Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Deciding to try for a baby whilst at Medical school… am I mental?

206 replies

NurseDoctor · 19/04/2014 13:35

Hi everyone. I've seen a couple of similar posts but nothing very recent. First post here as i'm not actually qualified to be a "mums netter" yet (as not yet a mum!). I am a mature student studying medicine and living with my husband. We have been married for almost 4 years and have recently had a sit down/serious think about when will actually be an optimal time to have children. I am just finishing my first year and will have 4 months off for summer to work and build up our currently sad savings account. Due to the length of the course (5 years) and the 2 years of foundation training following this, followed by specialty selection and training, I can't see any "sensible" time for pregnancy and babies at all. In fact I can see it being put off until very late in life indeed. Unfortunately for me this isn't really a risk I want to take, as I have endometriosis, and, as my GP has kindly pointed out a number of times, the longer I delay the less chance i'll have of a natural conception. So here we are, one year into the course, seriously considering trying for a baby. Our thoughts at present are to possibly try between Sept-Dec this year for a Summer baby (during my holiday) but very aware that the chances of being lucky enough to achieve this are slim.
My question really is, are there any other mums out there who have had babies at university? Did you cope ok with the course? I am also very aware that, as the only married person on my course I will probably be of great interest to fellow students if I were pregnant, how did that make you feel? Sorry for the long post. Fortunately my husband is self employed and works from home, he is incredibly supportive. Pros with waiting seem to be mostly money and cons are time with the baby, chances of conception dwindling which would cause even greater stress.

OP posts:
scottishmummy · 19/04/2014 21:58

Professional job,ft work,family is achievable.just don't put self under pressure to have it all
Work and family.This is what working people do every day.you just get on with it
IMO,be realistic,accept something gives and don't compare yourself to other people.

ImSoOverIt · 19/04/2014 21:55

No I very much doubt I'll be indispensable (I'll probably be more of a liability to begin with to be honest!) I just mean it might be tricky to just leave sometimes, especially if there are things that need doing on the ward. And on the occasions I have had to leave I have made no apologies for it.

I just mean that when I have a bit more responsibility there may be occasions on balance where it is easier for dp to leave work than me. He has done as much if the childcare than me, so could offer as much comfort to dd is I could if she was ill etc. But if I was genuinely needed of course I would have no guilt in going.

I have also found as a student, may be different as a doctor, no one has ever judged or objected when I have had to take emergency time off for childcare issues.

nocheeseinhouse · 19/04/2014 21:52

I would disagree with the idea that GP=good for families, acute specialties= bad. I think these myths are unhelpful. GP can involve long days, where you wouldn't see the child at all, where as shifts may allow more time at home in their waking hours. I think this myth allows misogynists/HR to continue to make life hard for females in acute specialities, for wanting rotas in advance etc, by pushing towards GP.

TBH, I doubt it's a 'bloody nightmare', I'm sure it's as manageable as for most professional parents. People have jobs, people have babies. There are options to sort it out. Being a displaced person in Syria is a 'bloody nightmare', not sorting out childcare for a well, developmentally normal child.

flossietta · 19/04/2014 21:45

I think it depends in what speciality you want to go into. Im a GP, it is easier for GP trainees to manage to have babies and train.

I just remember F1/2 and also ST1-2 the horrible hours, night shifts, unpredictable rotas where you're only given them a week before starting a job and the exhaustion was awful and that was before I had my DD!

My plan (and thank God it worked out) was to have a baby at the end of my ST2 year, take a year off, go back and do ST3 full time (including my exams). It was beyond tiring but I managed it.

I know a few people who had babies during F2 or their early ST years (even if you do GP you would still be doing hospital rotations with night shifts etc in ST1/2) and they were so tired but managed it, everyone has. I don't know anyone who had had a baby and quit medicine/became bad at her job. However if you don't have much help/can't afford a nanny it can be a real challenge. We don't have help with DD and can't afford a nanny so use nursery care and even now it's a bloody nightmare with the shifts I work (GP lifestyle ain't 9-5).

I knew a few mature students (and I mean in their late 30s) who had babies and they also managed but financially it was tough.

