Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be disappointed that my child is not clever?

138 replies

Whichusername · 21/09/2014 13:16

Academically or otherwise. Said child is 5 years old and is always at the bottom of everything child tries (dance/sport, reading & maths etc.) Ofcourse I love my child but just wish child would shine in something. Am I alone?

I must mention that I never let my feelings show. I always praise child for effort etc. Child always cries when coming last in a race game with friends. I tell child that winning is not everything and to remember to have fun. I don't think it is so much about me actually. Child always wants to win in everything but never good enough. Breaks my heart. For child's sake I hope we find something that child will truly enjoy and maybe does not involve comparing self with peers. Child will be joining musical theatre soon as enjoys singing and drama.

Any words of wisdom?

Please be kind.

OP posts:
Coolas · 21/09/2014 14:01

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

MrsSchadenfreude · 21/09/2014 13:57

My friend's daughter was in remedial classes for everything, all through primary. They were told that their DD was never going to be academic, and they should think of a career for her, such as helping with animals or working in a nursery. She went to secondary and really took off academically. She's now at an RG university studying maths, having got a string of As and A*s in her GCSEs and A levels.

Please don't write him off yet!

fascicle · 21/09/2014 13:56

Said child is 5 years old and is always at the bottom of everything child tries

How can you know where your child ranks at the age of 5? I'm not sure too much comparison to others at that age is healthy. As long as they're happy, making progress etc. And 'being clever' does not necessarily translate into academic or other success.

WorraLiberty · 21/09/2014 13:56

For example, my sewing teacher at school despised me because i couldn't get eight small neat stitches to the inch. I felt bad. But as an adult, I've made clothes, curtains, bedlinen for my precious baby (years ago), pantomime outfits, and they've been fine, good, even.

Same here, except as an adult I discovered the delights of wonder web and never looked back! Grin

LonnyVonnyWilsonFrickett · 21/09/2014 13:56

So the tennis coach slowed his instructions and tone of voice down so your child could better understand what was required of them. And you pulled the child from the lessons? Is that right or have I missed something?

Perhaps the coaches tone left something to be desired, but they will have a range of strategies to try with each individual. Unless there is more to that anecdote, all you taught your child there was that we give up when we don't like someone's tone - can you see that?

BravePotato · 21/09/2014 13:55

I think it is wrong to tell a child that winning doesn't matter, it is all anout taking part etc.

Firstly, that is a lie and the child, even at this age, KNOWS you are lying.

Much better, imvho, to say :"what a shame you lost. It would have been nice to win. Not everyone can win." Then move on to the next thing. Telling a child "it does not matter" when it does matter to them is frustrating, and makes them feel you either don't understand or you tell lies.

Better to acknowledge their feelings. Nothing wrong with feeling a bit put out. You learn to pick yourself up and dust yourself off and try again!

OP, 5 is very young. You will find out what her talents are over the next 6 yrs. most kids are good at something, or even a few things.

WorraLiberty · 21/09/2014 13:54

My DS2 was similar at that age, OP.

Then when he got to year 5 (9yrs old), the class were given violins to learn. As you can imagine, me and DH shuddered at the thought of him practising at home Grin

He'd never even held a violin before then, yet he took to it like a duck to water. He was eventually put on the G&T register and to this day (he's 15yrs old now), he still plays the violin and has taught himself to play the guitar.

No-one in our family could have possibly seen that coming. So there really is a world of possibilities out there...especially for a child so young.

plinkyplonks · 21/09/2014 13:53

Whichusername

This could have been written about me years ago.

It took until my late twenties to 'shine'. Your DC is 5 - at that age they should be enjoying exploring life, stress free and learning to interact with other kids.

HPparent · 21/09/2014 13:50

OP you sound like you don't have much confidence yourself?

I really would not worry too much. At 5 my child was written off as having SN (largely because of severe anxiety) and never being able to reach her true potential. She turned out to be very clever, all A and A*'at GCSE and A level.

I think sometimes the things we are good at come later. My BF at primary school was always second best at everything, but is now a high flyer in the civil service largely through her personality, rather than because she is particularly clever.

HumblePieMonster · 21/09/2014 13:50

Will try to relax and keep encouraging
The perfect way forward.

What I've noticed about life is that you don't have to be 'the best' or 'perfect' in order to do well and have a really good life.

For example, my sewing teacher at school despised me because i couldn't get eight small neat stitches to the inch. I felt bad. But as an adult, I've made clothes, curtains, bedlinen for my precious baby (years ago), pantomime outfits, and they've been fine, good, even.

Child who doesn't shine but is mum's beloved will be just fine.

