Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

10% of NHS budget is spent on t2 diabetes vast majority is self inflicted, aibu to think they should contribute?

355 replies

Lauranda · 06/05/2014 14:09

Its estimated that the cost will go up 17% by 2020. Something needs to change or the NHS will collapse.

Maybe make people that are overweight pay something towards their treatment would in courage people to eat better and exercise more.

OP posts:
Bodicea · 06/05/2014 21:24

Obviously it is a daft idea but unfortunately the NHS does not have endless amounts of money. It is being stretched to breaking point and diabetes is a major part of the problem along with everyone living longer.
People who get hysterical and say everything should be free are dilusional and burying their heads in the sand. Money doesn't grow on trees.
Something will have to change in the future. It can't go on like this. I don't like the American system either - which costs more per head because once you go private everything suddenly costs more. People get more unnecessary tests etc.
I don't envy the politicians the task of sorting it out and whatever they do they will get it in the neck.

rumbleinthrjungle · 06/05/2014 19:34

I paid NI and worked until I became too ill to work full time, I will be chronically ill for the rest of my life. (Not self inflicted, just very bad luck and genetics.) Between the medication, immobility and depression that comes with 24 hour pain and the stress involved, I am now overweight. If it helps, I hate myself for it. Blush I am just about managing to support myself financially. I could not afford to pay for my medical care, I just would have to do without it. Long life ahead? I seriously hope not, and it's not too likely. So I shouldn't be too much of a burden on anyone else.

So as one of the fattys laying on a sofa a lot of the time, I can spare you a Biscuit

Lemiserableoldgimmer · 06/05/2014 18:43

Of course it's true that people have a genetic predisposition to developing type 2 diabetes.

But being massively overweight makes this much more likely.

In Mexico nearly 1 in 3 adults is now obese. Not just overweight - obese.

And diabetes is the primary cause of death in women. :-(

14% of Mexicans have or are developing type 2 diabetes (ie have high glucose levels).

It's an epidemic, and we're not far behind. Very, very worrying for anyone who lives in a country with a publicly funded health system.

elfycat · 06/05/2014 18:33

Love that the OP is only reading responding to the bits of comments that agree with her. Not much of a AIBU if you don't engage dear.

Or AIBU?

Lemiserableoldgimmer · 06/05/2014 18:33

I don't agree that we should charge fat people extra to use the health service. Partly because I'm fat myself, as is dd, dmil, dfil, dsil and dbil. Also because it's inhumane.

Three of my inlaws are morbidly obese. Between the three of them they have severe hypertension, diabetes, stroke, a pace-maker, and long term problems related to botched abdominal surgery made more complex by large amounts of abdominal fat. Between just MIL and FIL I think they've clocked up hundreds of thousands of pounds worth of NHS treatment.

The health service WILL collapse under the strain of caring for the growing numbers of fat elderly people who tend to have more, more complex, and longer term health problems than old people of normal weight.

I don't know what to suggest. I think we just have to accept that the growing levels of obesity and an ageing population will finish off a public health system which is already creaking under the pressure.

I'm nearly a normal BMI now because I'm dieting. The biggest motivator for me is not wanting to be part of the problem that will finish off the NHS. I think trying to be slim and fit is a public duty in a country with a publicly funded NHS.

Ploppy16 · 06/05/2014 18:28

What about pregnancy related diabetes? Do they have to pay twice? Once for the diabetes treatment and once for antenatal care?
Precisely where do you stop this particular train you numpty?

EllaFitzgerald · 06/05/2014 18:26

I hope to God that neither me or any of my loved ones are ever in a position where we're reliant on someone with your views to care for us.

Your post suggests very little understanding of the various causes of this illness, not all of which are related to weight and/or lifestyle choices. Perhaps you should post a few details of your medical history, your sporting activities, your social life etc, so we can all make judgements on what contributions you should make to any future NHS care.

susiedaisy · 06/05/2014 18:22

Op yabu, the people I know with type 1 and 2 diabetes aren't fat. They were a mixture of very young (2 years) old when diagnosed. Elderly. And someone who lost their parent had a breakdown and developed type 1 diabetes. None of them were fat or deserved to get diabetes.

winklewoman · 06/05/2014 18:17

Dinosnores, I was interested in what you said way up thread about 80% of your weight being down to genetics. I always notice how few fat people are visible in post-war and fifties newsreels. Obviously there was less food around then and certainly much less high fat, high sugar, junk. But if weight was largely genetic wouldn't you expect a good many of those people to be fat regardess?

It is frequently said on here that being overweight is because of some underlying problem, but I do wonder how often that is simply an excuse. I know why I am over weight, too many calories going in, too few going out.

I've just been diagnosed with Type 2 diabetes, and yes, I do think it was largely self inflicted.

WooWooOwl · 06/05/2014 18:06

I'd rather see people contribute to the cost of their maternity care before we start charging people for the privilege of illnesses and injuries they'd rather not have.

Dreamer789 · 06/05/2014 17:49

I think Dreamer meant Lauranda might be sick of seeing 'fat gits' at Lauranda's own place of work. She is employed as a carer, apparently, and what a truly caring person she is, on the evidence of this thread

Yes this. I wonder whether her work as a carer who sees the complications of diabetes has contributed to this view not that it is justifiable

Musetta · 06/05/2014 17:23

How have you failed to realise that the nhs is not free? Do you not look at your pay cheque every month? Or is this just an excuse for some fat shaming op?Hmm

AbbeyBartlet · 06/05/2014 17:21

YABU - as PP have said, what about pregnancy, car accidents Etc - most things are 'self inflicted'

AllMimsyWereTheBorogroves · 06/05/2014 17:17

Sorry, Dreamer! Irony detector failed. Thanks for you too.

Dreamer789 · 06/05/2014 17:10

I was being sarcastic about OP, no offence intended to anyone, apologies Thanks

HecatePropylaea · 06/05/2014 17:01

ok, so, given that people already contribute to the nhs through taxation, according to their income, what you are proposing is an additional sum on top of this which is based on your lifestyle? Isthis lifestyle generally or are you limiting this top up contribution to being fat?

What about drinkers? Smokers? Drug takers? people who engage in risky hobbies? People in high risk occupations? City dwellers? People who live in high crime areas?

What about social class? That has a proven impact on health, according to statistics? As does mental health.

People on low income it has been argued live a less healthy lifestyle, should this extra charge include a poor people surcharge? If you have less than £x monthly income it is assumed you will be less healthy so you pay £x more?

And will all this be means tested? or proportional to income? Or will it be a flat rate per habit, hobby, figure or lifestyle choice?

How much will it cost to administer such a system? Will it require a whole government department? Will people be subject to annual medical exams and at what cost? Or will we see an insurance style system with everyone getting an individual quote based on their circumstances? If someone lies on their forms and later needs treatment for, say, a smoking related disease when they claimed they didn't smoke, will they be fined? How will money be recovered?

How much money is likely to be saved by introducing such a system, roughly? You know, the savings to the nhs - the cost of administration of such a system?

I assume that you have given it a great deal of thought and I'd be interested to know how you think such a system would work.

ilovesooty · 06/05/2014 16:57

I'm a bit sorry the OP's not in my area. I was thinking of enquiring whether her towel toting tweeting fitness guru of a husband offered discounts to mumsnetters motivated by the OP's particular brand of encouragement.

RandallFloyd · 06/05/2014 16:50

The Daily Mail eh?
It never ceases to plumb new depths.

AllMimsyWereTheBorogroves · 06/05/2014 16:49

I wouldn't apologise to Dreamer, STDG. She was the one who introduced the idea of fat gits, not Lauranda.

passmethewineplease · 06/05/2014 16:46

YABU.

So many things can be regarded as self inflicted, why target one particular group?

MrsMaturin · 06/05/2014 16:45

And just to try and make something of this thread for anybody worried reading it - yes weight is a risk factor for Type 2. However so are genetics, racial background, exercise profile and other health conditions and treatments. Most of those risk factors are very hard to influence - even weight. Exercise is by far the easiest for us all to do something about and exercise lowers both blood sugar and BP. So if you're worried don't beat yourself up about the things you can't change - just try and go for a swim or a bike ride or a brisk walk or do the hoovering at ultra speed or some intensive gardening.

Quangle · 06/05/2014 16:42

I think anyone who has ever smoked anything, ever, or anyone who has ever drunk more than 14 units in a week or anyone who has ever gone a day without eating 5 (no wait, 7, no 10!) fruit and veg or anyone who has ever gone outside without sunscreen on should pay for the whole NHS all by themselves. Oh, hold on, that's everyone in the whole country and we are all already paying. Tricky business this health policy lark Grin.

MrsMaturin · 06/05/2014 16:40

The OP is clearly a candidate for NHS treatment herself. Unfortunately there is a sizeable waiting list for the particular procedure she needs so her head will have to remain jammed in her posterior for the next wee while at least.

ddubsgirl77 · 06/05/2014 16:36

my t2 is herited but yes im overweight my mum and both her parents had it just because someone may be fat may not be why they have diabetes!

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 06/05/2014 16:34

You might be right, AllMimsy - and if you are, that makes Lauranda a truly vile person, to be in a caring role and to judge her clients in such an uncaring fashion.

Dreamer - I apologise.

Swipe left for the next trending thread