Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

10% of NHS budget is spent on t2 diabetes vast majority is self inflicted, aibu to think they should contribute?

355 replies

Lauranda · 06/05/2014 14:09

Its estimated that the cost will go up 17% by 2020. Something needs to change or the NHS will collapse.

Maybe make people that are overweight pay something towards their treatment would in courage people to eat better and exercise more.

OP posts:
HolidayCriminal · 08/05/2014 08:27

There isn't a special obesity gene. We're nearly all programmed to enjoy our food to excess. Almost all of us can all easily gain weight if we don't burn it off. This is the normal human condition.

DinoSnores · 08/05/2014 08:26

"But doesn't determination to resist this urge to eat come into it too?"

Certainly and a surprisingly huge amount of that is due to brain chemistry. We all know that willpower is a challenge (don't need to be a scientist!) and that anyone who wants to lose weight will have to permanently keep their eye on the ball to keep it off.

"I'm confused - does this obesity gene mean that you want to eat more than you need, or that you eat the same amount as other people but you store fat instead of burning it off? Or both?"

There are numerous 'obesity' genes. The most famous one (if you are in to that sort of thing) is the FTO gene which actually only makes a couple of pounds difference, so there are lots of different genes, most of which we probably haven't identified yet. They probably have lots of different effects from making you fidget less, eat more, store fat in the 'wrong' places. Get lots of them and they cause more problems.

"If she read some of the views on this thread which suggest that weight is probably beyond anyone's control I think it'd have a seriously bad effect on her. I don't want her to believe that exercise and a moderate diet won't help or aren't achievable for people who have a genetic propensity to obesity, as she may well do. :-("

It isn't "beyond anyone's control" but there is a big genetic part of it that can't be ignored.

We tell everyone that a healthy balanced diet and exercise is the best thing and the most important treatment. The genetics isn't an excuse to avoid a healthy lifestyle sadly!

Exercise reduces fat in the muscles so reduces insulin resistance, reducing the chances or severity of T2DM potentially. Patients with a genetic predisposition to obesity need to be very aware that they must watch their diet constantly because it is going to be so easy to put weight on.

Patients who want to can, but you just need to watch an episode of 'Secret Eaters' to see how much we all delude ourselves about what and how much eat, so we all need to take responsibility for ourselves in that regard.

Lemiserableoldgimmer · 08/05/2014 08:00

I'm confused - does this obesity gene mean that you want to eat more than you need, or that you eat the same amount as other people but you store fat instead of burning it off? Or both?

Both my PIL and SIL are obese. They eat colossal portions and always have done. Double the size of a normal adult portion I'd say. I have observed this for years and years. MIL has type 2, SIL has abnormal blood glucose levels. My dd (15) is very overweight too. She was normal weight as a child but teenage rebellion has seen her diet deteriorate, now she is able to spend her pocket money on junk food. Does she have an obesity gene? Is it that which is compelling her to go to the chicken shop three times a week and buy full fat coke? If she read some of the views on this thread which suggest that weight is probably beyond anyone's control I think it'd have a seriously bad effect on her. I don't want her to believe that exercise and a moderate diet won't help or aren't achievable for people who have a genetic propensity to obesity, as she may well do. :-(

winklewoman · 08/05/2014 07:46

Thanks dinosnores for your reply. I watched the video, well most of it, it was late and I snoozed off, but the twin comparison was most interesting.

I do get your point about the body being programned to stock up on food when it is available, as it readily is now. But doesn't determination to resist this urge to eat come into it too? How can people be helped to do this? Obesity does seem to increase as people get poorer and/or are lower down the social scale, and yes cheap food is often full of fat and sugar.

During my occasional encounters with Weight Watchers, I was always amazed at the number if people who could not sit through the session without continuosly munching on WW crisps, sweets and cereal bars. How do you break this habit?

OwlCapone · 08/05/2014 07:08

What are the risk factors for being a goady fucker?

OwlCapone · 08/05/2014 07:08

I still think the answer could be that straightforward as eating too much of the wrong food and not moving enough

Why would you persist in this stupid belief when more qualified people have pointed out that you are wrong?

LackaDAISYcal · 07/05/2014 23:29

*Nancery sorry!

LackaDAISYcal · 07/05/2014 23:28

slightly different cancery, but I have coeliac disease and am constantly getting the Hmm look as people just assume I'm being faddy when I say I can't eat anything with flour, barley, rye and most oats in.

I've reported your last comment OP for being goady and fattist. And in the interests of fairnessI've reported myself for calling you patronising, smug and twattish even though you are as that is a personal attack and not allowed.

