Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate these kind of comments about surviving cancer?

291 replies

Sallystyle · 08/02/2014 09:57

I am pretty sure everyone by now is aware my ex husband died in December of cancer leaving three of our young children behind. I know I mention it a lot but it has been a devastating few months.

I think I have mentioned my dislike of these type of comments elsewhere as well.

I go onto FB and see a friends status about how she has been recovered from cancer for over 8 years now. That is fantastic, I have sent messages saying how happy I am for her etc but I take great offence at some of the comments which are on the lines of:

'Of course you fought it, you are strong'
'Cancer could never beat someone like you'
'Hold your head up, this just shows what an amazing strong person you are, cancer never had a chance'

So reading this hit me hard this morning and I have since hid the status in question but I am sitting here feeling really pissed off. This is not the first time I have read stuff like this.

I just want to shout and say cancer doesn't care if you are a strong person or not, dying from cancer doesn't make you any less stronger than the next person. I know no one means any offence but how hard is it to just say congratulations I am so happy for you or something?

Maybe I am just hurting and bitter but I so wanted to comment on it but I did the right thing and just hid it instead and then came straight here to vent.

So am I an unreasonable to hate these type of comments?

OP posts:
manicinsomniac · 08/02/2014 14:03

But mouldy that's you. The wife of my friend that is dying is desperate to get him on that diet (but he is struggling to keep much down). We know 2 men who were diagnosed terminal, given a few weeks to live, followed the diet and are still here 2 and 3.5 years later, still living with cancer but doing incredibly well.

The chances are it won't work for my friend. But the stories of these two men are keeping them going at present. And you never know. What's the harm in them offering their experience and advice?

It upset you so, presumably (I hope!) your friend shut up about it. But she couldn't know whether it would be something you would want to hear or not.

SantasLittleMonkeyButler · 08/02/2014 14:01

I remember a celebrity who had recovered from cancer (possibly Jennifer Saunders) receiving criticism for saying she didn't see her illness as a battle ot fight & didn't want to talk about "my fight". It is a devastating illness, some get lucky some don't.

Also the "cancer we're coming to get you" advertising slogan makes me blood run cold. As someone with a genetic tendency to cancer it makes me think "yes, we probably are". Actually, I think it was a very very poor choice of phrase.

mouldyironingboard · 08/02/2014 13:29

Samu2, I would recommend getting bereavement counselling for you and your children. It can probably be arranged from your local hospice.

When my ex was in his final few weeks one of my close friends told me some rubbish about a special diet which could cure cancer. I was so cross that I snapped and told her to grow up and either start dealing with the reality of his impending death or not to phone me again until after the funeral.

BsshBossh · 08/02/2014 13:15

YANBU. I'm a cancer survivor but always put my survival down to sheer luck. When I still had it I never saw myself as "battling" it out either as the cancer was part of my body and I simply couldn't conceive of "battling" against my body. I simply put all my trust into my oncology team and treatment. No one understood my way of thinking but I didn't care.

So sorry for your loss. I was single and childless when I had cancer. My experience would have been so much harder if I'd had a spouse and children...

waterlego6064 · 08/02/2014 13:08

It does make things hard, minsmum. I'm sorry to hear your mum has cancer.

In an ideal world, we could just politely say to those people 'actually, this is not anything to do with strength, it's going to be about luck and medicine', but I know I didn't have the energy to say that to people at the time.

When my mum was told her treatment had not been successful, and that no further treatment was being offered, she felt frustrated and helpless. I remember telling her that this was not any reflection on her strength of character or her determination or any of that. I'm not sure she really believed me and it saddens me to think that some of those 'you're strong' comments were having such an impact on her.

diamondlizard · 08/02/2014 13:05

yanbu i HATE these type of thoughtless comments

i know why people do it though, as they want to fall themselves that cancer wont get them as they will fight it
as if they have some sort of control

they dont want to handle the fact shit terrible devestaing things happen to good people all the time everyday

they like to think if they are good people good things will happen to them

when really its all bloddy pot luck

but it must be extremely upsetting for people with cancer and their families

also i dont like they way people with cancer are pressuried into being positive all the time
as if, if your not positive enough cancer will kill you
as if these poeple dont have enough to deal and cope with

minsmum · 08/02/2014 13:03

My dm has cancer she was diagnosed 4 months ago. Her treatment is due to start next week. Because she is unable to keep food down they think she is too weak for the treatment. We keep being told she is strong she can fight this.
It means you can't talk realistically to people and just makes everything harder

waterlego6064 · 08/02/2014 13:02

difficultpickle I was only speculating on that based on conversations I've heard people have about cancer. I'm really glad to hear that you don't feel 'invaded' by your illness :) And you're right in what you said about arteries and so on.

I have a feeling my mum saw her cancer as an adversary which had rudely invaded her body. She used to 'talk' to it (and tell it to bugger off Grin)

Viviennemary · 08/02/2014 13:02

Of course it is reasonable for you to hate those remarks. It's nothing to do with the harder you fight. Absolute nonsense. But on the other hand I think people only say those things to people to give encouragement so I suppose they mean well although not very senstive to others. Flowers

waterlego6064 · 08/02/2014 12:58

tunnock I can see why 'inspirational' must irritate you. I'm very sorry to read of your DH's diagnosis. What a terribly cruel thing to happen to a young family. I wish you and your DH and children all the very best.

