Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be disappointed that my child is not clever?

138 replies

Whichusername · 21/09/2014 13:16

Academically or otherwise. Said child is 5 years old and is always at the bottom of everything child tries (dance/sport, reading & maths etc.) Ofcourse I love my child but just wish child would shine in something. Am I alone?

I must mention that I never let my feelings show. I always praise child for effort etc. Child always cries when coming last in a race game with friends. I tell child that winning is not everything and to remember to have fun. I don't think it is so much about me actually. Child always wants to win in everything but never good enough. Breaks my heart. For child's sake I hope we find something that child will truly enjoy and maybe does not involve comparing self with peers. Child will be joining musical theatre soon as enjoys singing and drama.

Any words of wisdom?

Please be kind.

OP posts:
TheWordFactory · 21/09/2014 16:39

OP even if your child did shine at everything, it wouldn't mean much at 5Grin.

When parents of children at this age used to try to show off about their DCs achievements I would always say 'how very sweet' or 'oh bless.' Because as an adult I cannot be impressed by such silliness.

As time marched on some of these wunderkind did not prove themselves exceptional . Frankly most people aren't you know. And that's cool.

Sleepswithbutterflies · 21/09/2014 16:38

I feel the same re my ds. He's also 5, young in his year 1 class as a summer born.
He's struggling with everything literacy wise. Numeracy isn't quite as bad but because he inverses his numbers gets things wrong. For example he had homework for one more and one less and for one more / less than 60 he'd written 59, 60, 61 but had inversed the 5 so it looked like 29 and so was marked as incorrect.
Reading is hopeless. Not getting anywhere fast. Writing is marginally better.
I actually don't know how children learn to read because mine has made no progress whatsoever since starting school last September. He could CVC then and that's where he is now.

fuzzpig · 21/09/2014 16:35

Oh palen that's lovely. A far bigger reason for pride than running a bit faster than some other children! What a sweetheart.

OP I kind of get what you mean. It makes me really sad that my DD struggles with maths. Really struggles (I'm starting to look into dyscalculia). It is a shame because I had these dreams about my DCs being little maths geeks like me, and of course I don't want to see her struggle and lose confidence in something. I work hard on increasing her self esteem and when there's something she can do (eg 'partitioning' which I'm sure wasn't called a fancy name when I was her age Wink) I challenge her and she relishes the chance to shine at it. I don't want her growing up thinking "I can't do maths" as that's something that stays with you.

It struck me that 5 is surely quite young for a tennis coach anyway?! Lots of children don't have the coordination or strength at that age anyway. So maybe with these things it's not that she is terrible at them, it's that she is not developmentally ready to try them - I know my DD wouldn't have enjoyed gymnastics at that age as she was all flailing limbs, but now she's gradually developed the body confidence (purely by playing at the park more, and DH getting her mattress down in the living room for DCs to tumble on) she is often wowing her friends at the things she can do, and I'm hoping to get her into gymnastics club ASAP because she is ready for it now.

The problem with trying stuff too young is that it can put them off for life if they aren't ready. Not just that activity specifically but also giving a general sense of failure. I agree with those who've suggested less competitive stuff. I think it's a real shame that so many clubs put an emphasis on competing at such a young age.

oddsocksmostly · 21/09/2014 16:34

Hi OP. Where do your and child's father's natural talents lie? There's a good chance that your child will have aptitudes for some of those.

LokiBear · 21/09/2014 16:21

Does your child think of others? Is he/she caring? Funny? Thoughtful? Silly? Easy - going? There are so many other things to feel proud of than whether your child is better at things than others.

gamescompendium · 21/09/2014 16:17

Your child is five,my Mum was worried about my brother at the same age because he wasn't such a smarty pants as me. The very wise headmaster said he would improve with age. He went on to get a PhD in maths and has a very well paid job in insurance in the city.

They are very little at this stage, some kids develop later than others, the most important thing is that you support you child and encourage them to work at things (like the tennis) that they want to be good at. There's a great banner up in our local leisure centre that says 'Allow yourself to be a beginner'. No-one is brilliant the first time they try something, but hard work and persistence and practice, practice, practice is what gets you to become an expert. Remember 10000 hours.

Whichusername · 21/09/2014 16:17

Palen, that is very touching. Your daughter sounds lovely.

Purple, I'm glad things improved for you. Did you feel labelled as 'thick'? Is there anything you feel your parents could have done differently to support you?

OP posts:
combust22 · 21/09/2014 16:14

purple- my son was exactly the same. Bottom groups in everything at age 5, struggled to learn to read, improved a great deal by the age of 8 and came romping in at high school. Some kids are late developers.

phantomnamechanger · 21/09/2014 16:13

paleninteresting I appear to have gotten something in my eye while reading that. Wow, you should be so proud of her. What an example!

Purplepoodle · 21/09/2014 16:12

I was wrote off as being thick in primary school, bottom of everything, struggled to follow instructions. Hit secondary school where they spent a year testing us to see our potential and I ended up top in everything and flew through school. I just hadn't enough maturity in primary to make the next of myself and secondary let me shine.

