Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Deciding to try for a baby whilst at Medical school… am I mental?

206 replies

NurseDoctor · 19/04/2014 13:35

Hi everyone. I've seen a couple of similar posts but nothing very recent. First post here as i'm not actually qualified to be a "mums netter" yet (as not yet a mum!). I am a mature student studying medicine and living with my husband. We have been married for almost 4 years and have recently had a sit down/serious think about when will actually be an optimal time to have children. I am just finishing my first year and will have 4 months off for summer to work and build up our currently sad savings account. Due to the length of the course (5 years) and the 2 years of foundation training following this, followed by specialty selection and training, I can't see any "sensible" time for pregnancy and babies at all. In fact I can see it being put off until very late in life indeed. Unfortunately for me this isn't really a risk I want to take, as I have endometriosis, and, as my GP has kindly pointed out a number of times, the longer I delay the less chance i'll have of a natural conception. So here we are, one year into the course, seriously considering trying for a baby. Our thoughts at present are to possibly try between Sept-Dec this year for a Summer baby (during my holiday) but very aware that the chances of being lucky enough to achieve this are slim.
My question really is, are there any other mums out there who have had babies at university? Did you cope ok with the course? I am also very aware that, as the only married person on my course I will probably be of great interest to fellow students if I were pregnant, how did that make you feel? Sorry for the long post. Fortunately my husband is self employed and works from home, he is incredibly supportive. Pros with waiting seem to be mostly money and cons are time with the baby, chances of conception dwindling which would cause even greater stress.

OP posts:
NurseDoctor · 19/04/2014 22:24

Bertiesgal thanks for your input! I think some people are very naive to the realities of F1,F2 etc. I think that's partly why I'm considering babies during training. However I'd then have to cope with children instead, which I guess isn't a whole lot easier. Can I ask why you were expected to do 90 hour weeks when on 50%? Thanks!

OP posts:
ImSoOverIt · 19/04/2014 22:23

I also really don't like the fact that at a careers event I went to recently, every specialty was trying to sell there's as being family friendly so "great for women".

I also hated the fact that less than full time training sales pitch seemed to be aimed at women as well. I have absolutely no objection to people working part time if they want to, but I don't want to thank you! I would only ever work part time if my husband/partner was prepared to do the same.

flossietta · 19/04/2014 22:23

Well I have no experience as a mum in hospital speciality so I guess I can't say for certain nocheese but speaking with my friends who are in hospital specialities and have children and similar circumstances to me they struggle more.

Childcare in general is massive bugbear of mine. The Race for Pickup is a cause of massive anxiety for me in work.

However thinking about it I get highly pissed off that a lot of my hospital colleagues say GP in general is the easy option so maybe I'm just perpetuating that stereotype in a different way? My head now hurts...

bertiesgal · 19/04/2014 22:19

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

NurseDoctor · 19/04/2014 22:19

ImSoOverIt woh... And he wants his daughter to grow up to be what exactly?

OP posts:
flossietta · 19/04/2014 22:18

When I went back after Mat Leave to Full Time for ST3, I got a lot of comments of 'why on earth aren't you going back part time' from everyone in GP because that is the norm. I was seen as the weirdo. I'm still full time now, my daughter hasn't suffered (despite what MIL said). Perhaps if DH was in the medical profession as well there would have been even more pressure for me to do LTFT.

One of my best friends in F1 is now an ortho SpR, she always said to us we should 'be the change'. I still hold to that.

NurseDoctor · 19/04/2014 22:17

I think GPs are an important, vital part of medicine. I also know half of medical students now (actually slightly more than half) are female. Yet far more men are consultants than woman, either the women are giving up or being pushed out. There is no way that proportion of women have no other medical speciality they want to pursue.

My other issue is, due to knowing absolutely no one who has had a baby on my course I really have no idea how supportive my university would be...

OP posts:
ImSoOverIt · 19/04/2014 22:17

On my first day back at medical school after having dd, the surgeon I was in theatre with was asking me lots of questions about my background so inevitably I told him I had moved from a different medical school after having my daughter etc. one of the registrars overheard and said I should be at home looking after my daughter, like his wife who was a "good mother". Shock

Wanker

nocheeseinhouse · 19/04/2014 22:15

Oh, sorry, flossietta, I wasn't calling you a misogynist, just that I think the GP-myth is peddled by a misogynistic NHS/society. Then they beat us as being the cause of the breakdown of the NHS.

nocheeseinhouse · 19/04/2014 22:13

I don't think it's true, flossietta. Perhaps proved by the fact you find childcare such a struggle?

Life, in general, is not easy. It's not fair, and it's not easy. But if you're finding something a 'bloody nightmare', then perhaps GP isn't 'the easiest'?

Some deaneries are certainly better than others, and I can name one which is absolutely shite, and peddles the 'GP is the only way to have a family' crap at every level. I wonder if you're there?

