Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

faking reduced movement.

138 replies

Onsiequeen · 03/02/2014 23:20

am I alone in thinking its not right to fake reduced movement, so the hospital induces you? ive noticed a few people saying it but ive never even considered it. It seems really selfish.

OP posts:
WeAreEternal · 04/02/2014 09:52

I know someone (my cousins DW) who has done this with all three of her pregnancies.
She has also lied about bleeding and pain to get extra scans, she had seven scans in her last pregnancy all on the NHS.

she is an incredibly entitled person and seems to genuinely believe that it is acceptable behaviour.

Surprisingly I don't like her very much.

sashh · 04/02/2014 09:50

You would be amazed at what people will attempt.

Lung function tests - no just holding your breath will not make it look like you have lung damage.

ECGs - no wiggling the wires will just create an artifact not make it look like a heart attack

Ambulances - just because you don't want to pay your taxi fare home don't phone for an ambulance because you live near the hospital (OK that's one I don't have first hand knowledge of, but it was a reliable source, the third time the took him to a hospital miles away).

Waiting in A and E for 2 hours, suddenly developing chest pain to be seen sooner.

I've also heard the one about smoking, the, 'well she was 10Lbs, if I hadn't smoked she would have been huge, better that I smoked'.

formerbabe · 04/02/2014 09:47

So sorry for your loss lambsie....

I don't think lying to a doctor is ever a good idea. How can they administer correct treatment when its based on lies. It is selfish and a waste of NHS resources.

BumPotato · 04/02/2014 09:41

So sorry Lambsie. Your post reinforces my opinion that those who try it on are disgusting.

Lambsie · 04/02/2014 09:38

I had reduced movements. The hospital after monitoring me said baby was fine. He was stillborn (and half the weight he should have been) a week later. On my next pregnancy I insisted on a planned section at 37 weeks although I ended up having him at 35 weeks as an emergency section.

BumPotato · 04/02/2014 09:35

I went 2 weeks over due date with both my two, so I understand fully the frustration of STILL being pregnant. The people who fake reduced movements are selfish and ignorant.

First time round I was taken straight upstairs for monitoring at 32 weeks when I'd mentioned I hadn't felt the baby moving that day. It was about 11 am and usually she started stirring about 9am (after my morning tea). The minute the monitor straps went round my belly she started kicking furiously and I had to stay there for an hour, very embarrassed. I'd hate to think the staff there thought I was trying it on.

MTBMummy · 04/02/2014 09:34

I'm 34 weeks and also at that fed up stage, I must admit when I get to 38 weeks, I will start looking at raspberry leaf tea, pineapple, hot curries etc, but I tried them all with DD and she still had to be forcibly evicted at 42+1 so I'm not sure I can be arsed.

Besides I'm still working and the last thing I want is to go into labour in the next 3 weeks because it'll probably be in the office or on the train!

I am shocked that people will make up stories to get attention, which could be crucial to someone else

lilyaldrin · 04/02/2014 09:30

How bizarre! Can't think of anything worse than being induced, especially early.

ipswichwitch · 04/02/2014 09:28

Te monitor actually does pick up the baby's movements - the button pressing is to correlate what you feel with what baby's doing. The spiky lines on the printout are baby's movements.

CuntyBunty · 04/02/2014 09:27

Pity those poor children born to such short sighted, selfish people. Human life it seems, is a commodity Sad, something to fit in around an agenda.

MinesAPintOfTea · 04/02/2014 09:26

I'm puzzled: surely the fb woman was just waiting to see a consultant because they make the call? Not that she would have got one if she hadn't seen the consultant.

I went into hospital with reduced movements: it got me half a night on a trolley attached to the monitor then most of the next day on another trolley waiting for a doctor to come and see me (as my hospital routinely scan for reduced movements and it showed up a minor issue). It was another 10 days before I was actually induced at 40+12.

Laststop · 04/02/2014 09:25

I know someone who done this and was induced even after monitors showing otherwise Confused

VodkaJelly · 04/02/2014 09:17

I was induced with DC3, he was 15 days late and showed no signs of moving from where he was.

It wasnt that bad, it was my shortest labour and the easiest birth. Having the drip and my waters burst wasnt nice but I didnt think it was that bad.

But again, why would you want to be induced? Leave the baby to cook unless they go too far over.

Mmmbacon · 04/02/2014 09:15

Appologies typos on phone

Mmmbacon · 04/02/2014 09:14

Not similar at all but ds kept putting me in pre labour twice we drove down with me in horendous pain, only to be examined find out I was 1cm dilated and for it to all stop, brankston hicks was mentioned, I was asked.was I anxious, was everything alright at home, them sent in my merry way,

Third time I was still 2 weeks early, went down, this time waters broke and I got to 8cm before it stalled again 2 hours to get to 8cm and them no pains at all for.over 2 hours, doctor was called, wanted to induce me at 8cm, I was having none of it and started bouncing on my birthing ball again, I was high from adrenalin and kept telling them, see I told you, this us what was happening all the other times I was on labour.and no one believed me, and look its stopped again, midwife was lovely, and we agreed on a sweep to see if it would get things moving as we were no where near worrying about getting baby out now,

We had lots of little complications with ds along the way, I was on bed rest very early on for a few weeks, query ectopic so had scans before there was a heartbeat, spotting during, vomitting big that left me dehydrated in hospital on drip that they could barely get a vain for,

Hospitals need bed for people who genuinely need it, either for medical or genuine anxious reasons, to get induced v early is just selfish,

Confuddledmuchly · 04/02/2014 09:13

Well this is one of the more selfish things I have ever heard.

Selfish and really ignorant.

Induction is really not a good way to go if you can avoid it. High intervention and complication rate. Idiots.

Unimaginativecow · 04/02/2014 09:01

I was 12 days overdue with DS2 and was booked for an induction (he came the day before scheduled date) but I was dreading it. I can't comprehend why people would do it when its not needed! Reading this thread with horror!

Homebirthquestion · 04/02/2014 08:56

Gah.

Every time you feel a movement and the machine picks up heart rate and Braxton hicks/ contractions. So if you wanted to fake movement you'd just not press the button.

Homebirthquestion · 04/02/2014 08:55

I'd never have thought of people faking it.

I have a thread on here from three weeks ago about reduced movements from when I was in hospital. The rule was that once at term, two sets of reduced movements would mean an automatic induction recommendation once at term.

When you're monitored it's you who presses a button every time t

Seff · 04/02/2014 08:43

Quite surprised at this, seems like they are more bothered about themselves than their baby.

I'm 35 weeks, and starting to get to that fed up stage that my mind had conveniently forgotten about but to take resources away from those that really need it is pretty disgusting.

People lose babies at full term, what if they couldn't get seen because someone was faking it?

IdaClair · 04/02/2014 00:13

It is a thing. Same as the people drinking who know what and having spicy carries and bouncy sex and saying all they want is their baby out at about 36 weeks because its 'term' don't you know.

Elective induction is totally routine in the us. Just schedule it.

I can't imagine anything worse. I've been the person in the monitoring bay with the pads being applied looking for a heart beat and hearing only the gentle whooshwhoosh of my blood flow as the monitors in the bays around me buh-bum around me. Let me tell you that's not a fun place to be.

perfectstorm · 04/02/2014 00:07

I had to be monitored for movement a lot in my first pregnancy because the placenta lay right over the front of my womb, like a cushion, so I didn't feel a lot. Monitoring shows whether the baby is okay or not quite easily, which was brilliant in my situation as it reassured so much - so how would this work?

And God, it's on my birth plan that I won't be induced: I would prefer a planned section, because the pain and intervention levels of inductions are so high. Of 5 women I know who were induced 4 had crash sections and 1 a ventouse delivery, which I appreciate is purely anecdotal but erm, I don't care? The idea of wanting to be induced... they must not realise the implications!

HaroldLloyd · 04/02/2014 00:02

I have suspected several drama llamas of faking bleeding I have spoken too, to get an early scan.

But it's not something you can come out with.

That's awful too, if you do want an early scan you can pay for them and don't waste resources and cause delay for people who are genuinely going through that.

I can believe there are people that fake reduced movements.

Onsiequeen · 04/02/2014 00:01

@bobafetacheese. The same group are also suggesting castor oil, raspberry leaf tea and 3pints of orange juice. Surely you'll only be birthing 1 thing with all that and that ain't a baby.

OP posts:
TheXxed · 03/02/2014 23:58

I had pain in my side early on in my pregnancy. My GP referred me to the EPU at kings college, I went on Tuesday full, Wednesday full and finally got an appointment on Thursday.

The idea that people faked bleeds pisses me right off.