Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Football in back gardens - serious debate!

89 replies

Cherryad3 · 03/07/2014 17:43

Hi, this is my first post - I am genuinely curious as to what is and what is not deemed unreasonable regarding the playing of football in a back garden.

I have one child who is 4. Next door have 3 boys of 8, 9 and 10 and now the weather is nicer they are predictably in their back garden kicking a large leather football around and about...often up until 9pm and sometimes later.

While I appreciate it is lovely that children are enjoying fresh air and exercise, at what point does this become harassment to neighbours. I am talking about the same heavy ball hitting my child hard in the face, squashing my carefully cultivated pot plants and garden shrubs and generally causing horrid noise and damage to 6ft fence as it bangs against it on a regular basis.

Should neighbours such as myself just tolerate such inconvenience as part of life and keep passing the ball back so that it can be kicked in again at a later date.

I know this is an issue for many many people - some the owners of little footballers and some the neighbours of them - I feel like there should be an official guideline on what is and is not acceptable...what do you think?!

OP posts:
dancingwithmyselfandthecat · 04/07/2014 15:36

dogs barking is different from football because the dogs are in your garden, not bouncing a ball against a fence and kicking it over damaging property! Granted if the dogs were constantly making noise or doing so at night, I'd be peeved at a neighbour but dog ownership doesn't mean you can never complain about someone's inconsiderate and damaging behaviour.

Really surprised at how many people seem to think football against fence or kicking over is ok. My sisters and I would have got a right telling off and even in our fairly large garden weren't allowed hard balls. My nieces and nephews threw a frisbee over when I was over last weekend, and even though their neighbour was nice about it my sister made them play with something else. (And my sister is very far from perfect and a long way down the I am entitled because I have kids road).

Cherryad3 · 04/07/2014 15:28

Thanks again for all the replies - it sounds like there are a lot of garden users who do find the heavier balls against their boundaries and landing in their gardens a real nuisance.

I take the point about suggesting a softer ball - however I feel that parents of the footballers should really consider these options once the issue has already been raised by neighbours with damaged property.

I also take the point that there are lots of other actions people do in their gardens that cause inconvenience - as outlined by Tumbles..however given how simple it would be to avoid upsetting neighbours with footballs it would be nice if more people took this on board.

Hugest sympathies with everyone affected by the issue - I think unless you have sat on the other side of a boundary that you paid for (makes it worse if it is your expensive fence being battered) and had your child hit and your plants squashed then you don't understand the stress it can induce.

Staywithme - to have it on all 3 boundaries..eek, hope you get to enjoy your garden this summer xx

Oh - and Dancingwithmeandthecat - maybe you should run for prime minister - I would vote for you - what a reasonable set of guidelines you suggest :-)

OP posts:
BumpNGrind · 04/07/2014 15:27

I do think that some families aren't considerate of their neighbours and think that because they have children, they are entitled to make as much noise as possible. I was brought up in a terraced house and there's no way that I would have been allowed to bounce a ball constantly against the neighbours wall or fence.

There are certain unspoken rules you try and follow if you live near other people, you notify your neighbours if your having a bbq in the garden when they have a line full of washing for example, or you try and make sure that noise is curtailed during certain times, if you live in a flat you don't put your washing machine on at unsociable times unless it's absolutely necessary etc.

Staywithme · 04/07/2014 15:04

My dogs only bark because they bounce the ball of the fence! Didn't I just state that? I DON'T have a problem with kids playing in their garden, I've brought up three kids, and if you'd read what I wrote you would see that my issue is with the balls that come over 3/4 days and the damage to my fence! Why should I have to accept that? I don't know why you seem hell bent on only picking out what suits your argument. Can't be bothered explaining myself further on this topic!

MrTumblesBavarianFanbase · 04/07/2014 14:46

Stay the sound of your dogs in no way impacts anyone?

Some families who allow garden football may be horrible and aggressive, so may the kids, and so may many families who don't allow garden football but smoke near a boundry, have loud/ late parties (or ones that seem loud and late to attached neighbors with light sleeping small kids), some may park inconsiderately but not illegally, some may do building work that is legal but causes noise or dust or access inconvenience....

Kids playing football in their own garden is a normal part of life in a residential area - but of course parents should be receptive to a neighbor politely asking them to make the kids use an appropriate softer ball and take reasonable measures to ensure it doesn't go over the fence most of the time.

