Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

to think older teens should be made to watch what an abortion is in PHSE. (sorry possibly triggering)

546 replies

StraightLineOfResignation · 13/01/2014 17:19

I know this may be controversial but I have thought this for some time.
Abortion is legal in this country but still straight forward , informative talks about it are clouded by morality and judgement and at the end of the day, sometimes people need to have one in tragic circumstances i.e people who are made critically ill by pregnancy.
And are often as well as already scared and sad, i don't think most people make this decision lightly, are woefully underprepared which i'm sure must only add to emotional trauma.
and of course there are too many potential uninterested fathers who just utter 'get rid of it' at the hearing of potentially being a father, so disgustingly flippantly like throwing a crisp packet in the bin, I do think if they especially had seen a medical video of the procedure, well i think the number of people who just thrown that term around would be significantly less, if they had actually seen that image with their own eyes , and would be less detached from the idea and process.
I'm talking older teens , like 16+ here , not 11 year olds.
my mum and i have always though this, i would find it traumatising and pretty shocking, but compared to people who feel shame, go backstreet putting themselves at risk and people who go through with pregnancies they did not want/need. Surely a bit of discomfort is better then that being a legacy of another generation.

OP posts:
Wallison · 13/01/2014 19:20

Whereas everyone who hasn't seen that programme merrily has one abortion after another with a sense of blithe glee.

Hmm
NunsArePeopleTooDougal · 13/01/2014 19:20

We watched a video of an abortion at 8 weeks in my R.S. class in sixth form a few years ago. As far as I can remember it didn't change anyone's mind about abortion, we were all still pro-choice coming out of that lesson. In fact, many of us were amazed at just how simple an early abortion is, even a non-pill one. We were not disgusted and if it had been done to try to convert us it would have failed miserably.

KittensoftPuppydog · 13/01/2014 19:18

Why is putting women off having abortions necessarily seen as a good thing?

LineRunner · 13/01/2014 19:16

Now, now DadonIce, no need for swearing.

longjane · 13/01/2014 19:15

There was a programe on the bbc when teenager call some like "doctors in training".

It followed people becoming doctors .

On they show 2 abortions an early one and late one.

It put off abortions for myself for life .

LineRunner · 13/01/2014 19:15

rainydarkskies, that also describes my experience. Thank you for articulating that so well.

FortyDoorsToNowhere · 13/01/2014 19:14

I am 28. I know about abortions and how they are carried out. I wouldn't want to see a video of an abortion.

In fact I think showing the video would put a lot of women having one.

KittensoftPuppydog · 13/01/2014 19:14

Btw, it doesn't have to be a traumatising experience.

KittensoftPuppydog · 13/01/2014 19:13

For gawds sake. What the hell business is it of yours?
Just want to make girls feel good and guilty, do you?

DadOnIce · 13/01/2014 19:12

I must admit I don't read the OP as necessarily being religious. She obviously has her views and has put them and most of us have disagreed with her.

If she wants the thread deleted, she's allowed - it's not "tough shit".

rainydarkskies · 13/01/2014 19:11

No, not at all Writer - so sorry to hear yours was in awful circumstances. Mine was too, but I think I feel sad and traumatised by the circumstances, not the procedure - does this describe you? Flowers

I think I just picked up on it as I felt so relieved and light and free after mine. I had been so ill in early pregnancy and being released from that and free to restart my life felt like being reborn. I became myself again after that, laughing, socialising, happy. And I felt guilty about it, because I felt like I should be sat in a room crying :) But I've come to realise most women feel largely as I did.

Huge hugs x

Writerwannabe83 · 13/01/2014 19:09

rainy - I have had a termination myself (I would have thought my post would have come across that way but obviously not Smile) and it was in generally shitty circumstances. It was 14 years ago now and I'm still waiting for the upset to pass... Sad At the time I never felt so low and I dread to think what watching a graphic video would have done to my state of mind.

btw - in case it doesn't come across, I am very pro-choice. I didn't mean to imply in my post that women should feel guilty about their choice if they do terminate so I apologise if I accidentally offended anyone.

bordellosboheme · 13/01/2014 19:07

Sorry I think this is a really stupid post op. are you catholic or something?

bordellosboheme · 13/01/2014 19:06

Traumatising the youth. A very bad idea.

echt · 13/01/2014 19:05

It's not often an AIBU gets such a resounding Y.

rainydarkskies · 13/01/2014 19:04

I have to be honest - I read the OP as more naïve and not fully understanding why most women have abortions, than horrible/nasty.

Writer - most of us don't find the termination affects their life forever and to be honest it's that sort of propaganda that is hard as women fee guilty for not feeling guilty, if that makes sense.

It is fine to have an abortion. Sentence ends there, no 'but' or 'because' or 'if'. The only person who can decide if it's right or not, is you - if you feel abortions are wrong, you don't have to have one. But if you DO want one, you can have one and you don't "have" to feel anything at all.

SaggyOldClothCatPuss · 13/01/2014 19:02

Maybe your agenda is to allow abortion but to make women feel as guilty as absolutely possible about it?

LineRunner · 13/01/2014 19:01

The OP wants the thread deleted.

Tough.

Writerwannabe83 · 13/01/2014 19:00

What a horrible, horrible thread. I read the OP and was just aghast.

For most women choosing to have a termination is a very difficult and emotional choice and one that affects their life forever.

And you think making them feel even worse by showing them such videos is a good idea??

Why exactly?

Your whole OP just screams of judgement on your part and that women should be shamed into having babies they don't want or can't have.

What about women who choose abortion for medical reasons? Do they need to sit through such films to be guilt tripped and made to feel like shit too? Or is termination 'allowed' in those circumstances?

SaggyOldClothCatPuss · 13/01/2014 18:59

Yes. and an explanation from a doctor should be enough. Being made to watch in graphic detail is too much.

Alisvolatpropiis · 13/01/2014 18:55

I really doubt that many women don't know what the procedures depending on what stage of pregnancy the woman is at, will not know what it entails. Doctors are generally inclined to explaining medical procedures...

lilyaldrin · 13/01/2014 18:54

rainy - as I understand it the nervous system and brain connections aren't developed enough until 24-26 weeks for a foetus to feel "pain", however it is still debatable at that point whether they have to consciousness to experience nerve stimulation as pain.

TwattyBojangles · 13/01/2014 18:54

This is a horrible and inconsiderate thread. Unfortunately, no matter how many videos you could have seen, sometimes shit happens, and you have an abortion.

How does knowing EXACTLY what happens help anyone, ever?!

NorthernLurker · 13/01/2014 18:54

' By their words so shall you know them..'

And your words OP? 'well thats not a good enough reason ' - in a nutshell that's your pov isn't it? That a good enough reason must given for TOP? This thread is anti-abortion bullshit from you isn't it? I have reported it and I hope it will be removed.

BOFtastic · 13/01/2014 18:52

It's a medically inaccurate piece of Catholic propaganda showing a late-term abortion which is very unrepresentative of the vast majority of terminations, rainy. It is designed to be as emotive as possible, and to be shown to young teenage girls in an attempt to hammer home a religious anti-choice message, cloaked in the guise of relevant sex education in some schools.

Much like what the OP seems to be suggesting, really.