Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To not understand why "friends" are abandoning a friend in need?

163 replies

runnermum1974 · 09/03/2014 22:04

My friend attempted suicide and did real serious damage to themselves.

Days after the attempt 3 of their close friends have said they are going their separate ways. They have given some reasons, but they are pretty lame - like they are not compatible, and deciding that now, after 5 years of friendship!!

I am not saying that they have to be friends or anything. But the timing is bloody awful.

I do not understand how friends can abandon a friend in need. Anyone can be a friend in the good times. The test of friendship comes in the hard times.

If anyone has a story about abandoning friendships when a friend is in a difficult place, then I will appreciate the insight.

AIBU to think it is unkind to leave a friend in need?

OP posts:
Dinosaursareextinct · 11/03/2014 10:10

Yes, that glaring inconsistency in the storyline is worrying. The OP shouldn't change the facts in order to improve her argument.

Sillylass79 · 11/03/2014 10:09

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Thetallesttower · 11/03/2014 09:56

Sorry to nit-pick, but you said you'd all been friends since uni and were 40, but then that you'd been friends for five years. It's a bit confusing.

I am not sure if this makes a difference but to some extent, if you are old friends who don't see each other much, it is quite cruel to gang up like this and send a letter. I would have a lot more time for someone if they just set their own boundaries and kept out of it. Was this friend involving them a lot? I don't like this gang mentality, especially when the friend is very vulnerable.

Having said that, I think sometimes for your own sanity and life you do have to distance yourself from people. I'm one for sticking around with friends and have a couple of friends with long-term depression, but helping someone in the middle of a MH crisis can be both stressful and scary and your sense of responsibility skewed- you start to think you can stop them killing themselves (or it is your responsibility to do so).

On MN there's a phrase that comes up on dodgy threads that says something like 'don't offer more than you can afford to give' and I think this applies to friendships.

Cleartheclutter · 11/03/2014 09:52

runnermum1974 There is a lot to be said for 'treat others as you would want to be treated yourself

Would you like your "friends" to be slagging you off on mumsnet? Like everyone has said time and time again, they could their own private reasons why they are not able to support the suicidal person

Put your energy into helping your friend, why do you insist on criticising them again and again?

I don't think you are giving the full story here, quite a bit of exaggeration

IAmNotAMindReader · 11/03/2014 09:45

You can't fix her, you are not trained in mental health. You won't know the times when your input will be enabling her or harming her by lending credence to a delusion.
Have the words treating them would be a bottomless pit been heard from you directly from a senior health professionals mouth?

Is what they meant actually they haven't the money to deal? Or more a reflection on the possibility that at this point your friend is being her own worst enemy as she currently doesn't want to face her issues and has no interest in getting well at this time?

Does your friend hoard animals? Animals are in no position to be an emotional crutch for someone, they need love and care themselves. Where the mental health professionals seeing she had too many balls in the air with them and was beginning to neglect their primary needs for care?

While animals can be towers of strength for their owners emotionally, they are not a substitute for something that is seriously lacking in their own mental stability. It is unfair to ask them to fill such a hole and like you say when it all falls apart they may well ultimately answer for it with their lives. The real question here should not actually be are they your friends life line and do they keep her going and are her only reason for living? More is she providing them the care and support they need, even animals can't be all give, they need love in return as well.

This is a complex situation OP and you can't use a love will conquer all attitude as a band aid and say it will be ok, it won't. I am not saying don't help her but you need a hell of a lot more information about what help you need to be offering her and what may initially be seen by you as help but which may actually make your friends situation worse.

Refusing to see the finer complexities and seeing that for some people they have to walk away as the illness is selfish and will demand they sacrifice everything they have to your friends needs and just saying they didn't have enough love or weren't very nice is not seeing the bigger picture.

