Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Buying presents for those with more children than you

157 replies

metropolis · 28/12/2014 02:57

Christmas is for giving and not receiving and all that. But does anyone think its slightly unfair when you have to buy Christmas/Birthday presents for family who have more children when they don't give much back for your only child? A few years ago my brother-in-law and his wife decided they no longer wanted to give myself and my partner (his brother) presents, nor receive any as they didn't see the point in it. They have 2 children and we carried on buying their children presents as usual. Years later we had a child. We never used to have a threshold for cost of presents - we just asked what their children wanted and they would tell us. She has since capped a £10 budget on each child. Fair enough I suppose if they have 2 kids and we only have 1. But when they get a present for my DS they spend as close to £10. They never get him anything much more. I think its a little unfair as we end up spending £20 on their kids and they only spend £10 on our DS. Money never used to come into it till she made an issue out of it.

OP posts:
Merguez · 28/12/2014 16:47

YABU to 'count' the amount spent on anyone's present.

Surely it's about how much the presents are enjoyed and appreciated not the amount people spend...

Bulbasaur · 28/12/2014 16:43

I don't see how it's unfair if each child gets at £10 gift. You can't possibly think it's fair for one child to get a £20 gift while another gets a £10 one. Confused

I can see how it'd be frustrating though that as soon as you have your child, your SIL suddenly decides she doesn't want to buy nice presents for him like you did for her kids.

Personally with DD we get a small gift for her uncle from her. She's a baby though, so I really couldn't be bothered with how much anyone spends on her, she doesn't need anything. Even when she's older I won't care. But I do appreciate that adding her to the mix stretches everyone budget and changes how much money goes into each present pot.

FannyBlott · 28/12/2014 16:20

But surely you are buying for the child not the family? If you think about it as 5/10/15 quid per child/person then it's not unfair at all!
I have only 2 dcs, this is fewer than some of my siblings. I budget five pounds per child (I have loads of nieces and nephews). I think that's fair. I think it would be a bit shit to get a family with three children three five pound presents but their cousin gets a 15 pound present from the same person.

To be honest I can't quite believe anybody even thinks like this! Just be grateful for what presents you do get and if you're only giving to receive something of equal value back then don't bother giving in the first place.

mustbetimeforacreamtea · 28/12/2014 15:48

I get where the OP is coming from. I suspect if the present limit had been instigated from the start it may have been different. It's just the lack of acknowledgement that it's disproportionate that grates.

Mind you it is the same as if you have been to loads of weddings and not married yourself.

Savvyblonde · 28/12/2014 15:33

I get your frustration. I have 1 child. DB and DBIL each have 2DC. My brother send a present from both his DC and receive a present for each. DBIL send 1 present from both. With extra complication of birthdays at christmas for my DC and both of DBIL. Last year I found myself buying 4 presents but watching my DC only getting 2 in return. This year I bought DBIL DC joint presents for both birthday and Christmas and watched with interest as DBIL and DSIL had to explain that the kids had to share. True evil but have to mention both presents were of very good quality. Passive aggressive point made!

bigmouthstrikesagain · 28/12/2014 15:27

rereading the thread and the op I am still erring on yabu. Not cos I am a 'hater' of the op situ but because the action of the sil can be viewed differently, as she instigated the limit when op had a child of her own. which could be interpreted as a understanding that with their own child to buy for the op and her dh would be buying less indulgent presents for their dn's. As the sil had not been buying any presents for the grown ups for years but now they were buying gifts for their new dn maybe did not want to spend much as they are still buying for their own dc. it is circumstance, rather than malice or at least it could be viewed that way, and unless the sil was very mean and grabby which we only have a one sided pov on - the op was never actually forced to be indulgent in the past.

I have less discretionary spending money now I have children. when I was buying larger gifts I was renting and sis with 7 kids owned a house - that had no bearing on how much we had to spend at christmas. we have a big mortgage now and less cash to spend as a result. So it could be that op is not unreasonable but really it is irrelevant what strangers on the net think in this case - only the op and if you are unhappy then decide if it is worth the inevitable bad feeling that raising the issue will bring you.

homealone42 · 28/12/2014 15:27

I see why you are hurt having been generous to her children. I have the oppossite issue. I have 3 dc and my single siblings buy presents for 5. I try and buy them a bigger present to compensate and have told them not to bother buying for me and dh.

naty1 · 28/12/2014 15:08

Yanbu. I think it wouldnt matter if yours got a better present from them. £10 gifts are pretty pointless anyway.
Hope you get it all passed down.
I feel for people with 15 nieces and nephews say, and would quickly change to a family gift once over say 3 as it is the parents choice. With several kids they get to play with each others anyway.
As we wont need hardly a thing for DC2. Not even sure what they'd get first few xmas and birthdays.
Probably request money and use when they are older and want stuff.
We have got a lot of unnecessary stuff. Including duplicates of stuff we have and more cuddly toys :(
Better to have a couple of really good presents

NotOnMyWatchOhNo · 28/12/2014 13:50

No it wasn't clam the £10 limit was set when the op had her child. Please read the op again.

