Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to want to close my bank account after this gross invasion of privacy?

369 replies

somanymiles · 02/01/2014 11:49

I went to get cash out of my bank account this morning to pay the builders (£6,000) and was told I could not take that amount out without hard copy proof of what I was spending the money on eg an invoice. I was given no notice of this so of course did not have anything except a quote on my phone which they did not accept, even though I offered to email it to them. This was not a question of confirming my identity- it was that they have a new policy where you gave to prove what you are spending your cash on. When I asked what the threshold was for the new policy I was told they were not allowed to tell me. I am furious. Surely what I spend my money on us nobodies business but mine. It certainly isn't HSBC's business.I am thinking of closing my accounts there with all the hassle that will entail. AIBU?

OP posts:
CaptainTripps · 02/01/2014 19:18

Hmmm - just because the government has decided that cashiers in banks can be added to the list of those who may intrude on our private lives without good reason, does not make it right. If I choose to withdraw £2,000 from my bank it is not the business of the cashier why I want it (regardless of the exasperation seen above from those in the banking industry). In my opinion, the quote above does not justify intruding on my right to a private life.

Yes! This! Sarine you are spot on. This insidious invasion into our personal lives is way overstepping a mark. I personally feel we are on a slippery slope. Joking a bit, Russell Brand said that we need a revolution. We bloody need something. How dare they. Way too much governmental interference.

Sarine's post was followed by a post by fishfingers From the tone of your original post, perhaps the reason they asked for further proof in the form of an invoice was because you were acting defensively bla bla.
Wtaf?? Just bend backwards over a bit more, fish. Let them walk all over you. That's right. A bit more...yep that's right. Now let them walk all over you. Nice and easy. Yep that's it.

Binnky · 02/01/2014 18:24

Loving the superfluous reference to "Coutts"

handcream · 02/01/2014 18:23

I am wondering too...Are you paying in cash to avoid VAT. That I suspect is what the bank are looking at. I wouldnt mind tbh a bank questioning why for example my 80 year old DM was taking out a lot of cash. In fact she did it a few years ago fo some 'builders' who said it would be easier for her to pay them in cash. She then tried to draw out the same sort of amount as you.

The bank was nervous and she called me. I told the builders to provide a proper invoice for the amount. After some mucking around they did. I also told them as they had quoted £5k that was what the invoice would say. They didnt do a bad job tbh so all OK.

larrygrylls · 02/01/2014 18:20

A deposit has always effectively been a rolling overnight loan, callable on demand. The bail in is all about allowing other capital holders ( equity, loans etc) to take a hit before governments bailed a bank out. In last resort, depositors over euro 100k would lose their deposits.

WantToShop · 02/01/2014 18:16

(Rules out First Direct sorry!)

WantToShop · 02/01/2014 18:15

Anyway wrt to "it's my cash and I want it now" - wasn't it last year that there was a new rule passed that means when you give your cash to the bank it's not "yours", but instead you agree to "loan" it to the bank - hence beware bail-ins etc.

snowed · 02/01/2014 18:15

YANBU. Who wants to leave their money with Nanny Bank? Go elsewhere.

WantToShop · 02/01/2014 18:14

Thanks Quangle, I guess that rules out HSBC too?

Quangle · 02/01/2014 18:12

Wanttoshop I would genuinely advise against HSBC then. They are basically rebuilding themselves after their ML fiascos and are tougher than almost anyone these days. They've just fired a whole load of their customers from one of their banking divisions because it was deemed too much risk to have a concentration of these kinds of (legitimate ) customers.

MrsAMerrick · 02/01/2014 18:10

We had a situation recently where an endowment policy matured and was paid into our bank account, dh made immediate arrangements to transfer the money to our Building society account to pay off part of the mortgage. I was then phoned at work by our bank's fraud department and asked if I was aware that several thousand pounds was being removed form our joint back account, and was I happy for the transaction to go ahead. I had no problem with being contacted - the bank was presumably just checking that i was aware, that I wasn't being robbed blind by dh and that it was above board. I think it's responsible of the banks to check on this.

TBH, whilst I appreciate that the OP is annoyed by what she perceives to be intrusive questioning, if this incident and subsequent MN response has made her think about why her builders might be wanting £6k in cash, then I for one think it's a good result. hangs head in shame as realise I sound just like a DM reader

LondonNicki · 02/01/2014 18:08

It's a question of balance between your data privacy rights and the bank Anti Money Laundering responsibilities. I personally think it's a massive hassle changing banks so probably wouldn't do that esp as mentioned by others that all banks are required to have the same controls.
They should have given you some content/explanation around it however to avoid you getting upset...for that alone I would complain/feedback to them. They want the customer feedback and branches are performance rated on this as well as other factors.

Quangle · 02/01/2014 18:08

It's the same standard of proof required, that was my point

larrygrylls · 02/01/2014 18:07

Quangle,

You are confusing insider dealing with aml.

WantToShop · 02/01/2014 18:04

This is all so depressing. I know 6k is a lot (in cash) - but in the big scheme of things, it's nothing. There are plenty of mn'ers who have that much (and multiples of) go through their accounts monthly. Having to explain why you want cash - jesus wept.

I was just about to open an account with HSBC too and I'm a cash gal. :(

Quangle · 02/01/2014 17:58

Thanks caitlin.

Actually in one of the most famous Aml cases an employee was sent to prison for buying share in his company before the release of positive sales figures. He went to prison vbecause he could have had access to the sales figures ahead of time. Not that he did have access (that was never proved) but that he could have.

The obligation on banks is to make checks whether or not you think they are speculative.

Caitlin17 · 02/01/2014 17:56

larrygrills any one regulated by FSA is supposed to be alert to ml activities. The teller cannot just turn a blind eye to a cash withdrawal of that size. It is an unusual transaction.

There are very few reasons (tbh I'm struggling to think of any beyond perhaps the intention to make lots of very small gifts to a very large number of people )where it would not be more convenient for both the payer and payee to pay by bank transfer. For that reason the teller is obliged to ask. If OP then gets shirty or evasive and/or this becomes a pattern the teller has no option other than to pass on her concerns.

larrygrylls · 02/01/2014 17:45

Withdrawing cash is tax neutral. Not much more I can say. You are insinuating that a bank can consider your role in what a 3rd party who receives the cash may or may not do with it. They have no legal right to do this unless they have a real (not ridiculously speculative) reason to suspect tax evasion.

Rooners · 02/01/2014 17:44

The post office thing is (I think) because there are new regs on prohibited items and they either have to check as a box ticking exercise, or they are trying to prevent you from sending something you're not allowed to.

But the thing is - why aren't you allowed to, and what's on the list? That might help a bit.

Caitlin17 · 02/01/2014 17:43

This is going to sound arrogant but I have to agree with quangles re the misunderstandings of how money laundering and proceeds of crime work. Quangles and Craic and others have explained it really well.

Believe what they are saying or not but as someone who has to complete money laundering and proceeds of crime training and compliance annually I can assure you they are correct.

Take it up with your bank , mp or whoever you like. The law won't be changed to suit you, nor should it, nor should a junior teller at HSBC be expected to prejudice her career, her reputation and in the worst case scenario, her liberty because some of you take the hump.

This last point will make some of you fume even more but it is possible to be convicted of failure to comply with ML requirements even where it is not proved the transactions involved dirty money/tax fraud but were of a nature where the person dealing with the money, if acting reasonably, should have taken steps to verify the position but failed to do so.

Quangle · 02/01/2014 17:40

AML covers tax evasion. That's why withdrawals are covered. Not sure what else I can say.

Quangle · 02/01/2014 17:38

Sorry to worry you but a bank is not a safe. It's a financial institution with a set of responsibilities beyond holding customers' money. It seems like a safe but it's not. In fact money on deposit is more akin to a loan to a bank than it is to cash under a mattress. That's why you can have a run on the bank - because the bank might not be able to pay you back. You can't have a run on a safe iyswim. And that's why we have the £85k guarantee on deposits - to reassure customers that it is more likea safe than it really is. BUt it's not the bank's guarantee - its the FCA's guarantee effectively.

This is a bit far into the legalities of banking for this thread but if you want total dominion over your money you need to keep it in cash and if you don't want state intervention you need gold but that's not really practical hence the choice to abide by certain regulations and participate in the banking system.

That said, no of course the bank can't hold your money without cause. But they could if they could show they had good reason. As I keep saying , at this level they need to show they have a process which they have done.

larrygrylls · 02/01/2014 17:30

Qua gale,

See my post above. It is also ironic to discuss aml in the context of cash withdrawal. The entire point of money laundering is to turn dodgy cash into a nice safe deposit in a bank. Withdrawing cash is the precise opposite.

Quangle · 02/01/2014 17:26

The rules are fairly broadly drawn but more guidance is being issued all the time by the Jpint Money Laundering Steering Group suggesting new ways for banks to up their game. As Craic and I have both said, it's not the transaction per se that's a problem but something about it triggered some questions which is what the AML rules require. You have to show that you have processes in place to trigger checks when necessary - it's not about blocking the transaction necessarily. The FCA wants to see processes in place for raising questions at the right time. Large cash withdrawals would and should trigger questions if they are unusual on your account t and cannot be explained otherwise. Some banks might choose to implement the rules differently but they all have to show they have a considered approach and a robust process. That's why there is nothing defined in legislation about withdrawals - its for the institutions to consider the guidance, act accordingly and show that they have a process. But again as Craic says - this area is only growing.

This is how AML works - and tax evasion is covered hence the questions. Also as Craic pointed out, retail has a different standard to IB.

larrygrylls · 02/01/2014 17:22

Craic,

The enitire raison d'être of the banking system is to store money on behalf of customers until such time as they need it. It is not a bank's job to suck your money into a black hole and only give it back to you if you fulfil certain arbitrary criteria.

Certain banks with over zealous compliance officers might be (wrongly) interpreting broadly phrased government guidance. I suspect, however, they would pretty quickly have to give you as much of your own cash as you wanted if legally challenged, regardless of you supplying a reason.

If banks cease to provide their primary function to customers, you will quickly see sales of safes going up. I am shocked to hear this is happening and would be curious to see what the government's official line would be. Good question for question time.

caroldecker · 02/01/2014 17:13

I think at the post office, you have to complete a customs declaration if posting outside the uk

Swipe left for the next trending thread