Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate these kind of comments about surviving cancer?

291 replies

Sallystyle · 08/02/2014 09:57

I am pretty sure everyone by now is aware my ex husband died in December of cancer leaving three of our young children behind. I know I mention it a lot but it has been a devastating few months.

I think I have mentioned my dislike of these type of comments elsewhere as well.

I go onto FB and see a friends status about how she has been recovered from cancer for over 8 years now. That is fantastic, I have sent messages saying how happy I am for her etc but I take great offence at some of the comments which are on the lines of:

'Of course you fought it, you are strong'
'Cancer could never beat someone like you'
'Hold your head up, this just shows what an amazing strong person you are, cancer never had a chance'

So reading this hit me hard this morning and I have since hid the status in question but I am sitting here feeling really pissed off. This is not the first time I have read stuff like this.

I just want to shout and say cancer doesn't care if you are a strong person or not, dying from cancer doesn't make you any less stronger than the next person. I know no one means any offence but how hard is it to just say congratulations I am so happy for you or something?

Maybe I am just hurting and bitter but I so wanted to comment on it but I did the right thing and just hid it instead and then came straight here to vent.

So am I an unreasonable to hate these type of comments?

OP posts:
mrsjay · 08/02/2014 11:39

TBF on the people who say Survive cancer have usually seen it elsewhere normally from cancer charities they use words like you can fight it or survive, strong etc ,

Gimmesomemore · 08/02/2014 11:36

Yanbu, it's insensitive as well as being offensive to others that have lost loved ones.

lljkk · 08/02/2014 11:35

argh, I don't want to be unsupportive, but those FB comments aren't about cancer at all.

90% of what I read on MN & increasingly what I hear in RL I have to rephrase and then I realise the poster/speaker meant something quite different to what was literally written or said. This is a pain but I would take offence at everything ever uttered if I didn't.

Those aren't comments about what other people did or didn't do (whether they were strong or not). They're meant to encourage the survivor to keep their morale up. That's all they're about. So... yabu, sorry.

mrsjay · 08/02/2014 11:32

you are really not being unreasonable I never understand the survive word used about serious illness, I am so sorry for you and your childrens loss Flowers

Twunk · 08/02/2014 11:31

YANBU in that I agree with you. Ds2 has leukaemia and when people have said "he's strong he'll fight it" I did actually correct them - his "battle" is chemical, it's whether the little white blasts die in their billions in response to the drugs he's taking.

I take no credit that he's now in remission, save for getting him to the hospital when needed, caring for him and giving the medication as directed.

YABU in assuming anyone has really thought about it beyond that it is something people just say. It's almost a convention. It's a cliché. Clichés are lazy sometimes but people use them without thinking through the implications.

I wish you much love and kindness over the next few weeks, months and years. xxxx

Thetallesttower · 08/02/2014 11:28

You are so not being unreasonable.

Trice sorry about your situation, too.

As for why people say it, I know they don't know what to say, but exhorting another person to 'be strong' 'don't let it beat you' it just completely insensitive when they are facing such a nasty disease and possibly their own limited lifespan.

The research also shows it's bollocks- the last meta-review I read said that positive thinking was not associated with longer life after cancer diagnosis, although as the very sensitive poster who is in palliative care pointed out, it may help some people with what they have to cope with. But- you can't cure cancer through thinking positive, it's just so many magnitudes of more devastating than a few nice thoughts running through your brain.

EauRouge · 08/02/2014 11:21

Not comparable, but I had a traumatic birth with DD2 and I hate seeing comments about how positive thinking etc can help to have a pain-free birth. People want to feel like they're always in control and not at the mercy of nature. It's a scary thing knowing that you have no control in some situations and this is the way people cope.

It's shitty for you to read stuff like that and I'm sorry for your loss Thanks

crazykat · 08/02/2014 11:20

I hate those kind of comments too. I recently lost my mum to cancer and she fought so hard to stay with us for a year after the doctors told her she'd be lucky to have two months. It makes it seem like she wasn't strong enough to beat it which I know is total rubbish. She fought as long as she could but her spirit was stronger than her body and it wasn't to be.

I think people make these comments without really thinking about how you can be the strongest person in the world but cancer doesn't care.

DelGirl · 08/02/2014 11:19

I second John Diamonds book, when you're ready. He put into words things I know my dh was feeling but couldnt express and also validated my feelings as the one left behind

HesterShaw · 08/02/2014 11:16

I think Race for Life was guilty of it "Hey cancer, we're coming to get you" etc. As if cancer "cares".

littlemisssarcastic · 08/02/2014 11:12

YANBU OP. Statuses on Facebook such as those you describe seem to suggest that an individual can survive a disease based on something they do. I do not believe this at all.
Cancer kills athletes, Cancer kills the most stubborn of people and the people with the strongest reasons to live. There is quite often nothing more those people could have done to change the outcome.
There are also people with cancer who are not athletes, are not strong minded and who feel they do not have as much as other people to live for, possibly because they are also depressed, yet they survive.

It is not a choice to die from cancer.
Those statuses almost suggest it is.
They are wrong.

chocoluvva · 08/02/2014 11:09
Thanks

I completely get how you feel and agree with you 100%.

(When I was having treatment for cancer I used to be annoyed at all the magazines in hospital with articles about women battling breast cancer cheerfully - it's usually breast cancer - and going in to their work during chemo even though they were very poorly. It felt like bragging to me.)

I would have died if my diagnosis had come a few months later - there is so much luck/bad luck involved.

waterlego6064 · 08/02/2014 11:08

YANBU to find it upsetting OP. I'm very sorry that you and your children have lost someone so important to you all.

Birdsgotta Is right that people just grasp for something to say- and these sort of comments are what they know, what they've learnt. As PPs have said, some of the cancer charities use this sort of language in their advertising and so it becomes part of the collective public dialogue around cancer. I think I may have used such language myself in the past, before my family was personally affected by cancer.

My dad had 4 weeks from his diagnosis to death, and by the time he was diagnosed, he was cognitively impaired (multiple brain tumours) and unable to understand that he was ill and so there was no way he could have 'fought' it. (A brain full of tiny tumours can't be treated anyway).

My mum, despite being a tiny little person, really did attempt to fight her illness. She remained relentlessly positive and brave in the face of it. If there were medals for cheerful cancer patients, she should have got one. But the bastard disease killed her anyway. Any suggestion that she 'lost' her fight makes me feel profoundly angry. She tried very bloody hard to not be ill. It was mum's second cancer, the first one having been treated successfully. Of course this gave people the green light to say 'well, she's beaten it once before, hasn't she? She'll beat this one too!' All very well-meant but unfortunately misguided. This was a completely different cancer, in a different part of the body and she was 20 years older than she'd been with the first one. Totally different set of circumstances.

Sending best wishes to all on this thread affected by cancer- those who are living with it, and those who have been bereaved by it.

hackmum · 08/02/2014 11:08

OP, YANBU and I am so sorry for your loss.

My mother died young from cancer. It wasn't because she wasn't brave or strong, it was because it was diagnosed late and the doctors weren't able to cure it.

People don't seem to talk in these terms about other diseases like pneumonia or Parkinson's or malaria or heart disease, or any of the other range of things that could get you. Surviving cancer is absolutely nothing at all to do with the character of the individual (how could it be?) and everything to do with what kind of cancer it is, how early it's discovered and what kind of medical treatment you have access to.

OP, have you ever read John Diamond's book about his cancer, C? He has a lot of contempt for this "battle" idea. I don't know if it would help to read it (perhaps it's still too raw) but you'd know that you're not the only person to feel this way.

Pagwatch · 08/02/2014 11:06

It's so difficult.
Because people think they are being supportive. It's come from those wanky true life inspirational films and magazine stories. I think people say it as a reflex -as if its shorthand for 'i support you'

It pissed my dad off. My sister kept saying 'that's it. You have to keep fighting. You have to beat this'
One day he said to her 'I'm not fighting. I'm just being treated and trying to be positive. All you are doing is making me feel that if I die, if this thing kills me, I will have let you all down'

I'm sorry for your loss. I lost my dad and then my sister. Cancer sucks.

DelGirl · 08/02/2014 11:05

Yadnbu, I dont like seeing or hearing comments like that either. When dh was having chemo people were, I know trying to be helpful, saying be positive and telling him to eat this, not eat that and it cured so and so. He knew it wadnt going to end well and needed the energy to concentrate on himself and not be made to feel he was somehow failing if he didn't do this that and the other. Like I say I know its with the best of intentions but thought I'd mention it as you never know who's reading and who it might help.

manicinsomniac · 08/02/2014 11:04

While I totally understand why people who view things the way the OP do feel that way it's quite hurtful to say that the comments are 'ridiculous' and 'thoughtless'. They aren't. They are coping mechanisms just like acceptance, denial, very open grieving, emotional closing off, jokes and any other number of strategies that are possibly upsetting to others in similar situations.

Cancer sufferers and their friends and families just do the best they can to deal with their situation. And it's unfair to suggest that is wrong in some way.

pigletmania · 08/02/2014 11:03

I noticed a lot of comments criticising how those with cancer approach their illness, it's up to them if they want to 'fight' it or they see it as a battle, nobody has a right to cast judgement, it is up to the individual. But in reaction to the op, those comments relating to her status were thoughtless. Btw I lost my dad when I was 11 to cancer and my Gran

HesterShaw · 08/02/2014 11:01

YANBU.

Cancer isn't a conscious entity which takes notice of what kind of person you are. Your friend has been lucky. You and your family have been unlucky.

I'm so sorry xxx

Birdsgottafly · 08/02/2014 10:59

"" she was following medical advice and doing her best with a very very shitty situation.""

But some people don't.

They carry on drinking/smoking being Cunts. During my FIL stay in a Marie Curie Hospice, he ended up telling a man in the bed opposite to stop speaking to the staff like shit.

One of the mans visitors actually said to my FIL "he never been particularly nice, this has just exasperated his nasty side".

Doing everything that you can is part of a "fight" in a way.

It depends on your type of Cancer and when it was diagnosed, as well, of course.

I watched people drink themselves to death, as well as die through drugs, in my personal life, as well as work.

Whilst nearly all deaths are equal personal tragedies, there is difference in reality.

magimedi · 08/02/2014 10:58

YANBU at all.

I talk to his widow a few times every day as she still has the children often and we are very good friends. We really were like one big family but I also have some guilt because towards the end of our marriage I did some things I am not proud of.

That is wonderful for you & your children & I hope that you can put your guilt away & be able to hold onto such strong relationships.

Flowers for you, his widow & your children.

pigletmania · 08/02/2014 10:57

Yanbu at all how thoughtless. They were very lucky, cancer can get anyone no matter how hard they fight!

He11y · 08/02/2014 10:55

I haven't been in this situation and don't say such things myself but I've definitely heard them so I know what you mean and, tbh, I've never thought of it from this angle.

I know it's upsetting, but could you reply to the thread on FB and say you feel upset by it?

I say that as I'm pretty sure most people don't have a clue and I'd feel awful if one of my FB friends was feeling as you do now.

I'll definitely think more now I've seen this.

midnightagents · 08/02/2014 10:54

Yanbu. Those comments are ridiculous. There's a lot of telling people how they ought to behave, or how things ought to work out in the face of disaster. Truth is everyone and everything is different so, (much as we like to) we can't categorise and explain life so simplisticly. Really sorry for your loss..
The intent of the posts was probably to big up the person they were talking to, but it doesn't make it any less untrue and perhaps insensitive.

Amethyst24 · 08/02/2014 10:53

I hate the anthropomorphisation of cancer. It's a disease, ffs. People don't go around saying, "I beat the common cold!"

NBU.