Aeroflotgirl · 21/09/2014 13:49

Well that's encouraging Which, as everyone said, hes only 5 not yet developed and still growing. Lots of praise, encouragement, and trying out different activities to see which one he likes. We cannot be top dog in everything, and that's what you need to bring across to ds.

slightlyglitterstained · 21/09/2014 13:48

You get good at stuff by being interested enough to keep trying and getting timely, relevant feedback on how to improve. I think "finding something to shine at" is mostly about finding that - something you enjoy, and a coach/mentor/teacher who gets you. (Unlike obnoxious tennis coach!)

"Shine" doesn't have to mean best, either, just that's your thing & you like it. At five, upset about coming last + shyness may just mean wanting to feel accepted and that they have a place, IYSWIM?

Whichusername · 21/09/2014 13:47

No, school has not specific concerns. Last year's teacher was rather inexperienced though (first teaching job) so will be speaking to this year's teacher to find out whether they have any concerns.

I like the idea of trying a new instrument together.

OP posts:
LondonRocks · 21/09/2014 13:44

You need to reassure child that there is so much more to life than coming top.

And then reassure yourself of that.

Whichusername · 21/09/2014 13:43

2mins, yes I read with my child, do maths etc. Actually not too bad at reading to be honest. Always tell child they are the best thing that has ever happened to me and that is the truth.

Thanks again everyone. I was welling up reading the encouraging posts. Child is competitive and hates losing. I think that is why I wish for this for m child. Will try to relax and keep encouraging.

OP posts:
TeWiSavesTheDay · 21/09/2014 13:40

You need to teach him/her that it's okay to come last or take a lot of time to learn something.

Why don't you take up a new instrument or sport and show them that it's normal to be crap to begin with!

As an aside I was rubbish at pretty much everything at 5, it doesn't mean I'm not smart, I have an excellent degree!

Aeroflotgirl · 21/09/2014 13:37

Which that tennis coach is not the right one then, he does not sound good with young children. Your ds is only 5, they need instructions to be clear and concise. Don't put pressure on him, just let him be himself. Are school worried about him?

Greythorne · 21/09/2014 13:37

I do hear where you are coming from. My DD1 is spectacularly unsporty, borderline dyspraxic. Hurts herself a fair bit, never catches the ball, took ages to learn to ride a bike, knows how to swim but hates it and only swims under sufferance, you get the picture.

When I see other kids zooming about on scooters and climbing trees and arguing with their big brothers to have a go on their big bikes, kids just "taking" to roller skating or gymnastics without any help or teaching, I do feel a bit sad and disappointed for her. Seems like she is missing out on a lot of fun of childhood, but it's just not her thing.

velvetcloakofsilence · 21/09/2014 13:36

Indeed quangle - reminds me of school assemblies and 'Everybody has a talent'; I'd look at the slack-jawed faces around me and think 'nah.'

You don't need a talent or to shine it to be remarkable. Just yourself.

Whichusername · 21/09/2014 13:35

Thank you all for your quick responses. The reason I use child is to not be easily identifiable. Thank you for the reassurance. I will keep praising and encourage fun side of things. Child can be very caring to friends and will always run to help when a friend falls over etc.

Child is rather shy though and probably that is what is holding child back. I will give an example. At the tennis lessons coach kept giving instructions but child couldn't exactly follow. Coach ended up using that slow patronising tone when speaking to child. Broke my heart. Pulled child out of those lessons so looking for a different class as child insists on keeping in with the lessons.

OP posts:
drbonnieblossman · 21/09/2014 13:33

The child is 5. Stop listening/taking note of other peoples children who have allegedly sat their a-levels, composed a musical piece and all in time for a 6-30 bedtime.

If your child is happy and doesn't feel a let-down at such a young age, together with encouragement will find their own path.

2minsofyourtime · 21/09/2014 13:33

How much support and encouragement do your give child, do you read to her, make list do simple maths?

Quangle · 21/09/2014 13:32

I hunk it's a myth that people just have to find their thing and then they will shine. Most of us are no better than average at most things.

Children need to have fun. And five is much too young to be worrying about their special thing. They don't even really notice yet if they are good or bad at stuff as long as it's all fun.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe2726 · 21/09/2014 13:32

Agree with the previous posters... your child is 5; plenty of time for them to experience everything and find lots that they enjoy and become good at. Slow down, it's not a race and nobody's judging you. Thanks

Aeroflotgirl · 21/09/2014 13:30

You know, I totally understand where you are coming from, dd 7 has ASD and developmental delays, and it breaks my heart that she is not like her NT peers and that ds 2.7 years, whilst a happy and sunny little boy, is delayed in speech and language and some other areas. It makes me sad that his peers are chattering away and he is still talking in baby language or not communicating at all at pre school. Why can't my kids be like other kids. Of course I don't let that show to them and praise them always.

You know what, your child is only 5, not fully developed yet, and probably is a late bloomer, will show his passions and interests later on. I had developmental delays when I was that age, not good in anything really, but I have a good BA (hons) in Psychology and MSC too and have got various hobbies which I enjoy. Enjoy your child, and don't put pressure on him, theres' enough of that in life.