Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to want to close my bank account after this gross invasion of privacy?

369 replies

somanymiles · 02/01/2014 11:49

I went to get cash out of my bank account this morning to pay the builders (£6,000) and was told I could not take that amount out without hard copy proof of what I was spending the money on eg an invoice. I was given no notice of this so of course did not have anything except a quote on my phone which they did not accept, even though I offered to email it to them. This was not a question of confirming my identity- it was that they have a new policy where you gave to prove what you are spending your cash on. When I asked what the threshold was for the new policy I was told they were not allowed to tell me. I am furious. Surely what I spend my money on us nobodies business but mine. It certainly isn't HSBC's business.I am thinking of closing my accounts there with all the hassle that will entail. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FallacyTide · 08/11/2022 21:38

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster

dozy52 · 17/12/2018 22:10

Banks are getting worse: Today, (17 December 2018) I was questioned subtly while withdrawing a mere £500 in cash - in 50's, because there are birthdays + family youngsters at Xmas. I am a pensioner and regularly withdraw about 600 p.m. just to live on. the teller said "do you run a shop or something?" I felt this was a bit intrusive so I said "Its interesting that you should ask that". He said "Why?" I said "Its just interesting that you should ask that". The person in the queue behind me laughed out loud.
Having worked in construction a bit, 6k is not such a huge amount: a builder will often pay subcontracted trades (sparks plumbers, plasterers etc) who often are earning below the VAT threshold, on a day to day basis in cash, and will pay VAT on his materials in any case. I always declared ALL my cash receipts (yes, really) without suffering too much in taxation, though I did prefer bank transfers just for ease of accounting.
Builders etc want to avoid paperwork more than the VAT itself, which is thankfully easier now the threshold has been raised to a sensible level.
VAT was originally introduced as a tax on luxuries . . . Anyone remember the dual rate on half covered chocolate digestives?

GreenIsTheWord · 02/05/2014 19:05
Hmm

Do you work for a competitor by any chance?

1mike23 · 02/05/2014 19:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

topknob · 26/01/2014 19:04

The real reason for this IMHO is that if everyone in the UK decided to withdraw all their money on the same day, the banks wouldn't have the actual cash to cover this, so they make up stupid rules like this. money laundering makes more sense though

NetworkGuy · 26/01/2014 19:00

Maybe I should add I am looking forward to the day when I can withdraw say 30K a week (Mon, Wed, Fri) and not tell the bank anything other than how much I will be withdrawing the following week...

NetworkGuy · 26/01/2014 18:49

Pumpkinette - can see your support (wrt possibility of forcing cash from someone vulnerable) for policy, but if I had the funds in my account to withdraw say 5K or more, 2 or 3 times a week, then yes, the bank might be suspicious but it's really none of their business what I want to do with my money.

I'm on a loser, whether I say "I like to party with friends, and we snort a lot of coke, so I need cash for my dealer" or if I suggested it was "none of their business". Neither is a "suitable reason" yet the money is still mine, and I don't see how the bank can refuse me access to it...

Pumpkinette · 26/01/2014 14:41

Not read all the replys so sorry if this has been said already.

I work for a bank (not in a branch but still) and we go through training every 6 months for fraud and money laundering. We are trained to question usual large cash withdrawals. If you do not usually withdraw large amounts if cash this would raise a red flag.

The banks logic: you could be money laundering, you could be in a situation where someone is forcing you to take the cash out (more common with vulnerable adults/ young people and the elderly), you could be a fraudster stealing the funds from a stolen card. The cashier should be trained to judge how genuine someone is by there answer and if they're not happy then they can ask for proof/ refuse the payment.

Now I'm not saying that what happened to OP was correct but from the other side I can see why it happened. If the OP kicked off or refused to answer what the cash was for then the cashier would most likely just be following her training by not handing the cash over.

We are trained a nice friendly conversation to ask what the cash is for eg: '£6,000 Mrs Smith - are you planning on buying something nice?' Mrs Smith : ' oh I'm buying a car, mine broke down last month so I'm having to buy a new one' ETC

Having seen the type of fraud that happens to people on a regular basis I am inclined to agree with the banks. I am happy to know my money won't just be handed over to anyone should I lose my bank card or be victim of identity theft.

conorsrockers · 26/01/2014 13:36

This happened to my mother in law a while back - it's fortunate they did ask her as she was being ripped off by some unscrupulous gents for 'fixing' her drive way. The bank called the police and the police took her home and sorted it out Grin However, I would go bat shit if my bank questioned me ... but I've never drawn large amounts of cash - I always do bank transfers so I can prove transactions. £6k cash to a builder sounds dodgy. I am sure Her Maj would be more interested than your bank ....

JadedAngel · 26/01/2014 12:08

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

nauticant · 26/01/2014 09:50

OK, FootieOnTheTelly my argument is that just because you've never needed £1000 in cash, it doesn't mean that no one else could possibly have the need of £1000 in cash.

Once this is understood, then putting this together with the HSBC climb-down showing that they were refusing to hand over large sums in cash simply because they didn't want to, it follows that it is unreasonable for a bank to refuse to hand over, say, £1000 in cash without an objective reason beyond the fact that is doesn't suit the bank.

Paintyfingers · 26/01/2014 08:13

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Objection · 26/01/2014 07:42

switch to Halifax.
You fill out an online form and the do everything else. (seriously EVERYTHING)
They'll also give you £100 for switching and £5 a month after that.

I was in love with Halifax after my switch and then we had our mortgage with them and they sent us a parcel with wine, chocolates and a tool set as a welcome!!!!

Bloody LOVE halifax!

innisglas · 26/01/2014 04:24

Sorry if I am mentioning something that has already been said, but HSBC are notorious money-launderers for Mexican drug lords and terrorists. I'm referring to cases where this bank has been found guilty. I think they are trying to prove that anti-money laundering regularions are not enforceable.

EmmelineGoulden · 26/01/2014 01:25

"It may be your money but it's their bank"

I don't understand this as justification at all. If I park my car it may be NCPs car park, but that doesn't mean they should be entitled to demand to know (with documentary evidence!) where I'm driving to before they will release my car. The dry cleaner isn't entitled to see my next black tie invitation before they give me my ball gown back. And the Ocado should not demand copies of my recipies before they will hand over the food I ordered.

FootieOnTheTelly · 26/01/2014 00:43

nauticant. Yeah, and being sarcastic to other posters rather than come up with your own valid arguments is one of my favourites. Hmm

foreverondiet · 25/01/2014 22:30

Maybe looking for tax avoidance? Money laundering? We have been paying builders by bank transfer - much easier than carrying cash around but obviously we are paying the vat.

PigletJohn · 25/01/2014 22:02

not that it matters, but when I last bought a car I used Fastpay to electronically transfer the funds to the seller's bank account.

I had already put a deposit on it in the same way, the day I viewed it, and the bank phoned or texted me (can't remember now) to make sure no-one had hacked my account. Having confirmed that, the big payment to the same account went through on demand.

If the seller had been a crook I would at least be able to prove that I had paid him.

nauticant · 25/01/2014 20:41

I can't think of a single occasion in my whole life where I have needed more than £1000 or so cash

Why-can't-everyone-in-the-world-be-like-me reasoning is my favourite.

sarine1 · 25/01/2014 20:39

I see that HSBC are now grovelling following the customer feedback (and media publicity):
"However, following feedback, we are immediately updating guidance to our customer facing staff to reiterate that it is not mandatory for customers to provide documentary evidence for large cash withdrawals, and on its own, failure to show evidence is not a reason to refuse a withdrawal.We are writing to apologise to any customer who has been given incorrect information and inconvenienced."

And quite right too. I know on this thread there are a number of bank employees (and others) stating that this was a fine and acceptable policy which really amazed me. Glad to see the bank's U turn in the face of public feedback.

JackNoneReacher · 25/01/2014 20:36

I'm happy to go along with things that increase security. But how does telling the bank how I'm going to spend my money increase security?

Especially if all I have to say is "on a pair of golden shoes"?

How will that increase security or stop money laundering?

I recently withdrew £5k to buy a car. Didn't get asked what it was for but phoning in advance meant they had it ready.

FootieOnTheTelly · 25/01/2014 20:18

Well I don't see it as an 'actual problem'. Hmm I am happy to go along with things that increase security. It's a bit like when my credit card gets blocked due to unusual spending - it's inconvenient but I would rather that than risk card fraud.

I can't think of a single occasion in my whole life where I have needed more than £1000 or so cash. I don't pay anyone especially builders cash and would use bank to bank transfer if anyone needed instant cash.

It may be your money but it's their bank Confused. There are other banks or underneaths of mattresses

honeycrest · 25/01/2014 19:30

I don't know anyone could see this as 'not an actual problem'. The banks have no right to deny someone access to their OWN money. It's none of their business what they are spending it on.

I find it ironic that is is HSBC implementing this rule. The same bank that was actively involved in laundering money for drug cartels.

www.forbes.com/sites/nathanvardi/2012/12/12/forget-the-drug-dealers-and-iran-hsbc-is-having-a-great-year/

TootlesPootles · 25/01/2014 18:36

I listened to MoneyBox and wondered if the OP was one of the people interviewed. Grin

I still don't get the anger over this - I get that it's annoying but not that it's an actual problem.

I noticed that the panel all thought that getting money out to pay builders in CASH was to avoid paying tax Confused

NetworkGuy · 25/01/2014 13:16

Just a matter of "interpretation" I suspect, some having guidance more strict than others :)

Thanks for the BBC link.