Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

to think the 'common law/freeman on the land' thing is a whole load of bollocks?

794 replies

qwertypop · 01/06/2014 20:10

I've come across a few people over the last few years that take it very seriously and bang on at length about how the police and courts have no authority over them as they are self declared 'freemen'. Something to do with common law being the only true law in Britain, I think? And not having to wear bike helmets or pay for TV licenses or repay your debts also seem important to the ones I've had the dubious pleasure of meeting.

A couple I met at the weekend have taken the biscuit though and not registered their baby's birth because apparently this will mean said baby grows up to be a 'freeman' (she's actually a girl but the term appears to be freeman anyway). They believe quite firmly that to register her birth will mean that the law assumes her and her name (which is a fucking corker, of course) are one and the same and that only by NOT registering her birth can she be free to be a human being. Quite what this actually means is a mystery to me and tbh the mumbo jumbo they gave me by way of an answer leads me to suspect they don't really know either Hmm

I've tried to read up on it but all the info I can find is written in a style you'd expect of an paranoid, delusional, and possibly hallucinating chimpanzee let loose with a legal dictionary.

So AIBU to think this is bollocky woo of the most fucking ridiculous type? Or is someone going to come along and actually enlighten me as to wtf its all about, preferably in plain English with no pseudo-legalese?

OP posts:
FundamentalistQuaker · 03/08/2015 16:51

'No implied right of access' is the law anyway, surely? Putting it on a notice doesn't change anything.

FundamentalistQuaker · 03/08/2015 16:51

"can anyone tell me if the court procedure used is still from the County Court Act 1984?"

Bits of it possibly, but the County Court and the High Court and Court of Appeal now use the same set of rules- the Civil Procedure Rules. The Supreme Court does too but additionally has its own set of rules for some things.

Unwritten law still matters, usually only as a guide to general principles and values. Judges swear an oath to try cases fairly 'according to the laws and usages of this realm'.

LisaMed · 03/08/2015 16:39

I don't mind the licence fee as I shamelessly take advantage of the subsidised programmes like Last Night of the Proms, Remembrance Festival at the Albert Hall, the educational stuff etc. I don't watch much commercial stuff apart from Doctor Who.

Coffeemarkone · 03/08/2015 16:34
  • I was thinking about the BBC goons re the TV licence....
LisaMed · 03/08/2015 16:31

Coffeemarkone I think that if the FMOTL was true then there would be widespread forums/websites/blogs and there would be people happily sharing the details for free.

I am tempted by the 'no implied right of access' but as I only ever really get a postman, and the ones round here are lovely, it would be a bit pretentious.

LisaMed · 03/08/2015 16:27

One interesting point - Anglo Saxon law codes were published in English as well as Latin and court procedings were in a language everyone understood. That obviously changed with the Norman Conquest, but cases were heard in English relatively soon after the conquest. I had in mind that it was during the time of Henry IV or V but when I was looking up the dates the Act goes back to 1362.

I suspect that means that since at least 1362 there has been a man in a pub/inn/tavern who had heard about this thing where if you followed this particular rule then you would get off, happened to his mate's cousin, honest...

Coffeemarkone · 03/08/2015 16:19

" I think that the FMOTL movement isn't about liberty or individualism. It isn't about challenging unfair laws. I suspect it is about otherwise disadvantaged people trying to find a way that they are smarter than the rest of us and buying into what is nothing to do with law or history but is hokum. "

I think that is a fair analysis tbh. Any FMOTL types that I have met have been the types to tell you all about their superior knowledge, you know, the kind of people that do that long blink while they are talking to you?

However I think that some of their ideas could be useful to the rest of us, such as putting a 'no implied right of access' notice on your front door.

LisaMed · 03/08/2015 16:15

RedDaisyRed sorry I was using 'English History' in the sense of a historian. The Anglo Saxons arrived in 449 according to Bede and while many academic papers have been written about this, they were probably here some time after AD 300 and sometime before AD 550. That is where I would take the start of English (not British) history, and as I understand it the common law came out of traditions that have been identified as Germanic and thus coming over with the Anglo Saxons (I'm willing to be put right on that). A legal code was one of the first written items when general literacy came over with Christianity.

According to some Roman writers, the Druids did not allow Pre-Roman law to be written down although they used writing for other purposes. There was a class of people that memorised the law and were required to declare it. There has always been social sanction to balance the 'do as I say or I'll beat you up'.