NurseDoctor · 19/04/2014 22:13

Sorry flossietta definitely wasn't aimed at you. I see nothing wrong with being a GP, especially if it suits your lifestyle. One cardiology consultant I've met with 2 children said her key to success was a super supportive OH, willing to put his career on the back burner. She had her first as a reg but did do medicine at 18. I think deaneries definitely seem to vary, as do work colleagues who can themselves seem to totally change the atmosphere medic mothers have to be part of. I guess I just feel there should be opportunity for female medics to enter any speciality regardless of children

OP posts:
ImSoOverIt · 19/04/2014 22:12

There are also many medical couples at my hospital where the husband is a consultant and the wife is a part-time staff grade because she had kids. I know it is their business what they do, but it still makes me cross. It always seems to be the default for a woman's career to take a back seat, but yet a man can still have a family and a career, and no one judges him if he works long hours.

flossietta · 19/04/2014 22:12

Oh and I am NOT a misogynist.

scottishmummy · 19/04/2014 22:09

Exactly,it's that assumption the female will go on mummy track.its not expected of men
Chose specialism by your ability,interest and desire to do it.let's face you'll be working 30+ odd years
Best wishes with your studies

flossietta · 19/04/2014 22:09

Can I just say I dont 'have the stereotype' or whatever. I don't like that it is easier to have babies as GP. But it is and that is the way it is. I don't know how it can change or as I say it has changed since I was in hospital but according to my hospital friends who are mums, it doesn't seem to be the case. Perhaps I'm in a really backwards deanery?

NurseDoctor · 19/04/2014 22:08

Before recently I never considered a baby during uni an option, but when you sit down and take a hard look at the career path there are very few opportunities...

OP posts:
ImSoOverIt · 19/04/2014 22:06

I always do try not to take the piss, I have actually gained a reputation for having good attendance at medical school - as I mentioned earlier lots of the other students have the odd morning off for hangovers etc but I always try to turn up to everything and be on time, so that if I do then need time off for a genuine reason, people don't think you're taking the piss.

Dd's got the constitution of an ox though and is rarely sick (touch wood) so hopefully all will be good once I start work! Smile

flossietta · 19/04/2014 22:06

Nocheeseinthehouse I do find childcare a bloody nightmare. It is the bane of my life. Comparing that to the Syria situation is rather ridiculous. Perhaps you find that phrase overdramatic so I shall rephrase, I have found the childcare aspect a real struggle.

And I shall rephrase. If you are a doctor like me, who has absolutely no help at all and a partner who works shifts, nights and weekends and also cannot answer 'the call' then GP is easier for those mothers. As I said I'm a GP, I'm aware of what my job involves thanks. We don't have changeable rotas given with minimal notice, we don't do nightshifts and we have weekends off (at the moment) However we still do very long days and do on calls once a week but I can plan for that as my rota won't change. If I was in an hospital speciality I can tell you now there would be no way I would have coped with it as a mother. Maybe it was the hospital I worked at or things have changed since I was last in hospital but IMO GP is an easier option to have babies in. If it wasn't then I don't know why lots if my colleagues who have kids have reapplied to GP.

I wish it wasn't the case and perhaps it is no longer the case and things have changed since my last hospital based job in 2009.

NurseDoctor · 19/04/2014 22:05

In all honesty I find it shocking so many people still have this stereotype that women should only pick certain specialities if wanting children. It's hard because I know it's best to find the right fit for your lifestyle, but I've met male consultants with 4...5 even 6 kids and no one ever says well when do you see your children? I guess I'm fortunate that my DH sees us as equals, if anything he's pretty enthusiastic for my career to take the lead. We shall see! ImSoOverIt this is kind of how I was thinking about it. So long as I'm a student patients care/treatment won't be compromised if I have to miss the occasional day, whereas when I'm employed the buck stops with me

OP posts:
angeltulips · 19/04/2014 22:04

One of my closest friends did exactly this - she sat her second set of exams 9 weeks after she gave birth to her first.

She graduated with honours and is now a general surgeon. It can be done!!

nocheeseinhouse · 19/04/2014 22:04

Exactly. If only the NHS had more dicks in it, we'll be hunky-dory.

themockingjay · 19/04/2014 22:03

I was in a similar position to you I was completing my masters when I decided to try for a baby.

I thought the sensible option was to wait until my mum told me if You wait for the 'right' time to have a baby you'll never have one. I took her advice Grin

I was pregnant before the course finished I had to take 1 year maternity leave to pick up all my modules a year later. But Loved having a full year off tbh, though it was hard getting into the studying frame of mind again I managed it and now have my masters. (not that You can tell with the state of my spelling and grammar on mnet Grin )

I was also on a masters where I had to work / study

ImSoOverIt · 19/04/2014 22:02

And if course according to the daily mail, increasing numbers if women doctors are solely responsible for the NHS financial difficulties...Hmm

nocheeseinhouse · 19/04/2014 22:01

You sound sensible!

People may well judge you for taking time off for childcare issues once you're a doctor. If you need time off, you have to not let that get to you. (But also, not take the piss! Wink) There may be resentment, but you need to keep in mind that resentment is, at root, of 'the system'/HR, not actually you, who is being entirely reasonable. The time when your kids are young is a tiny part of your entire career. If you can defer to DH, then it'll probably help you keep on everyone's good side!

ImSoOverIt · 19/04/2014 21:59

Nocheese - tell me about it. I hate the whole "women shouldn't be surgeons because they have kids" bollocks. Had quite a heated debate with a male student on this topic.