Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

about Food Tech? And the cost?

82 replies

AlwaysInBed · 18/11/2013 19:10

I think Food Tech is way too expensive.

DD's first term of doing Food Tech (she missed a term and a half of school last year, due to a serious illness, so missed a term of Food Tech) is next term. Today we got sent out the recipes/ingredients osit (why now?) and we can't afford it, end of.

AIBU to think there should be a way of receiving financial support? Alternatively, in each class, every student pays in x amount and then people receiving (for example, FSM, tax credits, etc;) don't have to pay as much or anything.

There's £5 worth of ingredients, roughly, per project, and cooking is once every two weeks. How does that work out? I will end up having to get food off my mother, who's not exactly well off either, but for many people, their mother isn't an alternative. What do they do?

OP posts:
MayTheOddsBeEverInYourFavour · 19/11/2013 08:26

YANBU

the cost can be big and I know it might not seem a lot to some people but it's a real struggle for us

One time the ingredients list insisted on four chicken breasts as well as lot of other ingredients, it ended up costing about £15 and then it didn't get sent home so we couldn't eat it. That is a lot out of our weekly budget and while we didn't say anything to the dc it made things really difficult for us

waikikamookau · 19/11/2013 08:14

we are lucky in that case, the school provided most of the materials, at a cost of 50p, sometimes . occasionally i would have to provide mince, toms, but not costly and that may be due to the fact that dd forgot she had food tech.

bigTillyMint · 19/11/2013 08:11

We don't have to pay/buy anything apart from the odd raisins/nuts to jazz up the standard recipe for their final project. Which is just as well as I don't get to see/eat any of it as they scoff it down before they get home!

heronsfly · 19/11/2013 08:09

I dont think any of us are suggesting that £2.50 per week/fortnight is not manageable .
But, like Saggy i have had one list that cost around £20 and ingredients normally work out at about ten pounds, and yes I do buy morrisons own when possible dd peels the labels off

IdreamofFairies · 18/11/2013 22:15

My ds cooks in school he enjoys it and tbh it doesn't really cost that much. If he makes a meal that's what we have for dinner, stretched out if its not enough bulked up with other things. i make a big deal about him having made the dinner himself and it has done wonders for his self esteem.

i cant see how either of the examples you have given cost anywhere near £5 to make. surely if you know whats coming you can budget the ingredients buying them gradually.

NearTheWindmill · 18/11/2013 22:06

So are you saying a fiver a fortnight? She's your daughter - can you rustle up a fiver for a bottle of wine? Do you smoke? Could you get a job during school hours? Could she get a job/babysitting, etc.

It's a small amount of money towards preparing her for a GCSE. What would you do if she was musical and needed to learn to play an instrument?

I think this is so so sad.

AlwaysInBed · 18/11/2013 21:54

I don't know. Most of the meals (from some friends who are doing their term this year- it's rotating, she does DT one term, FT next term, Computer and Photography stuff the last term, and there's all different orders so some do FT now etc;) seem to be stuff like sausage rolls, rock cakes etc; but there are still weeks to go. It's £5 per meal or so, not £2.50 iyswim, ey have a prep lesson, a making lesson, a prep lesson etc; and I just think that £5 just seems a lot for one meal.

I will try to get her to team up but I know she'd be embarrassed too. But, tbh, I think not having the ingredients would be more embarrassing! Thanks for the (hopeful) solution. I don't know their parents but she has some very strong friends who she trusts with everything practically, so I'm sure she will find someone Thanks

OP posts:
SoonToBeSix · 18/11/2013 21:22

I don't think £2.50 a week is a lot tbh especially because you get to eat the food afterwards.

WooWooOwl · 18/11/2013 21:07

We share with two other people in the class as well, makes it much easier. You need to get your dd to team up with someone in her class that's reliable. Although relying on someone else comes with it's own problems, so need to choose people wisely!

ReallyTired · 18/11/2013 21:04

I have found the answer is to team up with a friend to buy the ingredients.
I find it frustrating that all the ingredients have to be weighed/ measured out at home.

I don't think that £5 every two weeks is that unreasonable. Its part of the cost of bringing up a child. To put it into proportion £2.50 is the cost of one school dinner and often your child will bring home a meal that will feed a family. (Certainly the case at our school)

CrohnicallyTired · 18/11/2013 20:32

Saggy- I guess that is a clear instance of where buying in bulk would be an advantage! Presumably, a jar of each spice would have been enough for the whole class to do the curry!

