Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

to think older teens should be made to watch what an abortion is in PHSE. (sorry possibly triggering)

546 replies

StraightLineOfResignation · 13/01/2014 17:19

I know this may be controversial but I have thought this for some time.
Abortion is legal in this country but still straight forward , informative talks about it are clouded by morality and judgement and at the end of the day, sometimes people need to have one in tragic circumstances i.e people who are made critically ill by pregnancy.
And are often as well as already scared and sad, i don't think most people make this decision lightly, are woefully underprepared which i'm sure must only add to emotional trauma.
and of course there are too many potential uninterested fathers who just utter 'get rid of it' at the hearing of potentially being a father, so disgustingly flippantly like throwing a crisp packet in the bin, I do think if they especially had seen a medical video of the procedure, well i think the number of people who just thrown that term around would be significantly less, if they had actually seen that image with their own eyes , and would be less detached from the idea and process.
I'm talking older teens , like 16+ here , not 11 year olds.
my mum and i have always though this, i would find it traumatising and pretty shocking, but compared to people who feel shame, go backstreet putting themselves at risk and people who go through with pregnancies they did not want/need. Surely a bit of discomfort is better then that being a legacy of another generation.

OP posts:
Maireas · 02/11/2021 17:00

@MoominIsGoingToBeAMumWaitWHAT

YANBU. All the options should be shown to them - including keeping the baby.

At the minute, sex education is pretty much non-existant in many rural areas, and lacking even in more populated areas. The extent of my sex education was "Don't have sex. If you do, boys should wear a condom". Literally, that was it. Nothing of the consequences, nothing of the options should it happen. (This is going to be my dissertation topic so I'm a bit militant about it Grin ) My brother and sister haven't even had any sex education whatsoever - they're 14 and 12.

They need to be taught the practical and emotional consequences of pregnancy and abortion and relinquishing a baby for adoption, as well as the support available in each instance, and more in-depth about the different types of contraception. It's all well and good saying "Don't do it", but if you leave it at that, once they've gone and done it anyway, they're screwed. Same goes for STIs, they need to know that they can be tested and treated confidentially and without judgement.

I think also what might help would be to have young women who have had babies, and others who have had abortions, as well as young fathers and young men who've supported their partner through an abortion, to talk about the realities, rather than a middle-aged school nurse reading it off a whiteboard.

What's wrong with a "middle aged" nurse? Surely they'd be aware of the realities? Nursing is a very hands on job, right?
Ozanj · 02/11/2021 16:53

@StraightLineOfResignation

I know this may be controversial but I have thought this for some time. Abortion is legal in this country but still straight forward , informative talks about it are clouded by morality and judgement and at the end of the day, sometimes people need to have one in tragic circumstances i.e people who are made critically ill by pregnancy. And are often as well as already scared and sad, i don't think most people make this decision lightly, are woefully underprepared which i'm sure must only add to emotional trauma. and of course there are too many potential uninterested fathers who just utter 'get rid of it' at the hearing of potentially being a father, so disgustingly flippantly like throwing a crisp packet in the bin, I do think if they especially had seen a medical video of the procedure, well i think the number of people who just thrown that term around would be significantly less, if they had actually seen that image with their own eyes , and would be less detached from the idea and process. I'm talking older teens , like 16+ here , not 11 year olds. my mum and i have always though this, i would find it traumatising and pretty shocking, but compared to people who feel shame, go backstreet putting themselves at risk and people who go through with pregnancies they did not want/need. Surely a bit of discomfort is better then that being a legacy of another generation.
Most abortions happen before 14 weeks so it’ll be a heavy period.
EishetChayil · 02/11/2021 16:52

Also, lets not forget that when a baby dies (of natural causes) in-utero, the woman is made to give birth naturally. In what world is that ok and why isn't a quick c-section done?

Because it helps the healing process to give birth vaginally, and doesn't leave a scar that could be an upsetting reminder. Most doctors and psychiatrists recommend vaginal delivery for stillbirths.

ColinTheKoala · 02/11/2021 16:50

AAAAGGGHHH.

Sorry for posting on the zombie thread.

ColinTheKoala · 02/11/2021 16:49

@Justforlaughs

I agree OP, and have thought so for a long time. Too many teenagers (and adults) believe that a quick pill is all it takes - regardless of how far gone the pregnancy is.
No they don't. And very few women have an abortion without giving it due thought.

The vast majority of women do not use it as a form of contraception.

Also, lets not forget that when a baby dies (of natural causes) in-utero, the woman is made to give birth naturally. In what world is that ok and why isn't a quick c-section done?

Brefugee · 02/11/2021 16:42

No.

anon12345678901 · 02/11/2021 16:40

Although a zombie thread, I had an abortion at 18, even if I'd seen a video I wouldn't have been put off. It's one of the best decisions I have made.

caketiger · 02/11/2021 16:37

I think that you want to put people off and are trying to dress it up as informing people....

blubberyboo · 02/11/2021 15:44

Sounds like it would be used by teenage boys to pressure girlfriends into keeping babies that they end up walking away from 6 months after birth

PrincessNutella · 02/11/2021 14:15

You know what you should show? A young woman going to university and getting her degree, instead of being a a 20 year old with 3 kids living at home with her 35 year old single mother in a crowded council flat and her little sister who, at 16, has a couple of kids of her own.

x2boys · 02/11/2021 13:52

After eight years hopefully the Op has had a rethink ,Zombie thread !

Allsorts1 · 02/11/2021 13:47

Probably better to give good sex education on contraceptive methods and the morning after pill don’t you think? Hmm

TeaBooksCrumpets · 02/11/2021 13:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

TeaBooksCrumpets · 02/11/2021 13:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

KateSMumsnet · 14/01/2014 14:53

Hello everyone,

Thank you to everyone who reported this thread to us. Can we please remind you of our guidelines www.mumsnet.com/info/netiquette.

WhosLookingAfterCourtney · 14/01/2014 13:02

Well said ThatIsAll

Judgement and shaming is never helpful.

Oh, and ... yabu, but you know that. Take it easy OP.

poorincashrichinlove · 14/01/2014 12:30

Time to lay of OP now MNers.
She expressed a poorly thought out argument (that most disagree with), born out of an abusive history and dysfunctional thinking. OP is clearly in need of some love and support here.
OP, I'm sorry for what you went through at the hands of your parents. I wish you peace and hope you have support in RL
Thanks

BettyBoo246 · 14/01/2014 11:44

Agree linerunner
No wonder she views it as a 'dark' subject

LineRunner · 14/01/2014 11:31

brought up, that should be ^

LineRunner · 14/01/2014 11:31

I'm beginning to wonder if the OP, brought by abusive parents and influenced by their views, wasn't try to argue that teenagers should be made to be scared of having sex. And thus not risk pregnancy and its awful (for her) consequences.

Maybe.

Who knows. Sad, though.

BettyBoo246 · 14/01/2014 11:11

Op you said in your op that both you and your mum think enforcing shock tactics on teenagers is a good idea -
And yet your mum beat you when you was pregnant which made you miscarry???????

Thatisall · 14/01/2014 10:57

madis my daughter is 11 I am 29. I was a teenage mum.

Your last post is possibly the most personally offensive thing I have ever read. You deserve more expletives then MNHQ would let me get away with for that. I worked 2 jobs to support my child while her father continued his studies. He is now a fairly high ranking officer in the RAF and I am successful in my career.

Now the important part. My daughter is happy, well balanced and loved. She is top of her class. I've done a marvellous job frankly.

When she asks about my teen pregnancy I tell her that while I might have got pregnant 'by accident' I have birth on purpose. She was born because I chose to be a mother. It was not some teenage whim. How dare you, how fucking dare you.

MoominIsGoingToBeAMumWaitWHAT · 14/01/2014 10:27

Going from one stereotype - of all abortions being "the easy choice" or whatever the OP was trying to suggest - to another, of people who choose to keep the baby being 'disgustingly flippant', is just as unhelpful. Just as people who've had abortions would read this thread and feel hurt by what the OP is saying, young parents and young parents-to-be are reading this thread too and those stereotypes aren't a nice thing to read when your confidence in your abilities is already at rock bottom.

HesterShaw · 14/01/2014 09:48

How was anyone supposed to know about unwanted pregnancy and abuse if you didn't mention it until this page?

The point is, that people disagree that your plan would have any effect whatsoever. And most people think the availability of abortions in this country is a good thing. Why should there be any more unwanted babies condemned to a miserable childhood? There are people entirely unsuited to parenthood conceiving all over the place. This does not mean they will always be unsuited to parenthood, but neither does it mean they magically and automatically become good parents the second they give birth. Similarly, there are women and men who have their families already, and have no desire for more.

People disagree with you OP. This does not make them nasty.

IWillOnlyEatBeans · 14/01/2014 09:46

We were shown a video of a surgical abortion being carried out as part of PSE. It was the most horrific thing I have ever seen. Lots of people cried. Some were sick.

In my class quite a few went on to have abortions. Probably all the video did was make a stressful decision and experience even more so.

YABU