Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be disappointed that Cheryl Cole is now the most successful british female musician of all time

145 replies

toriuk · 06/11/2014 07:04

Looks like this weekend she alone will hold the record for most British female number one singles. I like her but she just has people pick songs for her and records an album in a week.

Currently the record is shared with Rita ora and geri halliwell. Ora has an amazing voice. Halliwell wrote lots of her songs and even signs many of them so her deaf fans can enjoy them.

m.youtube.com/watch?v=_xN5yUwNRZY

OP posts:
Poopooweewee · 06/11/2014 15:59

dustarr73

Is that you Chezza?

squoosh · 06/11/2014 15:41

Gimme a break, there are plenty of artists a lot younger than Cheryl whose music I enjoy.

dustarr73 · 06/11/2014 15:38

I see the claws are out again.Shes successful off her own bat and works hard.Had one misdemenour 11 years ago and hasnt repeated it since.There are worse people out there.
And about her songs i dont think they are meant for the old gimmers on Mumsnet.

Rebecca2014 · 06/11/2014 15:29

How did, I don't care get to number one? is it a horrible song yet idiots are buying it?

It is a shame as she is shit and arrogant to boot.

MajesticWhine · 06/11/2014 15:25

YANBU. I like Cheryl. I may even have bought one or two of her songs Blush. But I am shocked she is now the most successful british artist. She is lovely looking, but very lightweight, and not particularly talented.

DoJo · 06/11/2014 15:23

The figures are not statistically sound - you need far fewer record sales to achieve a number one today that you did in previous decades when singles were a legitimate indicator of success, so Cheryl Wotsit's number ones are not 'worth' as much as other artists from days gone by. And that's how I haven't gnawed my own arm off and beaten myself to death with it!

squoosh · 06/11/2014 15:22

And I'd challenge the idea that 'hard work' has got her where she is. Finding fame through a reality TV show isn't exactly on a par with spending three years gigging your way around the country's fleapit music venues before anyone takes any notice.

squoosh · 06/11/2014 15:19

Surely we can slag off Britain's so called most successful female musician for not possessing any discernible musical talent?

fakenamefornow · 06/11/2014 15:14

I like Cheryl.

I agree she's a performer, not a musician, and not a performer to my taste.

She's come from a poor background, worked herself up using all that assets she has, including the good looks she was lucky enough to have. The fact that her pretty face (and undoubted very very hard work and determination) has brought her so much success is societies problem, she's just worked the system we have.

As far as I can see the only reason to slag her off is her criminal record and the fact that she changes her name to that of whichever man she's with at the time. Being success through your own hard work is not something to be slagged off for imo.

ChickenMe · 06/11/2014 14:56

She's very pretty but so boring. I would be bored with myself if I lacked personality to that extent.

Thinking back to the 80s the standard was higher. Lack of internet/mtv/videos/reality tv meant you had to be a half decent singer. I don't think she would've got away with it back then as youngsters wouldn't have been prepared to shell out for her singles when she can barely sing.
Compare her to someone not hugely known like Siobhan Fahey who was in a bubblegum type group but is/was reasonably credible afterwards. Not to mention the great Annie Lennox who also left a successful pop group and went solo and it's embarrassing how far standards have slipped.

enriquetheringbearinglizard · 06/11/2014 14:16

If she's a musician at all she strikes me as the kind who offer a one word or one line change in the lyrics and then get credited.

I've never thought of her as a musician at all, more a 'performer' in the broadest sense. I can't imagine she'd ever have had much of a career without the Cowell factor and TV exposure.

squoosh · 06/11/2014 13:56

Love a bit of Dusty.

Nanny0gg · 06/11/2014 13:55

Dusty Springfield.

That's who it should be.

aquashiv · 06/11/2014 13:50

SOrry I don't understand Gerri Halliwell is the most successful artist really how is this true?

ouryve · 06/11/2014 13:44

Musician?

Bloody Nora.

Bramshott · 06/11/2014 13:43

By "of all time" they presumably mean "of the very short space of time since which recording has been invented and we have had sufficiently good systems to organise single releases into a chart"?

Poopooweewee · 06/11/2014 13:05

'Radgie' Geordie term for aggressive twat.

AesSedai · 06/11/2014 13:02

I prefer my national treasures not to have a conviction for GBH.

I didn't know this - and I bet millions of others didn't either. It was 11 years ago (I looked it up). Whatever happened to 'spent conviction'?

ExitPursuedByABear · 06/11/2014 12:54

What's a radgie?

Poopooweewee · 06/11/2014 12:47

Agree about Annie Lennox!

Chezza is stunning, that can't really be denied in all seriousness, but she absolutely cannot sing, her 'personality' makes me cringe, she takes herself v seriously and is well, a bit, naff, and worst of all, she's a proper little radgie.

ExitPursuedByABear · 06/11/2014 12:44

Annie Lennox gets my vote as well.

squoosh · 06/11/2014 12:41

Actually I think Wuthering Heights is Kate Bush's only UK No.1. That to me proves that these kinds of statistics are a nonsense.

It's safe to say whose musical legacy will be listened to and spoken of 30 years from now.

slug · 06/11/2014 12:36

I think Kate Bush has had more No 1s than Cherl Kerl

wickedlazy · 06/11/2014 12:13

Agreed Adele is a much better candidate.

toriuk · 06/11/2014 12:10

How has everyone forgotten halliwells hits?

I even posted her most recent song, sang live. The one where she signs bullshit many times for all her deaf fans

OP posts: