Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be disappointed that my child is not clever?

138 replies

Whichusername · 21/09/2014 13:16

Academically or otherwise. Said child is 5 years old and is always at the bottom of everything child tries (dance/sport, reading & maths etc.) Ofcourse I love my child but just wish child would shine in something. Am I alone?

I must mention that I never let my feelings show. I always praise child for effort etc. Child always cries when coming last in a race game with friends. I tell child that winning is not everything and to remember to have fun. I don't think it is so much about me actually. Child always wants to win in everything but never good enough. Breaks my heart. For child's sake I hope we find something that child will truly enjoy and maybe does not involve comparing self with peers. Child will be joining musical theatre soon as enjoys singing and drama.

Any words of wisdom?

Please be kind.

OP posts:
StepDoor · 21/09/2014 21:18

Don't worry.

We are family full of people who have excelled academically. Ironically, the two people who left schools with just GCSEs and didn't study beyond are the ones who are now millionaires.

girliefriend · 21/09/2014 21:11

I think this is really tricky as am sure most of us would like our children to do well in life in academic as well as the social sense.

My dd appears to be following in my footsteps of being very average intelligence, can do well but will have to work at it. I find this a bit sad as I had hoped that dd might have found school and learning easier than I did.

comedancing · 21/09/2014 21:09

I found with my first D's l had him in coaching stuff far too early..more my over enthusiasm.. Violin at 5 etc!!..realised with others that they come to things later and is about having fun..my youngest D's was always quiet and shy but now at 19 he has so many friends..still quiet but seems to get on so well with people and has kept friends for years..not too majorly gifted in any area but pretty OK at most stuff and very interested in life in politics etc...l find him great company but he never won a medal in his life or got a prize...when you think of your friends they are probably like that and that's why you love them

StickEmOnTheWall · 21/09/2014 21:02

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Bulbasaur · 21/09/2014 20:57

I am good at certain things. Those are my personal strengths. But when compared to other people I measure up solidly in the middle. Not best there ever was, but certainly not shabby either.

(I'm just using "he" as default gender)

You can't compare what he's good at next to other children. You need to compare what he's good at based on his own personal strengths and weaknesses.

Kids have some natural talent, but it takes about 10,000 hours to master something. He has not yet poured 10,000 hours into something. Find out what your child loves and encourage him to keep at it just for the sake of it. If he loves doing something, with enough time he'll eventually get good at it.

The difference between a talented child and untalented child is the amount of practice and discipline they put into their craft.

HappydaysArehere · 21/09/2014 20:56

Has your little one got friends? Does he/she enjoy playing? Is school enjoyed? Is he/she healthy, lots of energy and happy? If so, the rest takes care of ltself. Still not convinced! Take a walk around Great Ormond Street.
Read lots of lovely stories, have outings, play games and talk, talk, talk. All will be well, achievements will follow naturally.

Chrysanthemum5 · 21/09/2014 20:47

OP I grew up in a very competitive, abusive environment, and as an adult I feel ill about trying new things as I don't know if I'll be good at them. And the fear of failure is crippling. I'm having counselling to deal with it becuase I worry about its impact upon the DCs. I don't want them to ever feel they are not brilliant as they are.

And recently, DS taught me an amazing lesson. He's been doing rugby for years, since he was 4 and it was every weekend. Now he's 9 his school is running rugby teams, and he's been put in the bottom team, with the boys who have never played rugby because realistically he doesn't have the aptitude for rugby. I found that incredibly hard because I felt as if all the weekends of taking him to rugby had been wasted. Then I spoke to DS and he was so excited about playing at school, and he told me he didn't care which team he was in, because he just loves it so much. And I realised he's right, and I need to respect his good sportsmanship, and positive attitude.

Your DC may never be the best at something visible like sport, or academically, but she will be the best at being her own, unique self.

Don't be too hard on yourself, but also don't worry.

SallyMcgally · 21/09/2014 20:34

DS1 was way behind at age 5 both academically and at PE. He's very dyspraxic.
He won his Primary School talent competition when he was 10 for doing a comedy routine. Top of his class at English, doing well in everything else except science and PE and loves drama. Also one of the nicest people I know.
5 is really too young to think your child isn't bright.

impatienceisavirtue · 21/09/2014 20:06

Ds1 at five was way behind all the other kids. It honestly didn't bother me at all, but I'm pretty pragmatic about stuff like that.

He's now 10, and the top of his class. At five I was absolutely sure that academics just weren't his strong point, and that was cool, he's a fantastic lad. But really it doesn't mean anything whatsoever at that age. He still has no common sense whatever but he is academically brilliant.

