Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Deciding to try for a baby whilst at Medical school… am I mental?

206 replies

NurseDoctor · 19/04/2014 13:35

Hi everyone. I've seen a couple of similar posts but nothing very recent. First post here as i'm not actually qualified to be a "mums netter" yet (as not yet a mum!). I am a mature student studying medicine and living with my husband. We have been married for almost 4 years and have recently had a sit down/serious think about when will actually be an optimal time to have children. I am just finishing my first year and will have 4 months off for summer to work and build up our currently sad savings account. Due to the length of the course (5 years) and the 2 years of foundation training following this, followed by specialty selection and training, I can't see any "sensible" time for pregnancy and babies at all. In fact I can see it being put off until very late in life indeed. Unfortunately for me this isn't really a risk I want to take, as I have endometriosis, and, as my GP has kindly pointed out a number of times, the longer I delay the less chance i'll have of a natural conception. So here we are, one year into the course, seriously considering trying for a baby. Our thoughts at present are to possibly try between Sept-Dec this year for a Summer baby (during my holiday) but very aware that the chances of being lucky enough to achieve this are slim.
My question really is, are there any other mums out there who have had babies at university? Did you cope ok with the course? I am also very aware that, as the only married person on my course I will probably be of great interest to fellow students if I were pregnant, how did that make you feel? Sorry for the long post. Fortunately my husband is self employed and works from home, he is incredibly supportive. Pros with waiting seem to be mostly money and cons are time with the baby, chances of conception dwindling which would cause even greater stress.

OP posts:
flyingchick1 · 19/04/2014 20:13

Hi nurse doctor

I am a consultant in a medical specialty with one DC whom I had as a registrar. I would absolutely agree that the easiest times are either as a consultant or as a student. Although having a baby as a student will be difficult and you will need almost ft childcare, the hours that you " work" will actually be 8-5 ish, no night shifts or weekends or long 12 hour days which I think are especially hard with young children . Obviously you will have to do some studying in the evenings but this will still be the case when you are working full time and trying to study for postgrad exams ( which are in every specialty, including general practice). I know how hard it is for mums of very young children to be working as core trainees/ registrars and trying to pass their exams. I know of 2 ladies with similar backgrounds to yours who had babies during med school. They were very well supported by the uni and have since gone to become nhs consultants. So in summary I would say go for it now if you can manage financially and accept it will be hard graft for a few years!!

nocheeseinhouse · 19/04/2014 20:12

There is no right time to have a baby... People will be shocked (a female, having a baby, in her prime fertile years!), and will ask repeatedly 'are you keeping it?' 'but, it can't have been planned?!'

If you want a child, go ahead. Life (and medicine) will fit around it. PM me if you need any help navigating mat leave- you will get your NHS bursary in the same year, even if you take mat leave, you know, so that should help.

ImSoOverIt · 19/04/2014 20:05

I agree with your friend, having a baby means you have to become more disciplined and really make it count when you do get chance to study. In the first and second year I seemed to be constantly studying and still did fairly well, but when I went back I just had to accept I couldn't spend ridiculous amounts of time studying. I expected my marks to drop but that just wasn't the case. It helps that in your clinical years you just pick things up naturally from having more contact with patients.

ImSoOverIt · 19/04/2014 20:00

Everyone at medical school has been incredibly supportive. In fact I transferred medical schools between 2nd and 3rd year to be closer to family, and both medical schools have been extremely accommodating, although I haven't really needed any special allowances/extra help if I'm honest. But they have made it clear it is there if I need it.

It does frustrate me that we are always told we can't have it all, as men seem to be able to!

And for me, having a baby didn't change my priorities that much. Of course i love her to death, I have done all I can to make sure she is happy and well looked after - she is 3 now and very bright and well adjusted. What I mean is that I am still as career driven as before, maybe even more so as I want to build a better life for us as a family. I suspect that will also be the case for you as a mature student, you have worked hard to get where you are and I doubt you will suddenly want to jack it in if you have a baby.

