Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The poorest half of the Uk own 3% of the wealth

120 replies

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 02/05/2014 20:29

Am I being unreasonable to think we should be taking steps to change this as a country.

And in case you wonder if your household income is less than around £33k you are in the bottom 50%

It didn't use to be this bad. So it CAN be better, we don't have to shrug and accept it.

OP posts:
TucsonGirl · 02/05/2014 20:56

Say you give every adult in the country £10,000 tomorrow, and next week some people are pleading poverty because they blew it all. What do you do with those people? Give them more money?

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 02/05/2014 20:55

Actually studies have shown that giving people a big chunk of cash is usually a good idea. Most people are very sensible when given a wedge of cash. More so than drop feeding the cash.

OP posts:
TucsonGirl · 02/05/2014 20:53

It's not ok. But taking money from the people that earn it and giving it to people who didn't earn it can only go so far. Give some people £10000 and they'll think "great I can go on holiday, buy a car, go out drinking every weekend for a year, etc etc". And some other people will think "what can I do with this money that will turn it into more money in a years time". You need to educate people to think the latter instead of the former. But that is hard to do when people have been raised in an environment where you take enjoyment when you can get it and don't think about the future too much.

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 02/05/2014 20:51

No, not dictating what people do with their money. Dictating what proportion the state takes for social good.

You know, like we've done for centuries....

OP posts:
ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 02/05/2014 20:49

Just out of interest are the 'oh but there's nothing we can do' crowd saying it's ok?

OP posts:
ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 02/05/2014 20:49

Ok make it taxed as per income taxes. Link payment to citizenship (as the us do)

OP posts:
TucsonGirl · 02/05/2014 20:47

How do you suggest we "make them" pay up, ThinkAboutIt? Saying close loopholes is easy in theory, much harder in practice.

WooWooOwl · 02/05/2014 20:47

So basically dictate what people can and can't do with their own money that they they have already paid tax on?

Yes, that sounds like the sort of country I'd like to live in Hmm

ClockWatchingLady · 02/05/2014 20:46

www.positivemoney.org/

Have a read.

(I promise I'm a sensible human being).

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 02/05/2014 20:44

Close all loopholes on inheritance tax so the richest actually pay it.

Only 5% pay inheritance tax and then only on anything over £650k (couple). Let's make them pay up.

And that would include me by the way.

OP posts:
specialsubject · 02/05/2014 20:44

alternative suggestions welcome!

ClockWatchingLady · 02/05/2014 20:40

(YANBU)

ClockWatchingLady · 02/05/2014 20:40

It is totally fucked up.

The banking system itself (debt-based money system) is largely to blame.

I can never quite believe it when programs like Benefit Street encourage outrage about the financing of people who are (for whatever reason) living down-trodden lives, when the amount of money we all give to finance the super-rich is so very, very much more.

specialsubject · 02/05/2014 20:38

and your proposed steps, OP, are....

dictatorship?
violent revolution?

or just stand for parliament in our democracy, with a practical proposal?

(sits back...)

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 02/05/2014 20:37

Yes it would take a while but it has taken 50 years for it to get this bad.

In 1906 it was this bad. In 1950 it was up to 6% and it has taken 60 years to grind it back down.

Time the pendulum swung back a bit.

OP posts:
TucsonGirl · 02/05/2014 20:34

What do we do about it though? Tax and redistribute it in the form of benefits? I honestly don't think that works, not to any great extent anyway. You need to change peoples habits. And that takes a long time, generations even. If you took all the money in the UK now and distributed it all evenly, then came back in 10 years, my guess is that you'd find a very similar disparity in how wealth was distributed. Probably even more so in fact.

MaryShelley · 02/05/2014 20:33

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 02/05/2014 20:33

Maybe. But I'm not affiliated. Though I am a labour donor.

OP posts:
ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 02/05/2014 20:32

And the 5 richest families own more than the poorest 20%.

That's 5 families with more than 12,600,000 families. Angry

OP posts:
StarGazeyPond · 02/05/2014 20:31

Sounds a bit like a Party Political Broadcast Grin

Swipe left for the next trending thread