Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to want to close my bank account after this gross invasion of privacy?

369 replies

somanymiles · 02/01/2014 11:49

I went to get cash out of my bank account this morning to pay the builders (£6,000) and was told I could not take that amount out without hard copy proof of what I was spending the money on eg an invoice. I was given no notice of this so of course did not have anything except a quote on my phone which they did not accept, even though I offered to email it to them. This was not a question of confirming my identity- it was that they have a new policy where you gave to prove what you are spending your cash on. When I asked what the threshold was for the new policy I was told they were not allowed to tell me. I am furious. Surely what I spend my money on us nobodies business but mine. It certainly isn't HSBC's business.I am thinking of closing my accounts there with all the hassle that will entail. AIBU?

OP posts:
Gryffindor · 04/01/2014 14:37

There is zero point in complaining by the way, banks are protected against customer impact in the course of their compliance with AML Regulations as long as the bank acts reasonably. In this case Hsbc will say that the transaction was unusual for you and therefore potentially suspicious.

Over-zealous application of legislation, but all banks are under increasing scrutiny and have been protected by the Courts (eg recent case law Shah v HSBC).

Mignonette · 04/01/2014 14:17

Err.....The original post doesn't say anything about being asked to pay cash.

And BTW my Husband is a reputable builder and he is often paid cash by (possibly) disreputable customers.

Do NOT make the assumption that cash transactions = trashy conmen.

And maybe the reason vulnerable people 'don't listen' is because they are, um, vulnerable.

NiceTabard · 04/01/2014 14:14

It was about 5 years ago now but I went through a spate of withdrawing large sums of cash from the local Barclays.

I had to take lots of ID which is fine obv, and they asked what I wanted it for - I just said building work - and it was fine.

Having to show multiple pieces of evidence before they will allow you to withdraw your own money is preposterous.

OP I think you should change your bank.

PigletJohn · 04/01/2014 14:05

Reputable builders don't ask to be paid £6k in cash.

However, rogues who prey on the uninformed and vulnerable do.

However some uniformed and vulnerable people won't listen so I suppose they are free to chuck their money down the drain if they want to.

Mignonette · 04/01/2014 14:03

What on earth is the problem in paying cash stage payments to tradespeople? I don't understand that at all. Some people prefer to hand over cash, often because it is convenient to them. Not everybody is crooked!

My Husband is self employed. He is often paid cash but the transaction is recorded in the same manner as bank payments.

PrincessFlirtyPants · 04/01/2014 14:00

Not interested in 'winning a point'

nauticant · 04/01/2014 13:58

If you want to win that point why don't you use a reference to a regulation rather than passive-aggression?

PrincessFlirtyPants · 04/01/2014 13:48

Larry,

I'm well aware of the anti money laundering legislation and it is to do with withdrawals as well.

Thanks for your input though.

larrygrylls · 04/01/2014 13:35

Princess,

The point of money laundering is to stop dirty money (normally in the form of cash, or in an account in a dubious jurisdiction) from getting in to a bank account in a mainstream bank, at which point the criminal can do what they like with it.

If the money is already in an account in a mainstream bank, then it has been deemed by that bank to be clean. Thus, taking it out is not subject to the ML regulations. In fact, as I pointed out upthread, withdrawing cash is the opposite of what a money launderer wants to achieve.

Tulip26 · 04/01/2014 13:32

You should tell them you want to put it on a horse. Banks are a joke, really. Couldn't you get the amount in a cheque to give to the builder? Cash does sound dodgy.

PrincessFlirtyPants · 04/01/2014 13:24

ummm if she is taking from the bank then the origins can be traced so not subject to ML regulations...

Of course it's subject to money laundering regulations! Why wouldn't it be? Confused

larrygrylls · 04/01/2014 07:46

You keep stating this, Caitlin, with zero evidence to support it and despite being contradicted by many experts in this thread.

Caitlin17 · 04/01/2014 03:43

sadandlonely withdrawing £6,000 in cash is for the purposes of ml/poc an unusual transaction. The cashier is obliged to ask. There is no reason for paying builders in cash. There may have been a valid reason but the obvious one is this was a cash in hand payment not going through the builders' books.

A few people on here seem to think that's only for the builders ' conscience, it isn't.

sadlonelyandconfused · 03/01/2014 22:22

ummm if she is taking from the bank then the origins can be traced so not subject to ML regulations... If she was paying in huge amounts then they may want to check that but not if she is taking it out surely...

peggyundercrackers · 03/01/2014 22:19

we have started taking cash out of our account and using it on a daily basis rather than using a DC - fed up of the monitoring on what you do on a daily basis, where you spend etc. etc.

larrygrylls I think your correct in that HSBC don't seem to have the same standards throughout their own branches when it comes to the rules as I seem to have been treated differently to others commenting on here.

as for internet banking - dont make me laugh - when they make it safe I will consider using it however that's a long way off yet. I work in the IT industry within banking and have a connection to 8 out of 10 banks in this country and you would be astonished if you knew some of the things I do that goes on behind the scenes in some/most of our banks.

ascarg · 03/01/2014 21:21

Same thing happened to me, i needed to get an invoice for 10k in cash, it is obviously for money laundering but they should be checking the money going in, not going out. i threatened to close my account but they didn't give in and still wouldn't give me the cash without a letter or an invoice, so i closed the account. i opened a new one with Halifax and explained what had just happened and they laughed and couldn't believe what they were doing, saying it was my money and i could do what i wanted with with it. i had a six digit bank balance and HSBC didn't even call to try and keep me as a customer, or why i had closed the account, that's how much they respect your custom. To get the 10k i just transferred 5k to a friend who withdrew that and i withdrew the other 5k, a pain in the arse but it worked. They don't mind 5k but i think 10k sets alarm bells. I'd say close the account and go somewhere else, just as i did.

whatever5 · 03/01/2014 16:24

Because a bank's policy doesn't necessarily mean the applicable regulations but can often be an interpretation of those regulations. And if you have a bank which, perhaps because it corrupted itself, is being over-zealous in stamping out often imaginary money laundering, customers will walk away.

Okay maybe not all of them will have exactly the same policy but I bet a lot of them will have similar policies now. You can hardly ask when opening the account what their policies are regarding withdrawal of large sums of cash.

whatever5 · 03/01/2014 16:20

Many people do like to use cash. Sure, it is a minority, but not an insignificant minority and, in general, probably they constitute richer rather than poorer customers.

I don't agree that a significant proportion of people prefer to use cash for expensive items/services. Surely anyone with any sense would prefer to pay with visa debit/bank transfer etc rather than walk around with thousands of pounds in their pockets?

larrygrylls · 03/01/2014 14:59

Correct.

It is amazing how zealous the most dodgy banks are with their small customers, while bending over backwards for oligarchs of dubious origin.

nauticant · 03/01/2014 14:53

if all the banks have the same policy regarding cash withdrawals for large sums

Because a bank's policy doesn't necessarily mean the applicable regulations but can often be an interpretation of those regulations. And if you have a bank which, perhaps because it corrupted itself, is being over-zealous in stamping out often imaginary money laundering, customers will walk away.

larrygrylls · 03/01/2014 14:49

Whatever,

I am unconvinced that all the banks have the same policy. I am even unconvinced that HSBC has a consistent policy across all branches and customers.

Many people do like to use cash. Sure, it is a minority, but not an insignificant minority and, in general, probably they constitute richer rather than poorer customers.

Plenty of people still feel that they want both control and privacy regarding their own money. Some people may never feel the need to draw a large sum of money in cash but certainly feel that they ought to be able to should they wish to do so.

whatever5 · 03/01/2014 14:06

Why would they lose 1000s of customers though if all the banks have the same policy regarding cash withdrawals for large sums? Most people don't withdraw 1000s in cash to pay for something. The majority of people won't care if banks know who they are paying.

larrygrylls · 03/01/2014 13:05

Braganza,

Thanks for confirming the point that I have been trying to make throughout this thread. It seems there are plenty of bankers/compliance officers who are the equivalent of head teachers who ban conkers based on 'health and safety' law.

It is for the government to put in place broad guidelines and for compliance departments to interpret them sensibly and proportionately. Those who use them to try to destroy privacy or to attempt to co-opt us all as tax inspectors deserve to lose our custom. And to the poster who said 'HSBC does not care about 60k'. In itself that is true. But if they start losing 1000s of this type of account, it will start to hurt both financially and, more importantly, reputation ally.

Quangle · 03/01/2014 12:54

I'm an MLRO too (not in retail) but this is correct. And this will increasingly be a part of our every day banking relationships. We have seen a dramatic increase in AML efforts over the last few years and this is only the beginning - we in UK financial services have also almost by accident been made responsible for implementing the tax avoidance legislation of other countries (eg FATCA which is a piece of US legislation but which many other countries are seeking to copy). This is quite new territory for all of us and we should all be aware that this will increase year on year.

ML is mainly but not only about the source. But as I have repeatedly said, this is about banks having to show that they have processes in place to ask questions at the right time. It's not about the transaction per se but about having the process in place to trigger a series of questions.

Coutts' recent AML fine was not necessarily about mistakes of content (ie that they were actually handling proceeds of crime) but that they had no evidence of having the right processes in place.

I agree with all the posters who think this does make life difficult - it really does. I struggle with all the paperwork myself - especially the utility bills as the utility companies all want to move to online statements which are not, as yet, accepted, as KYC documents. But this just is the way things are going.

THECliffRichardSucksEggsinHell · 03/01/2014 12:43

Sensible post Braganza but I fear this topic will drag on and on.

Swipe left for the next trending thread