Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to want to close my bank account after this gross invasion of privacy?

369 replies

somanymiles · 02/01/2014 11:49

I went to get cash out of my bank account this morning to pay the builders (£6,000) and was told I could not take that amount out without hard copy proof of what I was spending the money on eg an invoice. I was given no notice of this so of course did not have anything except a quote on my phone which they did not accept, even though I offered to email it to them. This was not a question of confirming my identity- it was that they have a new policy where you gave to prove what you are spending your cash on. When I asked what the threshold was for the new policy I was told they were not allowed to tell me. I am furious. Surely what I spend my money on us nobodies business but mine. It certainly isn't HSBC's business.I am thinking of closing my accounts there with all the hassle that will entail. AIBU?

OP posts:
ButICantaloupe · 05/01/2014 20:32

TalkinPeace I very much doubt HSBC will close OP's account if she makes a complaint.

TalkinPeace · 05/01/2014 20:29

You should write to head office, copying in the bank manager, ask for an explanation and recompense for the inconvenience and embarrassment caused
They will close OP's account and leave her without one.
Banks do not want troublemakers unless they are making lots of money out of them.
They do not make money out of people with savings and ready cash.

Sweetishdelight · 05/01/2014 20:25

YANBU. It is to do with money laundering, but that's beside the point. Unless you had been hold in advance of the requirement to provide an invoice in order to be able to it hydras that sum, they were out of order. You should write to head office, copying in the bank manager, ask for an explanation and recompense for the inconvenience and embarrassment caused.

TalkinPeace · 05/01/2014 20:24

CallmeNancy
They can be dumb like that.
I had a cheque from my Dad at Christmas 2001 that they did not like so they said they would contact his bank branch.
I told them that would be a bad idea and to look at the address on the cheque.
World Trade Center.
They did not get why that was relevant.
It was Lloyds too ....

CallMeNancy · 05/01/2014 20:22

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

CallMeNancy · 05/01/2014 20:21

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

TalkinPeace · 05/01/2014 20:17

Having been doing tax returns for builders for over 20 years
if its in cash it rarely turns up in the tax return
I hassle them all the time and use their petrol receipts to fill in the gaps

With FPS, there is no reason for cash payments if they are being properly declared.
With cash payments the householder has no proof that they are not handing money to benefit cheats / illegal migrants etc etc
and the work is highly unlikely to be covered by any insurance / guarantees

PigletJohn · 05/01/2014 20:15

It's really rather odd to think anyone using £6k cash is not evading tax

Serenitysutton · 05/01/2014 20:13

I'm well aware plenty of people pay cash in this world. It's also not my place to decide whether or not those people submit their tax returns correctly without any evidence.

PigletJohn · 05/01/2014 20:12

it was odd to go around assuming people dealing in cash evade tax

If a trader asks to be paid £6k in cash, and it was not just an eccentric whim of the customer, then I certainly think it is very fishy. It might just be that the contractor is an itinerant with a false name and address who will overcharge for substandard work and flit. Or perhaps there is some decent and understandable reason that did not occur to me.

TalkinPeace · 05/01/2014 20:09

serenity
if you work for a house builer you deal zero rated and all your subbies gleefully do not have to charge it

the subbies will be up to their ears in VAT evasion

just hang around in a builders merchant at 7.30 in the morning to watch the cash economy in full swing

Serenitysutton · 05/01/2014 20:06

I'm also an accountant. For a major home builder ;) I didn't say tax and VAT were the same thing, I said it was odd to go around assuming people dealing in cash evade tax

TalkinPeace · 05/01/2014 20:02

LOL - I have the HMRC rates and tables page as my first bookmark Wink

PigletJohn · 05/01/2014 20:01

ooops

too slow

PigletJohn · 05/01/2014 20:00

income tax is at a higher rate than VAT. Registration does not apply.

TalkinPeace · 05/01/2014 20:00

Serenity
Tax and VAT are not the same thing.

I'm an accountant. Piglet is in the trade.

Class 2 NI kicks in once taxable income is over £5,725
Class 4 NI kicks in at £7,755
Income tax starts at £9,440

VAT is of course based on turnover not profit.

Serenitysutton · 05/01/2014 19:57

Huge numbers of builders- a big part of the industry- aren't VAT registered. It's really rather odd to think anyone using cash is evading tax.

TalkinPeace · 05/01/2014 19:56

MLR is indeed a daft sledgehammer to crack a very small nut
but its there
live with it or move overseas

PigletJohn · 05/01/2014 19:54

last time I checked the terrorists were still terrorising & the drug dealers were still selling

You are suggesting that all attempts to reduce, limit or detect crime are futile and should be stopped?

TalkinPeace · 05/01/2014 19:53

The MLR rules changed several years ago.
I am an MLR compliance bod - cos I'm an accountant
its well known that banks are asking for proof. I would carry it just in case.

The OP might have a rather severe problem opening a new bank account if they do kick off about this because the bank will put a 'flag' against her name that every other bank will see as part of their MLR account opening checks.

If she has lots of builders doing lots of work, unless she is very clear about paying each of the subbies separately and the materials herself, chances are VAT is being evaded, let alone tax.
I wonder if she's seen her builders liability insurance cert?

Serenitysutton · 05/01/2014 19:49

Talk in peace plenty of posters have already mentioned why someone might want cash. Why not? It's perfectly legal tender, designed to be used to settle a debt .

I can understand the cashier asking what the money is for, as a box ticking exercise- what I don't understand is demanding proof (and rejecting the proof supplied as not good enough ) as has been mentioned above, what if you said I'm going to the races and want to spunk the lot? They wouldn't refuse to give you it.

TalkinPeace · 05/01/2014 18:58

why did your builders want payment in cash rather than bank transfer ?

could it be that they do not plant to pay tax or VAT on the work they are doing for you.

Lattetogo · 05/01/2014 18:47

Is this really about money laundering or stupidity? Is 5k (that is the alarm limit) going to make or break a money laundering operation? Is it about tax evasion? Is income tax on 5k so vital to the inland revenue?

If above is true then why not focus on the likes of amazon, google & Starbucks who use sophisticated means such as off-shore share options, HQ's, overseas distribution networks and campaign contributions to legally launder money (non taxed income).

I'm afraid this restriction is more about making sure that we leave a digital footprint - the limit used to be 20k, then 10k & now 5k, pretty soon it will be down to 1k and shops will refuse to take your cash as banks will make it to expensive to handle cash.

Meanwhile last time I checked the terrorists were still terrorising & the drug dealers were still selling so what exactly has been the result of all this anti-criminal anti-laundering laws and restrictions? Who is it exactly that is being restricted apart from OP .... Read here www.economist.com/news/britain/21580182-british-exports-china-are-rising-government-policy-holding-back-business-eastward

NotMeNotYouNotAnyone · 05/01/2014 13:18

I work for an investment company, not a bank, we don't deal with physical cash. But one of our products does not officially allow withdrawals. This is such a shit rule that we got around by allowing withdrawals in exceptional circumstances. The threshold for who agrees them started at senior management and has now ( five years later) got to the point that as long as a reason is given we don't need approval we can just do it. We've accepted "because I need the money" before. This isn't a regulatory issue though, just shitty terms and conditions that the staff like myself try our best to work around.

Six grand in cash is a lot, especially if you never normally make that kind of transaction, of course your bank should question it. If they don't and it turns out to be dodgy they get in shit.

Not being profitable is not a valid reason for a bank up deny someone an account. However having a history of fraud or money laundering convictions is!

My company is FCA regulated and we get as much shit whether we mess up over 1p, £1k or £100 k.

Floppityflop · 05/01/2014 10:17

I'm sure there are much bigger fish than people withdrawing cash at the limit, as people who work in banks know - they have been identified before and banks fined. Money laundering is about more than just cash withdrawals and banks could make their controls more sophisticated. However, I believe proof of ID is all that is required. Wouldn't asking fir anything more constitute a tip-off anyway?