Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

to think the 'common law/freeman on the land' thing is a whole load of bollocks?

794 replies

qwertypop · 01/06/2014 20:10

I've come across a few people over the last few years that take it very seriously and bang on at length about how the police and courts have no authority over them as they are self declared 'freemen'. Something to do with common law being the only true law in Britain, I think? And not having to wear bike helmets or pay for TV licenses or repay your debts also seem important to the ones I've had the dubious pleasure of meeting.

A couple I met at the weekend have taken the biscuit though and not registered their baby's birth because apparently this will mean said baby grows up to be a 'freeman' (she's actually a girl but the term appears to be freeman anyway). They believe quite firmly that to register her birth will mean that the law assumes her and her name (which is a fucking corker, of course) are one and the same and that only by NOT registering her birth can she be free to be a human being. Quite what this actually means is a mystery to me and tbh the mumbo jumbo they gave me by way of an answer leads me to suspect they don't really know either Hmm

I've tried to read up on it but all the info I can find is written in a style you'd expect of an paranoid, delusional, and possibly hallucinating chimpanzee let loose with a legal dictionary.

So AIBU to think this is bollocky woo of the most fucking ridiculous type? Or is someone going to come along and actually enlighten me as to wtf its all about, preferably in plain English with no pseudo-legalese?

OP posts:
Micqdc · 03/06/2014 14:02

SlowlorisIncognito - the bill of right was a statutory copy of the declaration of rights. written by the king at the time.
they changed the wording a lot but the original is still their and is still in full force.

Lilymaid · 03/06/2014 14:00

I love these threads with loony bollocks and great spelling mistakes -
Cannon Law (boom boom) - Canon Law
Statue - Statute
Petrel (stormy?) - Petrol??
Repel - Repeal
As someone pointed out on the UK Human Rights Blog:"You can’t reason someone out of a position that they didn’t reason themselves into"

Perhaps we should have a Rawlsian debate on rights and duties rather than constant reference to Magna Carta, a document that was for the benefit of the barons rather than the people.

Micqdc · 03/06/2014 13:55

what happens to some dogs when you give them a bone and an hour later you try to take it off the?
they get made and bark at you.

a society by definition "A society is a number of persons united together by mutual consent, in order to deliberate, determine, and act jointly for some common purpose" so if you wanted to creat a society with other people where you wont have private property then fine go ahead, that would be a rule which will be apart of that society.

also notice how that definition does not say its a geographic location, so people who are saying to leave the country then you should take note of that.

legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/society

SlowlorisIncognito · 03/06/2014 13:54

As I understand it though, with statute laws, the most recent law takes precedence (unlike common law where older judgements usually take precedence). This means that any laws passed since the Magna Carta have precedence over it. It's not a special document like the US constitution which has to be changed through special process. Every law passed since the Magna Carta or the Bill of Rights can contradict them.

For example, the Bill of Rights said there could be no royal interference with the right of people to have arms. However, since then, laws have been passed restricting the ownership of weapons. These laws have precedence, because they are more recent.

Trying to apply historical laws to today's legal systems simply don't work, and if you want to avoid things like tax, you usually need to find an expensive accountant who can help you out with all the legal loopholes.

Tbh, stuff like this is why we should be teaching more about how the legal system works in schools.

desertgirl · 03/06/2014 13:44

Micqdc, how on earth does not taking property form part of 'natural law' (as you describe it) when not all societies actually had a concept of property ownership?? It's totally culturally specific.

LRDtheFeministDragon · 03/06/2014 13:40

I know, I was kidding.

NigellasDealer · 03/06/2014 13:40

and did you mean 'was not' rather than 'want'?
sorry to be picky but...

Micqdc · 03/06/2014 13:38

LRDtheFeministDragon - I meant repealed

LRDtheFeministDragon · 03/06/2014 13:32

What's repelling a law, then?

Micqdc · 03/06/2014 13:31

the magna carta want a statute it was a royal charter they the government couldn't touch so they copied it into a statue so you can repel it.

you people actually believe that all tax money goes to roads and all that.
read the declaration of right its says in their that the royal family is responsible to pay for the army.

as for roads you pay 60% petrel tax which pays for that roads, everything else is paid by import tax and tax like that not income tax and council tax.

do you really want books on all this?
their is loads written by people this me but if you want some from history then watch this video he shows all the books that confirms everything he says.

calculatorsatdawn · 03/06/2014 13:28

sorry, my spelling on the last thread was awful probably from the laughing

LisaMed · 03/06/2014 13:28

LRDtheFeministDragon I know, I know. I just read stuff that's for popular consumption and I know that in England no-one got exempt from taxes.

I suppose they could try in France where there were a load of immunities and areas of private law in the Middle Ages, but I suspect that they wouldn't be able to get past the Code Napoleon. Those immunities never applied in England.