MissDuke · 28/12/2014 13:31

I have 3 kids and my bro has 2. He usually asks me what they want, and I always suggest things that range from £5-10 to give him a choice what he spends, I suggest a fair few things for each and keep it quite vague so its totally up to him what he spends. I spend around £20 on each of his, and I would say adding up that a similar amount was spent by both him and me altogether when including all presents. I think that is only fair tbh, I wouldn't want him spending much more than me. I also spend more on my sister as she has no children, yet is buying for 2 siblings and 5 nieces and nephews. She would never expect me to, but it seems only fair to me?

Therefore I see your point op! Although I think your sil was very sensible suggesting a tenner limit, it gets totally out of hand otherwise!

GokTwo · 28/12/2014 13:26

Would she seriously be that petty over one child's gift though? i would never have started the thing of buying expensive presents for her kids in the first place. Spend what you can afford, don't be pressurised into spending more.

clam · 28/12/2014 13:21

That's not what the OP said, NotOnMyWatch. The £10 limit was for the SIL's own children initially.

NotOnMyWatchOhNo · 28/12/2014 13:19

You are 100% not being unreasonable, they were greedy and grabby before you had children, now you have they only want to spend £10 on your child.
I agree with you and it would piss me off aswell.

clam · 28/12/2014 13:17

"I'm getting this thread removed now."

I don't think you can just get a thread removed because you don't like some of the answers you've been given.

2015 · 28/12/2014 13:07

YANBU (possibly) Smile

I can see what the OP is saying. It's not the current £10 cap that she minds it's the fact that the SIL was happy to accept expensive gifts for her DC but only until the OP had her own child. I think it COULD be dodgey behaviour on the SILs part but it could just be that she is skint.

OP, do you get any hand me down toys or baby things from your SIL? If so, that would help address the imbalance.

HerrenaHarridan · 28/12/2014 12:57

I have an only and money is very tight.

As a compromise to this situation (although we hadn't set limits) for families with multiple children I add half again per child and buy a joint present.
So this year my budget for other peoples kids was £5 + £2.50 per additional child. Then I used that budget to get the best deal I possibly could on a shared present.

I would love to have the finances to not have to worry about how much I spend on other people kids but it's my dd that will go without and there's already few enough people that will give her a gift.

Birthdays I spend equally as they are spread out.

Viviennemary · 28/12/2014 12:30

No point really in moaning about this kind of thing. Either go along with it or say shall we not bother with presents from now on. But they are a bit cheeky to have accepted presents for years and now put a cap on the cost when it's their turn to fork out. I'd be tempted to say let's not bother.

skinnyamericano · 28/12/2014 12:27

floggin your're absolutely right - it isn't a general discussion about how much to spend on other children, it's a specific situation with a grabby SIL.

I wonder if she was a bit nervous at the thought of having to reciprocate with expensive presents that she couldn't or didn't want to afford?

She shouldn't have asked for gifts for her DC in the past though, that she wouldn't have happily given herself.

aurorasky · 28/12/2014 12:24

Yes, what Flogging said.

aurorasky · 28/12/2014 12:22

When you have no children yourself and give presents to nieces and nephews for years, presents that are expensive and actually specifically asked for, for it's all lovely and as posters who have no children agree it's a 'non issue'.

Then many years later you have your own child and the rules have been changed so you do not get to dictate what expensive gift they will be buying as they have done when their children were having their special childhood Christmases.

I can see why you feel it's unfair.

Floggingmolly · 28/12/2014 12:18

Most people are (deliberately?) missing the point... Your SIL was happy to ask for expensive gifts for her children for years; but quickly put a £10 cap on gifts as soon as you had a child and she had to reciprocate.
Yes, that's grabby and it'd burn my hide a bit too. Not the money, but the sheer calculated meanness of it.

skinnyamericano · 28/12/2014 12:12

We have 4 DC so I always feel a little awkward about receiving gifts for all of them, especially when it is from friends with 1 or 2.

I always try to spend similar to how much they would have to - so if they spent around £10 per child, I would spend £40 split between their children.

It does make birthdays and Christmas expensive, but I feel that it was our choice to have so many children. And I am always trying to get people to stop buying for ours, but it hasn't worked so far.

PastPerfect · 28/12/2014 12:08

usefully

I'm with you.

SoonToBeSix · 28/12/2014 12:02

How would it be fair for your ds to have a present that is twice as expensive as his cousins?
Yabu.

silveroldie2 · 28/12/2014 11:58

YABU - In my case I have no children but over the years have always bought gifts for family and friends' children. Should I feel hard done by? Of course not. You either give a gift with a glad heart or frankly don't bother. All this angst over £10 is ridiculous.

PS You can't delete the thread just because you don't like people's honest replies.