Not quite the same, but my parents died within 10 weeks of each other last year, and lots of people have told me they think I'm 'amazing' or 'inspiring' 'so strong' etc. No. I have just continued to get out of bed every morning to face the day, which is the same thing anyone would do. No-one knows how they will cope with an awful situation until they're in one, and then we find that coping is just what we do, because there's no alternative to it.

Sunflower As an alternative, people could say 'what awful luck' or 'I hope the treatment goes ok'. In the example give by the OP, people could say 'I'm so pleased you got better!' Or 'I'm glad your treatment worked'.

CouthyMow · 08/02/2014 12:54

My DD's best friend was a strong, healthy 14yo. She died of AML. Cancer doesn't discriminate. My Great Aunt was a strong woman, who died of breast cancer. My Nan (her sister) has survived breast cancer, 7 years now. She wasn't 'strong', she was lucky.

difficultpickle · 08/02/2014 12:53

thegreylady some cancer patients are cured. If I survive treatment I will be completely cured, not in remission. It so depends on the type of cancer you have.

myflabberisgasted · 08/02/2014 12:52

YANBU

I'm so sorry for your loss Thanks

I lost my mum to cancer and those sort of comments hurt me too, she fought as best as she could. Doesn't mean she wasn't a strong woman. It's all just down to luck.

Sorry OP ThanksThanks

thegreylady · 08/02/2014 12:51

YANBU
Some say it's a battle like a war between two nations
Some say it's a journey with stops at different stations
Some say you can survive it if only you are strong
Let me tell those someones how completely they are wrong.
Cancer is a vile disease. You don't get better if you 'fight' how do you fight a disease? It's not about strength or weakness or even about ignorance or knowledge. It is about the type and location of the cancer and how far it has spread when it is found. Cancer patients aren't cured they are in remission often for many years. Many die of other things. I have had breast cancer, seven and a half years ago, so far I am well. My close friend was diagnosed at the same time as me and she has been dead for three years. We had the same medical team, she was 18 years younger than me. If fighting could have conquered then J would be climbing mountains today. The main difference was that her cancer was a higher grade than mine though mine was technically more aggressive.
So sorry for all of you who have lost loved ones or are suffering yourselves. Love and luck to you.

difficultpickle · 08/02/2014 12:51

I don't know waterlego, isn't your body responsible for growing the stuff that clogs up your arteries too? I'm very healthy in that I have low cholestrol, healthy heart, kidneys, lungs, liver etc but the cancer is in my blood that will most likely kill me. Nothing I've done or not done and nothing to do with my lifestyle or what I eat or don't eat. I don't feel invaded Smile

tunnocksteacake · 08/02/2014 12:49

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

pigletmania · 08/02/2014 12:48

Yes it is luck, and a whole load of factors, type of cancer, how advanced it is, how the person is responding to treatment. Yes I think people do perceive it as a foreign body to be gotten rid of, it seems the way it is viewed is different to other illnesses.

bootsycollins · 08/02/2014 12:46

Oh Sam Flowers

Sunflower49 · 08/02/2014 12:45

YANBU. I hate the anthropomorphism of it as well, and I also dislike when people say someone is 'strong' in terms of dealing with any illness or situation, cancer included.

'Strong' doesn't really mean anything I don't think-what does 'strength' actually mean in this context?That if it gets you down you're weak?If an illness beats you and you suffer illness or death then you're weak?As is said above, it implies this-that cancer only beats 'weak' people and the 'strong' people will get through it and survive. People know that isn't true so why say such things. I wonder what a good alternative could be?
I'm so sorry for your loss . xxx

waterlego6064 · 08/02/2014 12:44

That's an interesting question difficultpickle.

Is it because cancer can be perceived as a 'foreign body' of sorts? Of course, it isn't, but I wonder if people visualise it as something that has 'invaded' the body? It must be hard for some people to accept that it is the body itself that has produced a tumour or tumours.

GlitzAndGiggles · 08/02/2014 12:42

I agree with you. My mum was a fit and healthy 38yo when cancer took her. Every person fighting cancer is strong. Cancer isn't a little person who decides who should die or not depending on their strength

difficultpickle · 08/02/2014 12:39

I do think it is odd that 'fight' seems to be only associated with cancer. For example you have heart disease but you don't fight it. You have high blood pressure but don't fight it. You have high cholestrol but you don't fight it. I wonder why that is?

difficultpickle · 08/02/2014 12:36

myitchy I think you are spot on. Luck seems to have a lot to do with it. When your cancer gets discovered, what care you get etc. I've so far been lucky that my local consultant referred me to a world renowned expert for the sort of cancer I have. They've been honest with me too and told me because it is so rare my prognosis is uncertain. Nothing I can do about any of it. All I can do is take the drugs and hope the treatment works. If it does then I'm lucky. If it doesn't then I'm just another statistic.

pigletmania · 08/02/2014 12:36

Deals doh

pigletmania · 08/02/2014 12:36

Thanks waterlego, yes I can see where some of you are coming from, but it is nobodies business how the person pedals with their illness. So one has to check with Mumsnet to see if it's ok to fight cancer Hmm. Yes some people take that to other illnesses too, not only Cancer. But yes it is mainly used by those with this illness.