Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

about Food Tech? And the cost?

82 replies

AlwaysInBed · 18/11/2013 19:10

I think Food Tech is way too expensive.

DD's first term of doing Food Tech (she missed a term and a half of school last year, due to a serious illness, so missed a term of Food Tech) is next term. Today we got sent out the recipes/ingredients osit (why now?) and we can't afford it, end of.

AIBU to think there should be a way of receiving financial support? Alternatively, in each class, every student pays in x amount and then people receiving (for example, FSM, tax credits, etc;) don't have to pay as much or anything.

There's £5 worth of ingredients, roughly, per project, and cooking is once every two weeks. How does that work out? I will end up having to get food off my mother, who's not exactly well off either, but for many people, their mother isn't an alternative. What do they do?

OP posts:
Groovee · 19/11/2013 15:19

Oh and they have fridges, the class leave them to cool and the teacher pops them in the fridge once they are cool. If they don't collect they get a punishment exercise and if it happens again a phone call home.

Dd worried about doing Home Ec because of the cost but her dad and I told her that was our worry and not hers. Usually manage to save £1 coins in a piggy bank over the term for the following term.

Groovee · 19/11/2013 15:14

We pay £25 in first year for our children. They cook once a fortnight, get all containers and ingredients included in that. Head of year says she regrets having to charge but on the little amount of money the department gets, she could offer a wide variety of cooking such as fajita's, soup, baking, bolognaise.

Dd has taken it as a choice (S2 chose subjects this year) and it's £22 a term. She cooks/bakes twice a week. I'm very impressed with how much actual cooking she's done like chili, carbonara, quiche, soup, pasties as well as tarts, cakes, scones. All containers to bring it home is included.

I'm pretty shocked at what I've heard others say about their child being asked to take ingredients in and in some cases ready made fajita's packs etc. My dd's school teach from scratch and what spices to use etc.

cashmiriana · 19/11/2013 15:11

At DD's school everything is stored in fridges and they deliver food to the food tech dept before school and collect it at 3.15

I would object to bulk purchasing because as a strictly vegetarian family we'd end up subsidising meat eaters, and I wouldn't be able to check that every ingredient was suitable. As DD always adapted recipes to suit our diet, it rarely cost much for us to supply what she needed, and if something wasn't suitable / too expensive / not to our tastes, she took slightly different ingredients. She also changed the recipe if she thought it needed it based on mine and DH's 54 years of veggie cooking between us!)

heronsfly · 19/11/2013 15:11

My dd wont deviate from the printed sheet either, although Im not sure if thats the schools instructions or just normal 'teenage girl cant be different from anyone else attitude'
To be fair to our school,food tech is the last two periods of the day and if her and her friends havent scoffed the lot on the way home we do normally eat what she makes with a few exemptions but i dont reheat.

Gileswithachainsaw · 19/11/2013 15:00
Shock

Seriously every chef on tv say to check seasoning/add more lemon/sugar/cream or whatever to taste!! There's natural variation with ingredients it's never as simple as 1tsp with seasoning you add it to taste. Ffs.

Ticktock80 · 19/11/2013 14:57

In my day, the school bought everything and we paid 50p or whatever to cover costs. That way everyone had the same. Tis was in 1996 though.

TantrumsAndBalloons · 19/11/2013 14:57

It wasn't part of the printed instructions, you see. Apparently using your own initiative is frowned on in food tech. You may not variate from the printed instructions.

She snuck a bay leaf into her sausage casserole as well. That got her marked down on her work.

She doesn't do food tech anymore.

Gileswithachainsaw · 19/11/2013 14:52

A detention? Seriously? Ffs. Seasoning meat lands a detention. I'm speechless

TantrumsAndBalloons · 19/11/2013 14:50

I would just like to add that I would never eat anything that ds1 or dd cooked at school so you don't actually get a family meal for £2.50.
They are both good cooks, they regularly cook dinner at home.
But the food at school sits in their bag for an entire day.
And they cannot add any extra ingredients to it, to make it taste nice. My dd got a detention because she seasoned her chicken the night before. This was not part of the recipie

Gileswithachainsaw · 19/11/2013 14:49

Can u use skinless/boneless chicken thighs? Be cheaper.

Gileswithachainsaw · 19/11/2013 14:48

It depends really. I would only pay if a) - they had storage for it. So the stuff can be refrigerated properly.

And b)- that it's something edible. I wouldn't waste money on a meal blatantly thrown together using nothing but jars and packets. From that list to be honest it looks like maybe some kinda stir fry/sweet chilli chicken. Surely the noodles would be better cooked at home. That doesn't look a recipe tbh that would suit being kept and re heated. What's wrong with teaching a shepherds pie or a chili or a chicken and veg pie or cakes and biscuits. A curry perhaps where tbh if you can't afford to supply exotic additions you can sub with carrots or potato or cans of chick peas.

heronsfly · 19/11/2013 14:36

Yes Shona, thats exactly what I'm going to do Grin and I think i've got a slightly aged garlic clove left from the last lot too
I wouldn't get any assistance as working full time, minimum wage topped up with wtc.and I certainly dont expect other parents to contribute towards my childs ingredients, I just wish the schools would choose slightly more 'budget' menus, maybe with something more exotic once a term.

Shonajoy · 19/11/2013 14:08

If you can adjust the items included, can't you adjust the quantities? I'd send her with enough chicken to serve one.

Inertia · 19/11/2013 14:04

I think you should talk to the school and explain that you cannot afford to provide this food. If your child is allocated Pupil Premium (I think this applies to children who have been registered for free school meals within the last 6 years) , then this is exactly the sort of thing that pupil premium should be used to pay for.

heronsfly · 19/11/2013 13:59

Here is this weeks list of ingredients needed by dd3, I have left off the herbs and spices as most of them I have had to buy on other occasions, and she dosent like pine nuts so have left them out too.

300-500 g of fresh chopped chicken breast.
1 onion.
1 Leek.
1 garlic clove.
2 carrots.
2 large tomatoes
1 bottle/sachet of sweet chilli sauce.
1 bag of fresh rice or egg noodles.
1 small bottle of oil for cooking.

I cant see that coming to much less than ten pounds
And its not pay day till next Monday Grin

Shonajoy · 19/11/2013 11:49

Don't know if they had fridges at their school- they dropped food science a couple of years ago. As for eating what they made for lunch, it depends when their class is, am or pm, and also what they'd made- cake not great for lunch.

Pearlsaplenty · 19/11/2013 11:33

These threads always surprise me. We never paid anything (I think the food was delivered in bulk) and there was never any problem with food going bad as we collected it from the class at the end of the day so it was refrigerated if necessary (teacher was always there for collection). Seemed so simple!

vj32 · 19/11/2013 10:31

Ay my school they have big fridges to store pupil's creations and cook a variety of things, not just cakes. So the food can be safely taken home and eaten. I would check this out with the school though as I know some don't. £5 for a meal that can be eaten safely at home is very different to food that has to be eaten at school or thrown away.

And on the school trip thing about subsidising - maybe the rules have changed but when I last organised a trip some parents did end up paying for others. Theoretically the shortfall should come from school funds but what school has spare money to subsidise a trip, even if its a really education one? Any profit would be paid back to parents but I was told I had to allow extra in the money charged to parents to pay for any that wouldn't/couldn't pay.

mrsjay · 19/11/2013 09:19

well it depends what period they cook really , and tbh some of it is rank,

AnotherWorld · 19/11/2013 09:18

Why wouldn't they eat what they cooked at school as lunch? That way there's no lugging it around half hot and festering - and it would save the cost of a school lunch.

(Mine are still primary age so the wild world of secondary school is a mystery to me)

mrsjay · 19/11/2013 09:12

shona dd get to keep her cooking in class in her early years i didnt eat them cos they looked like they had been poked Grin but i taste it now but 1st 2nd year nah i didnt touch it

mrsjay · 19/11/2013 09:10

why dont you call the school and ask if there is another way you can pay what age is your dd I dont understand how it is compulsary but if she is in a junior year then I can see why . fwiw dd has always done food tech so i have paid a lot of money int he last 5 years but it is a one off payment and the children who have not paid still get to cook just not what they payers get to cook, I was £50 the start of term you need to find out the recipies she will be doing and see if you can buy in bulk

Idontknowhowtohelpher · 19/11/2013 09:03

dd2 in Year 7 did fresh fruit salad - she was asked to bring in at least 6 types of fruit with two being "exotic" - that was expensive! and they ate it at school...

Shonajoy · 19/11/2013 08:30

Must be different here in Scotland ours don't make big proper meals, just individual servings.

Shonajoy · 19/11/2013 08:29

I don't think it's fair to suggest subsidising people- what if most of the kids parents get tax credits? That's one of my pet hates mind you- BIL is very very wealthy and the rest of the family think he should pay for all meals out, etc. I don't think it's fair, so we take turns, only eating at expensive places if he chooses.

I'm surprised at people managing to eat any of the results either- by the time we get them home they've been in a Tupperware container in a backpack for any amount of time.

Swipe left for the next trending thread