I was 28 when I had dd btw. Interestingly my endometriosis wasn't diagnosed until after I had her. So with hindsight I was glad she came along when she did, as I don't know how easy it will be for me to conceive again if I decide to try for another. I'm 32 now and start f1 in August - no big rush to have another, but I am aware my clock is ticking! Also want to make sure I will get maternity pay for the next one.Wink

It is good that you have your bank nursing as a back-up, as you won't get any student loans or maternity pay if you take a year out. Also if you have been working in the lead up to your pregnancy you will be entitled to maternity allowance, it is calculated based on your typical earnings so make sure you do as much bank work as possible before you have the baby. Smile

NurseDoctor · 19/04/2014 19:54

ImSoOverIt Definitely don't apologise for it, shout from the rooftops! Very impressive! I only know one person who has done it and she said she found the less time she had to study the more proactive she was during that time. No more watching Keeping up with the kardashians and online shopping! I wasn't sure whether to believe her or think she's just crazy clever!

OP posts:
yellowdinosauragain · 19/04/2014 19:52

And nothing wrong with being boastful about such a fantastic achievement. Not that I think you sounded boastful anyway... I didn't do nearly as well as you at med school and that was without a small baby (although probably significantly more drinking than you will have managed with a newborn :o)

NurseDoctor · 19/04/2014 19:51

smartypants1000 No offence was meant. I have people in my own family with mental health problems, but as you would never call someone with these issues "mental" I have never found anyone who has been offended. Definitely wasn't meant that way, it's just a term i've always heard in an informal/jokey manner, same as saying am I insane to consider this? I'm not actually referring to anyone with mental health problems and if i've offended I apologise.

My husband runs his own business from home, mostly online, and has very flexible hours. He is incredibly supportive and luckily very good with children (his brother and sister are much younger than him, he helped to bring them up). My mum has also offered to stay with us after the birth to help with the newborn, something i'd gladly jump at if everything works out. You're right, if we have more than one we probably would have to consider doing this during medical school, or possibly before my F1 year. This is another reason I am hesitant to delay until i've 32, as this would mean i've be mid 30s by a second baby. My gynaecologist was very pressing that before my 30s my chances would be far greater. I guess it's swings and roundabouts!

OP posts:
yellowdinosauragain · 19/04/2014 19:50

Massive hats off to imsooverit. Bloody well done to you and I wish you all the best in the future too

ImSoOverIt · 19/04/2014 19:46

Thank you. Blush I know I sounded a bit boastful there, but just wanted to get the point across that having a baby won't necessarily mean you'll do badly!

Dp is very good though, and does as much around the house and childcare as I do. I took a year out, but most of that was spent pregnant so I got a job as a receptionist, so if you can carry in studying throughout your pregnancy that could be better. I had dd in January,went back when dd was 9 months and I felt ready, still breastfed her to 12 months - managed to get a good childminder, dp starts work early and finishes early, and family help out so she is only I childcare 3 days a week. It will definitely help if you have good support from your dh and family. I don't think it's any harder having a baby at medical school than it is balancing any demanding career.

Just make sure that dp is prepared to take over childcare/housework in the run up to ISCEs/assignment deadlines etc.

NurseDoctor · 19/04/2014 19:44

ImSoOverIt Ha we are twins! So glad to hear of someone in similar shoes doing so well! Did you find your Medical school supportive?

OP posts:
smartypants1000 · 19/04/2014 19:27

The term "mental" is as offensive as "mong" and "spaz", op, just so you know.

Aside from that...hmm, a lot to consider and only you will know whether it's right for you. Personally I think it would be highly unrealistic not to plan on taking a year out. Do you plan to breastfeed? Also something to think about when condisering how much time off you'd need. Don't underestimate how difficult it would be to leave a baby of 3 or 4 months old. For you and for the baby. What does your dh do? Any chance of him being at home with baby for a bit? From my experience, it's not so much the physical recovery from the birth but the fact that after having a baby I wasn't able to focus on much outside of my baby bubble, and motivating myself to study was very difficult (I had my first during a PhD, never completed, now have three children and one on the way). But I do know people who have been different than I am and gone back to work quickly.

Also, I read that you're only 26...that would make you 32 when you finish f2, which is hardly late in life. I understand about endometriosis and the fears around that but also wonder whether delaying until the age of 32 will make as much of a difference as you think? Also, think about whether you're going to want more than one child. Will you want a 7 year age gap? If not, you'd need to do this twice during Medical School??

AreWeThereYeti · 19/04/2014 19:24

Lol, cross post.

The endometriosis isn't impressive but the rest is Grin

AreWeThereYeti · 19/04/2014 19:23

ImSoOverIt That's really impressive. Smile Thanks.

ImSoOverIt · 19/04/2014 19:23

Sockqueen is also correct that you can apply directly to your foundation school if you have a child. That's what I did, although you do still have to compete for jobs within the deanery.