The oral tradition of law carried on for a long time after the first law codes (which were mainly compensation lists and matters concerning the church) and tradition played a massive part all the way through the Anglo Saxon and Norman periods. Local history played a part as well, and legal traditions continued for a long time to vary between the old Anglo Saxon kingdoms and the areas previously under Viking rule.

However the proliferation of laws mean that most of the times people would have used tradition have been superseded by written law. The law in England originally and then England and Wales has become more and more standardised. For example, gavelkind was a type of legal proceedings that referred to land and was mainly confined to Kent. It has been held up as a tradition from the time of the Anglo Saxon conquest. It was superseded in 1925.

People have always been able to refuse to obey written laws, but there have always been sanctions. I err on the side of the libertarian, but I think that the FMOTL movement isn't about liberty or individualism. It isn't about challenging unfair laws. I suspect it is about otherwise disadvantaged people trying to find a way that they are smarter than the rest of us and buying into what is nothing to do with law or history but is hokum.

Re the presenting of strange documents - can anyone tell me if the court procedure used is still from the County Court Act 1984? Doesn't that set out how stuff should be presented?

RedDaisyRed · 03/08/2015 12:24

it is not true to say we have had written laws in most of English history. There have been humans in England even back to the time when were joined to France and there was no writing.

Every person decides what laws they obey in any state and I obviously encourage people to obey laws just as it makes sense in communes if people obey the rules as it makes life simpler but it is for each person to decide what is right for them. The UK still has English common law. As I said above it's our greatest export and is the foundation for US laws, Australian and many other places.

It is not an easy life to try to live outside regulation surveillance and the law in England and I don't recommend it to anyone but it's up to them if they want to try it. If you want to be more lawless there are places with more space and less efficient states where you would do better. People like the Amish escaped Swiss persecution to move to the less regulated US. Thjere were Scots in Patagonia. There are groups in New Zealand although it's probably harder to get lost there. Mind you we've masses of illegal immigrants who operate off the radar so it's probably not that hard even in England.

syne · 03/08/2015 10:47

I found this really interesting. Too weird for The Wire,
www.washingtonmonthly.com/features/2008/0805.carey.html

A bizzare use of the founding ideas that went on to form most of the basis for freeman ideals in order to beat the death penalty.

The main problem with the freeman ideals isn't that it's batshit crazy, It's just that it's a few centuries too late. It's what led to the formation of the laws in the first place that we have now in order to try to protect the 'weaker' members of society.
The 'wear a wolf's head' is what the freeman would like -without the lopping off part- but it's nigh on impossible to integrate a 'freeman' within an organised society, which in it's very nature is a constricting and therefore not free environment.
The only way to achieve that, as mentioned earlier is with a large army at your rear which would somewhat defeat the point.

I have my own -longer- theories and opinions on freeman ideology which I might post up later if I can be arsed.

HarveySchlumpfenburger · 03/08/2015 09:40

Please, please try and get your unregistered self into another country without valid ID and claim to immigration officials they can't restrict your movement. And let me know so I can be there.

I'll refer you back to Spero's video as an example of what might happen.

ComposHatComesBack · 03/08/2015 06:44

There's no 'think' about it, the freeman on the land thing is bollocks as has been proved countless times in court.

However telling its adherents that their views are based as they are based on a fundamentally unsound understanding of history and the law is a waste of time as they are convinced they are victims of a massive conspiracy to rob them of their rights they'll derride you as a mug or as part of the system.
Unfortunately there are enough fellow loonies out there spreading this guff that they get caught in an echo chamber in which their views are defect back to them.
I encountered exactly the same thing on a thread on conspiracy theories, which attracted every tinfoil hat merchant on mumsnet, who didn't understand that the unreferenced, unsourced ravings of a fellow conspiracy theorist wasn't proof of anything. I gave up in the end as any attempt to counter their claims were met with variants of 'but that's what they want you to think' or more conspiracy websites.

fastdaytears · 03/08/2015 06:29

Rags I stand corrected! Still not sure that the latest poster was going to get the help she was looking for here.

HeartsTrumpDiamonds · 03/08/2015 02:29

There are some corners of MN where I swear I have wandered over to the dark side. Honestly do these nutters really exist in everyday life??

LisaMed I've learned a ton from you as well - thank you Flowers

DioneTheDiabolist · 03/08/2015 01:38

And no Giddy.Sad Your sentence is not the longest sentence on MN.

