Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To not understand why "friends" are abandoning a friend in need?

163 replies

runnermum1974 · 09/03/2014 22:04

My friend attempted suicide and did real serious damage to themselves.

Days after the attempt 3 of their close friends have said they are going their separate ways. They have given some reasons, but they are pretty lame - like they are not compatible, and deciding that now, after 5 years of friendship!!

I am not saying that they have to be friends or anything. But the timing is bloody awful.

I do not understand how friends can abandon a friend in need. Anyone can be a friend in the good times. The test of friendship comes in the hard times.

If anyone has a story about abandoning friendships when a friend is in a difficult place, then I will appreciate the insight.

AIBU to think it is unkind to leave a friend in need?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NadineMumsnet · 16/08/2022 15:47

Hello @Bobbie1976 , we are really sorry to hear you are feeling this way.

We hope you don't mind, but when these posts are flagged up to us we usually add a link to our Mental Health resources. You can also go to the Samaritans website or email them on [email protected].

Support from other Mumsnetters is great and we really hope you will be able to take some comfort from your fellow posters, but as other MNers will tell you, it's really a good idea to seek RL help and support as well.

We wish you all the best Flowers

FarFarFarAndAway · 16/08/2022 15:30

@Bobbie1976 I'm sorry to hear you feel so terrible. Have you seen the mental health topic- you could post in there your story as I don't think many people will see it on this old thread from years ago. I have found the Samaritans very helpful when you feel like no-one else will listen, definitely call them if you want to talk:

www.samaritans.org/how-we-can-help/contact-samaritan/talk-us-phone/

Bobbie1976 · 15/08/2022 19:09

I'm dealing with this right now. I am suicidal, there I said it. Out loud.

I have no one. My friends know how I am feeling. I've lost my Mum, Dad, most of my pets and am by myself. I thought reaching out was the right thing to do. I've heard nothing from the person I thought cared about me the most. My male friend (gay). He is always out partying, surrounded by people. I'm alone at Christmas, New Year, everything. I have tried to be a good friend to all my friends but have had to admit defeat since I started to feel like this. My male friend promised my Mum he'd never abandon me.

So I'm at a point now where I think I should not have told them. Like it's my fault I was honest. So where it's a different side of the coin to your topic, I just wanted to say that it f hurts to be left. I don't know why we are encouraged to talk about mental health if this is what happens as a result. Thanks for letting me talk.

AngelaDaviesHair · 13/03/2014 15:17

My former friend was intelligent, witty, and creative. She could be very good company and was superficially at least, kind and interested in others. We had a lot of common interests.

She had also threatened suicide many times, turning up at her neighbours' flats holding knives and saying she was going to harm herself, so that they had to call 999. She was persecuting the psychiatrist treating her (not her first-others had had to withdraw) and had viciously abused other HCPs when they displeased or thwarted her. She absconded from hospital. She had no boundaries, frequently behaved in a very sexually provocative manner and then had a crisis if the men concerned appeared to reciprocate her interest. She was preoccupied by her condition and situation to the exclusion of just about everything else and expected all friends to be similarly preoccupied with it. Anyone who befriended her was cast in a helping role while she was the centre of attention. She betrayed my confidences and tried to exert control over what I did.

I accepted I had no control over what happened-this was an extreme drama in which no one could predict how things would end up. I was not prepared to hand my life over to her. I bailed. When I told her, she actually said she understood. I do not regret it. I do not actually think my being there would have made a great deal of difference: her problems were complex and ingrained and she was very resistant to all the therapeutic or treatment suggestions put to her (as she often told me).

springykyrie · 13/03/2014 14:52

If the intervention is available

Did anyone see the A&E (I think?) series where they focused on parademic intervention with people with MH difficulties? Even the paramedics were largely ignorant of what they were facing (and most desperately admitted that). One man they visited was completely off his head, repeatedly saying to camera I NEED HELP! HELP ME! but the NHS had ignored him, despite his repeated pleas. At the end of the prog they showed a clip of him 'in his right mind' ie he had received intervention. (the LHA probably heard he was going to be featured on the telly, or someone Important intervened and wouldn't let go )

Actually, that's a point - perhaps a constructive step could be to harangue the LHA to do something about treatment/intervention? yy the patient has to be the first to make the move but at least it's on record and, like the man in the programme, perhaps the patient has been begging for help but they're deemed NOT ILL ENOUGH Angry

ormirian · 13/03/2014 09:51

"My experience of my friend and that part of their MH difficulties, has been of an all-encompassing and wretched condition driving away the thing they want the most; security, and causing confusion, turmoil, misery and wrecking a life, reducing them to only being able to cope with the most basic and menial things, despite a high IQ and prior abilities, and no innate ability to control their problem, or overview that might allow them to ab/use it for their benefit. "

