Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate these kind of comments about surviving cancer?

291 replies

Sallystyle · 08/02/2014 09:57

I am pretty sure everyone by now is aware my ex husband died in December of cancer leaving three of our young children behind. I know I mention it a lot but it has been a devastating few months.

I think I have mentioned my dislike of these type of comments elsewhere as well.

I go onto FB and see a friends status about how she has been recovered from cancer for over 8 years now. That is fantastic, I have sent messages saying how happy I am for her etc but I take great offence at some of the comments which are on the lines of:

'Of course you fought it, you are strong'
'Cancer could never beat someone like you'
'Hold your head up, this just shows what an amazing strong person you are, cancer never had a chance'

So reading this hit me hard this morning and I have since hid the status in question but I am sitting here feeling really pissed off. This is not the first time I have read stuff like this.

I just want to shout and say cancer doesn't care if you are a strong person or not, dying from cancer doesn't make you any less stronger than the next person. I know no one means any offence but how hard is it to just say congratulations I am so happy for you or something?

Maybe I am just hurting and bitter but I so wanted to comment on it but I did the right thing and just hid it instead and then came straight here to vent.

So am I an unreasonable to hate these type of comments?

OP posts:
harticus · 10/02/2014 12:40

Manic - the positivity thing really worked for you and your Dad and your family ... and that is all that matters.

But one size never fits all especially when it comes to illness.

I absolutely love life and I shall do all I can that is scientifically proven to try to make sure I am here to raise my son.

If one day an extensive robust scientific study proves that "positivity" is effective against cancer then I can assure you I shall be bouncing around like Anthea fucking Turner on a space hopper.

LuckyBitches · 10/02/2014 11:47

YANBU

My brother has cancer, and he's not "fighting" anything. He doesn't have the energy. He's submitted himself to the treatment process, and that obviously feels right for him. He needs rest.

Sallystyle · 10/02/2014 11:42

My ex was determined to see Xmas day. His last wish was to see our children on Xmas day.

On the 10th Dec I was sitting with him while he told me he believed that the reason he was still alive was because he was determined to see Xmas day. He told me that he knew he was going to make it and then after that he would be ready to go. I kind of believed him.

That evening he became delusional, on the 13th Dec he died.

He never got his wish. His positivity didn't help after all.

OP posts:
MrsDeVere · 10/02/2014 11:27

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

firesidechat · 10/02/2014 10:24

Something I haven't said yet is that we are incredibly thankful that my husband is still here and relatively well. It has been a hard slog at times, but it could have been so much worse. We were lucky - it was caught early and he responds well to the treatment (not everybody does sadly).

Some of the posters on here have gone through such terrible sadness and I'm so sorry.

maillotjaune · 10/02/2014 09:59

Manic my DH was negative. Terrified, even, despite the type of cancer he was diagnosed with having a good prognosis when detected early (pretty shit if caught late).

He is clear 2 years later and this has nothing to do with positive thinking. Should I worry that his gloom makes recurrence more likely? He fears it, certainly, but that is normal isn't it?

expatinscotland · 10/02/2014 09:52

Any belief one has control over one's fate in such a situation is an illusion.

firesidechat · 10/02/2014 09:48

Manic I know you mean well, but I have to disagree with you.

My husband will probably be having cancer treatment for the rest of his life, but even if he did somehow "beat" cancer, he would hate, hate, hate to have anyone attribute this to any strength on his part. It will be because the treatments have improved and because of our health insurance and because of an excellent consultant who we have known for over 6 years now.

Do you think my husband relishes the prospect of being "positive" for the rest of his life, just so other people can feel better.

As it happens, we are quite positive people and we still enjoy all the good things in our life. That doesn't stop the tears and distress when we have to drive to the clinic in the middle of the night and endure painful, undignified procedures and the occasional emergency op. Sometimes the mere thought of any kind of fight is draining beyond belief. So we don't think like that and what's more it will have absolutely no impact on the final result.

MrsDeVere · 10/02/2014 09:31

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Sallystyle · 10/02/2014 08:12

Thanks again everyone.

I just want to point out again that he was my ex husband, father to three of my children.

I don't want anyone to read another post from me about my husband then think I am a faker or something Grin

OP posts:
bodygoingsouth · 10/02/2014 08:02

why talkat all. just be there to listen. just be there to cook,clean,drive, help in any way but mostly just listen.

TarteAuxRiz · 10/02/2014 07:46

I think most people are terrified of death because of its meaninglessness and so cast about for something, anything, to say to make it 'better'. People just don't know how to 'handle' the bereaved at all. There should be manuals for this situation. Actually I think just having someone there to listen to you talk and say very little, or hold your hand in silence is really valuable. I don't actually know anyone who can do this!!!

Stinkyminkymoo · 10/02/2014 07:41

I'm sorry to hear about your husband Hmm

YANBU, I lost my uncle, godfather and a dear friend to cancer within 14 months, DF & DGF on the same day in December.

I feel the same as you, none of them had a chance and went downhill very quickly and then suddenly died. I've always found it secretly insulting as I feel it insinuates they couldn't be bothered to fight it or weren't strong enough when I know this wasn't the case.

In fact I know only 1 person who has survived cancer Hmm

chocoluvva · 10/02/2014 01:23

That must be sickening expatinscotland. Losing a child is surely every parent's worst nightmare.

expatinscotland · 10/02/2014 01:16

"I know what you are going through because my nan died last year"; "I understand how you feel because my dog died recently" (I kid you not!).

Parents bereaved of a child get this, more often than you think. It's crushing. You do not expect your nan to live for another 70+ years. Losing a child is a LIFETIME of loss, of all the things Nan got to do, but they will never. They never get to BE a nan, or a parent, at all. And people think it's the same thing?

And your dog has a max lifespan of about 20 years, you know this when you get a dog. Dogs aren't expected to become adults, drive a car, get a job, have boyfriends or girlfriends, grow roses.

Also the, 'You can have another baby.' Sure, let me go pick up a replacement child at a supermarket.

Even Kevin Wells, whose daughter Holly was murdered, age 10, nearly 12 years ago, has been told, 'Isn't it time you moved on?'

To where? Where do you move? Never-fucking-never land?

Stuff mostly starts to roll off you because, as MrsDeVere points out, it's mostly said for the benefit of the speaker.

growingolddicustingly · 10/02/2014 00:57

ThanksSam

My husband died of cancer 4 years ago this New Year's Eve past. My real bugbear was the thoughtless comments I had from nurses (yes) and friends immediately afterwards. "I know what you are going through because my nan died last year"; "I understand how you feel because my dog died recently" (I kid you not!).

They had no fucking idea what I was going through. All my future, my hopes, dreams, plans died with my husband. I had to make a new future for myself and my DCs; new plans. I loved my nans but it wasn't the same when they died. I love my dogs but you have to be kidding me! I didn't scream in their stupid faces because what was the point - they were trying to be empathetic in their cack handed, non empathetic way. People can be very unthinking even when trying to come from a good place. God, I feel good getting that out of my system.

chocoluvva · 10/02/2014 00:37

That's what frustrates me the most: the number of late diagnoses as a result of GPs misdiagnosing.

And why the difference in waiting times between different types of cancer even when at an advanced stage?

expatinscotland · 10/02/2014 00:02

'surviving cancer is sheer luck, catching it early and good treatment.'

And, often enough, having a type that even has a decent treatment, or anyone at all. No one survives DIPG.

expatinscotland · 10/02/2014 00:00

'I am not brave I am terrified and I am not going to pretend otherwise so that the rest of society can feel less scared.'

TOO RIGHT. I'm curious, too, if 'positive thinking' helps, how does this apply to babies and young children who really don't even understand the entire concept?

My child's bone marrow was fundamentally flawed and produced immature white blood cells with two desperate mutations instead of healthy white blood cells. All the chemo in the world could not cure her of this.

