Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To not understand why "friends" are abandoning a friend in need?

163 replies

runnermum1974 · 09/03/2014 22:04

My friend attempted suicide and did real serious damage to themselves.

Days after the attempt 3 of their close friends have said they are going their separate ways. They have given some reasons, but they are pretty lame - like they are not compatible, and deciding that now, after 5 years of friendship!!

I am not saying that they have to be friends or anything. But the timing is bloody awful.

I do not understand how friends can abandon a friend in need. Anyone can be a friend in the good times. The test of friendship comes in the hard times.

If anyone has a story about abandoning friendships when a friend is in a difficult place, then I will appreciate the insight.

AIBU to think it is unkind to leave a friend in need?

OP posts:
iamsoannoyed · 10/03/2014 08:20

I agree with Juneau- "fading" is quite hard to achieve without it being noticed, and can be more confusing for the person being "faded| from (especially if done slowly over a protracted period of time). I don't think that would help your friend.

As for "inappropriate timing"- when would be a good time? And why a month?

Do they wait until your friend is starting to get back on her feet, and then tell her they are walking away? That risks damaging a fragile recovery, so could be deemed "inappropriate". No time will be a good time. Probably better your friend, and the professionals supporting her, knows what kind of support network she has from the start.

I think you are beginning to sound a bit self-righteous and unreasonable now.

You don't know the impact your friends illness and now this suicide attempt is having on these ex-friends- emotionally, on their relationships/family (if they have any)/work etc. It may be that they just can't cope any longer. By the sounds of it, though, you don't really care what their problems are as you've made your mind up that they are wrong to stop their friendship at the moment, no matter what the reasons (I suspect each will have their own reasons).

Sometimes you have to put yourself first and that is the right thing to do.

It is distressing for your friend to lose friends, though. I hope he/she get the treatment and support they need to make a full recovery.

Mimishimi · 10/03/2014 08:05

" The suicidal friend has been acting rather dramatic lately and has been very needy - lots of phone calls etc. "

There's your answer. I can completely understand CO friend's point of view. Life is hard enough without having the stress of a 'friend' threatening and attempting suicide. Would be quite different though if they were not being demanding though- then I'd definitely say it's a case of fairweather friends. In this case though, sounds like they've all put up with a lot for a long time.

juneau · 10/03/2014 07:56

It's sad that they chose this timing, but if they really don't feel like they can be there for this person again in the future - for their own self-preservation - then I think its better that they've been honest. Doing the fade is very hurtful - my sister's best friend just faded from her life after she got a diagnosis of depression. She couldn't work out what was happening, why she couldn't get hold of her friend, whether something had happened to her, etc. Some people just can't cope with the constant neediness and drama. I admit that I find it very tedious after 20 years and have, on occasion, wished that I could walk away!

Cleartheclutter · 10/03/2014 07:33

runnermum I think you are being quite judgy about the friends. You have no idea of perhaps what exactly was going on their lives. Maybe they could not wait a month. Something awful might be happening in their own lives.

Stop being so critical of others and put your energies into focusing on your friend

Morloth · 10/03/2014 00:19

People only have so much to give.

You don't know what is happening in their lives.

It is shit for your friend though.

Nothing you can do about it that won't make it worse.

wannaBe · 10/03/2014 00:16

on the whole people with such severe mental illness are incredibly selfish. That is of course due to the illness, but it doesn't make it any easier for those having to be on the receiving end.

Nobody should feel they have to be there for someone who is suicidal tbh. Most people have neither the emotional strength nor are they qualified to be.

And people have their own lives and their own problems. Your friend should be receiving professional help, but even if she isn't, it isn't the responsibility of others to be her unpaid psychiatric support, and nobody should be judged for that.

If your friend is needy, then it is possible that these three believe that her injury is, in fact self inflicted, and that that is just a step too far for them. It's their prerogative to walk away, it doesn't make them bad people.

manicinsomniac · 10/03/2014 00:12

I think it depends but, probably, I think YABU.

I have never actually gone through with a suicide attempt but I have been mentally ill with one or more of anorexia, self harm, a mild form of bipolar and (possibly - personally think it's unlikely) a personality disorder or two since my early teens.

When I was at university I was a total basketcase and unfortunately strained some friendships beyond repair. I don't blame those friends at all, it was me making the situation untenable, not them. No, it wasn't really my fault but it also wasn't theirs. They are not worse people than those I am still close friends with, they just have different limits and different requirements from friendship.

Looking back on myself then from an older and more stable vantage point I can see that I was manipulative, needy, self centred and very very annoying. I'm lucky that I had so many friends who could see beyond the illnesses to the actual person underneath them and stick with me. But the friends who couldn't did the right thing for them and that's fine.

