. Rather than anyone being inherently "more important" as a human being - which obviously they aren't.

I agree with you though that state support already on offer, with the cuts that have been made to it, mean that single people (those on JSA, even more than disabled) are generally on average struggling more than families

Breadrocks · 27/04/2015 09:16

Children are the most important and vulnerable section of our society, so by default that means that helping families is more important than helping those without children. It may not be your view but it's a valid one, and one a lot of people will hold and agree with, whether they have children themselves or not.

DoJo · 27/04/2015 09:15

In as much as a couple represents two votes, so appealing to them has twice the value of appealing to a single person, I suppose as far as politicians are concerned, that makes them worth more in terms of appealing to their votes.

bronya · 27/04/2015 09:12

I think she probably meant that your income has to stretch further if you have children, whether you are single or not.