Yes. I totally agree. There is no doubt that mental illness can do all the things you mention in the quoted paragraph I have been so low I have wanted to die. I have been so low I actually stood on a mway bridge and wanted to jump off. Only reason I didn't is because I had my dog with me and illogically I was more concerned about keeping him safe than all the other hideous consequences of my suicide. There are times when I have been reduced to a sobbing shaking wreck in the supermarket because I simply could not cope with the noise, the stress, the inability to work out what I needed to do. I have wanted to curl up somewhere dark and quiet and stay there.

The problem is that what I NEEDED from someone then was for them to take my hand, tell me what I needed to do and then physically FORCE me to go the GP. And I wouldn't have gone willingly until the point when I was ready to go. I needed someone to think for me, to act for me, to take over my entire life. You can't do that for someone else. My husband might have been able to convince me but at the time he was not all the invested in my wellbeing (to put it nicely Hmm). I tried with my friend but as she had taken herself off her med about 3 months prior to her partner leaving she wasn't going to take any advice on that! You can't force someone to seek help against their will. You can only support and support and support and it's exhausting, demoralising, frustrating and it can leave you pretty low yourself. Not to mention those of us who have families need to prioritise - I know that sounds callous but it's true.

I would suggest the friend in the OP is probably in the best position to receive medical help and support that she has been for years. Because she has finally done something that cannot be ignored. Is it kind to abandon her? I am not sure that kindness is going to be much good to her - intervention might be.

CinnabarRed · 13/03/2014 09:47

JGOWI - I think people are drawing a distinction between people with PDs, who as you say can't help who they are, and people who happen to be selfish individuals but don't have a PD.

JustGettingOnWithIt · 13/03/2014 08:59

I also find some of the views about PD’s etc here very sad.
Yes the effects of them on people around them can be absolutely awful and drive friends away or piss them of, and I can totally understand people wanting to get away from that, I often do and it’s not a judgement on either my friend or myself, just a reaction.

Perhaps I’m naive and there really are people with PD’s that can turn it on and off and choose when to be affected and have time of when it suits, and use it to their advantage, but I've not met them in R/L.

My experience of my friend and that part of their MH difficulties, has been of an all-encompassing and wretched condition driving away the thing they want the most; security, and causing confusion, turmoil, misery and wrecking a life, reducing them to only being able to cope with the most basic and menial things, despite a high IQ and prior abilities, and no innate ability to control their problem, or overview that might allow them to ab/use it for their benefit.

I’m wc disabled and wouldn’t swap problems with her for anything.

MusicalEndorphins · 13/03/2014 08:52

Just in reply to your message to me up there^
You did ask for insight.
I am a compassionate person, and have a lot of experience with unstable people in my own family. Several family members suffer anxiety and depression and serious mood disorders. One I did stop contact with for a while, they were so violent and scary, during which time they were arrested for some violent actions and then later hospitalized and put on the proper medications, that have helped them be on a more even keel.

There comes to a point when it is too draining...I have spent many hours worried sick and sitting in the hospital ER waiting for the Crisis Intervention team to evaluate someone. I deeply care about people, but I only can handle so much. Two of my children and myself have chronic illnesses, and I need to save something for us.

I stumbled upon the Serenity prayer that AA uses a few years ago, and is kind of what I remind myself when things get crazy. I removed the religious part.
"Grant me the serenity
to accept the things I cannot change;
courage to change the things I can;
and wisdom to know the difference."

springykyrie · 12/03/2014 19:05

Interesting that NOrman Tebbit's wife suffered from depression and she was later crippled in the Brighton Bomb. She was asked which was the worst, the depression or life in a wheelchair - she said no contest, depression was by far the worst.