I reckon in your circumstances, go for it. If you have your baby earlier on in your medical degree by the time you qualify they will be school ageish and it will be easier to cope with doing night shifts etc.

Good luck.

nocheeseinhouse · 19/04/2014 21:33

I'm a single parent, so I always respond to 'the call'. If it's a choice between ward and your child, there is always someone to cover the ward.

Don't do that doctor thing of thinking you're indispensable, no one is. The only place you're indispensable is when your child needs you. (I mean really needs you, and no one else will do.)

ImSoOverIt · 19/04/2014 21:30

It's always been me that has taken time off on the rare occasions dd has been sick, Mostly because dp is the one who's job actually pays the bills at the moment, and he is actually needed at work. Nobody has ever really noticed nor cared if I've had to leave the Ward early when on placement. In fact my attendance is still better than most if the other students! Probably another reason why having a baby at medical school is better, it is fairly easy to take time off, you are not being paid to be there and your presence is not essential, and your absence won't affect patient care.

When I start F1 I will be far harder for me to take time off at short notice, so dp will have to start responding to ^the call^ I think!

scottishmummy · 19/04/2014 21:21

Yes,stuff happens.thats life.you just plan which parent responds when you get the call

ImSoOverIt · 19/04/2014 21:18

No childcare can be cast iron anyway. Kids get ill, childminders get ill.

ImSoOverIt · 19/04/2014 21:15

My dd had a childminder. I went on elective and after being in India for a couple of days, my childminder emailed me to say she was quitting, so I had no childcare for when I got back. By email I managed to enroll her in a pre-school and she loves it.

Live can throw these things at you but nothing is insurmountable.

scottishmummy · 19/04/2014 21:06

Well yes that's the bottom line in childcare,if you throw money at it.it resolves
I had my summer childcare booked in jan.If something goes tits up,yes we'd chuck cash at it too
It's the territory of both working,you need good reliable childcare

nocheeseinhouse · 19/04/2014 21:01

Cast iron childcare will fall apart... and it's having the personal coping skills to deal with that. I went through a stage of thinking I needed cast iron childcare, then it fell apart.

Now, I make a childcare plan, but am aware that even if I haven't found someone to cover my night shift next week, it's a week away, and I'll sort something. I'm much more chilled these days. So, a) if you think your childcare is cast iron, it isn't, and there will be a time your kid ends up at work for half an hour at least, and b) don't fret that your childcare may not be 'cast iron', and finally c) you can always call in a favour, throw money at it, and you will get through.

I spent too long planning my 'cast iron' childcare, now I fudge it, and am more chilled, kids are adaptable, and I don't feel the world has ended when something I thought was 'cast iron' falls through, and I know it's eggshell really!

highkickindandy · 19/04/2014 21:00

I am a consultant. I had my 2 children when I was a specialist registrar and went back as a flexible trainee part time after both. That was not without its difficulties but it worked for me. You do see people more junior than you overtaking you but I wasn't too bothered by that.

One of the students in my year at medical school had a baby in 3rd or 4th year. She didn't take a year out but used her elective to catch up on blocks she'd missed. She was very bright and very motivated, won some prizes with finals. I think she had good family support. I don't think I'd have managed the way she did, but it's certainly possible.

scottishmummy · 19/04/2014 20:55

It's achievable with planning,cast iron childcare,and support
It's not insurmountable,it just needs to be approached realistically
But op has extended family and dh on board,so that bodes well

ImSoOverIt · 19/04/2014 20:55

I think I will probably go by my own experiences and the accounts from other people on here who have actually been to medical school and had children during that time, who have actually managed fine.

babydoctor · 19/04/2014 20:53

I am currently a full time fy1 trainee, who had my dd at medical school in my penultimate year. I studied till a week before my due date, took a year off, then returne to finish the year. I even did an exam on my year off with no childcare. Dd was also poorly and hardly ever slept and I was a single mum too.

It was hard going. I was competing in exams with students who had no other commitments, whereas I had to look after dd. I managed to do pretty well though.

I chose to do fy1 full time as ltft training adds significant time onto the already long training. This has been hard going at times though as all my jobs have been banded too, so I am doing lots of evenings/weekends too. It is great experience though, and I think that on calls are a vital part of training.