SaggyOldClothCatPuss · 18/11/2013 20:27

You still have to buy the ingredients though. The chicken curry I mentioned had 17 ingredients. Most of them were herbs and spices which come in jars. I had to buy the jars regardless of how much was sent in.

iHateMrTumble · 18/11/2013 20:13

What about sending her with smaller portions of the same to just make smaller meals?
or speaking to other parents if you know any others in the class about maybe each family providing for every other lesson and splitting the portions between two pupils?
Most meals are doable by halving all of the ingredients same techniques for prep and cooking.

SaggyOldClothCatPuss · 18/11/2013 20:10

YANBU! I've told this story before on here, but our record spend was about £27 for chicken curry ingredients!! Which then went to waste because the teacher was absent for the 7th time that term, and the ingredients were lugged round school on a hot summers day!
The final straw was when DD cooked chilli con carne. Again I forked out for the ingredients, again it went into the bin. This time because it was cooked first thing in the morning, the rice was added to the meat and the whole lot was left to fester, hot, in Tupperware containers under a desk in the food tech lab for the entire day! I went absolutely SPARE!
I sent a stinking email to the school listing at least 5 different types of food poisoning that could be caught from this meal, how this was in breach of safe food hygiene regulations, that maybe the teacher needed to undergo further training if she didn't know better and that it might be worth the school reassessing their food hygiene practices before someone, me reported them to the EHO! AND, that DD would not be participating in any more food tech practical lessons, because I was sick of wasting money on food that was at best inedible and at worst dangerous!

AlwaysInBed · 18/11/2013 20:05

And thanks everyone. I don't want others to pay for me btw, I'm not a schoolworker, or have anything to do with school, and I am bumbling around, being a bit clueless. I just feel hurt for my DD, although my way of sorting it out would be unfair in others, I get it! I just want to help her (and I admit that this want probably makes me immune to common sense sometimes!) so thanks for bringing me back to Earth. I just want to do something, ifyswim.

OP posts:
Golddigger · 18/11/2013 20:05

Talk to the school. If you know other parents who are in the same class, see if they think the same as you.

But even if they dont, speak to school.
Even 20 years ago, I was surprised how much Food Tech cost. I can understand that there must be several parents who also think that the cost can just be too much.

thefirstmrsrochester · 18/11/2013 20:03

Like The Pink my dc pay a set amount each year. £20 I think. Then the school supply everything right down to the takeaway container to bring their offerings home in.
That alone is a saving tupperware boxes going adrift in school.

AlwaysInBed · 18/11/2013 20:03

I don't know, we thought we were. Was it non compulsory? We paid in. Sorry for my mistake.

I just don't want my child to be barred from a subject which is compulsory in our school (whether it is optional or not nationwide?).

Sorry for wrong information, o obviously got the wrong end of the stick there. We paid into something to do something - I don't regret it or anything, just wish I didn't look like a complete idiot on here Grin

OP posts:
cece · 18/11/2013 20:01

I don't get it. DD does home economics. Most of the ingredients she has needed so far are standard ones I would have in my cupboard anyway. Occasionally I have to buy one or two things to add to it but not always.

uselessinformation · 18/11/2013 19:56

after paying a lot for ingredients and a squashed mess coming home I wrote to the school to say that ds would cook the food tech meals at home and to give him theory work in class. He cooked the meals at home and I took photographs.

Chocovore · 18/11/2013 19:51

But for your £3, you get a meal for 2? Doesn't sound too bad to me.

WooWooOwl · 18/11/2013 19:51

Things like this are reasons why using FSM as a marker of which children need financial support in the form of the pupil premium is ridiculously unfair.

Buying in bulk and paying a smaller amount would work well for parents, but isn't really fair on the teacher that has to do the shopping after they've finished work for the day.

On the whole, I think parents should just deal with it and pay for these things. Children cost money, and parents have a responsibility to pay for the things they need for their education. But if some children get their ingredients for free, then all children should get them for free.

HappyMummyOfOne · 18/11/2013 19:50

OP, no other parent subsidises any other child on trips, the school are not allowed to make a profit and have to show how they calculated the cost per child. If there is a shortfall from non payers the school decide if they can stand the cost or cancel the trip.

ThePinkOcelot · 18/11/2013 19:49

I dreaded this when dd went to secondary, but they charge £15 for the year and the ingredients is provided. Its definitely worth £15 I think. I think all schools should adopt this policy.

HappyMummyOfOne · 18/11/2013 19:48

Why should everyone else pay but you dont? Children come with costs and home ec has always had ingredients to buy. Its like for some people having to actually pay any of their childs costs is simply awful Hmm