Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The poorest half of the Uk own 3% of the wealth

120 replies

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 02/05/2014 20:29

Am I being unreasonable to think we should be taking steps to change this as a country.

And in case you wonder if your household income is less than around £33k you are in the bottom 50%

It didn't use to be this bad. So it CAN be better, we don't have to shrug and accept it.

OP posts:
ChishandFips33 · 04/05/2014 11:33

I agree there does need to be education of some people (not all) In how to handle the money they are given (I.e benefits, so the state is currently trying to even some balance and support the less well off) and what their priorities for that money should be

Some are technically very well paid through the benefit system, more so than some low earners yet because they choose to spend their money on the wrong priorities; materialistic things or cigarettes and beer/going out rather than food heat clothing for their children they then appear to have no money and are 'poor' and more money is thrown at them.

In my experience this is often when parents either didn't have their own needs met by their parents so continue to put their own needs before their children; are too immature (don't want to say too young as i know some excellent young parents) to be a parent and still have their own needs that need meeting or its the example they have been brought up with so know no different

There are so many issues in this country on so many scales (the above is just one small example at one end of the scale) that there can be no one blanket fix.

I grew up in a technically 'poor' family (on paper/income) but because my parents budgeted, prioritised and did without I didn't grow up with some of the poor issues reported today - going without breakfast, going hungry, malnourished, inappropriate clothing, freezing house etc

There is also a growing number of generational issues that will take an enormous length of time to sort and as reforms are introduced the backlash from them bring there own issues - like the stance on long term benefit claiming for those who are fit and able to work but manipulate the system - but I agree, it has to start somewhere

WooWooOwl · 04/05/2014 11:32

Perhaps you'd like to link to that research then ivykaty?

TucsonGirl · 04/05/2014 11:00

Sorry ivykaty but parental support of no benefit? That's utter bullshine. There's a clear difference between the sort of children who's parents value education and support/put pressure on them to succeed and the sort of children who's parents don't give a shit, and in some cases actually think it is funny that they get into trouble at school. Is there some crossover in the middle? Sure. But generally, the children who do well at school will have good, supportive parents, and the children who do badly at school will not.

ivykaty44 · 04/05/2014 10:18

Woo I read some research this week whereby they couldn't find any benefit to the child for parental support through schooling. In fact in some areas parental support through schooling was detrimental to the student.

I have two DDS and both have had the same level of encouragement but one would have and did dismiss the clean parks, piano, horse riding and the other embrassed it with glee. For both it was offered and encouraged at the same level.

Each DC is different and blaming the parents isn't a solution, it isn't the parents being educated

WooWooOwl · 03/05/2014 23:23

Squid, you are hoping for the impossible.

The biggest reason why children don't all have access to the same standard of education is because too many parents have low aspiration and low expectations of behaviour. Most schools are good, the thing that drags them down is a lack of support from parents.

You could give every child access to clean parks, libraries, horse riding and piano lessons, and it won't make any difference if their parents don't encourage them.

It's sad that there are so many incapable parents out there, but it is right that parents are responsible for their children.

You are probably right that some parents are debt adverse, but it's actually easier for the poorest families to access funding for higher education than it is for anyone other than the rich.

libertytrainers · 03/05/2014 22:45

all our jobs got cut in the public sector a few years back, the chief exec is on a salary of about 120k a year which would have kept us all in a job (and still delivering the service) for years

TucsonGirl · 03/05/2014 22:40

Maximum wage isn't remotely workable for the private sector. For the public sector, yes, absolutely. It's ridiculous how much some council chiefs are paid. They compare themselves to the heads of major companies employing the equivalent number of people on the same budget, but it isn't an accurate comparison at all.

TheTertiumSquid · 03/05/2014 22:40

In my mind the best way to reduce inequality is to give every child the same opportunities. Of course, each child's family values will influence them and some families value education more than others, but if every child had a really great education, and other opportunities like libraries, swimming pools, clean parks, space to exercise, it would flatten the disparities for the next generation. Especially if access to higher education appeared more accessible (the poorest families are often debt averse and therefore discouraged by the £9k/pa loans system). I'm a right old leftie, and this is what I would like to see - every child in our country has the same opportunity to better themselves and it doesn't depend on their parents wealth, education or influence.

libertytrainers · 03/05/2014 22:38

maximum wage would be good especially for public companies

TucsonGirl · 03/05/2014 22:28

If politicians were paid the national average it would become a job for the rich, even more so than it is now.

ivykaty44 · 03/05/2014 22:20

The priory, there have been some work places that have set up with a co- op type ethos where there can't be a worker earning more than say eight times what another worker earns for example. It does and can <a class="break-all" href="//worken.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mondrag%C3%B3n_Cooperative_Corporation" rel="nofollow" target="_blank">worken.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mondrag%C3%B3n_Cooperative_Corporation
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Worker_cooperative

ThePriory · 03/05/2014 13:50

These findings are good reasons to increase minimum wage, and introduce a maximum wage.

It is not in the interest of business to do so, so while business and government are in the same bed, it doesn't look promising. Legislation to limit the influence of business on politics, would be a social benefit.

I wondered if it should be the case, that rather politicians being paid a salary of £60+ p/a, why is their salary not set at the national average?

That would result in a direct intensive to level out wages / increase low-middle wages, particularly in the public sector.

weatherall · 03/05/2014 13:44

Near- it do think it's immoral and don't want any share of such a corruptable system.

ivykaty44 · 03/05/2014 12:46

the other recent quip about wages recently was that general Motors in the 1950 was the biggest employer in the USA and paid the equivalent of $50 per hour, now the biggest employer is walmart and they pay $8 per hour

Companies getting rich on the back of low wages is something that needs tackling, it sin't just in USA that wages are far to low

ivykaty44 · 03/05/2014 12:43

if the minimum wage had increased at the same rate as pay for the CEO of the 100 ftse index then the minimum wage would be £19 per hour
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/sep/06/recovery-election-question-living-standards

rabbitrisen · 03/05/2014 12:34

In that case, I dont understand Think's post.

NearTheWindymill · 03/05/2014 12:27

Yes, but it's progressive and banded.

rabbitrisen · 03/05/2014 12:24

I thought that the higher rate was after about £35,000?

NearTheWindymill · 03/05/2014 12:22

Well that's £120,000 per annum in tax then. Quite a big enough slug in my opinion.

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 03/05/2014 12:07

And in terms of tax rate you have to be earning a lot of money to give 40% of your income to the government. Even a 6 figure salary pays less than 30% on total income.
It must be close to £300k before your total is nearer 40%

OP posts:
ThePriory · 03/05/2014 11:51

I agree with everything everyone above has said. And Blochead, I agree with everything you said too except for your last statement
"We no longer have a truly free market, we have a system that is beginning to eat itself."

What we have firmly in place in the UK is a very effectively working free market. Thatcher and successive governments reduced and further reduced all legislation restricting the free market, removed so-called 'red tape' moved legislation closer to business interest and capital gain.

We are experiencing first-hand exactly what a free flowing, free-market capitalist society is like. (to repeat myself) It makes the wealthy even wealthier, and increases the gap between rick-and-poor.

I will only end up repeating myself again regarding what needs to be done, so I won#t but things need to change.

rabbitrisen · 03/05/2014 11:22

Tax loopholes should have more attention and be tightened imo.

I dont agree that tax should be more than 40%, that is quite high enough.
But if they all paid it, it would make quite a difference.

rabbitrisen · 03/05/2014 11:19

Also, I dont think that the wealthiest realise that they are more at risk of crime themselves when society gets very inequitable.

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 03/05/2014 11:08

There is nothing wrong with being wealthy.

Not intrinsically no. It is the wealth imbalance that is wrong. there is something very wrong with 5 families having the same value of assets as 12,600,000 families. That sort of wealth disparity is not good for a society.

Societies with the steepest inequality have worse health, educational attainment, happiness and higher crime, levels of anxiety and depression. Even the rich suffer on these measures in an unequal society. In an unequal society money can't buy you out of this. Which is weird and counter intuitive but fairly well researched.

OP posts:
NearTheWindymill · 03/05/2014 10:22

But if people's homes were taxed they would sell them and downsize and therefore pay less tax. If he did that your dad could gift you a nice £500,000 flat and providing he lived for seven years I bet you wouldn't say "no thank you dad, I believe that to be immoral".

Swipe left for the next trending thread