CSIJanner · 21/09/2014 20:01

My eldest DC dearly wants to be best at anything. Runs like Phoebe from friends, co-ordination like the stooges and cycles like a fish on a bike. But my goodness, DC can swim circles around peers. I take mine swimming every summer, lessons each week and the confidence has shot up!

It's just finding your child's niche. Eldest is swimming and reading. Youngest has a memory like an elephant and can sing! But neither of them can kick a football without an improbable trajectory that takes it out of the game. Your doing well in supporting and praise. They'll get there.

stayathomegardener · 21/09/2014 19:52

Your child could have been my child for years.
I have gone out of my way to encourage DD try the most obscure things,at 16 she is an accomplished scuba diver,photographer,model and pole vaulter.
Others would say she is poor academically and conventionally but both of us care a little less nowadays Wink

VivaLeBeaver · 21/09/2014 19:42

My dd has always been crap at stuff like running and other school sports.

At 5yo, probably up to the age of 8yo she wasn't great academically either - teacher said she was a year behind in Year 2.

Something clicked in Year 4 and she went on to pass her 11plus. She's now at secondary school and in the top sets for most subjects.

She's still crap at PE. But enjoys cycling and rock climbing and runs 5ks quite quickly. She's really, really good at art which we didnt realise until secondary school. She's got a talent for languages which again we didnt know till secondary school. She's also taken to IT like a duck to water and is teaching herself to code.

I've just tried to encourage her to follow her interests and supported her where I've been able to.

Not all kids are going to be in top sets or good at sport but I do believe all children will have something they're good at. Its just a case of finding that thing and having fun finding it.

amigababy · 21/09/2014 19:23

the dc of a friend, when at primary, was not apparently good at anything, appeared to be. "off with the faeries " so that's up till 11 yo

Discovered physics at secondary school, now has a degree, a masters in something incomprehensible, works in a v. important specialised job involving international travel etc.

Who knows what lies in future for your dc.

AlPacinosHooHaa · 21/09/2014 19:13

My gosh at 5 mine couldn't read well ( three word pages), couldn't write well, didn't win races...

now at 7 she is best at reading....in top sets....

I think you need to get into primary to get some perspective on what 5 year olds can do.

afterthought · 21/09/2014 19:12

I have a high IQ and loads of qualifications. I am however terrible at relationships and have an incredibly low opinion of myself. This had lead me to being a generally unhappy adult and I think the way I feel about myself has held me back to a greater extent than the qualifications have pushed me forwards.

Being clever doesn't matter. I would rate confidence and happiness much higher.

PS - please don't put too much emphasis on him 'trying his best'. One of my lecturers on my MEd mentioned that putting too much focus on effort does no good for children who really struggle as despite best effort they still come last which just compounds their belief that they have low ability. I have no idea if this is backed by any evidence but it makes sense. I think a much healthier approach is to emphasise enjoyment. As long as he is enjoying it, it doesn't matter where he comes.

mrswishywashy · 21/09/2014 18:22

I was that child, I was shy, I didn't excel at anything, I didn't pass many exams. Primary school I can remember coming last in running races. Going into high school I can remember the principal saying in front of me that "her grades aren't good enough to do a language", worse is when my mother agreed, I still feel the confusion about not been given the chance. High school was glum, didn't fit in to any friends groups, could skip classes and teachers wouldn't even notice. My first year at college was terrible with a warning that if I communication picked up then I wouldn't be able to continue. So I worked hard and my last two years of college I excelled the better I did the more confident I got. I graduated with high merit as an early childhood teacher. Fourteen years later and people who met me know wouldn't realise that I was terribly shy or lacked confidence but it has taken years to change my mind set.

Winning races, getting As is not what makes one happy, it's an inner feeling that we should all practice. With your little one find his special gift. Some of the children I've nannied for have been exceptional at currency, very emotionally tuned so that they are aware of others, there are 100s of things that one can excel at so help him find it.

blanklook · 21/09/2014 18:02

How many extra-curricular activities does your child do per week? I see some whose every waking minute is timetabled with activities and I feel so sorry for them because all most of them want is to spend some 1 to 1 time with one of their parents doing parent and child funstuff. Please try and factor some of that in if you don't already do so Smile

Martial arts are a good hobby to have, far from being violent, they teach self-discipline and responsibility. Individuals reach different grades and levels at their own speed but they can compete either individually or as in teams for their club etc.

RiceBurner · 21/09/2014 17:44

Apparently "grit" is one of the surest indicators of future "success" in life. Not natural ability. (Tho some natural ability/lack of physical problems will obviously help, & in some cases might be a pre-requisite.)

So, if your child can manage to stick at learning/doing something they want, (or have), to do, (however 'bad' they might be at it to start with), this (learned) "grit" might end up being a lot more useful to them (later on) than a mere high IQ or a natural 'gift'.

I also reckon that beating "yourself", (ie the desire for self-improvement) is a better measure of progress than beating "others".

Say I took part in a "5km Fun Run": I would obviously be trying to beat my own piss-poor previous time and not trying to compare myself to some marathon runner my age!

And in the world of work, effort, concentration and having long-term goals probably makes for a more valuable employee than flashes of genius, mingled with thinly-disguised boredom/lack of comitment.

I really like the fable "The Hare and the Tortoise". (Might be a good story to tell to your child, to give him/her some hope, in spite of being far behind the pack in many areas for now?)

Personally, I have seen talented people who gave up, (and under-achieved), as well as "try-hards" who slogged away and then surprised everyone by eventually becoming high achievers. So please don't despere!

Learning to come from "behind" is a really great asset for a child ... for the future. (As well as not having too much of an ego from having had things happen too easily.)

Agree that life is competitve & so it's a non-sense to say "never mind if you come last". But it's also good to know that:

a) someone always has to come last
b) taking part, (and coming last), is a lot braver than not taking part
c) coming last, (eg in the Olympic 100m final), does not necessarily mean you are bad at something
d) beating "yourself" is a better measure of progress. (As you can only do your best with what you have.)
e) slow and steady sometimes wins the (long) race!

You sound like a great mum by the way! :-)

brainfidget · 21/09/2014 17:36

EQ tends to take people further in life than IQ. IQ is great, but EQ is better.

Your little one may turn out to be fantastic at interpersonal relationships and all else that EQ entails.

Flowers for you, and Cake for your child.

Smile
TooMuchFuckingPerspective · 21/09/2014 17:34

Mine's as dosey as they come - but just wonderful, as I'm sure yours is.

On the bright side we won't have to save for her uni fees :D

LemonadeRayGun · 21/09/2014 17:32

5 is really, really young to label your child as "not clever".

spookyskeleton · 21/09/2014 17:28

I totally get where you are coming from as DS2 is in year 1 and cannot read anything more complex than CVC words and can just about write his (3 letter) name. He is reasonably ok with numbers.

I find it very difficult as DS1 (year 4) is incredibly bright and working at year 5 levels with ease in literacy and maths and is also incredibly sporty). It is so difficult not to compare them to DS2's detriment.

However DS2 shines in school plays and loves to perform so I need to harness that but drama classes are just so expensive Sad He is also incredibly kind and caring so maybe it is true that he has enhanced social skills.

notagainffffffffs · 21/09/2014 17:12

I felt like I was 'written off' as a child. Horrible feeling to be the thick one next to my genius sister.
Anyway I took something up as a hobby a coupke of years ago and have proven to be actually really really really good at it ( rather not say as I will out myself) ive built a new career around it that pays the bills and im competing in the top 10 later in the year for the uk final, ive also been invited to showcase all around europe and america.
My parents are totally flummoxed by the whole thing but are proud ive foubd my niche.
Your child will be an absolute star at something, you just have to be patient and continue to be his or her biggest fan. And remember they are 5.

drudgetrudy · 21/09/2014 17:09

I worked for many years in child and adolescent mental health and I think I learned a thing or two and radically changed my attitudes.
I was reasonably academic and my parents were very pleased about this. They praised me for achievement and pissed people off bragged about it.
They also favoured my eldest child who found academic work easier than her sister and cousins.
I took on their attitudes without too much questioning and praised and encouraged achievement.
Mistake-daughter experienced it as pressure-consequences not great.
Have seen many kids at work with dyslexia, dyspraxia, Aspergers etc and very low self-esteem. The low self-esteem mainly due to comparing themselves with others, focusing on their difficulties rather than strengths etc.

What have I learned.

  1. "Clever" is a very global and general concept. A very few people find most things easy, most people find some things easy and other things difficult and some people have to work hard at a lot of things. This is a description -not a judgement or evaluation.

  2. If you want a child to have confidence measure them against themselves-not other children. Praise effort and progress. Children develop at their own pace.

  3. Good social skills and self confidence are often more important than "shining". Some very "clever" children fall apart or become anxious. Some kids blossom late.

40 A parents job is to encourage and be a talent spotter. To find what your child is interested in. Five is often too young to tell what direction they will take.

5)It is disastrous to derive your own self-esteem from your child's achievements.
Agree with LokiBear that helping a child to develop their character will lead to greater happiness for them than comparing them to others.
Also agree that activities like Brownies, Cubs etc. may help-but again you need to try it out and see if it suits your child.

RedForsythia · 21/09/2014 16:58

How about helping child to enjoy doing things with just you there, rather than there having to be a comparison with other DC. Perhaps do some cooking together using a very child friendly recipe so child can produce something to be proud of. Help child to acheive and enjoy; forget about being the best.