Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

to think the 'common law/freeman on the land' thing is a whole load of bollocks?

794 replies

qwertypop · 01/06/2014 20:10

I've come across a few people over the last few years that take it very seriously and bang on at length about how the police and courts have no authority over them as they are self declared 'freemen'. Something to do with common law being the only true law in Britain, I think? And not having to wear bike helmets or pay for TV licenses or repay your debts also seem important to the ones I've had the dubious pleasure of meeting.

A couple I met at the weekend have taken the biscuit though and not registered their baby's birth because apparently this will mean said baby grows up to be a 'freeman' (she's actually a girl but the term appears to be freeman anyway). They believe quite firmly that to register her birth will mean that the law assumes her and her name (which is a fucking corker, of course) are one and the same and that only by NOT registering her birth can she be free to be a human being. Quite what this actually means is a mystery to me and tbh the mumbo jumbo they gave me by way of an answer leads me to suspect they don't really know either Hmm

I've tried to read up on it but all the info I can find is written in a style you'd expect of an paranoid, delusional, and possibly hallucinating chimpanzee let loose with a legal dictionary.

So AIBU to think this is bollocky woo of the most fucking ridiculous type? Or is someone going to come along and actually enlighten me as to wtf its all about, preferably in plain English with no pseudo-legalese?

OP posts:
Spero · 04/06/2014 10:49

Forget Law A level - how about an OU course or similar? come and join us!

LisaMed · 04/06/2014 10:47

Spero That is good, very clear. It is so hard. You just know that it is vulnerable people who are being dragged into this, and they may have had a case. On the other hand, I suspect that a lot of these are idiots trying to prove how clever they are and there is a reason why they are in the family courts Sad

I miss being part of the legal process.

Spero · 04/06/2014 10:42

I have amended post to say

We would be very interested to learn of any family case where 'Freeman' arguments have been deployed and have met with success because at present we are not aware of any such case - in fact the reverse appears to be true; 'freeman' arguments appear to be positively detrimental to people's chances of success in the family (or any other) court.

If you concentrate on making your arguments about why the court should recognise you as a 'freeman on the land' then any relevant arguments you do have about how the law should be applied in your child's case, will not get heard. Please consider very carefully if you want to go down this route, particularly as if you are a respondent in care proceedings you will be entitled to non means and non merits tested public funding to instruct a lawyer of your choice.

See our post from a family law barrister about her role.

Spero · 04/06/2014 10:32

Thanks Lisa, that is an excellent suggestion, I will amend post.

In answer to question about Law Society - I don't know, which I guess tells you something.

the court response I have met thus far seems to be just weary contempt/amusement. Most judges are very courteous and try to get people to engage but after a short time of trying they just give up and get on with the hearing.

It is such a shame because, as you say, someone could have a decent case but coming to court as a Freeman immediately starts warning bells ringing about your state of mind.

LisaMed · 04/06/2014 10:15

Spero - what does the Law Society think of this?

ChelsyHandy · 04/06/2014 10:13

Well I guess there is nothing to stop the self proclaimed "freemen" from using a judicial precedent in common law in their favour where someone has succeeded using this argument! (Except of course there isn't one).

LisaMed · 04/06/2014 10:13

Spero It looked very clear to me. The only suggestion I would make is to perhaps make clearer how much damage this sort of stuff can do to a legitimate case. In fact, I would say that the freeman stuff makes a case unwinnable and still leaves people at the mercy of legal sanctions - lose lose. Sad

Spero · 04/06/2014 10:04

Can I just again offer a VERY sincere vote of thanks to everyone who has contributed to this thread. I have been worried about the freeman movement for about two years now and I have been considering a blog post for at least six months - this has been the kick up the arse I needed and it has been very, very helpful to have access to some of the links.

I would be grateful if anyone has a moment, if they could cast their eye over this and let me know if you think it is clear and accessible and might actually help some people understand the dangers of going down the freeman road in family cases.

www.childprotectionresource.org.uk/category/the-freeman-and-common-law/

NigellasDealer · 04/06/2014 10:02

good post lisa - how can you not be subject to the laws of the land yet claim benefits and live in a council house - not that I want to start benefit bashing in fact the only 'freeman on the land' that I know has every good reason to do both of those - but surely if you want to live 'off grid' you have to go the whole hog.

