Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to want to close my bank account after this gross invasion of privacy?

369 replies

somanymiles · 02/01/2014 11:49

I went to get cash out of my bank account this morning to pay the builders (£6,000) and was told I could not take that amount out without hard copy proof of what I was spending the money on eg an invoice. I was given no notice of this so of course did not have anything except a quote on my phone which they did not accept, even though I offered to email it to them. This was not a question of confirming my identity- it was that they have a new policy where you gave to prove what you are spending your cash on. When I asked what the threshold was for the new policy I was told they were not allowed to tell me. I am furious. Surely what I spend my money on us nobodies business but mine. It certainly isn't HSBC's business.I am thinking of closing my accounts there with all the hassle that will entail. AIBU?

OP posts:
birthdaypanic · 03/01/2014 00:40

I too have been asked in the past why I wanted to withdraw money in my case it was the extra money we had added to mortgage to pay for alterations the money was from the bank who knew why we had added extra to the mortgage and had paid it into our account but still wouldn't let us have money without detailed explanation.
I understand about money laundering but in my df case he was not trying to withdraw all his money just wanted some for an emergency - paying for a new boiler and he assumed because he had been told it was ok by the bank that it was ok to leave money untouched.

fanjofarrow · 03/01/2014 00:28

My fella works in fraud prevention at a major bank. I'll ask him when he wakes up, but I suspect he'll just say exactly what others who work in the industry have already posted.

Misspixietrix · 03/01/2014 00:26

Caitlin I'm not giving you a lecture in contract law I'm just pointing it out. To be quite frank I'm finding many peoples attitudes on here a bit "well I work in the Financial Industry so we all know what I'm talking about" a bit Hmm because other people can't possibly know what they are talking about to if they don't list their qualifications first. futuredad is the only one that managed it without coming across with that attitude. Simply not agreeing with you is not 'missing your point'.

birthdaypanic · 03/01/2014 00:21

Yes Caitlin17 I do think it's out of order this money was in a joint account when dm died and my df changed the account to his name he had a meeting with a financial advisor at the bank and explained that he wanted to leave the money in the account untouched unless an emergency arose and that this may not happen for years or possibly never, he was told that there was no problem in just leaving the money untouched, then when he needed the money he couldn't get it so yes I do think it's out of order and I don't understand the relevance of you having to update clients Id.

TeaAndSconesTwice · 03/01/2014 00:14

I actually saw this on twitter, Micky norcross (ex TOWIE man, sugarhut etc) tried to withdraw £6000 at Christmas to do his Christmas shopping, they wouldn't let him, they wanted to know what he was going to be buying! Of course he couldn't give a whole list because it was Christmas gifts etc, they didn't let him have it & he turned to twitter very angry!

Caitlin17 · 03/01/2014 00:11

birthdaypanic As a solicitor I am obliged to update ID for all clients every 5 years.

Do you seriously think putting a temporary close on a dormant account is out of order?

Anyway rant all you like but the policy from bank to bank might vary in points of detail but they will all ask questions in relation to transactions like the OP's.

Caitlin17 · 03/01/2014 00:03

A lot of you seem to think these regulations are only aimed at drug dealers and forged money. That is only a part of it. The reason for being suspicious of cash in hand payments is tax and VAT fraud. Money is kept under the radar in the black economy. If the builders really were so desperate they needed cash that day every bank can organise a same day transfer. The OP can do it herself with online banking.

birthdaypanic · 02/01/2014 23:57

Another example of banks thinking the money is theirs.
My elderly df has an account with several thousand pounds (not boast) he has left this money in account for a few years untouched for emergencies. A few months ago he wanted to use some of the money but couldn't access it, I rang the bank on his behalf and was told that because he hadn't used the account they had made it dormant and to change this he would have to go into the bank in person. This is not easy because of the position of the bank difficult to park near even with disabled badge and df has extreme difficulty in walking.
They also require photo id he does not have passport or driving licence and will not accept disabled blue badge.
It has taken months of phone calls and arguing to get them to accept he doesn't have photo id and to accept his passbook as id.

