Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate these kind of comments about surviving cancer?

291 replies

Sallystyle · 08/02/2014 09:57

I am pretty sure everyone by now is aware my ex husband died in December of cancer leaving three of our young children behind. I know I mention it a lot but it has been a devastating few months.

I think I have mentioned my dislike of these type of comments elsewhere as well.

I go onto FB and see a friends status about how she has been recovered from cancer for over 8 years now. That is fantastic, I have sent messages saying how happy I am for her etc but I take great offence at some of the comments which are on the lines of:

'Of course you fought it, you are strong'
'Cancer could never beat someone like you'
'Hold your head up, this just shows what an amazing strong person you are, cancer never had a chance'

So reading this hit me hard this morning and I have since hid the status in question but I am sitting here feeling really pissed off. This is not the first time I have read stuff like this.

I just want to shout and say cancer doesn't care if you are a strong person or not, dying from cancer doesn't make you any less stronger than the next person. I know no one means any offence but how hard is it to just say congratulations I am so happy for you or something?

Maybe I am just hurting and bitter but I so wanted to comment on it but I did the right thing and just hid it instead and then came straight here to vent.

So am I an unreasonable to hate these type of comments?

OP posts:
myitchybeaver · 08/02/2014 12:32

YANBU

It gets my goat. As someone whose career has been working in Oncology there is very little evidence being positive has any impact at all. It gives a greater quality of life but doesn't extend your life.

Plenty nasty fuckers survive cancer. Over the years I've treated convicted paedophiles and all sorts of criminals, homeless people, the chronically depressed - seen plenty of them cured.

I've seen the most selfless, wonderful, positive, brave people die ALL THE TIME.

It's luck or fate or something that dictates survival but it isn't courage or positivity.

dramajustfollowsme · 08/02/2014 12:28

My mum always wanted to have a positive outlook and I do think it helped her cope as everything else was out of her control.
I've lost both parents, 3/4 grandparents and my grandad is also not going to get better.
No one could say they were weak. The cancer just was too much for their bodies to cope with.
It is a horrible, horrible disease.

LadyBeagleEyes · 08/02/2014 12:28

I have a secondary cancer, 10 years after I thought I'd beaten it. I won't beat this one.
I think people just don't think, they don't know what to say.
It's not just on FB either, it's all over the media.
Celebs saying how they beat cancer and won, fought it, thought positive and all that shit.
All you can do is take the drugs and hope for the best. That is it.

whatever5 · 08/02/2014 12:25

YANBU. I would hate those comments too. I don't have cancer but I do have a serious chronic illness and the suggestion that I can influence it through will power/attitude/exercise/alternative therapies etc gets on my nerves.

mrsjay · 08/02/2014 12:21

I guess people just like using positive words such as strong it helps them but it is insensitive so if a person dies does that make them weak absolutely not

EllaFitzgerald · 08/02/2014 12:20

I think it's a dreadfully thoughtless thing to say to someone. It seems to be a standard response from a lot of people though, almost as though they don't know what else to say.

I, along with most other people, have lost loved ones to this awful disease, and have been lucky enough to have loved ones recover. Without exception, all have found comments like these incredibly offensive and upsetting.

Minnieisthedevilmouse · 08/02/2014 12:17

Yanbu

I don't get all that talk either. You either survive, or you don't. You don't get to choose. It's luck. Or not I suppose. I never understand why you are brave to fight cancer either. I mean, what else do you do? Not much choice but try to get on with it til either you're better or you are not. Marketing BS is all it is designed to get your money.

MrsBungle · 08/02/2014 12:14

I do understand that people are coming from a good and very well-intentioned place when they say these things. I just don't like these terms at all. People who have cancer or who have someone very close to them with it, absolutely have the right to talk about it in what ever manner they like.

RudolphtheRedknowsraindear · 08/02/2014 12:10

So sorry about your husband, cancer is a b**rd disease. As you know, when you're diagnosed you are told how far it's spread & what your treatment options are. Then you just go onto the treadmill of treatment & surgery. There is no fighting involved, it is just the draw that you are given. I'm clear now, had my 1st 12 months all clear just before Xmas. I spent many a night sitting downstairs at 2am crying, feeling sick & being very scared. Not brave, not fighting, just getting through the process. People can be very judgy when cancer is involved. I've never smoked, I'm not a wino, I've always been, (fairly) slim & been sporty & fit. But, to read some of the stuff about cancer, it lays out blame about lifestyle. My oncologist said it was a load of rubbish & nothing that I'd done. Oh,it's not in the family either. I found that a lot of people are, "oh, you're OK now, why are you not just like you were before." I'll never be like I was before. I've had a boob cut off & will worry about every lump & bump. DH & DC' s now worry too, which is awful to see as I know it's my fault. New Year was spent going for tests for spinal bone Mets, which were negative thank G, just knackered discs. So no, not brave, not fighting & not my fault or fair on the rest of my family. So sorry for you & your family OP, a bstrd disease that is indiscriminate & not bldy fair.

Sallystyle · 08/02/2014 11:58

I might have been guilty of using the word battling cancer, fighting cancer in the past, I am not sure, so I know it is one of those things people just say but I don't think I have ever told anyone that they survived cancer because they are strong.