LisaMed · 04/06/2014 09:59

The whole thing about free men in the Middle Ages is a bit of a red herring. Before the Norman conquest most were assumed either free or slave with varying degrees of legal obligations. All free men had to pay their taxes, serve in the army/garrison the fort and maintain the roads and bridges (with the usual exceptions, caveats etc). This is not what the freeman movement want to hear.

After the Norman conquest (subject to transition, exception, Celtic fringe etc) the division was between those who were serf and those who were free. Those who were serfs were not allowed to take part in the legal process in the king's court. They had to accept the justice dealt out by the local manorial court. Those who were free (lords, mainly) took their legal matters to the king's court. It was a definition of being free that you took any dispute about land, property, etc to the king's court and that if you were accused of crime you were not hauled before the local manorial court but the king's judge. Ironic, really, if you compare it to the claims of the freeman movement.

There's loads of exceptions and twiddly bits, but I believe the above is a good general sweep.

I also love the irony that they try and prove that they are not subject to the law by pointing out bits of law.

ChelsyHandy · 04/06/2014 09:37

OldLady But I am coming mainly from a Scots perspective, and have little idea about how "England" evolved, which is why I'm finding the discussion so interesting, and informative

That's strange, because I went to school in Scotland, and I know a reasonable amount about British history. Its part of the history of Scotland too so this seems odd to me.

I wonder what you're reading if you're seeing "constant pushing of tartan, kilts, Gaelic and bagpipe culture"; I see none of this. Maybe you need to widen your reading material? I'd recommend www.wingsoverscotland.com

Yes, there is certainly an attempt to push a distinct Scottish culture at the moment, using all possible tools including political rhetoric (cf some of Salmond's quotes) and media sources.

I've done a Masters degree at a continental university, and I doubt that my reading material is narrow. I wouldn't really consider a biased internet website a particularly good source - why do Scottish nationalists tend to do this (patronisingly "guide" the well educated towards non-published sources of propaganda, in the mistaken belief that they are somehow in need of such guidance?)

If you can direct me towards any proper published sources you think I need education from, please do so. There is quite a difference between publishing your own blog and being paid to write a book. Wings over Scotland is extremely biased in favour of Scottish independence - typical wording reads Just for laughs, we thought we’d have a look on the BBC website this morning for some intelligent, detailed analysis of yesterday’s devolution proposals from the Conservatives. Yeah, we know. We must still be a bit drunk from last night and on in this vein Mr Wings doth proceed with his latest tirade against media bias. What are Mr Wings's actual qualifications? tbh I've got the opposite impression about the BBC's content, but the nationalists haven't liked it since that documentary about the Scandinavian countries which found them to be more right wing than Scotland currently is.

Theres actually quite a lot about the Scottish independence debate that reminds me of the freeman movement. I have a very personal viewpoint, and one even I don't take very seriously, and that is that there is a lot of rejection of the Norman Conquest going on still in the UK. I would be interested in reading a proper legal argument for the freeman movement, but so far none of what I have read makes sense. I think they are harking back to the Danelaw before the Normans introduced feudalism, but even then surely freemen were created as an honour by a powerful individual and not by self grant, as society then as now would have otherwise curtailed it.

ChelsyHandy · 04/06/2014 09:21

When I studied Scottish history, I was taught that Scotland was made up of Anglian bits, Pictish bits, Norse bits and Scottish bits. I can't remember exactly where the Scottish bits were. Anyway, the point being made was that Scotland was never purely Celtic.

Thank you Toad, very interesting. Were the Scots bits not Irish originally?

Perhaps this explains Alex Salmond's confusion over whether to claim that Scotland is a Nordic country (like the revered Norway) or more like Ireland (which has admittedly gone out of favour since its economic problems!)

ifyourehoppyandyouknowit · 04/06/2014 09:14

The past few pages have been really interesting, every day's a school day off on MN!

PleaseJustShootMeNow · 04/06/2014 08:57

My brother comes out with this sort of stuff all the time. He's uber clever and really knows his stuff. The thing is, he'd never try it court because he's smart enough to know it for what it is. I think he treats it as a form of mental gymnastics, interesting and good for stretching the brain. The problem arises from those around him who aren't quite so smart and take it all at face value and believe ie my mum who is totally convinced that the world is ruled by reptiles in human disguises, thanks bro for that one

LisaMed · 04/06/2014 08:34

HilfskreuzerMowe Thank you for dipping in.

I have enjoyed dipping in to the historical stuff when I calmed down, but as a human being I am so sad that people are going to get their lives trashed because they bought into this rubbish - literally. They have paid for the hokum that they bring to court.

On the diversion, I think 'English' was used for the areas conquered by the Anglo Saxons quite early on, from around the seventh century. British refers to the inhabitants before the Anglo Saxon invasions and you get British enclaves holding on until the seventh and eighth centuries. As for a kingdom of England, there was usually a king that claimed overlordship (Bretwalda) from around the eighth century but I don't think you can look at a king of England until the tenth century.

I've banged on about history and law, but it really isn't relevant. Those who bring this whole 'freeman' business into courts are not interested in the actual reality of law or history. They have just bought some magic beans and they are desperate to believe that they haven't been conned.

Spero · 04/06/2014 08:24

The Canadian courts are dealing with this very well

Seated in the prisoner’s dock wearing a hooded sweatshirt, cut-off shorts and leg shackles, Clifford began the day by refusing to acknowledge his name. Instead, he read from handwritten notes on foolscap held in a black folder.

The rhetoric is similar to that of so-called sovereign citizens who refuse to obey police, judges and other authority figures.

“Sir, are you Darren Murray Clifford?” asked Judge Patrick McIlhargey.

“I am Darren Murray Murphy, son of David Clifford and grandson of William Clifford. ... I am now being seen as a man with standing,” he told court.

“I refuse to accommodate the name of any capacity bound by your political organization. I never have nor ever will give consent to be associated with the legal person under the terms and conditions of a birth certificate,” he said.

When asked if he was ready for his trial, Clifford said: “I am under no securities agreement with Her Majesty the Queen, I am a land owner and Her Majesty the Queen is a tenant. This tribunal known as provincial court is trying to force me to act against my conscience. This is an unconscionable act,” he said.

...

Clifford, who didn’t cross examine Christie or take the stand to testify in his defence, tried arguing that the Mountie erred because when Clifford asked to see the warrant, he didn’t have it with him, and wouldn’t identify himself by name when “asked about 25 times,” said Clifford.

The judge ruled both points were non-issues — Mounties have no need to produce warrants, although it is preferable, he said. And the fact that Christie was wearing a uniform, gun holster and driving an RCMP truck outfitted with light was enough, the judge said.

Christie said Clifford told him his billing rate was a million dollars an hour and he wanted to see the arrest warrant and other documents, which Christie said were back at the office.

Christie’s conduct was commendable, the judge said.

“It seems to me the officer was extremely patient and in control,” McIlhargey said.

The Crown recommended Clifford be ordered to undergo counselling for “life management skills” as part of probation.

“He seems to be starting to develop a bit of a pattern of disrespect to the court,” Faught said.

But the judge said he didn’t agree with imposing anything to retrain the accused’s political beliefs.

“I feel like I’m being profiled,” Clifford said.

“There’s no evidence about my being associated with this Freeman thing.”

Spero · 04/06/2014 08:16

Nomorequotes - this from Mowe's interesting threads may shed some light on what is going to happen to your pixie clad friend...

Clifford appeared in court on Tuesday and urged the judge to read the paperwork from his brother and declared his autonomy.

“I am a non-resident of Canada,” he said.

Clifford was sent for a psychological assessment when he repeatedly told the judge he couldn’t understand his charges after they were read out to him.

“I don’t agree with the charges,” Clifford told the judge. “I understand the English language.”

He said he wouldn’t consent to a psychological assessment, but Judge Ann Brown said she felt it was necessary.

“I have some concern you can’t understand these proceedings,” she said.

He also asked the judge to read documents faxed to the court by his brother, Dean Clifford, a man who has numerous online videos and blogs outlining his viewpoints which include rejecting government authority, not holding a driver’s license and denying the police’s right to stop and detain people.

Spero · 04/06/2014 08:14

Now that's interesting - in Mowe's first thread he describes how the law society of a British Colombia took out an injunction against one of the freeman to 'stop playing the lawyer'.

But why would a law society do that and not the relevant government department? Or IS that the relevant gov department?