Most people with eg depression can't help it either. No different from a personality disorder in that way - it is an illness . As I said, lots of judgement on here about mental illness eg victim complex etc Hmm

troubleinstore · 12/03/2014 17:02

2rebecca yes I think my friend has a personality disorder too. She can turn on and off her 'can't cope with anything' mode as and when it suits, so the most difficult of tasks if it involves something she is interested in and wants to do, becomes easiest of all to do and the menial things she needs to focus on she 'can't - and they are too difficult for her' . This is where my frustration comes in. She can't cook for her kids - they eat sandwiches every night, but she come down the pub on a weeknight, go shopping with the girlies and can arrange for them all to go on a camping holiday - because she knows friends will take pity on her and help her out when she can't do stuff.
All of our friends are beginning to get wise to the fact, and
what they see is just 'laziness' not depression. I have tried to help her, but she seems to turn on the tears when things are not going her way. I sometimes wonder whether it is as bad as she is saying or just something she pulls out of the bag as and when required.
I know when I felt bad, I would not go out and socialise, meet up with friends, go to the pub etc ... she does ... but gets very defensive and angry if you ask her any questions which seem to question how she is feeling and suggest ways she can self help.
At the moment the bunch of friends we have seem to be all over a barrel because no one wants to upset her by saying or doing anything that may be seen as unkind to her.
I am the only person who has told her to stop being aggressive when things are not going her way and she is not being agreed with, or wont take advice. This backfired on my behalf and now I feel bad.
All of our joint friends are a bit stuck in the middle now and it's a bit awkward when we all meet up.
I am sticking to my guns though... I don't need the stress in my life.. someone else can help her now.

babyheaves · 12/03/2014 16:53

I have a friend who is a wheelchair user. The most help he ever needs from me is the very occasional bump up a kerb or slightly more planning on where to meet due to accessibility issues. That's it.

I have a friend who uses a wheelchair and she can kvetch and moan like the best of them. I've also met a lot of people who don't have any physical or mental illness, but are just draining whingy selfish gripe-bags all on their own.

You just can't generalise either way.

SaucyJack · 12/03/2014 16:41

ALso, more generally: if someone has a personality disorder, it's fair to say that s/he can't actually help having it, yet that surely doesn't mean that friends and family have to put up with abuse, manipulation, drama etc indefinitely with no hope of a cure.

Quite. Besides which, you are doing the sufferer no favours whatsoever by allowing them to think that their behaviour/victim complexes/thought distortions are justified or acceptable anyway.

SaucyJack · 12/03/2014 16:36

I agree Cinnabar

I have a friend who is a wheelchair user. The most help he ever needs from me is the very occasional bump up a kerb or slightly more planning on where to meet due to accessibility issues. That's it.

SolidGoldBrass · 12/03/2014 16:30

ALso, more generally: if someone has a personality disorder, it's fair to say that s/he can't actually help having it, yet that surely doesn't mean that friends and family have to put up with abuse, manipulation, drama etc indefinitely with no hope of a cure.

MiaowTheCat · 12/03/2014 16:28

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

SolidGoldBrass · 12/03/2014 16:22

OP, are you the one who's known SUicide GIrl for the shortest time? It sounds to me as though the others have either seen through her (she's not mentally ill, just self-obsessed and unpleasant) or are aware that there is nothing they can actually do to help, because she won't help herself.

I wonder what's in your past that makes you such a willing martyr.Were you brought up to be 'unselfish' ie accept unfair treatment and suppress your own needs entirely? If that's the case I can see how self-righteousness becoems your only comfort.

2rebecca · 12/03/2014 15:44

I'm not sure that talking about people with mental illness being "weak" is helpful. Depressed people aren't weaker than nondepressed ones. It gets more complex if personality factors are involved rather than depression and many of the people who self harm have personality disorders. They can have very strong often overwhelming personalities and don't come across as "weak" at all, just very needy. I suspect many of the chronically needy, self centred friends mentioned here have personality disorders rather than depression.
To be friends with someone with a personality disorder you have to have a very strong personality yourself to stick and keep to boundaries to stop them taking over your life.

springykyrie · 12/03/2014 15:26

No-one's going to sue you, I'm certainly not. Of course not - I am so sorry you experienced your dad's suicide when you were a young teen. Must have been, and still is, awful. I'm not surprised you can't bear to be around anyone who is suicidal.

I suppose it takes immense boundary skills to be around someone who is ill (to the point of not recognising social cues) and not many of us have developed those to the fine point that is required when dealing with someone who is mentally ill. Some people who are mentally ill can take the piss - though whether that's the illness or not is anyone's guess (a professional would have a clearer opinion about that I expect!).

CinnabarRed · 12/03/2014 14:53

Some of the opinions on this thread seem to illustrate the judgement towards mental illness over physical illness.

I think this is really unfair.

The truth is that it takes fewer of my resources (time, energy, emotional, whatever) to support any of my friends with physical illnesses than it does to support any of my friends with mental health issues.

None of my friends with physical health issues want to speak to me for hours on the phone.

None of my friends with physical health issues have asked me to drop other friends so that I can focus on them alone.

None of my friends with physical health issues have refused to engage with professionals because they can depend on me instead.

Many (but by no means all) of my friends with mental health issues have done the above things.

If my friends with physical health issues were to do those things then, yes, I would find them much more difficult to support. I would find them needy.

Realistically (given that I work FT, have 3 young children, and am doing everything I can to help my stepfather in his recovery from cancer) I don't have any more time or emotional energy to give to anyone, whether with physical or mental health issues.

And on the subject of suicide, I simply cannot engage with anyone who is suicidal. I just can't. My father killed himself when I was a young teen, and I can't be around suicidal people without it doing me enormous harm. So sue me.

ormirian · 12/03/2014 14:21

myprettytoes - have done the same. I could never work out why such an interesting and affectionate woman seemed to have so few friends. It took me ages to work out that her affection was always on her terms and was withdrawn if you displeased her. She has threatened suicide before now. She has mental health issues but refuses any medication.

Her partner left her and I was furious on her behalf - I was there day in day out comforting her, mopping tears, giving her hugs, reassuring her that she wasn't a horrible person. For months and months and months with no change - and I thought it strange that no-one else seemed to come around. Even her adult daughters avoided her. And then I realised she thrived on my emotional energy, she was a leech. I would arrive at her doorstep and take a mental deep breath, and leave wrung out like and old dishrag.

And then she started drinking again and I saw the violent angry woman that her partner had had enough of. And the anger was directed towards me and my youngest child who had come with me to see her. I kept trying to step back and she always texted me again with some sob story and I didn't have the guts to say now. Last October she reach out again and we went over for a 'family' party that she had arranged - she was yelling drunk when we got there and I ended up taking her son and the dog home with us because she wasn't fit to look after them.

She hasn't been in touch with me since. She knew she went too far.

I am a chronic depressive so I sympathise with her but I also know that she needed to take steps to fix herself and she wouldn't inspite of suggestions and advice and offers of support. Might add that my H had an affair a few months after her partner left and I was in a mess - she was still demanding and taking and she wore me out. The really tragic thing is that she IS a funny, clever, interesting, capable woman when she isnt in self-destruct mode. It's really sad.

Sometime you have to step away to save your own life.

The

runnermum1974 · 12/03/2014 14:01

I was trying to be deliberately vague and general about the details to protect my friends' identity. As there were 3 friends they all knew suicidal friend at different times (one since uni, so 20 years, another for 5 years since when we were all bridesmaids etc.), and I tried to keep it general so no one could be identified. They appeared to be close friends - that was the point I was making.

I did ask them why they wrote a letter and they thought it was the kindest thing to do. Seeing my suicidal friend in person would have been too upsetting and dramatic - there would be tears, and accusations etc. they didn't want that, so they did it by letter as that would also give the suicidal friend time to digest things.

I see what a lot of people are saying. It just felt, to me, it was like leaving the weak one behind. That's not nice, but it is logical. Maybe I'm the stupid one for sticking around and going on about true love is what keeps going - I need something! But I always think - anyone could one day become the weak one.

Maybe what we need is more positive psychology for people with mental health issues to help themselves.

OP posts:
springykyrie · 12/03/2014 12:18

Some of the opinions on this thread seem to illustrate the judgement towards mental illness over physical illness. the bottom line seems to be that people who have a mental illness are selfish drama queens and should get their act together, take responsibility for their lives, stop putting it on other people (aka pull their socks up). Ignorant imo, literally ignorant ie little knowledge of some of the true effects of mental illness.

It doesn't help that there is very little treatment available from our health service - which is being cut back even more, if that is possible, as we speak. So people with mental illness are hung out to dry in the community - which is often seeringly judgemental. Those in the community who do hang around to help can get ravaged by the effects of the illness, which should be being dealt with by trained professionals.

Conclusion: don't get mentally ill. You've had it if you do.

Sillylass79 · 12/03/2014 11:05

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Onesieone · 12/03/2014 10:56

I recently had a friend loose a child who had been very I'll. 2 of our other friends cut all contact after the funeral. I was more upset about this than my bereaved pal who obviously had more important things on her plate. I spoke to the two who CAT and they said bereaved pal had become very selfish. Turning every thing around so it was all about her. They said they couldn't handle listening to anymore "self absorbed sob stories" that's a quote so I have likely outed myself if they r reading!
I felt this was massively selfish but each to their own. Pal was like this before her wee man got sick!

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.