OP posts:
waterlego6064 · 08/02/2014 11:56

Kundry I think that doctor was on Radio 4 recently, and she talked about the battle terminology. She was very interesting to listen to; I might have a look at her books.

I had a friend implore me to take my mum to Mexico for 'nutritional therapy'. I nodded and smiled and didn't like to say that it was difficult enough helping her along to the bathroom at that stage, let alone getting her on a plane to Mexico Grin

manicinsomniac · 08/02/2014 11:55

Please STOP leaving comments like this if any of you do. They make people seethe.

No Mignonette, they make you and some others seethe. They make others upset. But they are what keeps still others going. Which I why I think that a family can't be wrong or inappropriate in the way they approach cancer.

Littleen · 08/02/2014 11:55

yanbu, my mum died a few weeks ago to cancer, and it's offensive to read such comments. Mind, a while back I read about someone with a preemie baby saying that "she pulled through because she knew how much we love her and how much we wanted her there" which to me is even more offensive!

Kundry · 08/02/2014 11:52

Oh and John Diamond's book is amazing. I'd read it years ago but when my Dad first became ill I truly realised how true it was. Suddenly we were bombarded with friends wanting to help him 'fight' and telling him he should take this or that herbal thing. Er, no, he's going to have the proven treatment thanks and let the surgeon and the chemicals do the fighting.

I can also highly recommend Kate Granger's books 'The Bright Side' and 'The Other Side'. She's inspirational but would be furious if you said she was a 'fighter'. She's a doctor with terminal cancer who writes brilliantly about seeing things from both sides of the fence.

neighbourhoodwitch · 08/02/2014 11:52

God no, so stupid and insensitive. YANBU!!!

hackmum · 08/02/2014 11:51

lljjk: "Those aren't comments about what other people did or didn't do (whether they were strong or not). They're meant to encourage the survivor to keep their morale up. That's all they're about."

I don't think so. I think the comments are all about the individual writing them. If they thought about the other person, they'd realise they don't help morale at all. I think all this business about being strong and brave is another way of saying "I don't want to hear about the pain you're in. If you're feeling weak and lonely and frightened, please don't tell me. Let's maintain this illusion that you're brave and strong and then I won't need to make an effort to listen to you."

waterlego6064 · 08/02/2014 11:46

...people's experience with cancer, unfortunately, those comments can be interpreted a different way- regardless of the intention of the speaker.

Mignonette · 08/02/2014 11:45

I hate these comments.

Children die from cancer. They are not weak.
My grandfather was felled in three months. I have yet to meet anybody who loved life as much as him, who was as happy as him and he was also a lifelong vegetarian cyclist. I will never stop missing him.

Please STOP leaving comments like this if any of you do. They make people seethe.

Flowers Samu. You talk about it on here as much as you like.

pumpkinsweetie · 08/02/2014 11:45

Yanbu at all, my brother died of cancer aged 16 nearly 8 years ago now and he fought it bravely & courageously everyday, just because it took him doesn't take away the above.

My sympathies op Thanks xx

Kundry · 08/02/2014 11:45

YANBU. I work with terminally ill people and I don't notice that they are 'weaker' than people who survive - they just have different cancers.

I find it really sad when families worry someone is 'giving up' or think they'll beat it 'because he/she is a fighter'. Coping strategies can really help you manage better but if you are chockfull of cancer it's painful watching people hurt themselves more having set themselves unachievable targets. Or relatives pressurizing a poorly person to 'keep fighting'.

Most of my colleagues (even those in the curative end) feel the same about the whole 'battle against cancer' narrative.

My Dad died of cancer. He was brave and strong and amazing. Part of his bravery was knowing when he'd had enough. People die, it's the way the world works, and it's offensive to suggest that if you tried a bit harder, you wouldn't have.

UsingMyRedPen · 08/02/2014 11:45

You are not being unreasonable. I've never really thought about those comments, much less made any myself, but I have seen them on posts and you've made me look at them in a whole new way. People can be so insensitive, even when they don't mean to be.

I'm so sorry for your loss Sam, I can only imagine the devastation you must be feeling. Thanks

ziggiestardust · 08/02/2014 11:45

YANBU OP

I'm so sorry for your loss Sad

I hate this stuff on Facebook, that seems to insinuate that if you're strong enough, you'll beat it. And if you don't beat it, you 'lost the fight' against cancer. Insensitive I think.

bragmatic · 08/02/2014 11:45

I agree with manicinsomniac. It's just something people say. It's up there with 'she's in a better place now', which people said about mum. She wasn't, but they mean well, there was no malice intended. I smiled and said thank you for your thoughts. Those same people would never uttered that phrase to my friend, who lost her 3 year old to cancer.

Facebook broadcasts messages to people who are not really the intended recipient. They put their own spin on it, and feelings are hurt. It's one of the downsides to social media.

waterlego6064 · 08/02/2014 11:45

lljk I see what you're saying (I think), and while you're right that those comments are absolutely not intended to make judgements about other peo

Sallystyle · 08/02/2014 11:44

Just bought the John Diamond book on my kindle.

Thanks everyone and much love to everyone who has lost someone to cancer, has had cancer and those who have it. Thanks

OP posts: