Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be disappointed that my child is not clever?

138 replies

Whichusername · 21/09/2014 13:16

Academically or otherwise. Said child is 5 years old and is always at the bottom of everything child tries (dance/sport, reading & maths etc.) Ofcourse I love my child but just wish child would shine in something. Am I alone?

I must mention that I never let my feelings show. I always praise child for effort etc. Child always cries when coming last in a race game with friends. I tell child that winning is not everything and to remember to have fun. I don't think it is so much about me actually. Child always wants to win in everything but never good enough. Breaks my heart. For child's sake I hope we find something that child will truly enjoy and maybe does not involve comparing self with peers. Child will be joining musical theatre soon as enjoys singing and drama.

Any words of wisdom?

Please be kind.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
dottiedodah · 20/11/2022 08:06

Tbh no one likes losing .just learns to deal with it.5 is very young. He has years ahead.have fun with him ,encourage him to do well. Lots of activities helps .I think often children will change a year or two makes a big difference. Just enjoy the time with him it goes so fast.

Tistheseason12 · 20/11/2022 07:58

Blondewithredlips · 20/11/2022 00:28

When my DD was 5 a nasty teacher said how "ordinary" she was. To me she was wonderful.
That "ordinary" child is a doctor.

Amazing to hear about your DD!

Blondewithredlips · 20/11/2022 00:28

When my DD was 5 a nasty teacher said how "ordinary" she was. To me she was wonderful.
That "ordinary" child is a doctor.

Tistheseason12 · 20/11/2022 00:21

I wonder OP how your child turned out. I know it's been about 8 years since this thread was posted but you never know 😀

wigglesrock · 22/09/2014 12:08

God, 5 years old is very young to be worrying about being at the bottom of class is it not. My dd1 couldn't have sat through tennis lessons at 5, she couldn't ride a bike independently, swim, was only just learning to write, she's 9 now and is flying through school and the odd club.

I'm currently looking at my almost 4 year old who's trying to clip hair clips onto tongue!

minipie · 22/09/2014 11:52

why thank you croissant Smile. Yes - by definition most people will sit somewhere around the average.

It's a difficult balancing act for parents between encouraging your child to do well and giving them the opportunities to find their talents, versus expecting them to shine at something.

ouryve · 22/09/2014 11:51

I could put my 8yo in your 5yo's class and could guarantee you that you 5yo wouldn't be bottom of the class any more. Whilst I dislike competitive parenting at either end of the continuum, I do think you need a sense of perspective and to learn to love your child for who they are.

trulybadlydeeply · 22/09/2014 11:47

Why should your child be clever? Are you / your child's father high flyers? I really think you need to turn it around a bit, as I do find it concerning that you are disappointed by this. Not everyone can be high achievers, there always a good proportion of people who will be towards the bottom academically and who aren't good at sports etc. of course we need a certain amount of people in society who excel academically and take that forward into high flying careers, but we also need the rest of the population, the more "ordinary" if you like (and I use ordinary very much as a positive) who will lead happy, fulfilling lives and make vital contributions to society through their careers and their leisure pursuits.

Please just enjoy your child! Celebrate their achievements- this does not mean when they are top of the class, but for them may mean when they get 2/10 rather than 1/10 in a spelling test. Teach them not to worry about comparing themselves to others, but simply to focus on doing their best at everything. Do activities with them that are not achievement based - walks in the park kicking leaves, looking at the clouds, do some baking together. This is what will help them to grow into a well rounded, balanced, valued member of society.

Also just to add to what others have said - you really, really cannot predict at 5 whether a child is "clever" or not. My son was very much average at school for many years, badly failed his 11+ etc. After getting straight As he is now off to a top university. Two of the others struggle with learning difficulties, and the other with a significant learning disability. Whilst I celebrate my eldest son's achievement, I really have learnt that being clever is actually irrelevant, what matters is that a child is happy, healthy (as far as is possible) and is supported to achieve to the very best of their ability.

WinnieK · 22/09/2014 11:45

Whichusername - I knew a family with a youngest daughter who struggled with everything academically and where her siblings were very musical etc, she wasn't. So they bought her a pony and she went on to become a top level eventing champ. Now obviously they had pots of money and ponies weren't a problem but I thought it was interesting that they didn't try to force her to be good at the things her brothers and sisters were good at, but tried to find something just for her. But as others have said, your LO doesn't need to win stuff to be special; the fact that he/she is so good at helping others is pretty special in itself

Thecroissantthief · 22/09/2014 11:42

minipie great post.