We tried to be as positive as possible, NO ONE wants to see a baby or child with cancer.

She still fucking died.

She, and others like her, don't need more 'positive thinking' and trite phrases. Her doctors need money and funding to try to figure out what causes this and how to better treat it, because this decades old chemo and these stem cell transplants are crap ways of doing it, but all they have just now.

winterhat · 09/02/2014 23:56

cancer cells don't have magic little positivity receptors on them

That sums it up harticus, well said.

bodygoingsouth · 09/02/2014 23:50

you are right op. surviving cancer is sheer luck, catching it early and good treatment.

my lovely mil died of cancer and trust me she was a fighter who wanted to live.

so sorry for your loss. xxx

manicinsomniac · 09/02/2014 23:46

It doesn't stop cancer cells mutating. But (according to my Dad this is, I haven't had cancer myself) it keeps you calmer, more focused, keeps your mind active, allows you to have more meaningful moments with those you care about and take away the bitterness that just makes you want to scream and cry. My Dad believed that his mental approach gave him more days than another approach would have done. I don't know if he was right but it certainly wasn't my place to tell him he was wrong.

I asked him once if he was afraid. He said, 'no. What have I got to be afraid of?' I said (I was quite young and very immature for my age) 'dying. Isn't it scary? Does it hurt?' and he told me that he believed he would have all the time he needed to do everything he needed to do. And he did. After that he went quickly. Coincidence? I don't know. But it helps me to believe that he had that element of control over his own fate.

harticus · 09/02/2014 23:33

And I firmly believe that positive thinking helps

How? How does it help?
How does it stop cancer cells from mutating?

None of my personality attributes or flaws will impact on my outcome in any way shape or form because the cancer cells don't have magic little positivity receptors on them.
I despise this tyranny of positivity and the pressure it exerts on patients.

I am not brave I am terrified and I am not going to pretend otherwise so that the rest of society can feel less scared.

manicinsomniac · 09/02/2014 23:16

This is the kind of situation where facebook is a very unhelpful medium.

There is nothing wrong with saying things like 'what a fighter', 'you've beaten cancer', 'you're so strong', 'you never gave up' etc to the cancer survivor. They deserve those kind of encouragements and most cancer survivors I know appear to experience a kind of pride and sense of achievement in their success (I can't say for certain because they only people I've been close to who've had cancer have died).

Those comments however, are not aimed at the eyes of the loved ones of those who were not so lucky. They're not meant to make anyone else feel that a person who died did the opposite of those comments. Nobody (I hope!) would say to the family of someone who has died 'what a loser' 'they lost to cancer' 'they were so weak' 'they gave up' etc.

The positive encouragements don't have opposites. It's not a strong or weak, winner or loser kind of analogy and unfortunately social media means that people have to read comments aimed at survivors while thinking of their own tragic loss. Which sucks. But doesn't mean that the survivor doesn't deserve the comments (people should perhaps learn how to private message!!).

Here's a case in point. 2 days before my Dad died a relative of mine posted this on his facebook wall (this was before the days of statuses and messaging being used a lot):

'Hey Uncle X, hope today has been a little easier on you. I just want you to know that you're the strongest and most inspiring Godfather I could ever have wished for. You keep on fighting, Uncle X, the world (and me!) need you around one hell of a lot longer. Love and positive vibes, xx'

the day he died the same relative posted this:

'RIP to the strongest man I've ever known. You never stopped fighting. I'm so sorry, there are no words.' xx

Both of those messages are filled with the positive fight metaphors, even though my Dad had died by the time the second one was posted. The relative had no thoughts that my Dad had 'failed' or 'given up', he was still a strong fighter, even though he died.

All cancer sufferers are strong fighters imo, regardless of their outcome.

And I firmly believe that positive thinking helps.

waterlego6064 · 09/02/2014 22:22

I agree re Tarte's post- I was nodding enthusiastically while reading it. It's about people not wanting to accept that they don't have complete control over what happens to them.