Maybe your friend isn't like I was (maybe still am - hope not!) but, given the nature of mental illness, I think it's likely.

LettertoHermioneGranger · 10/03/2014 00:09

It really does depend. I think it's impossible to judge the situation from the outside.

Sometimes you do need to cut people from your life who are toxic to you - I've done so with people with addiction problems, and friends who weren't necessarily in dire situations, but were pretty low in life and refusing to be helped or to help themselves. There's only so much a friend can do. It's not unreasonable to not be able to offer unending, one-sided support. It's a burden to carry. For me, I'm not sure I could do that for anyone other than a close relative. I wouldn't judge these friends, who knows what else is going on their lives? It was likely a tough decision for them, and this is why they discussed it, but your friend in all honesty is not their responsibility, nor is it necessarily "right" to offer another person unending support, especially at detriment to their own well-being.

AgentZigzag · 10/03/2014 00:05

That's so true springy, and it's always been the case. I feel a bit uncomfortable saying to people to get in contact with their GP/psychiatric team because it can often make the situation worse when they realise what a shower of shit the 'care' available is (if it's available at all).

Sometimes it's better not to have the added rejection and certainty that there is very little hope/help.

springykyrie · 09/03/2014 23:59

The awful reality is that the NHS MH budget is so tiny it often simply doesn't step up when people are in a bad way - because there's nothing there Angry . Then the ill person ends up splattering themselves all over people who are not experts and have no idea what to do. Add to that the stigma to mental illness, and therefore the judgements, and it's no wonder people turn their backs.

btw I'm not comfortable with the word 'needy' as it has too much of a judgemental flavour to it. If someone was in agony with a physical injury and was calling out for help, would they be termed 'needy'?

IAmNotAPrincessIAmAKahleesi · 09/03/2014 23:54

I do think it's hard to tell just from what's written here

If your friend has been very needy and demanding then obviously that is because she is ill, but that doesn't automatically make it easier on those she is leaning on

In general I would try to be there for someone no matter what but there have definitely been times in my life that I just wouldn't have been able to cope with any additional pressure and would have to take a step back to protect myself

SaucyJack · 09/03/2014 23:52

I think it would be terrible thing if they'd ended an otherwise good and mutually beneficial friendship just because the other person was experiencing health problems that happened to be of the mental variety.

But I strongly suspect this isn't the case here.

Your friend sounds incredibly needy, and I guess they'd just had enough. Not everyone is willing or able to act as an unpaid psychiatric nurse- and nor should they be expected to either tbh.

Hardtothinkofanewname · 09/03/2014 23:35

When our family started to experience Psychiatric illness most of our friends and family wanted nothing to do with it. There was no support from them at all.

Even now that things have stabilised the illness is never mentioned by my family, and is clearly not to be mentioned. There's clearly huge stigma attached to it.

It's terrible that your friend has been abandoned, but I think it's probably not uncommon. As others have said you don't know what is going on for them, or has gone on for them. I haven't been particularly supportive to a friend going through divorce, but then I have my children with their illness to think about.

I think you should support your friend. But please make sure they're also getting professional support.

itsatrap · 09/03/2014 23:31

Op, I think you sound like a wonderful friend who obviously cares deeply for the person involved. I think its amazing that you feel you can provide emotional support to them at this time, but not everyone is in a position to do that, and they should not be judged on that. I think I would try to focus on my friend and the support I could give them rather than what your other friends are doing. I hope your friend, and you, are ok through all of this.

runnermum1974 · 09/03/2014 23:29

Regardless of what those 3 were going through, the timing was inappropriate. They could have at least waited a month. Or just distanced themselves quietly.

OP posts:
springykyrie · 09/03/2014 23:25

Great post Glasshammer. I think people generally have no idea how to set boundaries in a respectful way and can feel out of their depth. But you stick with a close friend imo.

A lot of people don't understand, are ignorant, that suicide is an illness and assume the suicidal person is 'selfish'. couldn't be further from the truth, usually (though not always); just as some people think someone having a difficult time is somehow selfishly putting a burden on others (), they can view suicide in the same way. Particularly as mental illness is invisible.

it is very harsh for your friend that their friends have jumped ship at such a crucial time but I do hope the right support is now in place to step up and 'hold' them at this awful time. I do hope so.

HollaAtMeBaby · 09/03/2014 23:17

Agree 100% with iamsoannoyed

I've had to cut ties with people like this in the past too. You get to the point where the cost to your own well being is just too high. I want to be a good friend, but in a choice between supporting someone else through mental health issues vs preserving my own sanity, I'll choose myself every time. I think you're being a bit self righteous, actually. You don't know what the other ex-friends have to deal with.