Giving yourself over to your friends every whim is not being there. Doing whatever she asks is not being there and not being constructive. If you really care and want to do something you need to approach the mental health professionals and find out exactly what her needs are, then be her advocate and harass and harangue the health authority to ensure she gets that help. They will always help those who shout loudest over those unable to speak for themselves unfortunately. Being her shield against the world and knight in shining armour will not do her any favours and will exhaust you to a point where you cannot physically function. What will she do then when you have fallen apart yourself?
Just throwing your hands in the air and saying they won't help is going to land more on your shoulders, you are not Atlas. They have to be pushed to help and you have to recognise that the help your friend needs and the help she wants may be two very different things.

Don't delude yourself that you can do it alone this will be very harmful to your friend in the long run. Educate yourself about her illness and be one of her ports of call for aid, not the only port of call. Its not called a support network for nothing as we all have off days and she needs people to be there and one single person no matter how much they want to can be there 100% of the time. You will have emergencies in your own life which coincide with hers, her need will not wait and she will not understand this so you do need other agencies and people involved to take over. If she demands you to be her only support, compelling though she may be and no matter how much you want to do it you do not have the strength, no one person ever can. No matter how nice, saintly, loving, religious, compassionate or whatever else may be driving it.

Rooners · 11/03/2014 09:33

This is partly why I try never to share my own depressive/anxious issues with anyone either on here or IRL.

Because I would be asking for more than I can give in return.

I think unless you have a very special friendship with someone, that really does work both ways on that level and to that depth, you cannot really expect people to take on these huge, huge problems.

I don't mean to say it is the sufferer's fault. It's just that it goes above and beyond normal friendship, and that is asking an awful lot of most people.

I go to my own family if I am suffering and need reassurance or someone to see me through a tough day or something. Suicide stuff I have always kept to myself.

I don't see it as my other friends' problem.

Dinosaursareextinct · 11/03/2014 09:28

How awful to gang up together (always easier to do nasty things to someone else if you're in a gang) and get you to deliver a letter. They didn't even have the courage to talk to her. What did the letter say, do you know? Did they give their reasons?
A lot of people just seem to be saying that if you're the kind of person who doesn't like helping others then that's fine. No-one has suggested that they sacrifice their families for a friend - most people have some time in their lives that they can spend on someone other than their families. Insisting that your whole life has to be spent on family activities and on fun to be with friends, with anyone who has a problem being dumped, is very selfish. It's a well known phenomenon that people down on their luck get dumped - this can apply to losing one's money and/or social status as well as to having mental health problems.

MaryWestmacott · 11/03/2014 09:15

OP - you haven't answered - these other friends, do they have DCs, DPs and full time jobs? do they have other things that are (quite rightly) more important to them than your friend with MH problems? Because if you are talking about through the night calls, having to be there for her, that's energy and time they are taking away from their family and careers. If they can do both, great, but the suicide might well have just pointed out to them how much your friend needs and they just aren't able to do it.

Better to be honest and focus on their own families, than like Burren's mother, just put the friend first at the cost to everything else.

Also in my experience of the NHS (although I know this isn't universal) if care of any sort is available from the community, it's not forthcoming from the NHS/SS. By 'being there for her' your friends maywell have ruled out her chances of getting professional help.

mrsjay · 11/03/2014 09:04

If the person with mental health issues needs professional care - but that professional care is not available because of the NHS cuts etc - then what? Just leave them to rot and die? You sound like lovely people.

Not one person on this thread suggested you leave people to rot and die the language you use is quite emotive and dramatic it reads like you are the only person is the world this woman has you are not a HCP you are not a mental health nurse you are an ordinary woman who has a friend with mh problems you can't fix her all the support in the world will not help her if she decides to do it again and if she does die you will feel guilty you didnt do enough, she needs support and medical care you can only be her mate if you want to help her find local professional support MIND run mental health groups and support find it direct her to it and be your friend, these other friends have stepped back for their own reasons, tbh i don't blame them

Minnieisthedevilmouse · 11/03/2014 08:53

Friends become friends for various reasons. Usually all light hearted ones. Most friends can cope with usual levels of change. Some changes like MH push friendships to places that no party ever wishes to go.