ImSoOverIt · 19/04/2014 19:20

Oh and I have endometriosis too! And a mature student. Are you me? Grin

ImSoOverIt · 19/04/2014 19:19

And fwiw I am placed in the 2nd decile of my cohort and will probably graduate with merit, so it won't necessarily affect your performance.

NurseDoctor · 19/04/2014 19:18

Thanks everyone! It's definitely given me a lot of food for thought!
Will also depend how things pan out conception wise! May not be in the cards yet… Thanks for the input

OP posts:
ImSoOverIt · 19/04/2014 19:17

I took a year out to have dd between my second and third year of medical school, but she was unplanned. I i'm quite glad I had her then as I think it would've been harder after starting f1. We have managed fine

You get generous loans and childcare grants as a student parent.

I say go for it!Grin

yellowdinosauragain · 19/04/2014 19:15

Sockqueen is right that there is no perfect time. There are better and worse times for sure but these will be different for everyone depending on your speciality, what support you have and what your own personal stressors are.

Scottishmummy has it nailed though about not being able to have it all. Something has to give and with you it would most likely be not doing as well as you otherwise might at medical school and probably your marriage needing to take a break seat (to be honest this is the case really with tiny babies anyway).

You've had some good advice and the bottom line is it may work out for you or you may find it overwhelming but have a good think through your options with all the pros and cons. You will make a decision that is right for you and whatever happens in the future I'm sure you'll make it work for the best. Good luck

SockQueen · 19/04/2014 19:01

I think whenever you do it, it'll be tricky, but most people get through one way or another. At a work party a while ago, several consultants (possibly assisted by some vino) took it upon themselves to tell me their thoughts on the best time for me to have children. One said "wait till you've got your CCT," another said "get a registrar number" and another one said "well, my wife got pregnant in her house officer year and we managed in the end." I think there is no perfect time in medicine.

NurseDoctor · 19/04/2014 18:47

Onlysteelheals scottishmummy some really important points raised. I definitely think it will be an enormous challenge. Luckily my DH is incredibly supportive. When we discussed this he basically said he is willing to be the primary care giver if need be (for e.g. as he works for himself if child was sick and needed collecting from nursery he would be the one to do it). We basically made this decision when I decided to return to University for Medicine, as I knew at some point, whether it be during training or after, there would be a struggle.

I guess at the moment my main concern is the unknown. I can't think that i'll definitely cope with both when I have no experience of being a mum. It's really great to get some input from people who have first hand experience, or those with other related experience. Thanks everyone!

OP posts:
scottishmummy · 19/04/2014 18:31

Op Has a partner and family,they'll need to step in to support op if she has realistic chance of completion
What op need be mindful of is not be default taking on all parenting because she's mum
Trade off after the Initial slog is stable,in demand career

Onlysteelheals · 19/04/2014 18:31

I think that pp have raised a very good point. I have given up on being 'the best'. When I was in my early years of training, I was always in - coming in on weekends or staying late to get in on theatre as well as taking on extra duties/projects to get ahead. When DH was still working and I did pickups and had to leave on time. The weekends were spent as a family with a bit of time set aside for revision. It's much easier now with DH at home and a dept where most of the bosses have kids themselves and get the whole family work life balance.

I think things will be easier in some ways for you as a sister already. The language of medicine isn't new to you and you are already used to working all hours. I used to teach at a med school and by far and away the mature students were the ones with their heads screwed on. School leavers were shocked at the gear shift as well as constantly comparing themselves to non medics and struggling with the hrs.

2rebecca · 19/04/2014 18:26

The problem with going for a child now is that the child then becomes your priority. This makes studying and work stressful and it's a stressful career already. If you wait 4-5 years then you have had 4-5 lower stress years where you are more likely to have done well, plus you'll be working so can get part time work and mat leave.
I'd leave it.

scottishmummy · 19/04/2014 18:14

Yes you'll need to use ft childcare and yes you'll need to be focused upon career
No woman has it all you need to make informed choices and understand implications
That said,if you invest the mental.emotional,physical energy into your career you'll feel satisfied

But I see your a ward sister,and will have first hand experience of medicine and its demands.that'll be useful in being realistic and understanding the hierarchical nature of medicine.

Garner all available support from dh and extended family. Accept you can't have it all.if you want a demanding vocational career,something's gives.however as yiu progress and her more senior,you'll be more able to negotiate and suit your preferences

Best wishes