Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Buying presents for those with more children than you

157 replies

metropolis · 28/12/2014 02:57

Christmas is for giving and not receiving and all that. But does anyone think its slightly unfair when you have to buy Christmas/Birthday presents for family who have more children when they don't give much back for your only child? A few years ago my brother-in-law and his wife decided they no longer wanted to give myself and my partner (his brother) presents, nor receive any as they didn't see the point in it. They have 2 children and we carried on buying their children presents as usual. Years later we had a child. We never used to have a threshold for cost of presents - we just asked what their children wanted and they would tell us. She has since capped a £10 budget on each child. Fair enough I suppose if they have 2 kids and we only have 1. But when they get a present for my DS they spend as close to £10. They never get him anything much more. I think its a little unfair as we end up spending £20 on their kids and they only spend £10 on our DS. Money never used to come into it till she made an issue out of it.

OP posts:
timetoplay · 28/12/2014 08:57

I understand why you are upset OP, the present amount could have been capped years ago but now its your DC here the presents are capped, seems a bit unfair given that your DNs have had great and expensive presents from you but your son doesn't. Really, if it was me and I was well off I would cap for my own kids who are teens and have plenty and spoil my DN, but sounds like your SIL believes it's fairer all around this year.

I think that's different from having to buy 'more' for more children. It's actually that you've paid a lot for your DNs over the years but now yours is here your B and SIL don't seem so inclined especially when they have the money. Since this has you really down I wonder if this is part of something bigger you've noticed? Them not being so bothered with your child in comparison to you with your DNs?

GhoulWithADragonTattoo · 28/12/2014 08:52

Bottom line is you could always get a joint present such as chocolate, DVD or a game or something. I understand your point that SIL has only just put cap on now you have a child but perhaps her circumstances have changed. These days lots of people are struggling for money much more than 10 years ago.

ohtheholidays · 28/12/2014 08:51

OP are they maybe struggling this Christmas?Two children do end up costing more than one child,especially at Christmas and Birthdays.Maybe they're worried about money?

My brother got none of ours anything this year not even a card.
He's 13 years older than me and has 7 children.It's the first Christmas without our lovely Mum as well.

I have always bought all of his children Christmas and Birthday presents since they were born and I was only 7 when I became an auntie to his first child.Back then I used to do chores and save pocket money to buy them presents.

Now 5 of his DC have children of they're own,they have 12 children between them.So we buy for they're children now instead and the two sons who don't yet have children we buy them a gift for themselves.

We have 5DC,my brother hasn't even done us a Christmas card.That really hurt.He didn't even text or call to say thanks for his Christmas present.We spent nearly £30 on him and nearly £30 on his wife.We spent £120 on his Grandchildren and £15 between his two sons.

I know that's only £10 per great nephew and great niece but we managed to get them all two gifts each that would have come to £20 each with out the Christmas offers on.

I never expect anything back,I just felt heart broken for our children they adore they're uncle and our family has got smaller this year with the loss of my Mum and they were extremely close to they're Nan so this Christmas has been hard enough as it is.Just a Christmas card from him to each of them would have been enough to make them smile.

justmummyof2 · 28/12/2014 08:51

I really don't see your point, you now say that the number of children won't equal out. As if all that counts is the money spent. Do you not enjoy your sister's DC opening their presents? Do you not enjoy watching your DC receive their gift? That is what I love! but if you really have to think about the money, consider that in a couple of years their DC will be 18. That is when we stop buying presents in our family, but your DC will have 14 years of presents still due

For what it is worth, my sister has 5 DC from a previous relationship, and two years ago married and moved in with her DH who has 4 children from a previous relationship. Together they have had a baby. We have 10 children to buy for in just that one family, let alone other nieces and nephews. And we only have 2 DC. It has never occurred to me that they don't have to spend as much as us. We all just enjoy Christmas and sharing!

I will just add a final point, for whoever stayed with my post this long, but have ypu considered that the BIL has two children to buy multiple presents for, two main presents, two stocking fillers etc etc Whereas you only have to that lot once!

You should just be grateful they get your DC anything at all, they aren't legally bound you know!

IceniMist · 28/12/2014 08:40

I am conscious that my Dsis has no children and 9 nieces and nephews to buy for. She works hard in a low paid job so I spend on her the same amount I spend on our children.

I can see how it is annoying but I would just stick to the limit.

ZanyMobster · 28/12/2014 08:39

I think either way is fine. Part of me thinks the same amount per child is the right way but we end up spending £40 on our niece and SiL spends £20 each on my 2, I think the reason is because the older 2 (DS1 and DN) are the same age so it was just them to spend on so when DS2 was born here budget was split which is understandable.

This is fine at xmas but don't like it so much on bdays. I think it should be more even then.

MrsAmaretto · 28/12/2014 08:39

YANBU, suggest a £20 limit per family. We have a family limit with one set of friends, & I wish we did with BIL family instead of per child.

MinceSpy · 28/12/2014 08:34

If it really bothers you then get £5 gifts for the cousins. My sister only has one child, I have two and her BILS have four kids each but she never moans. We have the £10 limit but i do buy my DN double that, my choice though.

lbsjob87 · 28/12/2014 08:31

We have a similar situation, my OH's sister has 6 kids, we have 2 (one only 6mo so this was his first Christmas).
I also have 5 nephews and nieces on my side. We set a limit at £10 per child, or £20 for a joint present (this year 2 of the boys were getting an X box so we gave them a surprisingly cheap game, actually, think it was £18.99? It's probably not much good but they are 4 and 6 so they don't care if it's not the latest one and it's the thought that counts).
In the past my SiL has spent £30/40 on my DD, but that's her choice. Even with a limit we still end up spending twice as much as that on her kids because she has 3 times more kids than us!
But again that was her choice.
She could buy my kids a car if she wanted to, (she probably couldn't but it's an extreme example) but that wouldn't mean I would be in a position to spend loads more on hers.

But if she only spent £5 each on them, by your reckoning I would be £50 out of pocket, because I spent £60. Surely Christmas shouldn't work like that??

Pipbin · 28/12/2014 08:28

We buy for DH's 6 nieces and nephews, and their children.
We don't have any children. They don't get us anything because they are either children or young and just starting out so we've told them to save their money.

wowfudge · 28/12/2014 08:27

Sadly I have some experience of this kind of mental totting up of what has been spent. My aunt fell out with my parents because she begrudged buying two presents for me and my sis and felt my parents should spend what they did in two of us on her one DD, my cousin. However, this was never communicated by her and the presents from her became more and more stingy over time and she eventually blew up over a perceived inadequate present for a specific birthday of my cousin's. You couldn't make it up.

We weren't ungrateful, but as we got older we did notice we were being given things we didn't want or need (think the same present every year), but which were on bogof deals at a well known retailer where cousin got staff discount!

It's so petty it's pathetic. I have friends with kids and I don't begrudge buying presents for them when we have no dc for them to buy for. That would just be weird. I positively enjoy finding interesting things to give them all as they grow up and develop their own interests. One friend's kids want money because they are always saving up for different things - writing a cheque is no fun compared with finding a suitable present!

insancerre · 28/12/2014 08:23

Yet another thread full of Christmas spirit.
I have been really saddened bybthw amount of threads posted about unwanted gifts, ungrateful children not 'wowed' by their presents, ungrateful adults complaining about their presents
Its sad, very sad

CSIGingerbread · 28/12/2014 08:22

DSis has this with the IL's. Her BIL made a point that as the younger brothers, he must be loved less and as they don't have children, then all the love and wealth must be spend of DNep and DN. So now of course, the IL's have made a point of having an overall budget for each family, which suits BIL with his designer tendencies. Funny thing is, DSis and her DH have no problem with how much is spent as it's the thought that goes into their presents means more to them. Money does not equate love.

YABU.

CassieBearRawr · 28/12/2014 08:14

It's not a competition OP.

workhorse · 28/12/2014 08:12

I think YANBU. I have three DCs, BIL and SIL have one. So at Christmas they buy for our three and not us, and we buy for DN plus BIL and SIL. Seems fairer that way and I don't feel guilty.

QOD · 28/12/2014 08:08

Actually .... my sis has 2 kids (actually 3 this yr as we've gained a step nephew) and SHE said, about 7 years ago, that she was going to spend more on my Dd then I do on hers because she has 2
I spend about £30 on birthdays ... she spends £60

So I get you

ArthurSHappeyChristmas · 28/12/2014 08:06

YABU. And you clearly don't like your SIL.

I have an 'only', I have nieces and nephews, I have friend's children to buy for. I do not keep tabs on how generous people are to my son. I do not expect people to buy him crazy gifts.

I have one friend with 2 DCs who always buys my DS 2 gifts because I 'have to buy two' for hers. This makes me and DS uncomfortable and then her kids always seem a little disappointed by the fact my DS has 2 to open.

It's not a competition. Stick to the budget and be grateful for the gifts.

DoesntLeftoverTurkeySoupDragOn · 28/12/2014 08:03

You're getting the thread removed because no one agrees with you? Confused

One of my siblings has no children. They have 5 nephews/nieces. There has never been any hint that they begrudge buying gifts without getting an equal amount back.

Mammanat222 · 28/12/2014 07:59

What a bizarre post. My sis has 3 kids, bro and SIL will soon have 4 kids and bil has 3 kids. We just have the one so am I to tell my brother we expect a £40 gift to recompensate us for the gifts we have given his kids.

Nonsense.

TheRealAmandaClarke · 28/12/2014 07:47

And i have a larger home than some of my peers, with far less disposable income.

TheRealAmandaClarke · 28/12/2014 07:45

As someone who had children some considerable time after my sibs/ in-laws, and bought my DNs some superb gifts, I think YABU. But I see where you're coming from.
As the only parents in the set up your in laws were content for their children to receive generous gifts. Now they have to buy for a nephew they have set a price limit. It can feel unfair, especially after years of you being so "good" with gifts.
But that is "giving to receive" isnt it?
It is quite normal to set a limit a d £10 is as reasonable as any other.
Plus, they have two kids to buy for (and teenagers are EXPENSIVE) so they are their priority and their spending on others might be limited. I don't know your own financial circs but you are likely to find your spare cash pot is lighter than it used to be too.
And in many circles, once DNs reach adulthood then aunts and uncles stop the pressies, so that will happen later for your DS than for theirs.

Whatdoiknowanyway · 28/12/2014 07:44

This used to annoy me too. Not the gifts, I was happy enough to choose gifts for my two sets of three nephews and nieces when I only had 2 children myself. It was when one SIL decreed that hers just wanted the money so could I send £20 for each of them. So I would then send £60 in the post and receive £40 to divide between my 2. Futile, joyless and unfair.

Mehitabel6 · 28/12/2014 07:09

MNHQ don't just remove threads because you want them to- I started one once that went badly- you have to have a good reason. You asked AIBU and the answer was YABU.

phoenixrose314 · 28/12/2014 07:07

OP just seen that you're upset about getting flamed - I didn't mean to make you feel bad, but if you post on AIBU then you should probably anticipate that people might possibly tell you that yes, you are BU.

Sorry you're feeling down - give your DS a snuggle and watch a happy-making film Smile

Mehitabel6 · 28/12/2014 07:05

They seem very sensible- no presents for adults and not more than £10 a child- I can't see how it works if you then spend £20 on a child because they have no siblings.