Aeroflotgirl · 21/09/2014 16:09

That is something paleness really lovely Smile, exactly combust

combust22 · 21/09/2014 15:50

palen- that is so touching- you DD sounds lovely. X. Having compassion for others is a far more important thing than winning a race. She showed others too what really counts in life.

Paleninteresting · 21/09/2014 15:46

My DD has a mild developmental disorder which means any skills involving motor/co-ordination takes twice as long as many other children. Being last in a race one day meant she could help a child who had fallen and they ran to the finish line hand in hand.
Not a dry eye on the field that day and that incident will be remembered longer than whoever won the race.
Sounds like your child may have similar strengths which will shape her life for years to come.

combust22 · 21/09/2014 15:44

Too young to tell at 5. Does it matter? It's nice but it's not important. My DS is extremely clever, my DD "average", but she has life skills that can't be measured. she is intuitive, empathic and very sensible.

I was at a benefit dance show to raise funds for this teenage girl:

www.careforkatielou.co.uk/

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-south-scotland-18332045

Katie Lou was a bright fun loving teenager when drowning accident saw her brain starved of oxygen for 20 minutes. She suffered severe and permanent brain damage, unable to walk, talk or even eat.

Her parents are amazing and have supported Katie Lou to a huge exttent despite their devastation.

I am sure they would love to have a "just average" daughter. If I even get the teeniest thought of wishing my DD was cleverer I sharply remind myself of Katoe Lou and how very lucky I am to have a child that is healthy and happy.

tiggytape · 21/09/2014 15:40

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

manicinsomniac · 21/09/2014 15:38

Agree with everyone else about 5 being too young to tell. Your child could be great at all sorts. Or maybe she won't be. But she will still be great at being herself and at being you daughter. Nobody else can be that and with the right guidance, she won't suffer from not being an academic high flyer or having a special skill.

I hope the musical theatre goes well. I would strongly disagree with this though:
The musical theatre sounds good. Fun, enjoyable, not competitive.

In my experience musical theatre is one of the most cut throat, competitive hobbies out there. Far worse than sport. (maybe I'm bitter as someone who dedicated their whole life to it then couldn't quite make the cut in the professional world! :p) I teach performing arts and the amount of tears and bitchiness (I like to call it passion!) it can cause is extraordinary.

My 7 year old is hopeless at maths. My 11 year old is never picked for sports teams. Neither of them care a jot about these things. But if they don't master a dance move quickly enough for their liking or are disappointed with a role they are given our house becomes shrouded in despair and frustrated dreams (I am being a little facetious here!)

ithoughtofitfirst · 21/09/2014 15:37

give your dc time, opportunities and hugs

^ that.

ithoughtofitfirst · 21/09/2014 15:36

Try not to let it bother you OP. You sound like you're giving your DC the right messages i.e. winning is not everything/having fun is what counts. I lost half of my sight at 5 and was absolutely shit at everything. I remember how great my mum and dad were though and, like you, never made me feel sub-standard in any way. I think that's the best way.

Aeroflotgirl · 21/09/2014 15:29

Well ds certainly excells in cuteness and nothing else Grin

Whichusername · 21/09/2014 15:20

I was expecting some really harsh words. Thank you all for your kind words and suggestions.

OP posts:
ElephantsNeverForgive · 21/09/2014 15:15

A lot of that sort of age DCs are fiendishly competitive, DD2 was. She threw massive tantrums if she didn't win and tried to change the rules.

I've no idea when she grew out of it because no one in the family would play board/card games with her for years, because it always ended with her storming off.

And everyone is right 5y is far too young to know what your best at, or even be good at anything.

At 5 county swimming champions can do a width or two of a splashy stroke. No one would ever guess DDs very shy DF would be county champion at another sport.

No one knows who are going to be good singers, dancers or musicians at five.

Give your DC time, opportunities and hugs.

SuburbanRhonda · 21/09/2014 15:12

OP, I wouldn't ask your DD's teacher if she is "concerned" about anything.

They've been back two weeks (maybe less for you if it's prep school) so she won't be able to answer that question yet. And you will be told of her progress at parents' evening.

As a PP has said, please don't go seeking out signs of failure in your DD.

hebe242 · 21/09/2014 15:12

My dd1 was like this. The school got them to draw a self portrait for a tea towel and my dd was a circle with a triangle! Always last in sports, reading, maths etc! She had dyspraxia, dyslexia and ADHD. I thought she was doomed but is now 15 and predicted 5 As in gcse and the rest C and above. She's still not great at sports or maths but is amazingly creative and arty. Be patient your dc is still young and there is plenty of time to blossom. X

deakymom · 21/09/2014 15:01

at age 5 my dd excelled in cuteness and nothing else she is 14 now still cute but also top of the class in many many subjects and apparently "gifted and talented" so dont write the kids off yet x

knickernicker · 21/09/2014 14:58

It's wonderful your child is kind and looks out for other children. Dd is quiet and lacks confidence to make first move in social situations. If she ever were to go up to another child and ask if they were ok, I'd be so happy.