But keep trying pet. And you know what? One day you may get there.Smile

DioneTheDiabolist · 03/08/2015 01:33

Now I know that MN is subject to Justine's law.
Too right. And believe me Giddy she's a bitch. But we all accept her as a product of her environment. Her granny is terrifying! A local girl done good, if you will.

Thank fuck she is subject to the law. Just as you and 1Buntu are Giddy. Under the laws of this land, you are all equal. Doesn't that make you heave a sigh of relief?

TheBlessedCheesemaker · 03/08/2015 01:30

Has Henry III's law against the deliberate maiming of fairies ever been repealed? I think we should be told.

GiddyOnZackHunt · 03/08/2015 00:51

Well Lisa bless you for raising some very pertinent points. Now I know Mumsnet is subject to Justine's Law rather than that of England & Wales, so I do wonder whether the statement "Oh do piss off with your half assed internet bollocks of freemen on the land and test it in law when some fucker burgles your tent because you surely as fuck don't live in a house owned by someone who subscribes to conventional law like your parents " would be deleted.
And do I get a prize for sentence length?

DioneTheDiabolist · 03/08/2015 00:36

Lisamed, I love your passion for history, which has really come through on this thread. I have learned a huge amount from your posts. Thank you.SmileThanks

But sleep is really good important. Sleep well Lisa, knowing that you have taught us a lot about Canon law, Statuatory law, Common law, AngloSaxon law and the history of being a person on this patch of land.

You're class. Sweet dreams.Grin

RagstheInvincible · 03/08/2015 00:23

This is a thread about this FM thing on a site full of people who know nothing about it. 90% of the replies are people saying that this all sounds batshit.

No, the replies are saying it IS batshit and a number of posters have given links to legal cases explaining why this is so.

RagstheInvincible · 03/08/2015 00:17

Was FMOTL a reaction/result of common law?

FMOTL is a load of made up rubbish, with no basis in either law or fact. Those who believe in the FMOTL doctrine are (and I'm being charitable here) deluded.

LisaMed · 03/08/2015 00:11

This is the only thread where I have really used bad language, and I should have been in bed two hours ago.

LisaMed · 03/08/2015 00:09

I wonder, if the FMOTL is right, and they waved their pieces of paper and the judge said, okay then, fuck off but you don't have to pay your council tax, I wonder then if this FMOTL was defrauded of their life savings, would they be able to take it to court, or would they be fucked as they don't recognise the court so it can't help them.

Or if an angry lynch mob of two hundred legal and historical professionals came and beat them senseless and torched their house, what could they do? If they weren't part of the legal system? If they didn't want to be part of the system that had police and a fire service, would they have any protection?

LisaMed · 03/08/2015 00:05

Dione The whole idea that you can live in a country without being part of the country's legal system is quite frankly deluded. There is no country in the world that would accept that someone occupying space within their borders would be allowed to opt out.

I think it was mentioned up thread. The fancy background for the FMOTL movement isn't to impress the judges, who will just get irritated, nor the court staff who will get seriously irritated, nor any legal representation of the other side, who will be frankly delighted to have this as a defense against them. It is to impress those who pay money to get the 'secret'. Because it doesn't work.

What is hard is that someone may get sucked into this, and so fail to make the right defences or the right applications and so not only lose a case but also get stung with massive costs when they may have won the case if they had actually used the right procedure.

LisaMed · 02/08/2015 23:59

After the Norman Conquest there were three types of law. There was Cannon Law which isn't really relevant here. There was the law of those who were 'free'. This meant those who were not serfs. This meant that it was a very small amount of people who had to be bound by the law of the king's court and his judges That's what being free in Feudal England usually came down to - the right to be heard in the king's court. This meant the right to trial by jury and generally had judges who knew what the law was and who understood what was going on. The third type of law was manorial law which only applied if you were not free. The feudal lord who owned the serfs heard the legal arguments about who didn't do the ploughing they were supposed to and who got drunk and tried to steal a pig etc and dealt out judgements and punishments. At it's worst, it was 'do as I say or I'll cut you're hands off'. In England and Wales crimes such as murder were always heard in the king's court whether you were free or unfree.

There was still no loophole that said that you could avoid taxes. Free and unfree were taxed differently, but they were still taxed.

Swipe left for the next trending thread