I can now add ignorance of. Canadian constitution to the ever growing list of things I don't know about...

Spero · 04/06/2014 08:05

Thanks Mowe, I will definitely check out those threads, I am very glad to hear the Canadian courts have reacted sensibly.

Here I am afraid there is just exasperated bafflement, from what I have seen in the family courts, and the proceedings just role on regardless.

But given that there is a high risk that vulnerable people are being exploited, both financially and emotionally, I think our courts ought to be taking it more seriously and engaging in the way the Canadian courts have.

Well, maybe our civil courts already are, I don't have any experience of those. Just worried about how the family courts approach it.

nomorequotes · 04/06/2014 06:57

Thanks for that Mowe

I am very interested in what happens when these free men get to court as an ex friend of mine (who believes to save the world all she needs to do is dress as a pixie and tell people not to vote) is going through lots of legal processes at the moment to get herself off paying off debts she has accrued in the past and is prepared to go to court and announce her freeman status and how they have no power over her.

Intrigued to how it will all turn out.

Toadinthehole · 04/06/2014 04:46

Fwiw in 1450 the border was more or less as it is now. The last significant change was in 1093 when William II took Carlisle. There were periods when the English controlled parts of Scotland and vice versa (during Stephen's reign) but they weren't permanent annexations.

Much of southern Scotland is made up of former Anglian areas. Edinburgh takes its name from Edwin, king of Northumbria, I believe. When I studied Scottish history, I was taught that Scotland was made up of Anglian bits, Pictish bits, Norse bits and Scottish bits. I can't remember exactly where the Scottish bits were. Anyway, the point being made was that Scotland was never purely Celtic.

Pantsmagicpants · 04/06/2014 02:45

This is where I learnt about the Magna Carta. I think it's very informative. Not quite as informative as this thread though Grin .

Toadinthehole · 04/06/2014 02:42

Strathclyde was, for a period of time part of Northumbria, which was an Anglian kingdom. However, it was never ruled by a de facto king of England. Mercia, and most of the Danelaw became under the control the kings of Wessex over time, but Northumbria basically split in two, the northern bit falling under the control of the king of Scots.

Tortoiseonthehalfshell · 04/06/2014 02:20

Spero But is there no way to at least regulate people who charge for this tomfoolery?

Well, but are you looking to regulate the LEGAL PERSON or the NATURAL PERSON on the LAND?

Lisa, this has been a delight. You should absolutely do Law A-level, it's great fun.

HilfskreuzerMowe · 04/06/2014 02:10

Hi Mumsnetters!

Some subject matter 'googling' led me to your forum and this message thread. After reading the amusing and informative posts and exchanges I thought I'd add a few minor comments which I hope are of interest.

Micqdc seems to be quite enthusiastic about Dean Clifford, a Canadian Freeman-on-the-Land 'for pay' promoter. What Micqdc has omitted is that Dean has been having a difficult time of late, having been arrested in November right at the end of one of his weekend seminars on how to get free stuff and conquer the courts. There is video of that. Six months later he is still in pre-trial detention, facing multiple charges for illegal and prohibited weapons, operating a marijuana grow-op, and other ancillary offenses. Dean has been denied bail - which is unusual in Canada.

To date Dean has filed many applications to miracle himself out of jail, and has also attempted to sue the Canadian government for his alleged mistreatment. Nothing has worked and instead he awaits trial...

If you're interested in learning way too much about Dean he is one of the subjects tracked by Quatloos, an internet forum which specializes in online scams, frauds, and Sovereign Citizen/Freeman-on-the-Land types. I'm a regular on there - I specialize in Canadian litigants of this kind. Dean and his brother Darren are the subject of a couple message threads:

www.quatloos.com/Q-Forum/viewtopic.php?f=48&t=9364

www.quatloos.com/Q-Forum/viewtopic.php?f=48&t=9589

There are even copies of many of Dean's court documents! While his legal arguments are a little thin, his penmanship is impeccable.

It's interesting to read reports of how Freeman activity is on the increase in the UK. The movement in Canada has all but collapsed. There have been too many failed promises and now court responses are aggressive and strict. It has made a big difference, as have a number of high profile public relations disasters.

I'd be very pleased to answer any questions you may have on the situation in North America.

Again, thanks for some entertaining reading!

SMS Möwe