WilsonFrickett · 09/03/2014 23:15

I have complicated feelings around suicide that I'm not going to go into on here. But I would find supporting a friend through a suicide attempt extremely difficult. I like to think I could but tbh I'm not sure. Everyone has their limits.

However if they have all got together and decided to do this en masse to make some kind of point, that is extremely spiteful and YANBU.

Alisvolatpropiis · 09/03/2014 23:13

Not everyone can provide the level of support your friend clearly needs.

Do they have families who need them? Their own mental health issues which they do not discuss?

There are various things that could compromise the ability to provide support. It's great that you can provide that support but everybody is different.

I hope your friend gets better soon.

Glasshammer · 09/03/2014 23:08

They sound like fair weather friends - which is fine as Its natural to have a few. I treat my closest friends as family and wouldn't consider abandoning people I love. Our relationships are meaningful and special. Obviously if they were bombarding me, we'd have to talk it through.

ShadowsCollideWithPeople · 09/03/2014 23:06

I don't know. On the face of it, it's an awful thing for said friends to do. However, do you know what these friends have going on in their personal lives? For example, if a friend of mine attempted suicide right now, I would try my damndest to support them. But I also have 5 other, serious issues going on in my life or the lives of my very close family, that mean that I have very little left to give. I'm emotionally burned out, and I'd worry that in my current mindset, I'd do more harm than good. As, try as I might, I just can't switch off everything else that is happening. I personally am hanging on by a thread.

I'm neither defending nor condoning your friends taking a step back, just explaining why I might have to do so, if I were them.

I really do feel for your friend, and hope that they get lots of support from people who are in a position to give it.

iamsoannoyed · 09/03/2014 22:51

Well, I think it depends on the reason- there are valid reasons to distance yourself from someone who is "in need". For instance, could it be that they can't cope with all of this?

Maybe they are having to put themselves first at this time for their own physical or mental health? Maybe they don't feel they can actually help this person anymore, and are only likely to make matters worse.

It could be that they just can't be bothered and have "abandoned ship" of course. Which isn't nice, but your friend may well be better off without them if they simply can't be bothered.

You asked for stories. Here's mine.

I had a friend while at university, who began self-harming and displayed destructive behaviour (sleeping around, drinking too much resulting in her doing stupid things- and a few very mean and horrible things on a couple of occasions). I have heard through the grapevine that she has since been diagnosed with borderline personality disorder.

Her self-harming worsened around the same time as my dad became seriously ill (he was hospitalised for almost a year, spending nearly 4 months in and out of ICU) and as I was at university, we still had course work and exams etc.

I simply didn't have the emotional or physical energy to deal with her problems, my own problems and studying. I had already begun to tire of being one of her "shoulder's to cry on" (not to mention the emotional manipulation), keeping an eye on her and trying to perform damage to limitation after she had done something stupid/embarrassing/mean- and I had been considering distancing myself, as it all felt one-sided most of the time.

I guess my dad becoming ill just hastened what would have happened anyway, but I did quite suddenly just stop being there for her after one particular event where she self-harmed (she had done more damage than she had intended- it wasn't a suicide attempt) and I found her- this was shortly after I found out my dad was back in ICU and given less than a 5% chance of survival. She knew this. I just couldn't take any more and I had to keep away for my own sake.

When I backed off, a couple of other people did too. After talking it through with some friends, it seems a number of them were feeling as I had been, but were worried others would think they were horrible people if they stopped being friends with this girl, so carried on- but had noticed that there had not been a nasty backlash against me, so felt more able to walk away.

A few people did judge me harshly- used similar arguments to you. I'm no longer friends with them, but I don't think judging people is going to help you or your friend.

I understand you are trying to stick up for your friend, and it sounds like they are lucky to have someone who will be there for them. You know these other people and maybe they don't have a good reason and are simply being flaky when things get tough. Though they have stuck around for quite a long time for "flaky" people (I'm assuming they've been supportive for the 2 years of worsening mental health issues).

Has it occurred to you that one or more of these people do have a good reason that you aren't aware of? Maybe they don't have one "good" single reason, but just feel overwhelmed and cant cope anymore. It doesn't necessarily make them mean, selfish or heartless.

justmyview · 09/03/2014 22:39

Agree with Zigzag - nothing to be gained by criticising the 3 that have walked away

Hissy · 09/03/2014 22:38

I hope your friend finds that this is the 'bottom' and that she now has only 'UP' to go.

That's what happened in my case.

justmyview · 09/03/2014 22:38

How sad. In fairness, I think it would be easy for us to criticise the 3 friends who have walked away, but the phrase "walk in their shoes" comes to mind. None of us here (apart from OP) know what demands the friend has made on them. Still, it does seem very sad if they're abandoning her completely. As part of her illness, has she made allegations against them / criticised them?

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.