Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think any Secondary School with 75% High Attainers and 2% Low Attainers is A Grammar School no matter itsclassifaction

44 replies

motown3000 · 20/03/2014 11:35

I have looked on the Department of education Performance Tables, and have noticed Schools like Watford Girls/Boys Parmiters, are Grammar Schools. They are Called Comprehensive Schools to be Politically correct and admit 3 or 4 Low ability pupils each year to keep the Comprehensive classification.

Why do we have to have this "Fakery" of pretending to be a Comprehensive , because they are not allowed to be a Grammar school , despite actually being one.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 12/03/2022 09:09

A school that doesn’t select via the 11 plus is not a grammar.

Comprehensives that do well academically will typically be in more expensive areas and so a greater proportion of their intake will be from better off, better educated parents - who can afford to buy or rent in the area.

We’re in a grammar school area where already very high property prices are driven even higher by people moving here because of the schools.

Any better than average comprehensive within a relatively pricey catchment area will doubtless be the same.

Bunnycat101 · 12/03/2022 08:59

Parmiters is an interesting one. I had relatives apply being picking private. It was very much viewed as a grammar by them. The interesting dynamic is the siblings one so if you’re selecting 35% on academic and music there is probably an assumption that the siblings of those 35% are probably equally bright. Obviously there will be some families where that isn’t the case or there are additional needs which change the overall intake but you’re still going to be getting a pretty bright cohort.

balalake · 12/03/2022 07:26

The area a school is in and how oversubscribed means that it is possible for there to be 75% high achievers and not be a grammar, but the OPs point about what seem to be loopholes is well made.

Delectable · 12/03/2022 03:28

@Mintyy

It makes the results at my dd's school which is truly comprehensive and takes anyone and everyone look really good in that case Grin.
You reckon the results for these 3 are poor in comparison to most Grammars?
tiggytape · 20/03/2014 17:10

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

GertTheFlirt · 20/03/2014 17:05

sometimeslonely

You must be of my age or thereabouts. We still have the grammar schools here and the Tech Colleges as were, achieved Grammar Status. I do remember the introduction of 'comprehensives' but they didn't last very long round these 'ere parts.

Interestingly - any grammar school that has academy status (we are completely academy in this LA) has no legal standing as a grammar school BUT can call its self what it like and use selective testing. The new academy chains such as harris use the banded entry test, and although they wont admit they are selective, they certainly prune out

motown3000 · 20/03/2014 17:02

Department of Education Performance Tables Website. WWW. Dept Of Education Performance Tables...

OP posts:
Mintyy · 20/03/2014 17:01

Where did you get those stats from Motown?

Mintyy · 20/03/2014 17:00

It makes the results at my dd's school which is truly comprehensive and takes anyone and everyone look really good in that case Grin.

motown3000 · 20/03/2014 16:59

Some Interesting figures from the three schools that show similar attainment and FSM with the exception that Watford Boys has a Relative high no of SEN students. All three schools have the "Magic" 2% Low Ability pupils.

Watford Boys : FSM 3.6% , 8.5% SEN , Ability Range 2% Low 18% Middle 80% High % A*- C 91% Gcse % AAB @ A Level 50%

Watford Girls : FSM 3.3% , 1.5% SEN, Ability Range 2% Low 22% Middle 75% High % A* - C 92% Gcse % AAB @ A Level 34%

Parmiters : FSM 4.6% , 2.9% SEN, Ability Range 2% Low 25% Middle
73% High % A* - C 93% Gcse % AAB@ A Level 39%.

The three schools have results Especially at A Level that most Grammar Schools don't match and probably they are not 100% at Gcse is down to the 2% of Low ability students and a couple of Lower Middle Ability students.

OP posts:
GertTheFlirt · 20/03/2014 16:51

Whether you like it or not, often the state grammars do provide a superior education. There is enough of the socialist in me to know every child deserves an elite education and it shouldnt only be in the realm of the the top 22%. On the other hand I know that no everyone shares the same views with regard to valuing education.

dawntigga · 20/03/2014 16:25

The same way outstanding primary schools in our area seem to have a lower population of fsm students than the local population tells us they should have. LA's practice selection at this level and it makes it easier at comp level. There's nothing that can be proved but it's very telling which families make it in and which do not. This is not sour grapes as The Cub attends a fab local school and we didn't apply to the outstanding schools.