I sometimes feel money better under mattress.

Caitlin17 · 02/01/2014 23:57

Misspixie I don't need lectures in contract law. Your still missing the point that cash payments make banks, HMRC and my own profession not only nervous but we are obliged to act on that. Nothing in your explanation is a valid reason for paying in cash rather than a banker's draft or a same day transfer from account to account.

Caitlin17 · 02/01/2014 23:52

No it's not a typo. I can't recall the exact sum but it is very small certainly significantly less than £50. We have no reason for accepting cash. It's not appropriate for my business.

DoubleLifeIsALifeOfSorts · 02/01/2014 23:42

Btw if us poor rubbish people aren't of any use to a bank - why does HSBC feel the need to advertise? Brand equity anyone?

I think that belittling people for not having millions is a rather short sighted and yes, arrogant way of thinking.

PrincessFiorimonde · 02/01/2014 23:12

Caitlin
I know it's not the point of the thread, but early on you wrote 'The cash sum we can accept is tiny.I can't recall offhand but it might be as low as £10.'

Please tell me that £10 is a typo! If not, then I'm just Shock Shock.

MrsAMerrick · 02/01/2014 22:24

quangle I love that book, I always think it was the prototype Mumsnet.

Misspixietrix · 02/01/2014 21:43

LaGuardia :(

LaGuardia · 02/01/2014 21:29

I tried to pay in a cheque for just over 10k into the Halifax. They wouldn't take it over the counter and I had to sit at a desk around the back and explain where this cheque, written by a solicitor, had come from. It was my inheritance from my mum's estate. Cheeky fuckers. I closed my accounts as soon as the cheque cleared.

Misspixietrix · 02/01/2014 21:24

The sentence starting also isn't aimed at you Caitlin. I'm on my shit phone that doesn't do paragraphs its to all the other posts that mentioned it could be drug dealers.

Misspixietrix · 02/01/2014 21:23

Caitlin I think the OP gave one. Builders need money for materials for Jobs. There's cases all over Contract Law about them if you're ever feeling that bored. A lot won't start the next part of the Job without it. Which is exactly what my employers used to do they built Tesco stores. Money upfront for clearing land for example. Then more needed upfront for manpower / wages to start the structure etc. Which might be where the money due tomorrow comes from. The Tramworks in Nottingham for example are running late. They're actually being charged 50k a day as per the penalty clause for every day late they are. That's why some times these things can't wait. Also seriously what Drug dealer is going to openly pull out such a sufficient amount of money. They would be pretty fucking stupid a novice if they didn't think that would get any bells ringing. The gist I get from the OP is that she's not saying the Bank was unreasonable for asking questions. She deemed them unreasonable for refusing to give it her. Which she's quite entitled too. Regardless of the money laundering rules etc. Oh and also I've seen a lot of my Bank Manager recently where I asked him a question in relation to another Banks Policy. He told me he couldn't answer for them as every Banks' Policy is different. So theroetically not ALL Banks Policies would be the same on everything.

larrygrylls · 02/01/2014 20:51

Paying in cash is not per se dodgy. There is nothing wrong with it. Money is designed to sette bills. It is quick, efficient and 100% secure.

We have become a nation of informers if people question other people's right to settle a debt with specie.

Charlesroi · 02/01/2014 20:46

The last time I looked cash was a legal method of payment for goods and services - nothing 'suspicious' about it at all.
I can understand why a builder would want to be paid this way

  • he knows he's got the money. Cheques and transfers can bounce. No need to pay to factor his invoices.
  • he can immediately go and purchase any materials he needs for this job, or the next
  • his workers may well be paid weekly and in cash (with appropriate deductions for tax and NI)
  • he might save a couple of quid in bank charges
Banks have a legal obligation to check transactions over a certain sum (10k) but, despite all the noble-sounding claptrap, at £6k it's for securing a sales opportunity.
Quangle · 02/01/2014 20:07

And before anyone goes all "nanny state" there's a fantastic anecdote in "Can any mother help me" which is a collection of letters a group of mothers sent to each other during and post ww2 mainly seeking advice from each other about parenting etc. it's a sort of homemade MN.

Anyway one of the mothers explains in a letter to the others that she has been working and enjoying it. But her husband works for a bank and they will not extend a mortgage to him while his wife is working as it denotes a less stable family and therefore a less good credit risk Shock. So she has to give up work.

It's amazing. And only mention it because it illustrates that the range and extent of bank intrusion in our lives is not new. And that's what I mean when I say they are not purely commercial organisations like Tesco who don't have to stop you buying that extra bar of choc or bottle of vodka even though it's bad for you. Banks are actually supposed sell you only products that are suitable for you and not allow you to tKe on risky levels of debt. Few other commercial organisations have that responsibility. They fail repeatedly, of course, but my point is that they are not just like any other shop on the high st. Hence in part all the questions, "nannying" etc.

tb · 02/01/2014 20:04

My bank kept £60,000 of my money for nearly 2 weeks, while I proved to the satisfaction of their money laundering guy that I had the right to it.

It had come into our Crédit Agricole account from our Lloyds account via a currency broker and had the statement text 'Tfr to M+Mme B'.

There used to be someone in our branch who could ferret around in their suspense accounts and transfer it into our account, but he left.

Each and every time we transferred money for work on the house, I had to provide a complete dossier, from the completion statement after the sale of our UK house, to the transfer to the bank current account, to the savings account, back to the current account, to the transfer to the currency broker, to our account in France. It used to drive me mental.

Thankfully, we now no longer have any money, having lined the pockets of several not very competent tradesmen in the Limousin Grin

Caitlin17 · 02/01/2014 19:41

I think you'll find the government is complying with EU wide policy on money laundering.

Some one commented £6,000 isn't much and many people will have that going through their "accounts" each month. They will indeed the operative word being "account"

I still haven't seen any plausible explanation of why when you have a bank account you would want or need to pay that amount of money in cash. Some one suggested builders needed it to buy materials. I'd be concerned at using builders whose line of credit at their supplier's was so precarious.

Anyway rant all you like but this isn't really HSBC setting out to spoil OP's day.

princessalbert · 02/01/2014 19:41

Yes, I wanted to draw a few thousand out in cash a couple of years ago - to pay builder.

It wasn't as straightforward as I had hoped. I had to take in extra ID just to write myself a cheque to cash..

HSBC again.

Prior to that one, I thought my car using cash - well my debit card - and as it was over £10K I had to notify the bank first - stating what day I would be making the transaction. I didn't actually mind this one, as it seemed more useful in preventing card fraud. Unfortunately, once I had bought the car, I tried to get shopping in the supermarket and the card was blocked for the remainder of that day. Embarrassing Grin

Ebayaholic · 02/01/2014 19:38

CaptainTripps how do you think the government should combat financial crime then? Or should they just turn a blind eye and let the terrorists/drug dealers etc have an easier ride? What about the more minor offenders such as tax evaders-are you happy to prop up the fiscal system from your own purse while they get away with it comfortably without any awkward questions asked?

somanymiles · 02/01/2014 19:35

It may seem a large amount but it was for 5 builders (major renovation) and included materials. I'm not sure the youngest one has a bank account - still lives at home with his Mum! Regardless, my point is, it's my money, and I feel I should be able to take it out when I want. I was not defensive when the teller asked me why I was taking it out, I simply told the truth. I did get annoyed when she asked me for proof as I was unprepared. I did show her an invoice on my phone and offered to email it to her to print out. I don't know if all the builders working on the house are registered for VAT- we are paying a day rate. My point is that I should be able to take out any amount of my money and frankly make a bonfire in Trafalgar Square with it without having permission from the bank. Anyone who thinks that is okay has possibly not read 1984. Still angry! And no cash to pay builders tomorrow. Yes, they refused to gibe me my own money. I am not a drug dealer, just a mum trying to pay for renovations to our new house.

OP posts: