Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to want to close my bank account after this gross invasion of privacy?

369 replies

somanymiles · 02/01/2014 11:49

I went to get cash out of my bank account this morning to pay the builders (£6,000) and was told I could not take that amount out without hard copy proof of what I was spending the money on eg an invoice. I was given no notice of this so of course did not have anything except a quote on my phone which they did not accept, even though I offered to email it to them. This was not a question of confirming my identity- it was that they have a new policy where you gave to prove what you are spending your cash on. When I asked what the threshold was for the new policy I was told they were not allowed to tell me. I am furious. Surely what I spend my money on us nobodies business but mine. It certainly isn't HSBC's business.I am thinking of closing my accounts there with all the hassle that will entail. AIBU?

OP posts:
Braganza · 03/01/2014 12:37

As a Money Laundering Reporting Officer, it seems to me that someone at HSBC has misunderstood the guidelines. I would be really surprised if it was HSBC's official policy to demand an invoice for any cash withdrawal, not least as there are numerous legal reasons why an invoice would not be possible (e.g going to a casino, buying a car from a private seller) More to the point, guidelines refer mainly to identifying the source, not purpose, of funds. There is no obligation on a bank to assess whether you are going to pay a tradesman in cash; the obligation to prevent tax evasion may be present when a tradesman pays the money in, but for a single payment of £6000 this is highly unlikely unless it is part of a series of payments. My guess - the cashier had just misunderstood what they were meant to do.

PrincessFiorimonde · 03/01/2014 12:34

Thanks for answering, Caitlin. I was confused over the £10 thing because I thought you worked for a bank, but I see I misread.

Catsize · 03/01/2014 12:31

Sounds like a good excuse to pay a cheque instead of cash. I would never pay that much cash to a builder for the reasons given by others. If they quibble why you are then paying by cheque, offer to pay them the extra 50p it may cost to cash a business cheque. The price should be the same, as OF COURSE they are paying all tax on the cash.

StripyButterfly · 03/01/2014 12:25

Why didn't you ask for a bankers draft? There is no way I would feel comfortable walking out of a bank with 6 thousand pounds in my bag. What if someone saw the withdrawal and attacked you?

BackOnlyBriefly · 03/01/2014 12:11

The government may have created guidelines for banks to watch for certain kinds of money movement, but to the best of my knowledge they have not passed laws requiring me to actively assist the banks in this.

There seems to be an assumption that now we know why they do this we must cooperate voluntarily.

I understand the government's motives. Unfortunately the solution to all problems for a government will be to take away rights from individuals and introduce more and more controls. It's a known problem with all governments.

It's not about being difficult for the sake of it. It's about resisting the gradual erosion of privacy.

It's easy to say things like 'it's not a big deal' and 'why make a fuss', but it's essential to resist small, and probably well intentioned, changes that have us being required to prove we are innocent.

larrygrylls · 03/01/2014 10:16

Whatever,

Only cash can be guaranteed to be exchanged simultaneously with goods. Any other method allows one party to be in receipt of goods and money at the same time, creating risk for the other party.

snowed · 03/01/2014 10:16

If you can prove who you are, then it's up to you and no-one else to decide what you're going to spend your money on. There is no need for the bank to know. It would be better if they'd offer information and advice about how to avoid rogue traders etc, regardless of who may be spending what (and most amounts going to unscrupulous traders won't be thousands).

whatever5 · 03/01/2014 10:10

In addition, the safest way for an individual to take payment is in cash. For instance, if I sold my car privately, I would only take cash, even banker's drafts can be forged.

Nowadays you can pay via BACS electronic payments or direct money transfers though. I wouldn't hand over thousands in cash.

whatever5 · 03/01/2014 10:05

I wouldn't agree that it's a "gross invasion of privacy" to ask you what you are spending your money on. I would be annoyed if the cashier said that I had to "prove it" though.

As others have said, it is likely that other banks are doing the same thing as they all will be more concerned with showing the authorities that they are following regulations than worrying about whether you keep your money with them.

In your position I probably would move bank accounts as it would make me feel better and there are better banks than HSBC anyway. I wouldn't waste my time complaining though.

larrygrylls · 03/01/2014 10:00

In addition, the safest way for an individual to take payment is in cash. For instance, if I sold my car privately, I would only take cash, even banker's drafts can be forged.

Tubemole1 · 03/01/2014 09:50

Some people just prefer to deal in cash, both the service provider and its receiver.

HSBC can ask you what u want it for, but it is none of their bloody business. And besides, who is to say you are telling the truth? And why should that matter?

Paying tradespeople cash is very normal. Once they are in receipt of their cash, its up to them what it is spent on, tax or no tax.

Btw, have never spoken to a London taxi driver who has declared income for tax. They mostly fiddle the system by accepting cash only. Oddly, I don't mind...!?

Misspixietrix · 03/01/2014 09:00

Grin Princess.

larrygrylls · 03/01/2014 07:49

Caitlin's posts are a prime example of what over zealous employees will do with general guidance. They will interpret it to maximally protect themselves at the expense of inconveniencing their clients. Then they will shelter under a catch-all excuse such as alm, or tax evasion.

Withdrawing cash is not a crime. Paying workmen cash is not a crime. It is not an individual's responsibility to ensure that people that they do business with manage their tax affairs honestly. Funny how banks are v interested in paying builders a few k in cash, yet have other departments advising ftse 100 companies how to minimise (with dubious legality) their 'tax liability'.

At the moment, due to low interest rates, banks have v little interest in savers. Once interest rates go up, their attitudes will change.

fanjoforthemammaries7850 · 03/01/2014 06:19

They did this at the Halifax when i paid in a 5.5k cheque.

It is money laundering regulations as many have said, and not them being nosey or twunts.

kreecherlivesupstairs · 03/01/2014 06:09

Yes, i think YABU. i had to drive from Belgium to England to transfer some money for a house sale.
I was inconvenienced, but didn't consider closing my account down.

glastocat · 03/01/2014 03:22

Move around money.

glastocat · 03/01/2014 03:21

Of course you can feel pissed off by being inconvenienced the bank doing this, but these regulations are in place for very good reasons, without AML restrictions it would be very easy for dangerous and illegal organisations ( Al Qaeda, mafia, drug cartels etc) to move around and profit from their illegal activities. So what is a minor inconvenience to you is actually helping make criminals lives significantly more difficult, and even saving lives in the bigger picture yes I've done a few AML courses.

Thatisall · 03/01/2014 03:18

I've been asked what I intend to do with large sums before, but never asked to prove it :-S

I'm sure it's for your own protection •coughs* just incase it's ransom money or you're being forced to withdraw it by hooded youths Wink

fanjofarrow · 03/01/2014 03:03

Good lord.

PrincessFlirtyPants · 03/01/2014 02:50

Don't pay builders in cash. It is the black/criminal economy

Hmm
TheGervasuttiPillar · 03/01/2014 02:12

Don't pay builders in cash. It is the black/criminal economy. Your bank was being reasonable.

Misspixietrix · 03/01/2014 01:34

It doesn't need to be clear. Last time I checked you didn't need to be qualified in certain subjects to comment on specific threads. The AML/Tax Evasion/POC have been mentioned as a reason countless times. The OP still has the right to feel pissed off at them if she wishes too.

Caitlin17 · 03/01/2014 01:26

I would have thought it clear which posters are involved in professions which require a compulsory understanding of the legislation concerning anti- money laundering and proceeds of crime.

There is a lot of ill - informed posts about this being outrageous and that being outrageous ,blaming the government for snooping and a lack of understanding that this legislation does not apply only to dodgy looking blokes selling coca one and AK47s

The bottom line is the sort of transaction which the OP wanted to carry out sets tax evasion bells ringing. One of the key triggers we are supposed to look out for is "does this transaction make sense?" Answer no, it doesn't.

Misspixietrix · 03/01/2014 01:19

Ebear ??? Grin

EBearhug · 03/01/2014 00:55

What you can't send by post

I didn't think it was a new list, though they may be more vigilant about checking it now. It came up a while back at work, because a disgruntled former employee in one of our overseas offices had sent the office a box of dung. I was surprised to learn that there are a number of online companies where you can order this to be done, because I always thought it was something you weren't allowed to send by post in the UK - and indeed, it's not. (Although actually, I could do with someone sending me a good load of dung for the garden.)