Purely my opinion but I don't believe this makes friends that stay better than friends that go. It's personal tolerance levels of bigger stuff. That's why sometimes the ones who stay can be surprising ones, recent ones. And ones that can't are older.

I think it's sad all round. Don't assume that walking away was easy. It isn't necessarily. You cannot talk for others actions. Just your own. If you can be around, great, good on you. Doesn't make you better friends though or a better person. It's just different people.

LookingThroughTheFog · 11/03/2014 08:31

but that professional care is not available because of the NHS cuts etc - then what? Just leave them to rot and die? You sound like lovely people.

And if your friend needed heart surgery would you pop her on the kitchen table and hack her open with a carving knife?

Cogito's point is that she needs the help of a professional and not an interested amateur. If dropping her at the door of A&E forces the issue and gets her access to that professional help, then that is the right thing to do.

As it happens, I've seen Cogito reach out and help people with well thought out, sensible advice. She is, from what I've seen, a lovely person. She's just not naive about mental health problems.

Birdo83 · 11/03/2014 08:08

It sounds unreasonable when you read the OP but we don't know the full story and how much the suicidal person was putting on them or how they were acting. At the end of the day they are her friends not counselors who are qualified to help a suicidal person get better.

justmyview · 11/03/2014 08:05

Wow, that's nasty. Weird way of doing it

YouTheCat · 11/03/2014 07:57

That makes it even worse. What an absolute shower of shits.

I hope they get theirs in shedloads.

runnermum1974 · 11/03/2014 07:43

They did announce they were stopping being friends, and by letter (that I handed to my friend, not knowing what they had collectively written). These women are 40 years old and we had all been friends since university.

OP posts:
YouTheCat · 11/03/2014 07:37

Aside from the fact that your friend needs support, have these other 'friends' actually announced that they don't want to be friends any more? And if so, are they 8?

Tbh your friend with the problems doesn't need people like that in her life really. I do get that sometimes others have so much of their own crap going on that they need to distance themselves for their own mental health, but to proclaim not to want to be friends any more is just awful.

runnermum1974 · 11/03/2014 07:27

MusicalEndorphins and CogitoErgoSometimes

If the person with mental health issues needs professional care - but that professional care is not available because of the NHS cuts etc - then what? Just leave them to rot and die? You sound like lovely people.

So, if/when you or someone close to you gets seriously ill, you will totally understand people close to you running away and not looking back? Seriously doubt it.

There is a lot to be said for 'treat others as you would want to be treated yourself.'

OP posts:
MusicalEndorphins · 11/03/2014 02:47

I feel the same as this.
CogitoErgoSometimes Mon 10-Mar-14 08:25:06

YABU not to understand. Friendship can't solve everything, people have problems of their own, and sometimes for simple reasons of self-preservation it's important to create distance. That's going to sound harsh but I have seen a lot of people dragged down, marriages fail, and all kinds of other problems caused when someone else's problems start to become all-consuming. The person with the mental health problems needs professional care.

Morloth · 11/03/2014 02:19

Do you have DCs, OP?

What will you do if their needs clash with your friend's?

My order of priority starts with my kids, followed by my husband and then everyone else on a sliding scale.

Be careful in your 'rescuer' role.

IwinIwin · 10/03/2014 22:16

And in regards to people not walking when someone is sick of looking on issues in the same light, that's not true at all. One friend's DP walked when she had cancer. He became a right bastard saying she'd ruined and stolen years of his life in which he became a carer for her most of the time. Completely his choice to stay and then again to walk, he was a real cock when it finally ended. She understands his leaving because their relationship changed so much and they changed so much and he couldn't cope, but the nastiness was really shitty.

She's heard many a story about DPs/DHs/DW and parents and kids distancing themselves and sometimes even cutting off when someone gets long term ill. Thankfully she's completely fine now and her now DP is absolutely lovely, I wouldn't have many worries if it came back when she was with him- well I hope not anyhow.