Staywithme · 04/07/2014 14:38

Miaow

Grin they sound like me at the bowling ally. I sometimes think if I tried to deliberately miss the ions I might actually hit them!

Staywithme · 04/07/2014 14:35

Mrtumbles, I'm not saying that the use of my garden should trump the neighbours, but when I'm in my garden I don't want to have to duck every time a ball comes over the fence or worry that it might hit one of my two very tiny dogs. The little boy behind my house 'occasionally' knocks his ball into my garden and I used to go out and throw it back, but now I throw it back when I'm doing something in the garden. He's a lovely wee boy and the houses behind have very small gardens so I don't mind the occasional ball coming over.

However the two beside me seem to have copious amounts off balls and they would come over 3/4 times a day. I've already had to replace a fence panel at my own expense as the parents are unapproachable. I can't sit in my garden when they're playing football because they like to kick the ball at the fence to make it bounce and the noise is horrible and sets my dogs off. When these things are happening they are not simply playing in THEIR garden but impacting on my use off MY garden. When I go out to my garden it in NO way impacts on them! So tell me how me using my garden trumps them?

WhoKnowsWhereTheTimeGoes · 04/07/2014 12:25

Oh and the neighbour's garden consists of lawn and patio only, no pots or plants that could be damaged, so the sponge balls really are pretty safe.

WhoKnowsWhereTheTimeGoes · 04/07/2014 12:22

Our balls go over all the time, that is one drawback of sponge balls, they travel a long way and are somewhat unpredictable. Also the fence is only about a metre high and our garden is narrow. Any that land within about 5' of the boundary I hook back with a beach fishing net, those that go further are sent back by the neighbour, but we don't go banging on the door for them, he just pops them back next time he goes out in the garden.

MiaowTheCat · 04/07/2014 12:10

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

dancingwithmyselfandthecat · 04/07/2014 09:52

Oh, and don't throw balls back. If they come knocking, tell them you will return all balls once a day at 9pm. That'll teach them.

dancingwithmyselfandthecat · 04/07/2014 09:50

General sound of noise in garden, including football = ok during the day. 9 o'clock at night is getting towards the late side but not a problem in itself unless it is seriously rowdy.

Sound of football/tennis ball being kicked against fence = not ok at any time of the day. Fence is usually marker between two properties, to keep them separate and private. Repeated kicking against fence risks damage to it. Even if fence is wholly owned by parents of football kickers, this isn't fair on neighbours.

Footballs coming into garden - not ok unless once in a blue moon. It's an intrusion into my space and can be extremely unpleasant. (General principal of live and let live - not disrupting what boys do in THEIR garden but I want to sit in my OWN garden without balls flying at my face.)

Never ok to damage someone else's property in the course of a game, so no hard or leather footballs in a garden unless its so big that there is no risk of this. Same goes for playing in the street.

Playing football in park: absolutely fine but remember its a public space. This means do your best to set up game away from the mum and baby group and the couples sunbathing and reading. Under no circumstances use locations of said groups/couple to mark your goal. Leather balls fine but if you can't kick one with enough control to avoid hurting people or damaging property then use a foam ball.

General principle: if in doubt, give your kids a foam or soft ball and make sure they avoid intruding on others. Sets them up for life well with good lessons about compromising and being considerate. Anyone who complains about kids playing like this is a grinch, and that includes me. (Unless it's past ten and they are shattering glass with their whooping and hollering.)

Sorted. Everyone can enjoy the great outdoors. Even in a crowded city on a crowded island it really isn't that difficult.

RuddyDuck · 04/07/2014 09:23

If the children are 8, 9 and 10 then they should be going to the the local park to play football. My ds2 was a keen footballer, and we have quite a large garden, but from the age of about 8 we said he needed to go to the park if he wanted to play, as the risk of annoyance to the neighbours was quite high.

Unfortunately we had a neighbour who had a different approach. Her garden was very small, so not at all suitable for playing football, but she didn't like her ds playing in the park in case there were rough children there as she was a snob so allowed him to kick his ball endlessly at the wooden fence between our gardens. Drove me absolutely bonkers.

MrTumblesBavarianFanbase · 04/07/2014 09:12

Stay but why does your choice of how to use your garden trump the neighbor children's choice of how to use their garden?

The ball should not be coming over the fence more than once in a blue moon, and it is reasonable to request they use a softer ball which miggt be quieter and will do little potential damage, but the sound of a football - yes, that is hust the price you pay for living in a residential area where people live close together.

Undercurrent · 04/07/2014 09:11

As other posters have said - only return the ball to a parent. If you have to be disturbed, they do too. Their parents will soon get sick of it.

BumpNGrind · 04/07/2014 09:06

I hate the noise of the ball next door. My neighbours dc seem quarantined to the house even though they are old enough to go to the brand new leisure centre around the corner by themselves and there are plenty of children in our cul de sac who all play together in the grassed area directly opposite my house. I feel like I cant sit in my own garden as the constant thud of the ball, being hit or my flowers being squashed is annoying. I would like some peace and quiet.

Staywithme · 04/07/2014 09:04

I'm shocked at the number of posters who think that the OP should just put up with it because 'they' think it's ok to listen to the sound of a football bouncing of a wall/fence! So because you think it's ok then we should just suck if up, because that's what kids do! Why should the OP lose the enjoyment of her garden because the next door neighbours want to play football? If your behaviour, or in this case your children's behaviour, is impacting on other people then surely it's good manners to take that into consideration?

Lonecatwithkitten · 04/07/2014 09:01

I have found a method of reducing the number of items that some over my fence is only to return them when it suits me. This was after my front door bell was rung 7 times in one hour.
When I potter round my garden I return all balls, frisbees and arrows to next door, but it maybe three or four days till they get them. Arrows sometimes are damaged beyond repair Grin.

MiaowTheCat · 04/07/2014 08:48

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

BranchingOut · 04/07/2014 08:34

I would buy a decent sponge ball as a good will gesture and take it round to them, asking that they use that in future.

If the leather ball still comes over then keep it for a loooong time.

Is trellis on top of the fence a possibility?

MrTumblesBavarianFanbase · 04/07/2014 06:48

Its not only boys who play football Hmm my nearly 9 year old DD has been on a team since she was 5 - trains twice a week, tournaments once or twice a month, just as likely as her brothers to be out playing football with the neighbor kids (boys and girls) for hours.

Poor 4 year old if he OR she is not allowed to kick a ball about unless taken to the park - which I'm betting doesn't happen daily.

OP can't you ask your neighbor to have her children use a softer ball (sponge or plastic) emphasising that it comes over the fence a lot and has hit your child
and damaged things - if your neighbor is at all
reasonable he/she will make that change, because it is a logical request - just complaining or commenting without a specific request, or asking that the children not be allowed to play in their own garden would be unreasonable and most likely get you nowhere.

DejaVuAllOverAgain · 03/07/2014 21:22

It may be accidental that doesn't make it acceptable.

The OP's DS does have the right to play in his own garden without risk of being hit by a heavy leather football. The OP also has the right not to have her plants damaged. They should be playing with a sponge ball or some alternative that is less likely to cause damage and should also be taught not to hit it so hard that it constantly goes over the fence.

Why does the alternative have to be computer games? Do some people have no imagination? There are other games that can be played other than football or computer games.

WhoKnowsWhereTheTimeGoes · 03/07/2014 20:51

My 10 yo DS is obsessed with ball games, but we only allow sponge footballs in the garden, the leather ones are for park use only. I'm proud of my garden and don't want it destroyed, not to mention the neighbours, who are really good about sending them back over the fence several times a week.

Mine do play out till getting on for 9 at this time of year, but there are no younger children nearby and they are made to keep the noise down, screaming is not permitted at any time. Altogether I think this makes it reasonable.

Don't say you will only let yours play it in the park, it is great to be able to just send them out to kick a ball about any time of the day, it can be managed reasonably.

Montegomongoose · 03/07/2014 20:40

If your child is a boy you should think on, he might get invited next door to play football with the boys when he's a bit older.

I'd say YABU.

It's accidental, not deliberate vandalism.

If they've hit your child, let then know to be careful.

I love the noise of kids playing football in gardens.

TheFairyCaravan · 03/07/2014 20:40

cricketballs I don't have 4 yo's I have a 19.5yo and a 17.5yo, both boys, both liked playing football. Neither were allowed to kick a ball against a fence at any time of the day because it pissed me off least of all 9pm or later! If they wanted to play football they had to do it away from the neighbour's fences, if they couldn't do that they had to go to the park or do something else!