It's just cobblers, really. According to the judge in Canada (who sounded really sensible, grounded and lovely) a lot of this is sold by people to those who are getting done for eg driving four wheel drives in areas of special scientific interest and they are really fancy and complicated and ornate not to impress the court but to impress the person buying the toilet paper this stuff is written on.

I think that the Moon landings were real as well.

calculatorsatdawn · 03/06/2014 13:27

DP is a scientist and often sends me article that falls into the category of 'not even wrong' (I send him a birilliant one that other day about the effect of eating clay). first time as a lawyer that I've been able to send him a link to something legal to respond in kind Grin

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Not_even_wrong

LRDtheFeministDragon · 03/06/2014 13:26
Grin

It does come over, just a hint of it under your tone of sweet reason.

It's brilliant.

LisaMed · 03/06/2014 13:21

Can people tell that I don't like this sort of woolly thinking. I hardly ever swear on Mumsnet (you can check) and I usually am a bit on the pink and fluffy side, but I don't like seeing History being treated like this.

I'm going away to have a calming cup of chamomile tea. However all bets are off if anyone mentions the Magna Carta (aka fucking statute law)

LRDtheFeministDragon · 03/06/2014 13:20

But, but ... also, free men doesn't mean not having to pay taxes or anything like that, does it? I mean, I'm a medievalist who knows fuck all about the law but I do know that. It's not just that it doesn't have an equivalent. It doesn't mean 'free' in the sense of 'able to fuck off and do what you please'.

LisaMed · 03/06/2014 13:17

We are subject to the law not because of a contract but because of an accident of birth.

Not paying income tax means that those who are vulnerable have less support as the amount available is reduced. There are a shedload of other implications but one thing I feel okay about is knowing that part of my income tax is going towards supporting people who cannot support themselves. I hope I never have to access disability support, but I am glad that my income tax makes that support available, such as it currently is.

I suspect the whole idea of the contract is looking at the theory of feudal law (as opposed to the actual practice) where there was indeed a contract between free men. Free men in the Middle Ages had a very technical meaning and did not apply to the majority of the population. It is so irrelevant to today's society that it has no equivalent. However as the whole system of feudal dues was abolished then the idea of the contract between lord and vassals disappeared at the same time. At no time during the feudal period in England were any of the lords free from statute law and after 1215 there was a general agreement that even the sovereign was subject to the law of the land. You know, things like you have to pay road tax and have a driving licence. Stuff that is in Statutes.

I can't believe I am dignifying these arse apple arguments with a considered post.

LRDtheFeministDragon · 03/06/2014 13:13

Well, uh, yeah, paying tax does harm the people you're effectively stealing from! Hmm

lisa, I think I love you.

I also love the 'was it a book written in fucking crayon'. Grin

PleaseJustShootMeNow · 03/06/2014 13:09

Where the actually fuck do you get that deluded idea from? Was it a book written in fucking crayon?

What a brilliant response to nonsense. I'm filing that away for my own personal use in future dealings with my mother.

LisaMed · 03/06/2014 13:06

I'm not legally trained, but I'm familiar with a lot of it, and I got all nostalgic reading that document from Judge Rooke in Canada. I miss the quality of fruit loop that I used to deal with.

Micqdc · 03/06/2014 13:05

LRDtheFeministDragon - I can understand you point of view and the clarify what I mean by free is that we can go around as we please and do as we whish and exercise our right which are that we have the rights to life, liberty and property but if you went and stole someone's property or damaged them then your infringing on their right and we all naturally know that's wrong.

you have to understand that and interaction with other people is a contract, so what if we don't want to contract with government? that's what its all about

you will actually find that 95% of people who are in the freeman movement of any over movement similar are actually more responsible for them self and have more respect for other people and try to live an honourable life.

so to summarise all that we basically want to get away from laws that don't involve harming people or something like that, for example not paying income tax, doesn't harm anyone.

LisaMed · 03/06/2014 13:04

BarbarianMum I really, really feel your pain. Did they tell you that they paid your wages?

NigellasDealer · 03/06/2014 13:04

well I have glanced through the replies and get the gist.
however rather than dismissing these people as nutters and overgrown teenagers ( I do happen to know one ) I think we should be grateful to them as a symptom of a system/society where people are free to believe what they want. which we are bloody lucky to live in.

LisaMed · 03/06/2014 13:02

I can't believe someone confused Cannon Law with Common Law. In the Middle Ages the two were kept firmly apart and had completely separate courts.

If you are going to talk utter and complete fart products you should at least avoid stuff that is in the basic history textbooks.

BarbarianMum · 03/06/2014 13:02

Have just dealt with one of these delightful people through work. Apparently off-roading on sites of special scientific interest because almost all land in the UK is common land. And walkers/riders/cyclists/school groups have no more right on rights of ways than 4 by 4s cause once you could ride horses anywhere and vehicles are the modern horses. Oh and I was stupid and opening myself up to prosecution by not agreeing with him.

A few hours of my life I won't get back.