I would add that although all the personal anecdotes on this thread about children changing to become wonderfully academic or sporty could be viewed as heartening it is the case that most people are not brilliant at anything (although that does not stop them being happy and having wonderfully fulfilling lives). If you're continually waiting for a metamorphosis of your child into a genius or even very very good at something then you might well be always disappointed in your child and that's not good in the long run.

minipie · 22/09/2014 11:27

I have great empathy for your OP as I suspect I will be disappointed if my child isn't clever/good at things... even though I know I WBU to feel that way, I still would.

Things I have taken away from this very good thread:

  1. Dance, sport, reading and maths really aren't everything. There are so many other skills - being funny, being determined, being good with people, being organised are just examples.

When it comes to the child's long term future - say, in the job market or in their future relationships - these skills will be way more important than their maths ability.

  1. Child is only 5. Plenty of time for their skills to develop. Children who were top of the class at age 5 can be totally average at at 18, and vice versa.

  2. Competitive children (like my DH was, and I suspect my DD may be) have a bit of a miserable time. (Actually I think competitive adults do too). I will be doing all I can to dissuade DD out of a competitive mindset - though I realise it's partly just down to nature not nurture.

treadheavily · 22/09/2014 11:01

It's a person's qualities that count for so much more than their academic or sporting prowess.

Being kind, funny, loyal, persistent, enthusiastic, confident, respectful, willing to take risks... these are the qualities which make a fine person, a soulmate, a great friend, a sought after employee, a popular neighbour, a leader. And no one will give two hoots what their reading level was at 5.

Your chikd needs encouragement to try and to take risks, practise in listening to instructions and following group rules, praise for effort and strides towards independence, and time to chill out at home.

Pyjamaramadrama · 22/09/2014 10:54

Sorry but yabu. Your child is only 5 and I'm very sure that he/she is clever.

Your child has years ahead to try new things and improve in certain areas. And even if he/she is never amazing at something, so what?

Example, this time last year ds couldn't ride a bike at all, even with stabilisers, he cried when I got him a new bike for his birthday because he said he was no good at riding. Later that day he reluctantly had a go and he did it, two wheels. Yesterday we went on a 4 mile bike ride. If anyone said 6 months ago we'd be going on 4 mile bike rides I'd have laughed in their face.

Another example, reception sports day he came almost last in all of his races, year one he came first.

Point is that things can change very quickly, and even if they don't and your child just coasts or even struggles through, it doesn't matter. Praise and encourage and nurture and I'm sure that your child will be just fine.

cheeseandpineapple · 22/09/2014 10:51

Since this is AIBU, YABU!

Impossible to say at this age if your child is "clever". It's a very broadly defined term.

Your child sounds like a child of great substance. He/she is determined and kind. Fantastic qualities for the future, don't assume all kids have these.

Keep encouraging him/her to have a go, not to quit and keep trying. If he/ she doesn't want to try and isn't bothered, that's when it might be disappointing. Sounds like a great kid!

morethanpotatoprints · 22/09/2014 10:51

Your dd will be fine OP, they are all like this at this age from my experience anyway.
She will find her own and when she does she will be fine. I too don't think that 5 is the age to judge intelligence or cleverness, wait until she is about 7 and you will probably by then find her leaning towards certain subjects.
My dd was always average nothing more at all, and then she started to get really good at music. Turns out she is very talented about 5 years beyond her years according to specialists.
You never know what they will be good at when they are infants, give her time and watch her interests grow.

Greengrow · 22/09/2014 10:47

Put in 10,000 hours and you can be good at just about anything. My sister always says she was very good at art because someone told her her dog drawings were good as a child so she did more and more of them and got good. My brother only decided at 15 he wanted to read medicine at Cambridge so began working very hard and did it (although he was already in a very academic private school from a young age).

It is good if a child can find something it's good at even if just being kind to others (which where atheists as much as religious people can really help their children). A good few of my children work very hard to do as little effort as possible. I remember at pre school they would seek to ensure they never reached the final of the annual learn a poem by heart competition because finalist had to learn extra poems and go to the event. Even that avoidance can be a useful life skill (although of course I would have preferred had they been vying to win top prize).

If you do want them to be good do this:

  1. Be positive, smile and happy with them. Say 5 positive things for every negative.
  2. Hear a 5 year old read to you every single day at bed time. read them a bed time story.
  3. By the time they are 6 or 7 start them on one or two music instruments and hear them practise every single day without fail.
  4. Try to get them into a very selective academic school at 5 ( we did and it worked) so they are in an environment of excellence.
  5. Then just relax - a lot of children are born, not made.

