Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this father is overly obsessed with his daughter?

108 replies

Intrigued14 · 14/03/2014 15:16

Long post, really sorry.

I began a relationship with a man who seemed really quite sweet at first, really kind, understanding, funny and easy to talk to. He's in his late 20's and has a young daughter under 5.

At the time we met, he revealed that he and the mother of his child had been in a long-term relationship since his teens (over 10 years) and she is quite a bit older than him - they had outgrown each other apparently but had a civil relationship. What he didn't tell me immediately was that he had been married/divorced to this woman. He had been single for two years prior to meeting me and only had two very brief flings. But he was ready to settle down.

To begin with things went really well, he appeared to be a devoted dad. He lives close to his ex and sees his daughter often - on an almost daily basis. He has pictures of her and toys all over the house, T-shirts with her face on that he showed me. His profile picture on WhatsApp, is of her and only ever of her. He does not socialise with friends unless his daughter is present and it's a family type affair. Now I am already a mother, so it wasn't necessarily a bad thing to see.

However, some time into the relationship I started to notice that if he even went a day without seeing his daughter when he wanted to it would affect his mood, he would make angry comments about father's for justice/his rights and whatnot and become stroppy. He told me once that looking into her eyes he could see 'things' (relating to love ones he had lost, or something...his late nan had taught him) and that I wouldn't 'get' it as most people don't. And he made a series of inappropriate comparisons to his daughter when listing the most important people in his life, telling me once that only she could ever 'hurt' him.

At one point his ex informed him that she was going abroad for 3 weeks to see family, she gave him plenty of advance notice. He became immediately angry and depressed by this, told me he was going to bed and began to act like someone who was grieving. He told me that without her he had nothing, and that I wouldn't understand. He went silent on me on/off for 3 weeks, and began writing tortured statuses about what he was going through so I gave him time alone, and once his daughter returned he went back to normal like it had never happened.

Over a period of time...probably too long, I felt that there was just no future between us (there were also other factors involved) so I ended it. He didn't want to end it but we had a discussion and he said he understood.

A month later I found out I was pregnant. When I told him about the baby (a girl) he was upset and attempted to hide it from his family...so I told them myself. I later found out I'd annoyed him even further because he was apparently in the hospital with his daughter when I told them and that had offended him (?)

He subsequently told me that he has a daughter already, and he couldn't imagine loving any child like he loves her (this is despite the fact he works in teaching, has two nieces and a goddaughter who calls him dad and he seems to adore them all, takes them out as a group etc.). He has subsequently advised his family not to communicate with me and wants nothing to do with this child who is due in a matter of weeks.

The last contact I had with him, I was told "good luck and all the best with your future". Is there something wrong here...I just don't get it.

OP posts:
TheHoneyBadger · 14/03/2014 16:33

he looks into her eyes and sees things, he romantisises her to the only the person who could ever hurt him... it IS weird and isn't devotion in the healthy sense it's objectification and projecting his needs and his whole emotional life onto her.

ThingsThatGoBumpInTheNight · 14/03/2014 16:25

Ugh you totally dodged a bullet there

My ex was like this over our son, he has one child, ours, and refuses to entertain the idea that his new gf may one day want a child of her own, she has none, and I truly think he would leave her if she fell pregnant 'by accident' as he says, I've told her I don't want to be a da of kids with multiple women'

Such a shame as she is lovely, he was and still is absolutely hideous and obsessed with the idea one day we may get back together Confused
Don't think so mate, ds is 16 now that ship has sailed lol

Op, on the step parenting board I see lots of women saying similar things and they had to go for family counselling because their DH/DP had turned their dsd into a 'mini wife'

Agree with others, run and don't look back x

AFishCalledBarry · 14/03/2014 16:25

I think it's really sad that so many people are dismissing him immediately as weird. I'd say he is clearly devoted to his DD, which is admirable. The fact that he makes a point of seeing her every day would obviously make a three week stretch incredibly difficult. I couldn't begin to imagine having to go three weeks without seeing my own DD.