In summary: its hard but doable, and no time is perfect, so if you seriously want a child then I would go for it. Feel free to PM me.

scottishmummy · 19/04/2014 20:50

?hat I mean is,the have it all myth is exciting career,but always available to family
Career and family in equal uncompeting amounts isn't always attainable.something gives
There are compromises all parents make if in a ft career,IMO it's not possible to have it all

Certainly seniority and progression bring ability to negotiate and work a better fit.

ImSoOverIt · 19/04/2014 20:35

I get what you're saying Scottish mummy, but I don't agree that it is expecting too much to be able to complete a medical degree and also have a family.

I have managed to complete medical school quite successfully and raise a happy healthy child. Neither has had to suffer, so didn't feel the need to try and discourage the op from doing what will make her happy.

Fedupofplaystation · 19/04/2014 20:33

I had DD1 (now 2.5years) inbetween 4th and 5th year of med school. It was a very difficult decision to have her as I'd had some time out to have surgery for endometriosis, the result of which was my gynae consultant saying now or never.
It was the best thing I ever did. I went back when DD was 7 months and still waking hourly. We had no family nearby. DD went to a childminder, mostly paid for by NHS bursaries. It was difficult when DD was ill, but we juggled it. The med school (Nottingham) was very understanding and often let me make up placement hours in evenings and on weekends if I ever had to miss time.
I did well in finals and am now an LTFT FY1. I'm loving the work life balance that being an LTFT allows and, if my colleagues and appraisals are to be believed am doing well at work. I am now expecting my second child and will take a year's maternity leave between my two FY1 years. I'm 25, so in no rush to get to consultancy.
I think it's prooving easier for me, an LTFT FY1, coping with work and a young child than some of my friends starting families in reg years.
In summary: if it's what you want, go for it! Feel free to PM me if you want to talk about it further, I promise I'll be brutally honest about my experience so far Wink.

scottishmummy · 19/04/2014 20:30

No one has it all it's a myth.you want career and studies,something gives
Men certainly don't have it all,they are stereotypically expected to step up as earner
But then I don't think anyone should pursue the have it all myth.its unachievable

thewavesofthesea · 19/04/2014 20:30

Oh, and I am studying for postgrad exams currently. My DSs are 2 and 4. It is hard finding time to work (I currently work 3 full days a week) and study, but I am so much more disciplined and make better use of the time when I have it. Having a supportive DP is very important with this, and mine is :-)

uselessidiot · 19/04/2014 20:30

You will need cast iron child care plans. I'm a student (not medicine so less demanding) but having children pushes me regularly over the edge into exhaustion. Although tbf most people are more capable than me. My first sentence still applies though.

ImSoOverIt · 19/04/2014 20:28

It looks from that link that you have to already be receiving an nhs bursary to claim it when on leave. You don't get an nhs bursary at medical school til the 5th year, so medical students won't be entitled to it if taking time out.

Phew! Thought I'd missed a trick there!

thewavesofthesea · 19/04/2014 20:24

Hi,

Registered with Mumsnet just to reply to this! I am a doctor, and have two kids. To put a different spin on it, I had my first during the Foundation Programme, and my second within the first few months of my specialty training. I worked part time from after when I came back to work with my first, and was able to work at 50%. Not easy and means I have always had to be very on the ball and proactive to make sure that I organise my training around my childcare etc.

Have you considered a specialty yet? I know it shouldn't be the case but some are easier to train part time in then others. One of the downsides of waiting until after your degree and being part-time etc is that you end up being 'behind' and seeing people who were your junior progressing faster etc. It really doesn't bother me anymore but used to. I qualified in 2007 and and am only in ST2 (fourth year of training).

Please PM if you want more details :-)

nocheeseinhouse · 19/04/2014 20:23

Yes, it was 'clarified' a few years ago that it would be gender discrimination not to give it, I remember being surprised! www.nhsbsa.nhs.uk/1667.aspx

Probably better to start your family as a student, than in Foundation.

ImSoOverIt · 19/04/2014 20:18

No cheese, can you get nhs bursary during a year out? I didn't claim anything. Confused