Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

10% of NHS budget is spent on t2 diabetes vast majority is self inflicted, aibu to think they should contribute?

355 replies

Lauranda · 06/05/2014 14:09

Its estimated that the cost will go up 17% by 2020. Something needs to change or the NHS will collapse.

Maybe make people that are overweight pay something towards their treatment would in courage people to eat better and exercise more.

OP posts:
Lauranda · 07/05/2014 11:18

Lol yet another person calling me fattist, even though I never mentioned fat or weight? Hillarious

OP posts:
Lauranda · 07/05/2014 11:17

Hec you do realise I didn't even say weight...

OP posts:
Thurlow · 07/05/2014 11:17

How on earth are you going to decide what has caused a condition? I'm not medical expert, but I can imagine it's rarely that simple and obvious whether hereditary conditions or weight have caused a condition.

And yes, I would very much like to hear your opinion on other injuries and conditions and not just T2 diabetes. How about, just as a few:

  • STIs and unplanned pregnancy - should anyone having unprotected sex be charged extra for the consequences of that? How will you prove that it wasn't a contraceptive failure?

  • Injuries sustained during contact sports such as rugby, football, hockey etc.

There is clearly a discussion to be had about whether the system is working as it stands. But pointing at a 'fat' person and saying "you caused your own T2 diabetes, you must pay for more treatment" is not the way forward.

Lauranda · 07/05/2014 11:15

I usually don't reply to unpleasant people that feel the need to mock other people to make a point. But just this once, I have not mentioned weight here other than quoting someone else, so that says more about your prejudism claiming that I'm being fattist.

OP posts:
HecatePropylaea · 07/05/2014 11:14

So you are in fact saying that the only category that you would see require a top up over what the person pays to the NHS via their national insurance contributions is weight?

Nothing else?

Just weight?

Not smoking, not drinking, not skydiving, not taking drugs, not getting a tattoo on holiday from a drunken bloke with a sewing needle, not any of the ways in which it can be argued that people negatively impact on their health?

You're sticking with fat and nothing else?

LackaDAISYcal · 07/05/2014 11:12

And it's not working because of the steady chipping away of the service over the last couple of decades; reduced levels of funding, too many managers and not enough clinicians. I'm not an expert, perhaps someone who works in the NHS can comment further.

LackaDAISYcal · 07/05/2014 11:08

Could you answer the questions about other health conditions OP? as you are coming over as being a bit fattist by only talking about T2 diabetes.

Do you, yourself have any health conditions that get regular treatment? Are you aware that there is a lifestyle aspect of pretty much every health complaint? and are you aware that in this country we pay National Insurance Contributions which fund the NHS?

Are you also aware that you sound like an uneducated reactionary loon? I'm not sure there is currently a cure for that, but that's probably just as well as it seems to be self inflicted and wouldn't be covered under your rools.

Lauranda · 07/05/2014 10:56

I really don't understand this mentality that the NHS must at all costs be free at the point of use. Billions is spent in it and we have the 18th best health service in the world while the French have the best health service in the world where people who can afford do contribute towards their health care, but the state pics up the vast majority of the cost. People don't value something that is given for free.

If you claim job seakers you have to prove you've been doing your best to get a job in order to protect the public funds.

If you have a condition that is self inflicted through decades of abuse by eating junk food and doing little exercise I don't see the big deal in only giving free percriptions if the recipient is making an effort to improve their health.

Not sure why so many people are in favour of the status quo, its not working and getting increasingly unsustainable.

This makes me racist?

OP posts:
Lemiserableoldgimmer · 07/05/2014 09:40

Hotcross - given the striking correlation in the uk between poverty and obesity, I suspect that as a group the obese pay much less tax than slim and healthy individuals of the same age.

Lemiserableoldgimmer · 07/05/2014 09:36

Electric - the OP isn't talking about type 1 diabetes or epilepsy.

Joy - I don't think the OP has said or implied that type 2 diabetes can't develop in slim people.

Sillylass79 · 07/05/2014 09:01

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Geraldthegiraffe · 07/05/2014 08:38

mousmous - there is very little help for eating disorders if it is not anorexia. I'm lucky to attend a charity based eating disorders group but despite repeated attempts to go to the doctors for help its only now I'm really quite big and also suffering anxiety that I'm getting help.

The help I'm getting is mainly going to be for the depression rather than for the deep-seated psychological issues that lead to an eating disorder.