I would say that rather than him being weird he's more likely to have mental health issues. He wants to do everything right by his DD and he's having a very difficult time accepting the idea of balancing his life between two DDs. I'm not excusing his behaviour towards you regarding your pregnancy, but I do think he could do with a little more understanding.

TheHoneyBadger · 14/03/2014 16:19

i agree it's weird but it isn't that unusual. failed marriage, daughter on a pedestal and centre of everything that nothing and no one will measure up to. it's like a safe place to put their whole emotional life, in a little princess that can't break up with him and so is safe. not fair to a child imo. it's way too much weight even if it seems like being spoiled initially.

as for your baby just try to enjoy it and have things as chill and nice as you can when the baby is born and nest and bond, and help siblings bond with it. keep things simple and healthy which imo means not, for now, worrying about him and the why's and how's and stuff. let him choose for now if he's around, text when baby is born etc but don't push anything. focus on your family and getting settled and making sure everyone is secure and ok and see if he makes an approach. i'd say leave worrying what to do about it till the baby is at least six months old.

those first few months are so important to you, the new baby and your other child/ren. don't let anything spoil them. whatever the situation with him it will still be there six months later.

Intrigued14 · 14/03/2014 16:16

Thanks for replying everyone,

I'd just like to add - He didn't always come across as strange, it was more of a snowball effect type thing over a long period of time. He actually comes across as quite nice - he's very attractive, friendly, goes out of his way for family/friends, and most people don't have a bad word to say about him!

...then again, they don't know what I know.

Things seemed to really go downhill after his daughter's holiday, and it was there that it began to have an impact on our relationship. I did actually sit him down and speak to him about his daughter and whether he was even ready to devote himself long-term relationship and he claimed that's what he wanted...he was very sure about that.

The pregnancy, well no excuses we were not careful all the time. I have PCOS and only one fallopian tube (a small chance of ever getting pregnant again naturally I was told - he was not aware of this) so risks were taken. When I found out, despite things being over I felt it was a last chance for me and decided to proceed not really expecting the whole "I could never love another child speech". He has become increasingly odd and hostile since that moment. Not really sure who I met now.

DoJo This is really why I asked the question. I wonder to some degree whether he is just overcompensating. He did explain to me how disappointed he was that he has a failed marriage behind him, and that he didn't want his daughter to ever hear or see animosity between them - hence their friendship. To be honest I'm not sure that his ex makes things any better. Whilst on holiday she sent him a series of videos showing his daughter crying for him...why? I don't know. But sitting there trying to comfort him over that was extremely difficult.

He also mentioned that he didn't want to be the type of guy with multiple kids, multiple women etc because we were no longer together. He broke down in tears a few times over it, I felt sorry for him, but it seems the upset turned to anger. He claims to hate me and not the baby...at one point saying he'd bought her clothes! But he's shut me out from ever trying to contact him. The door is open...

OP posts:
msmoss · 14/03/2014 16:12

his ex-wife I mean

msmoss · 14/03/2014 16:12

The benefit of the doubt explanation is that I think he sounds incredibly sad about the fact that he can't be in his daughter's life everyday and possibly his reaction is to your pregnancy is based on him feeling like he can't cope with living separately from another child. However, he should really find a way of managing those emotions and dealing with them like an adult as the way he behaves is unacceptable and quite odd.

Not sure what you can do about this though.

Have you discussed his behaviour with anyone else in his family or with this ex-wife?

PeterParkerSays · 14/03/2014 16:11

I'm trying to imagine the relationship between this man and his current daughter when she's a teenager. I would have real concerns about him not letting her grow up and be independent. I would say that your baby is better off being away from such a dynamic, she'll feel rejected and unworthy of him whilst the older DD struggles to live up to his expectations.

YouTheCat · 14/03/2014 16:06

What Hooby said.

TheDietStartsTomorrow · 14/03/2014 16:05

He sounds very strange and extremely over the top. I think your lucky not to be in a relationship with him anymore but at the same time, your daughter when she's born, has the right to have contact with her father. I think you could try and see how it goes but make an early decision as to whether the relationship is beneficial for her or not. If not then wash your hands of him for good.