NotAConspiracyBelieverUsuallyTiggaxx

SometimesLonely · 20/03/2014 15:26

It wasn't just grammar schools and secondary moderns before comprehensives. There were three categories and the third was technical schools.

Secondary moderns produced children who could go on to further education at colleges and some whom I knew became 'stenographers', which was thought to be a desirable career in those days (working in an office v working in a factory).

Technical colleges produced all sorts as well and I know a man who went to one and finished up at the Royal College of Music and played a woodwind instrument in a well known orchestra. He was not alone.

As for the 11+ to get into a grammar school, it was possible to change to a grammar school when you were 13 if you were up to it but it did mean a lot of hard work once there. Probably still does.

NancyJones · 20/03/2014 15:06
SometimesLonely · 20/03/2014 15:06

My experience as a parent of children at a comprehensive is that they are allowed to 'select' after entry to the school and therefore stream so you get the brightest in stream A and the streams go down to Remedial classes. Subject classes are also in sets so someone from Stream B or C can be taught, say Geography, in Set B of Stream A so they still achieve. My children got into the school during its first year as a comprehensive after finishing as a grammar school and the grammar head stayed there. We were lucky. For languages, French, German, Russian,Spanish and Latin were taught. How many comprehensives teach all those?

It had a grammar ethos and its pupils aspired. There were always pupils who got into Oxbridge long after the 'grammar' head left (not mine though) and many have high powered lucrative jobs. That's what a comprehensive school should be like.

ReallyTired · 20/03/2014 14:56

Selection on location means that you get schools for the rich and schools for the poor. Similarly there is an element of protectionism which means that rich people who have bought a house on the doorstep of wealthy state comprehnesive want selection to be on location. Most people are in favour of selection(ie. test, location, faith) if they have a kid who gets selected and anti selection if their kid doesn't make the grade.

I look forward to the day when all state schools are forced to take their fair share of rich and poor kids. (Incidently I am not anti grammar schools)

tiggytape · 20/03/2014 14:54

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

tiggytape · 20/03/2014 14:51

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

missmarplestmarymead · 20/03/2014 14:26

I'm all for the reintroduction of grammar schools...for bright kids from disadvantaged backgrounds, they are often a golden chance.

Mintyy · 20/03/2014 13:58

"I thought that selecting more than 10 percent on ability in comprehensives and academies?"

Is there something missing from that sentence Fantastic Day?

I am really in favour of comprehensive education and luckily my dd is at a true comprehensive school. But, my God, the number of underhand and dubious applications that are made by my middle class peers in order to get in the slightly "better" secondaries around here are pretty shocking tbh.

FantasticDay · 20/03/2014 12:57

I'm a bit confused. In my area, many faith and academy schools select up to 10 percent on 'aptitude' (in languages, maths, sports and music in the four I am interested in), but have to either choose the rest from criteria such as religious attendance, or across the spread of ability bands (33% higher, 33% middle, 33% lower) in the entrance tests. I thought that selecting more than 10 percent on ability in comprehensives and academies?

LoonvanBoon · 20/03/2014 12:46

Well, I'm not in favour of academic selection, motown (& can't be arsed to argue the case, because: a) that wasn't the thread title; & b) I want some lunch!).

But I agree, as I said, that the schools you mention sound as if they are in effect Grammar Schools anyway.

motown3000 · 20/03/2014 12:35

Loonvan. The school should not have to use loopholes , to select . It should not have to admit 2% of Low Ability students each year to conform to "regulations". this is not a go at the school ( (I Like Academic Selection) more a go at the Nonsense of not allowing "Grammar Schools" in Comprehensive areas .

There is a current story regarding the Sevonoaks "Grammar" annexe , it is very unlikely to happen. This theory states they could admit 2% Low Attainers 23% Middle ability students ( Not that different from many Grammar Schools) and 75% 11+ passes ,call it a Comprehensive ( In reality being the Grammar Annexe they are after.

OP posts:
ReallyTired · 20/03/2014 12:30

Even comprehensives aren't comprehensive. Many parents move hell and high water to keep their little darlings away from poor rough children.

St George's harpenden is not a comprehensive. At least the Watford schools don't pretend to be a true comprehensive.

ilovesooty · 20/03/2014 12:25

The hard fact is that education isn't goingto be comprehensive whilst intakes are dependent on how much money parents have and how they can affafford to pick and choose their homes and catchment area. Social mobility or lack of it is what perpetuates inequality. That's far more disempowering that anything the OP is suggesting.