DinoSnores · 07/05/2014 23:21

nancery, just as a matter of interest, we are now seeing a huge crossover between T1DM and T2DM. It is often not clearcut when a patient presents with a new diagnosis which type they have and indeed with an ageing, heavier population, we are seeing more patients with probable T1DM AND significant insulin resistance. There shouldn't be patronising, pigeonholing and lecturing of any patient of course!

RuddyDuck · 07/05/2014 23:19

I spent serious amounts of nhs time and resources during my first pregnancy, which saw me hospitalised several times, and then special neo natal care for dc1 when he was born prematurely. As my pregnancy was "self inflicted" should I have contributed to the cost?

Dc 2 and I were both treated for sports - related injuries in the last couple of years, again "self inflicted" in that we choose to take part in the respective sports. Should we be paying for that as well? Or perhaps we should stay at home, being couch potatoes, so we don't run the risk of being a drain on the nhs with our sport-related problems. Oh no, wait a minute, then we'd be more likely to suffer from type 2 diabetes.......

dawndonnaagain · 07/05/2014 23:18
Grin
DinoSnores · 07/05/2014 23:17

Thank you, dawn. You are right, but it is just so tempting when someone (especially someone claiming to be a HCP) is wrong on the internet! Wink

xkcd.com/386/

dawndonnaagain · 07/05/2014 23:17

Although I do find dismissing a link from "cam.ac" to be supremely arrogant. Perhaps the op would care to share her credentials?

Nancery · 07/05/2014 23:15

In response to the OP - YABU in the numerous reasons pointed out.

Also, slight hijack here, attitudes like yours along with misunderstanding (including medics, they are often the worst) has ensured Type ONE diabetics like myself have been patronised, pigeonholed and lectured.

Thanks.

As you were...

dawndonnaagain · 07/05/2014 23:13

dino, thanks for the links, I shall spend some time reading and watching. May I suggest that the hard of thinking are best ignored. Wink

DinoSnores · 07/05/2014 23:12

"That video on YouTube that is supposted to answer many things hardly has any views and just the one comment saying "that guy is wrong" lol"

Hmm If you need to confirm the credentials of Professor Sir Steve O'Rahilly MD FRCP FRCPI FRCPath FRS FMedSci, then there is a biography at his lab website here www.mrl.ims.cam.ac.uk/staff/hod/ or indeed at his Wikipedia entry.

DinoSnores · 07/05/2014 23:05

I've tried to help and you are not having any of it, so I am at a bit of a loss! You obviously have your own ideas about things (not sure what that is based on but it certainly isn't up to date peer-reviewed medicine) and won't be persuaded otherwise!

Here are some papers by Prof O'Rahilly that might help (I've picked on him as I've linked to his lecture above):

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22915015

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22065844

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20870709

LackaDAISYcal · 07/05/2014 23:01

I know Dino, I'm not disputing that, rather the view that it all the fault of them greedy and lazy fat people, end of discussion.

your use of terms like "gorging on fat and sugar" is quite offensive Lauranda, for one who professes that she isn't fattist.

I think I'm going to have to hide this thread now, but I will definitely watch your video Dino. I have an auto-immune condition that predisposes me to other such conditions, diabetes being one of them so I try to do all I can to mitigate my risk.

Lauranda · 07/05/2014 23:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Lauranda · 07/05/2014 22:57

If your so educated and I'm so uneducated you could help out more as I can't watch video on mobile.

OP posts:
LackaDAISYcal · 07/05/2014 22:56

"Thats just a play on words.

Just like saying smoking is a risk factor for lung cancer"

Are you for real? It is just like saying smoking is a risk factor for lung cancer, because...we... it is Grin And in the same way that not all fat people get T2, not all smokers get lung cancer

Are you incredibly bloody minded and failing to accept what appears to be the majority view, or that other people are allowed to even have a view or incredibly stupid; I'm struggling to figure out which, so will leave you to your "I'm right and you're all stupid" bubble.

DinoSnores · 07/05/2014 22:55

Watch the blooming lecture! Spend 50 minutes away from MN and posting your uneducated comments and then come back and ask your questions if you still have any!

(which I will answer in the morning as I need to go to bed but I have enjoyed watching his lecture and was glad to have found it! He is a great speaker, even if I have heard variations on that talk just a few times!)

Lauranda · 07/05/2014 22:52

So your saying its not peoples fault if they gorge on sugar and fat?

OP posts:
DinoSnores · 07/05/2014 22:52

To be fair, daisy, I would say that obesity is a cause of T2DM in some people, but it certainly isn't clear cut. See my comments at 22:39 for example on the "healthy obese".

DinoSnores · 07/05/2014 22:49

My post was clearly meant for lauranda and not the two far more sensible posters above mine!