IwinIwin · 10/03/2014 22:11

I understand how upset you are OP, have you tried talking to these friend about it? Their perspective may be very different to yours. Many people have made good points making it clear just why said friends may have needed to walk away and distance themselves now, I suggest that you do read them and remember-however much you want to be a good friend- that you can't put your friend first to the detriment of
you and yours.

A good friend of mine ended up having a breakdown because she was that 'friend that just had to stay'. All the others walked away or distanced themselves eventually due to the emotional manipulation and how much they were put upon. They tried very hard to establish boundaries and keep the friendships but he was just too much for them all and didn't hear or wouldn't listen to the boundaries. My friend held on til the bitter end, she ended up extremely ill and suffered a breakdown. When told by her DP that my friend was very unwell and unable to talk to him a time later, he went ballistic- screamed at her DP, threatened all kinds against himself and it was just enough. My friend heard the call and she pretty much collapsed in on herself and her own doctor said she needed to cut her friend off until she got back on her feet.

If I hadn't known the things my friend went through I may have thought yadnbu about your friends and that people were shit but I know what my friend went through and she got the worst end of it. Though her friends that walked also didn't go unscathed- they had more self preservation then my friend but they also felt hurt, sadness, guilt alongside the relief. One ended up with severe anxiety due to it, you wouldn't have known at the time but she did.

LuciusMalfoyisSmokingHot · 10/03/2014 21:45

My ex DP, left me the same day as my suicide attempt, i had PND and he was cheating, i overdosed and he dropped me home from the hospital, packed and left, leaving me with an 18 month old baby.

Some people just dont have the emotional capacity, to give that kind of attention.

iamsoannoyed · 10/03/2014 21:29

I couldn't agree with Burren more.

Getting all self-righteous and standing in judgement of others will not make any difference to your friend. It may alienate you from others though. I find all the references to "love" and how "some people" don't know about love and you suddenly do, slightly OTT.

You don't know why they walked away. It may be due to stigma, lack of care or being "fairweather friends". It might not be. Friendship should not be to the point of overwhelming you or damaging your family/personal relationships/work. Sometimes you have to put yourself or your family (especially if they have DC) first.

You have made your decision, they've made theirs. If you're happy with your decision, get on with living your life and helping your friend- and stop bleating on about how you "love" your friend more than the others do as though you've won some competition.

Burren · 10/03/2014 21:00

I am the eldest daughter of a mother who was the 'last friend/relative standing' on more occasions than I can count throughout my childhood.

She meant well, but her inability to walk away from a situation, ever, put the four of us, and my father, through hell, and taught us from a very early age that our needs were less important than those of someone else who appealed to her guardian angel impulses. Our needs came last, behind those of any waif and stray, including people who walked all over us because she could not draw a line and be seen as the bad guy.

It became clear to me as an adult that her desire to 'help' came, not from a position of strength and generosity, but from rock bottom self-esteem and the idea that only deeply unfortunate people could want her in their lives. She has no interest in happy, fulfilled people, collects hard luck stories, tragedies and misfortunes, and -sadly - has not a genuine friend in the world.

As a result, I respect the decision of those who do draw a line when demands become too much. This may not be the case with your friends, but no one, however close a friend, can or should be expected to help beyond their capacities. This does not invalidate the friendship.

I think you throw the word 'love' around too lightly, and are hung up on self-sacrifice in friendship. Good on you for staying around to help, but let it be your decision, and stop harping on your friends' different choices. Perhaps they are fair weather friends. Yes. Or perhaps they are just wrung out from the situation, or tired of having the lives of their families compromised by the suicidal friend. Either way, forget about them. ''True love' is not an exam they failed and you have passed.

Loopytiles · 10/03/2014 20:07

That was a good thing to do lookingthroughthefog, what a good team / DM!

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread