Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate these kind of comments about surviving cancer?

291 replies

Sallystyle · 08/02/2014 09:57

I am pretty sure everyone by now is aware my ex husband died in December of cancer leaving three of our young children behind. I know I mention it a lot but it has been a devastating few months.

I think I have mentioned my dislike of these type of comments elsewhere as well.

I go onto FB and see a friends status about how she has been recovered from cancer for over 8 years now. That is fantastic, I have sent messages saying how happy I am for her etc but I take great offence at some of the comments which are on the lines of:

'Of course you fought it, you are strong'
'Cancer could never beat someone like you'
'Hold your head up, this just shows what an amazing strong person you are, cancer never had a chance'

So reading this hit me hard this morning and I have since hid the status in question but I am sitting here feeling really pissed off. This is not the first time I have read stuff like this.

I just want to shout and say cancer doesn't care if you are a strong person or not, dying from cancer doesn't make you any less stronger than the next person. I know no one means any offence but how hard is it to just say congratulations I am so happy for you or something?

Maybe I am just hurting and bitter but I so wanted to comment on it but I did the right thing and just hid it instead and then came straight here to vent.

So am I an unreasonable to hate these type of comments?

OP posts:
lazyhound444 · 09/02/2014 22:20

I agree expat. Tarte did nail it.

expatinscotland · 09/02/2014 22:16

Nail hitting head with that post, Tarte. Absolutely bang on. It's a way of control and of, on some level, distancing oneself from the reality that it can happen to anyone - not just those who are brave, strong, positive, etc.

lazyhound444 · 09/02/2014 22:11

YANBU. It's offensive and downright stupid and extrapolates to any terminal disease, not just cancer. I had a close friend who was diagnosed with an inoperable brain tumour, she had no chance of survival but had to endure loads of inane comments from well meaning but ultimately ignorant acquaintances saying things like "you never know, you're a strong person, you can beat this" blah blah fucking blah. Sorry for what you're going through, you don't need this shit.

TarteAuxRiz · 09/02/2014 21:51

Hi OP. Firstly sorry for your loss, and for your girls.
I think that the reason people do this is because we, as a society in general, seem terrified of things arbitrarily occurring. So often when something bad or sad happens people talk about karma or fate or other ideas of predestiny or 'justice' or strength to overcome disease or mortality.
My mum lost her husband in a car accident after months of him being in a coma and one of the things she most frequently said was 'why him, why me. Why us? Of course the answer was simply, 'because it was possible that it could happen'
I think this questioning and need to attribute ourselves with the ability to overcome, due to some 'power' that we have over adversity, is because to face the facts (that actually shit things happen because they can and that they can happen to any one of us no matter who we are and how good, bad, strong, weak or middling we may be and there's not a sodding thing we can do to stop it.) is too much for many people. Because if that's the way things really are then we're all so vulnerable and a lot of what we do could be seen to be futile. So they say comments like the ones you mention to convince themselves that if it happened to them they'd have a chance, that somehow they could change the outcome.
I know that noneo f this helps how shitty you must feel when you read those comments, and I'm sorry you had to deal with that tonight.

tiredoldmum · 09/02/2014 21:37

Sam, what an ordeal you have been through. I think people are just trying to be nice when they say those things because they really don't know what to say. Still, it is annoying the little platitudes and other nonsense. The oh he/she was so brave and never complained rubbish.

My ex also passed away from cancer. We were together 20 years. I go no support or acknowledgment about his death at all. Nothing. That was much worse than if someone said you are so strong blah blah.

After he got cancer and passed so suddenly and young at 57, I am paranoid about getting sick and dying. I'm 52. It has turned into a health anxiety.

Thanks
Sallystyle · 09/02/2014 21:24

but me*

OP posts:
Sallystyle · 09/02/2014 21:23

I am lucky with my GP too and my poor dentist.

I live next door to my dental practice so have had a lot of times where I have dropped in because I think I have oral cancer.

I am waiting for a specialists appointment for a lesion type thing my dentist is not worried about and two GP's said was nothing.

It's been there months now and hasn't changed but I still worry. I was referred in december after I cried and my dentist just hugged me bless him, they marked it as non-urgent so that put my mind at rest for a while. My appointment is at the end of March so no one but is worried Grin

OP posts:
MissBetseyTrotwood · 09/02/2014 20:20

HA here too. Sad

Great GP though, who knows our family's sorry tale always gives me the time of day. Smile

harticus · 09/02/2014 13:02

These types of cancer-fighter-strength comments are meant to be all about positive thinking, and inspiring cancer patients and their families.

Oh really?

Well thanks and all that but I really don't need fatuous clichés to "inspire" myself or my family.

Positive thinking - what a crock of glib patronising shite that is.

winterhat · 09/02/2014 12:49

Why would anyone be "inspired" by something that doesn't work though? Positive thinking or negative thinking do not cure or worsen cancer. It's no more than being "inspired" by a placebo.

firesidechat · 09/02/2014 12:41

I think you are being a bit unreasonable though. These types of cancer-fighter-strength comments are meant to be all about positive thinking, and inspiring cancer patients and their families. I don't think the implication is that those that die from cancer are less strong, more that the cancer was more vicious. That is how I see it anyway.

Sharaluck. The only thing I would ask is that if this is true, why do the vast majority of cancer patients hate this sort of comment? Most people with cancer are too polite to say how rubbish this sort of platitude can make them feel, so well meaning people will carry on saying it. Lots of cancer patients don't benefit from this type of stereotyping. Please listen to them.

Personally I think this thread has been incredibly useful if it only makes a few people rethink what they say to others who are suffering.

Sallystyle · 09/02/2014 12:33

I am sorry you have had HA too.

It's horrible.

I haven't been to the GP for 6 weeks now. I never used to go to the doctors until my ex got ill. Now not going for 6 weeks is something to celebrate.

OP posts:
Sallystyle · 09/02/2014 12:31

That son is 12, nearly 13.

They are 14, 12 and 10.

OP posts:
waterlego6064 · 09/02/2014 11:50

Oh Sam- your son sounds amazing, how old is he? What a sophisticated understanding he has of himself and his situation.

Like you, I have had periods of health anxiety over the last year. One month, I saw the GP 3 or 4 times, convinced I had (various different types of) cancer. It's exhausting and you have my sympathies. x

Sallystyle · 09/02/2014 11:04

I fear they are also going to lose two grandfathers this year too.

One has throat cancer that treatment so far hasn't helped and the other has cancer in his bile duct and gallbladder. I have awful health anxiety and petrified that I will get cancer next and they might lose me too.

I was looking through my child's Facebook as that was one of the rules of him having it, and I read a message from his friend. His friend had told him to keep his head up and keep strong and never cry. My little boy told his friend politely that while he knew he was being nice he doesn't have to be strong all the time and it is ok to cry, get angry and break down and it's strong to allow yourself to do this. I was SO proud of him.

Thanks again to everyone who has lost someone or dealing with cancer themselves. I wish cancer would just fuck off but it seems it is all I hear about lately and it is SO scary, it seems to be happening to younger people more often too, or maybe it just feels that way?

And thanks for the kind words and support, it means so much to me.

OP posts:
TheLightPassenger · 09/02/2014 09:36

yanbu at all OP. Thoughts with all those who have lost loved ones to cancer, and best wishes to all those on thread having treatment/waiting for test results.

IshouldhavemarriedEwanMcGregor · 09/02/2014 09:06

I'm so sorry for everyone who is living with cancer and who has lost people to cancer.

I totally understand the fury and despair at these kind of comments - I hate them too.

Thanks
difficultpickle · 09/02/2014 09:03

Sharaluck you may want to have a look at this thread. Lots of support and not just for breast cancer. I've got a weird very rare form of cancer (not breast cancer) and everyone on that thread really supports each other. I've found it helpful to ask questions there too. Good luck with your treatment. I think the worst for me is knowing I will be away from home and from ds for many weeks.

I'm off to hospital for at least 4 weeks this week (the first of several admissions one of which may be up to 3 months). I'm currently trying to finalise plans on who will look after ds when I'm there (single parent so no dp/dh to help), who will do the school runs, where he'll be at weekends. I've also had to get my consultant to negotiate with the hospital for ds to be allowed to visit (usually children aren't allowed

I also think that lots of people have different ways with coping with cancer whether they are the patient or the loved ones and friends of someone with cancer. For me I am rubbish at asking for help so I'm lucky to have some friends who have just stepped in to do things without me having to ask (as they know I wouldn't).

waterlego6064 · 09/02/2014 08:54

A bit off-topic, but I was reading yesterday of a family in my area in which the 3 year-old DC1 has cancer (brain tumour) and the father is having treatment for leukaemia. What awful, shitty, rotten luck that is in the cancer lottery for that poor family :(

waterlego6064 · 09/02/2014 08:52

Difficultpickle, shara, I wish you both all the best for your treatments and I hope for recovery for you. It must be utterly terrifying.

badday It's so good to read that people are learning something from this thread- thank you for saying that you'll be careful with your language if you are ever in this situation. Sadly, cancer is so common that it is likely to affect someone you know at some point.

Pagwatch · 09/02/2014 08:47

I think people of often say things for their own benefit - like 'gosh you're such an amazing mum. I couldn't do what you do' to me because I have a child with severe SN. I mean, what does that actually mean? They would not parent their child if he/she developed SN? Like I have a choice?
It's distancing. On a level they don't think about it 'rather you than me'

But to be fair I think it is the sort of thing we hear do often we feel as if its right. It's unthinking and knee jerk and words people reach for because they are talking to someone whose grief and/ or life is beyond their imagination.

It's human nature to try to say something positive because we think that's supportive.
Sometimes I wish people would say 'Christ how utterly shit'

One of our best friends has recently been diagnosed with advanced stage cancer and we try to ask him what we can do rather than tell him what we think he should hear.

Shonajoy · 09/02/2014 03:07

Sam, I had cancer two years ago, and am still dealing with things after having three surgeries, and I'm going in on Monday for another one. I HATE HATE HATE comments like this with a passion. I'm a member of a cancer support group and even they are doing it.

All this so and so lost her fight today,so and so is an inspiration?! Oh and all these bloody tattoos (I love tattoos don't get me wrong) with the logo and survivor underneath with a butterfly. I've got a sick sense of humour, was saying to dh I'd get my cancer back if I dared get a survivor one, that's my sort of luck. I'd never get one about cancer. I'm so glad you spoke up because people go all snotty about it at the cancer board, saying who am I to deny them comfort- I'm just saying my opinion.

Oh and if your a winner if you "beat" cancer, does it make you a loser if you die? Sorry for ranting and so sorry for your loss xxx

Sharaluck · 09/02/2014 00:15

Well I am truely sorry if I offended anyone, but I can only speak from my experience and positive thinking is the only thing keeping me going, especially with the fact Im soon to be separated from my very young dc for treatment. It is rotten bad luck, but I hope to think I might have some sort of control over the situation.

ginzillas · 08/02/2014 23:56

Op, I totally agree with you. To hear 'such and such lost their battle' when you know just how brave they have been sounds so inappropriate and wrong.

And it also puts so much pressure on people going through hellish treatment. Why should they have to put up a positive front all the time? If they want to moan and admit they feel shitty, so they bloody well should.

Someone I loved very much recently died of cancer and she was very angry in her last weeks. Not a super human saint - a real person going through the hardest time of her life.

lisad123everybodydancenow · 08/02/2014 23:55

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.