Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to want to close my bank account after this gross invasion of privacy?

369 replies

somanymiles · 02/01/2014 11:49

I went to get cash out of my bank account this morning to pay the builders (£6,000) and was told I could not take that amount out without hard copy proof of what I was spending the money on eg an invoice. I was given no notice of this so of course did not have anything except a quote on my phone which they did not accept, even though I offered to email it to them. This was not a question of confirming my identity- it was that they have a new policy where you gave to prove what you are spending your cash on. When I asked what the threshold was for the new policy I was told they were not allowed to tell me. I am furious. Surely what I spend my money on us nobodies business but mine. It certainly isn't HSBC's business.I am thinking of closing my accounts there with all the hassle that will entail. AIBU?

OP posts:
nauticant · 25/01/2014 12:36

So, it turns out that HSBC could replace their stupid policy at the drop of a hat:

www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-25861717

But that must mean that many of the comments from banking experts above were a load of hot air. Tell me that isn't so!

NetworkGuy · 25/01/2014 12:31

live with it or move overseas

The day one of my websites has a turnover in excess of £1M a month, I'll definitely be going overseas. (Though I would be aiming to employ a number of UK residents, perhaps 20-30 SAHMs, and VAT may still be payable in the UK.)

NetworkGuy · 25/01/2014 12:27

Just heard this come up on Moneybox with various 'justifications' and an MP saying he felt the banks were using the vagueness of the regulations to do what they want. HSBC made a statement to the effect they are going to alter the advice for staff.

I can see why some might regard payment with cash as being 'suspicious' but feel that until such time as cash becomes 'illegal' we should opt for this whenever we wish. It's none of the bank's business whether I am about to take a number of relatives out for drinks, a meal, and then off to some club, and would prefer to have cash to do so (or that I'm going to be playing poker with a few friends, or have arranged a stag do, and myself and 10 other men are going to a strip club).

Found it laughable - if I am planning a night out at a casino what 'proof' in advance could I give of my plan to spend a few thousands?

Preciousbane · 17/01/2014 09:23

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

OldDaddy · 16/01/2014 10:18

Money laundering. We once had a client bizarrely pay us 24k in cash for legitimate services. The accountant broke out in a sweat as he knew the bank would grill him when we tried to pay it in.

DolomitesDonkey · 15/01/2014 21:08

My dad tried to buy a brand new car this week, told HSBC in advance that he would be making a payment at the dealership. Security kicked in, dad's cash out there somewhere in cyberspace lost between HSBC and dealer. Indian call centre obfuscating the situation - had he been able to ring through to his local branch...

He should be able to collect the car at the weekend - if his money appears back out of the void.

PigletJohn · 08/01/2014 11:41

Established businesses, or private individuals?

I once had a fastpay to my window cleaner stopped and did not hear my phone, that we the first time I'd paid him that way, I confirmed it was OK and subsequent ones not stopped. I have an idea I was phoned when I fastpaid a friend for holiday tickets, but it was cleared straight away so no delay. The bank has my mobile number and texts me when I set up new payments. They are mostly things like credit card co's or car insurance so are recognised by the bank and not queried.

Floppityflop · 08/01/2014 10:56

Just normal transactions, nothing dodgy.

PigletJohn · 08/01/2014 08:42

What sort of people are you making these payments to?

Are you using internet banking?

Floppityflop · 08/01/2014 08:27

My bank's fraud dept calls me up and freezes my accountwhen I do a debit card transaction over £500 and the same has started happening with my credit card. It's very frustrating and I worry sometimes it is because the bank doesn't have enough cash but I suppose it's better than being a fraud victim

PigletJohn · 06/01/2014 10:47

Italy got very fussy about cash transactions with no receipt as they (used to?) have a big problem with black economy.

larrygrylls · 06/01/2014 06:06

The doctrine

I would be pretty pissed off if I went to pick my child up from nursery and they told me to prove where he was going before they were prepared to release him to me.

DolomitesDonkey · 06/01/2014 05:48

As I read this thread it occurs to me that it's only the British get ants in their pants about cash and prefer their every movement to be tracked by card.

It's more than normal on the continent to have large cash transactions - in fact in The Netherlands until quite recently big-ticket items were only allowed to be sold COD. I gave my notary 17k cash when I bought my house and nobody batted an eye-lid.

Credit cards aren't ubiquitous here, plenty of people carry large amounts of cash.

Lattetogo · 06/01/2014 04:11

That's an interesting way of boosting the economy & far more beneficial than chasing pennies from builders.

wetaugust · 05/01/2014 23:09

^ what happened in France when they adopted the Euro was a rush to build extensions and swimming pools - paid for in Francs (according to the Telegraph)

QuintessentialShadows · 05/01/2014 22:32

Imagine what is going to happen if/when the GBP is no longer legal currency and everybody needs to hand their cash into the bank to exchange it with Euro.....

Interesting to see how much "unaccounted for cash" will be knocking about.

Or how many people will go and buy TVs, fridges, cars, CASH to avoid this...... Grin

TheDoctrineOf2014 · 05/01/2014 22:23

To be fair, OP said in a later post the £6k was for multiple builders, not just one.

I'm with Gryffindor - the description plus the email regarding why the funds were required would seem sufficient and possibly if OP had asked to speak to a more senior person at the branch, that might have resolved the matter there and then, but the question itself was reasonable.

NT, it isn't "your money" at the bank; the account is a service they are providing with attached terms and conditions that you agreed to when you opened the account and for which they periodically send you updates, and the service is regulated by the FCA. Just like using a nursery, although it's "your child" attending, you can't tell the nursery not to, say, follow the Early Years' scheme in creativity for your child because they are regulated by Ofsted.

Dromedary · 05/01/2014 22:21

Come off it, builders and others quite often openly (or by strong implication) offer a lower price if you agree to pay in cash. Why would the houseowner go to the trouble of getting £6K out in cash (with the worry of having to carry it from the bank) if they could just as well pay the same amount by cheque or bank transfer? Helping someone to commit a criminal offence in order to save yourself money may or may not be criminal (I wouldn't know) but it's hardly taking the high road.

wetaugust · 05/01/2014 21:44

There is nothing dodgy in paying £6K in cash to builders. They do your work - you pay them, in cash if that's what they want. That's the contract.

What the builders then declare or otherwise is nothing to do with you.

I am not policing HMRC's tax collection for them.

EmmelineGoulden · 05/01/2014 21:41

Agree £6k in cash to a trade is more likely to be tax avoidance than not, but you can have a paper trail with cash, you just get a receipt.

FrankAndFurt · 05/01/2014 21:29

£6000 cash for builders! Umm, sounds a bit dodgy to me. Confused
I have never paid a builder in cash and none have ever asked for it. Bank transfer is immediate, safe and far more convenient. You don't have to leave your house to make the payment.

The most likely reason for a householder to agree to pay in cash is that there is an understanding that there will be a reduction in the cost due to tax evasion. Why would anyone choose a method of payment with no paper trail? Paying by bank transfer provides a record of what has been paid and to whom.

EmmelineGoulden · 05/01/2014 21:23

It isn't just cash withdrawals or depsoits. I had huge problems buying a house because the cashier wanted me to produce an invoice for the deposit CHAPS transfer (we had done everything with the solicitor electronically, so I didn't have one, had to kick up a huge stink to get it to go through).

Another time I had them asking me what a large some of money I wanted to transfer from my savings account to my current account was for. I said "stuff", they said "it's a lot of money to spend on stuff" so I said "I'm rich" (not true).

I also had an odd discussion with fraud team once who I received a call from following suspiscious activity on my account. They wanted to know what I had withdrawn £500 for - I said it wasn't any of their business and they said "it's just a security question", so I asked how it could possibly be a security question when they couldn't have any idea what I was going to spend it on. It was quite odd.

It does make me irate. Mainly because the people asking these questions either don't seem to understand why they are asking them or they lie to me about why. I haven't had a cashier sayt o me, "I'm sorry fi it seems intrusive, we have legal obligations to try and get to know your financial business because of money laundering regulations" it's always "I'm only trying to help" or "it's for your security" niether of which make much sense to me for the questions they are asking.

I would also be less annoyed by it if they didn't seem to use every bit of information about me to try and make more money out of me regardless of whether or not they are actually helping me and often by misrepresenting. 30 years ago I liked my bank and would have turned to them for advice. Nowadays I assume they are a bunch of sharks with no interest at all in my financial wellbeing, only in how they can get the biggest percentage of my money, so I'm not inclined to think well of their attempts to interrogate me and I trust little fo what they say. This isn't down to money laundering regulations, it's down to the appalling practices of high street banks over the last two decades. So I don't think claims of "poor banks are only enforcing the law" carry much weight. They don't only enforce the law, they also abuse their position to my detriment. If they didn't do this so much they'd be able to enforce money laundering regulations without getting people's backs up so much.

Dromedary · 05/01/2014 21:13

It sounds as if you're knowingly assisting the builders to evade (loads of) tax, in which case I wouldn't be so righteous about it. It's because of this kind of thing that the rest of us have to pay so much tax ourselves.

Snatchoo · 05/01/2014 21:07

Talkin that is bollocks.

whatever5 · 05/01/2014 20:58

HSBC may not close her account if the OP makes a complaint but it is clear from this thread that it would be a complete waste of time. She's certainly not going to get recompense for inconvenience and embarassment.

Swipe left for the next trending thread