It all pans out. Our oldest who got into her selective private primary school a year young stayed down aged 6 for 2 years in the same class (she is slightly dyslexic). She is now a City lawyer on just over £100k. Her younger sister could read every book that was shown to her at her school interview when she was nearly 4 ( so about 2 years ahead of her sister in reading) and she got almost identical A level and degree results and is also a lawyer in London. In other words the early differences have not born out. That second one, the sitting around a lot reading one when she was 3 and 4 ended up in the sixth form with whole school prize for sport and plays a sport of the England team. You just cannot predict although you can certainly seek to give them opportunities.

Put in effort and it usually pays off. How often does your child see you reading and loving it? Do you read to them every night? Do they read to you every day? Do you h ear their spellings and practise times tables with them? If not they may well not thrive as much as those children whose parents do those things.

Quenelle · 22/09/2014 10:42

I understand the anxiety about your child coming last in races. DS is the same and I know I'm projecting massively by feeling so sorry for him. At this year's sports day he didn't win any stickers until the end when every child got one for taking part, and that cheered him up. I was so anxious for him beforehand though, because I knew he was old enough to notice now and get upset.

Conversely, his friend is super fast, very strong and just more developmentally mature. He has a terrible time at sports days, and playing any game really, because if he doesn't come first in everything he is distraught. I think they will probably both grow up to become more average in ability and happier as a result.

TheIronGnome · 22/09/2014 10:36

Most children don't shine at anything at 5. I certainly didn't! But I went through, got a degree (if that's your thing), enjoy many different hobbies (one of which I earn a bit of money from and also win prizes at competitions from), I rent my own flat in London and earn over £35,000. I'm generally happy, have friends and family around me and live a varied life.

If you'd have asked my parents at 5 what I shined at they probably wouldn't have known what to say. I 'found' one of my current hobbies at 9 and I suppose you could say I'm particularly good at it but I wouldnt. When I was 9 however, it stood out a lot more.

Wow that sounds like a massive stealth boast but it's not trying to be, I'm just trying to point out that for most all of my primary school career I wasn't very good at anything really, yet I've done ok out of it all.

You need to be VERY aware of how you might be projecting your thoughts onto him, even if you don't feel like you are. Facial expressions, body language etc can really influence a child and you need to make sure you're not appearing to be disappointed or concerned for him. He's just fine.

giddly · 22/09/2014 10:26

But really, will all children shine at something? I'm not sure they will. Some kids will go through life just being better or worse at certain things, but there really is no reason to assume everyone has a fantastic talent at something. And surely that's OK too, and it's about finding things your child enjoys, rather than what she's exceptionally good at.

EugenesAxe · 22/09/2014 10:19

A really inspiring thread. OP personally I understand where you are coming from, and do not think YABU. Sometimes it can be wearing trying to keep repeatedly positive in the face of your DC's disappointment.

Didn't really have a thought on remedial myself, but dictionary says 'giving or intended as a remedy or cure', so could imply a child in remedial education is somehow broken, or 'wrong', which of course they aren't.

areyoutheregoditsmemargaret · 22/09/2014 09:55

My dd1 was like this at 5, she's dyspraxic and was very shy

She's nearly 10 now, has a beautiful singing voice and is in all sorts of special choirs etc. She's also turning into a good actor. She shines academically in some subjects, despite appalling handwriting and spelling, is bottom in others. She has loads of friends.

5 is too young to worry, though I understand your concerns as I had similar. Just be loving and encouraging and all will be well

bette06 · 22/09/2014 09:41

I was always a bit rubbish at sport as a child (and now!) and last to be picked for the teams at school but I enjoyed sport outside school partly because I went to a club where you worked for individual badges/awards rather than doing competitions. Lots of sports and activities are (or can be) organised like this and it means that every child has something to work towards and will have successes that can be celebrated. It also meant that the kids in the class weren't competing against each other and actually helped each to improve and learn the next skill.

I also think it's good to do something a bit different, rather than an activity that all his/her classmates do too, as it makes it their special thing which they will end up being better at doing.

ToysRLuv · 22/09/2014 00:58

DS is 5 and can read anything. G&T for that. Good at maths too. However, he can't write or draw to save his life. He hates practicing and failing at anything, gives up easily. So when everyone else cathes him up at reading, he will be "just" average again, as he won't put the work in. Maybe he will change as he matures, but only time will tell. I try not to worry about his quirks and full on personality, but it's hard not to.

writtenguarantee · 22/09/2014 00:04

I think I was considered thick until about 7. I have very few memories before then. I can confidently say I am not thick now nor considered thick by anyone.

He/she is only 5. They can take some time to grow into themselves.

somewherewest · 21/09/2014 22:09

We had the opposite problem in my family. My mother was one of those rare children who excelled effortlessly at almost anything they turn their hand to not a trait I inherited, which meant she never really learnt to stick at anything. My aunt is much more 'average', but achieved more in the long run because she learnt patience and persistence growing up.

Swipe left for the next trending thread