I'm sure if you haven't got an eating disorder it looks "easy" to deal with. Similarly if you don't smoke or drink it must look easy to give up (I've never had to battle either of those but understand it must be difficult for those strugling). You wouldn't say to a depressed person -"just cheer up", or to an anorexic "just eat". Similarly to someone suffering with binge eating disorder or compulsive eating you can't just say "eat healthily" as it isn't that simple sadly.

candycoatedwaterdrops · 07/05/2014 08:28

YABU and I hope I never come across you in your "caring" profession.

Joysmum · 07/05/2014 08:26

I get right royally fucked off with people who assume T2 diabetes is purely as a result of weight and lifestyle. In fact it is thought the a predisposition to T2 rears it's head in weight issues, rather than weight issues causing T2.

Then you get to the sticky situation of how to make your decision on fault. If I got T2 now and am a normal wight, how is anyone to know I only eat cakes, but not enough of them to get fat!

It's fine in principle to want people to pay towards issues they contributed towards but this can't be applied in practice and would have to be applied to all health conditions. It's simply not workable in a fair system.

ElectricalBanana · 07/05/2014 08:18

My daughter is 21, has autism and epilepsy.

She developed type 1 when she was 8

She developed insulin resistance last year

Yeah all her fault to... Silly silly thread

Sirzy · 07/05/2014 08:13

Mousmous the help that people get to lose weight is very much (like many things) a postcode lottery with very little help available in a lot of areas, or massive waiting lists to access help.

What we really need is much better easily accessible access to help for people who are worried about their weight (and no "your not heavy enough for us to support" type scenarios) AND more preventative, educational approaches in schools from a young age (for children and parents) to try to counteract the increasing problem.

hotcrosshunny · 07/05/2014 08:05

Yabu

What do you think taxes are about?

And we all pay taxes directly or indirectly by the way be it via vat or income tax etc etc. Except maybe children!

mousmous · 07/05/2014 07:59

yabu
overweight people should get help to lose weight (and they do if they ask), to find out if there is an underlying problem causing it.
but maybe people with pre-diabetes should go to weightloss clinics. but how to approach this, I don't know.

mousmous · 07/05/2014 07:55

yabu
overweight people should get help to lose weight (and they do if they ask), to find out if there is an underlying problem causing it.
but maybe people with pre-diabetes should go to weightloss clinics. but how to approach this, I don't know.

missymarmite · 07/05/2014 07:44

Surely if someone is in a care home their access to food is restricted, therefore they should lose weight. Or do homes not provide a healthy balanced and nutritious diet?

The reason there were fewer obese people in the 1940s and 1950s is obvious. Rationing restricted access, meaning people never developed a dependence on foods as a crutch.

Now, for those of us who struggle with weight, there is very little restriction, and even encouragement to eat crap, as it is usually cheaper than healthy food. I tried SW for several months, I cooked fresh meals from scratch. My food bills went up by about a third, and it was unsustainable. I stopped going mainly because we couldn't afford the weekly fees on top of the food.

YABU and frankly foolish.

Fwiw, My DM died from a massive heart attack long before the age of 50. She smoked, drank and was stressed out from teaching. She was obese. But she died so suddenly she was never a burden in the NHS.

deakymom · 07/05/2014 06:59

you can get lifelong thyroid conditions without having children i got mine 15 months before i even got pregnant mine is graves disease which is not considered lifelong (although ive had it for 16 years) i pay for my prescriptions i get sicker than everyone else as ive a compromised immune system i need a massive amount of NHS help

apparently it was most likely caused by working 3 jobs and paying lots in taxes although it might have happened anyway stress is a major factor

should i have stayed on the dole because of my "risk" of getting graves disease? all of my family has thyroid problems including my sister who has never had children she takes thyroxine as hers is under

Lemiserableoldgimmer · 06/05/2014 23:45

The elderly are indeed the biggest drain on the NHS. Especially the obese ones who are growing in number.

The three obese 70+ year olds I know have multiple and complex health issues. I do know many slim and fit older people in their 70's and 80's who are still active and are not on 15 different medications a day.

Obesity impacts most greatly on the health of older people.

stayanotherday · 06/05/2014 23:11

Is it still half term?

Goofymum · 06/05/2014 22:46

What an ignorant knee jerk reaction, OP.
How about we make all old people contribute for their healthcare, over and above the lifetime contributions they've already made. The elderly are the biggest drain on the nhs. If they can't pay they don't get treated and nature takes care of the rest. That's how ridiculous your AIBU is.

Mermaid29 · 06/05/2014 22:36

I think it is very difficult when you have a condition, I have bad osteoarthritis in my knee (amongst a myriad of other conditions) and so have limited mobility, the only way to not gain weight is to really restrict my diet. By doing this I have not gained weight despite not being able to exercise. I think this is something that most people would not be willing to do

So weight gain with a health condition doesn't have to be inevitable