He might come round. When I had my first baby and was pregnant with my second I used to have moments when I secretly wondered how I could love another child. Obviously I realised as soon as my second DS was born that I was capable of loving them both totally and equally but there was a point when I was unsure. He might also just need to be given a chance with your DD and maybe he'll also fall in love with her.

The intensity of his love for his first DD is totally inappropriate. I'd be wary and keep an eye on the relationship with your own DD should you choose to allow him in her life. Nip it in the bud if he starts getting weird.

Out of curiosity, how old is his first DD and how does she respond to his over eagerness?

CuppaSarah · 14/03/2014 16:04

Does he have mental health issues? Some of what you've said has struck a chord with how my sister is with my DD when she is having a difficult period.

ohfourfoxache · 14/03/2014 16:01

Wow.

Odd.

Very odd Confused

hoobypickypicky · 14/03/2014 16:01

"Now, have the kid and F Off to somewhere he can't find you.

He is weird and you don't need it! Nor will your daughter!"

You've dodged a bullet. Make sure it stays that way. A relationship between your child and this man won't end well. She'll either be rejected, as per his messages to you, or he'll turn about face and try to suffocate her by making her his reason for existing just as he has his other child. Whichever it is your child will have a very dysfunctional, uneasy and unhappy time of it and you will be in the middle trying to second guess his every whim and mood.

I don't say this lightly

DISAPPEAR.

Don't put him on the birth cert. Just move, get away while you have the chance.

SouthernComforts · 14/03/2014 15:53

He sounds obsessed! Poor child. I hope whatever kind of contact he eventually has with your dd you keep a close eye on things

TestingTestingWonTooFree · 14/03/2014 15:50

He does very strange. He might change when the baby arrives.

WTFlike · 14/03/2014 15:50

His poor ex-wife. Imagine having to deal with an ex like that? For 18 years!

OP, RUN LIKE THE WIND

Viviennemary · 14/03/2014 15:50

The way he has treated you is dreadfful. You are well rid of him. He sounds a bit emotionally unstable to me. And I agree with the poster who said there is sometimes no explanation for other people's weirdness.

NoodleOodle · 14/03/2014 15:50

Are you going to try to encourage him to have a relationship with the child? If so, how, it doesn't seem like he wants to - what can you do in this situation?

DoJo · 14/03/2014 15:48

There are elements of this which seem perfectly normal - he is a devoted dad who isn't happy with the fact that he doesn't live with his daughter and overcompensates for that in ways which seem inappropriate.

His refusal to engage with your pregnancy might be a means to protect himself from this situation occurring again. He already knows that he will not be able to live with your child, and presumably would find it very hard to split his time between two daughters, especially given how attentive he is to his first child.

Whilst I can see that this was a destructive relationship for you, and that his behaviour since you split has been rude and dismissive, I don't necessarily think that his relationship with his daughter is that weird. If my son was going away for three weeks without my say so, I think I would be sad whilst he was away and be dreading it from the moment I knew until the he was back - I might not mope around or make such a performance out of it, but I would miss him terribly and probably be pretty down in the run-up to his departure until he returned.

The stuff about looking in her eyes and ranking everyone behind her in terms of whether they could hurt him is a bit odd, but maybe he is just expressing himself poorly or trying too hard to cement their bond.

Nomama · 14/03/2014 15:46

Keep that last message...

Now, have the kid and F Off to somewhere he can't find you.

He is weird and you don't need it! Nor will your daughter!

TheKnightsThatSayNee · 14/03/2014 15:46

Lucky escape for your dd. I think you should be glad.

Trooperslane · 14/03/2014 15:45

So sorry op.

What nigella said Thanks

formerbabe · 14/03/2014 15:45

Thank her lucky stars for what?!

mymiraclebubba · 14/03/2014 15:43

Definitely a lucky escape and a very unique and unnatural obsession with his elder daughter!!!! Make sure you get what you deserve via csa and then thank your lucky stars!

daisychain01 · 14/03/2014 15:43

formerbabe - that's where I'm coming from - lucky escape hasn't got anything to do with it!

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.