Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think that using peer humiliation as a punishment for a quiet, sensitive child at the start of Year 7 is very bad practice by the school?

461 replies

pippalonglegs · 01/11/2013 13:21

Oh, I need help and advice please. I'm hurting so much for my DS that I can't think about anything else. Please bear with me - it's a story.

Basically, in a drama class the children were split into boys v girls. The boys started giggling and got themselves into a position in which they became helplessly unable to stop laughing. DS commented to his buddy that it was 'as if they were all on drugs'. Teacher (probably stressed) overheard, took exception to the comment and issued a detention. DS came home seeming so sad and withdrawn and was very upset. He told me about the detention and subsequently I emailed the school (Monday), taking great care not to take sides, simply in order to understand what had happened from teacher's point of view. On Tuesday she called me, and left a voicemail in which she said that DS had 'shouted out a completely inappropriate comment'.

I had no contact telephone number so emailed again (Tues) and explained that even prior to this, DS had been struggling with high school transition and was feeling sad to the point of really not wanting to go to school, and might perhaps benefit more from an alternative approach. I asked if we might talk about the detention before it went ahead. She didn't reply on the Tuesday, the Wednesday or the Thursday - in other words, she completely ignored/dismissed my concerns - and instead simply sent him home with a detention slip for the Friday. Of course I was furious, not least because my sensible and genuine concerns had been completely ignored, and I felt I'd been treated as a stupid, interfering parent.

But then the full picture emerged. I happened to be speaking to another parent who told me she had been very shocked to hear what had happened to DS, although initially I didn't fully understand what she meant. Her child gave an account (unprompted by me, I should add) that was identical to DS's. She said that nobody had even heard his comment (which in my opinion merely illustrated a mature understanding of the potential impact of drugs anyway) and that it was only the teacher flying off the handle that caused any interest in it. But - and this is the significant bit - it also transpired from this third party account that DS had been made to stand facing the wall until the end of lesson, and was at that point given the detention. And that was the bit that crushed me. DS is the most gentle, kind and sensitive of boys, has never been in trouble before, and there could have been no need to subject him to that kind of humiliation in front of his peers. Detentions and discipline, yes - but peer humiliation, most definitely no!!!

Suddenly it all made sense. No wonder he had come home from school so upset. And the thing that really distressed me was that he had felt so much shame and humiliation that he hadn't even been able to tell me about it. My heart broke for him. Little wonder that he was unwilling to go back into school to face his peers. Personally, I felt that such a punishment merely lacked a cap with a big 'D' on the front - a punishment more suited to 1913 than 2013.

I set about researching the pathogenic effects and the damage of peer humiliation (which has a profound impact on cognitive development and behaviour in children). Armed with the evidence, I emailed the head teacher with a formal grievance (the substantive points of which were 1. the failure of the teacher to engage with me and 2. the humiliation punishment that was used). That was acknowledged by the head, who said he would appoint his deputy (also the head of pastoral care) to investiagte, and would then meet with me to discuss the matter.

The deputy called me yesterday and Oh. My. God!!!! It has been a long, long time since I've spoken to anybody who was so bloody-minded and unintelligent. In spite of promises by the head, he refused to have a meeting with me, although I asked repeatedly if we could sit down to talk about my complaint. Every time I asked, his parrotted reply was that he 'would not normally meet with a parent to discuss a detention'. It didn't matter how many times I repeated that the detention was the least of my concerns, he wouldn't listen. In the end I even said that I felt like Jeremy Paxman and I said I wanted a straight answer to a straight question - but his reply was the same again!!!

In the end, I said I would redial and speak to the head, which I duly did. Of course, in the intervening minutes, the deputy had skidded down the corridor to forewarn the head and the head was, initially at least, every bit as hostile. We spoke for about ten minutes, most of which was decidedly heated, and I have to say, most (though by no means all) of the anger came from him not me! Clearly, he was unused to being challenged by a parent and he didn't like it at all. I felt his attitude was autocratic, verging on imperialistic - and told him so!! He actually told me that DS wasn't made to stand facing the wall, he was made to stand at the edge of the room, looking away from the class group!! Oh dear. Talk about semantics!!! Paradoxically, his refusal to accept that DS had been made to stand facing the wall seems clearly to indicate that he knew how unacceptable that would have been. I said that kind of ducking and diving, that kind of manipulation was fundamentally dishonest and slippery and wouldn't play out at all well in the press.

At about that point, we had a u-turn and he invited me in to see him on Monday for a cup of tea and a biscuit.

Basically, it would help me to know if anybody else has had a similar experience. I have the meeting next Monday and would really like to know what options I have/don't have. DS is really suffering and has lost a lot of confidence and self-esteem since this incident. I think it's something that he will carry around with him for the rest of his life.

OP posts:
AreWeThereYetttttt · 29/03/2022 07:57

I remember this punishment from my school days! To be fair if never bothered me or most in my class but none of us were sensitive or easily embarrassed around each other (it was a very small school so classes were all pretty close).

I can see why a particularly sensitive child in a large class wouldn't like it though.

I would however stop making such a fuss (going to the press!? Surely that would be more embarrassing for your son!

Sparklingbrook · 29/03/2022 07:48

I think you need to answer yourself 2 questions.

I need to know why you'd reanimate such an old thread.

comealongponds · 29/03/2022 07:44

@Yesiknowyes

The child in question will be about 20 now so I’d guess he’s over it

BurntEnds · 29/03/2022 07:25

This is a very old thread

Yesiknowyes · 29/03/2022 07:23

I mean it was the first time it happened*

Yesiknowyes · 29/03/2022 07:22

I think you need to answer yourself 2 questions.
Did your son behave appropriately? Answer is No.
Was it the first time it happened? Or it happens regularly and unfairly to your son? No.
I’m saying it like a mother of a very sensitive child. We will have to learn to live in the real world, both us and our sensitive children. We need to teach them to reuse the waves, to accept negative events and consequences, to be emotionally resilient. Because it gets worse and worse later on. It seems like you’ve never learned to be emotionally resilient and I don’t blame you, I’m not either. But we need to change the attitude and help our children to face this kind of events with emotional resilience.

ShirakawaKaede · 05/11/2013 19:31

Pippa, your son did nothing wrong, and having been in his position at a similar age, I sympathize. I'd have perhaps just said to DS "do not go to your detention, I don't believe you've done anything worthy of punishment" - and I'd make it clear to the school that I had no intention of making him go. I expect I'd have been as angry as you were, too - especially with the hair-splitting over whether he was standing in the corner or not (nice derailing by the headmaster there!)! Too often, it is the quieter, less confident children who end up getting punished for reacting to the poor behaviour of others, and often children take advantage of that. It's the same for my sister (who has asperger's), and no doubt she is not alone in this. These things do knock your confidence. It takes time to heal. Are there any particular children in his class he is close to? One staunch friend can make all the difference!

ShellyF · 05/11/2013 17:42

Sorry Forfawkes I was refering to OP.
Sorry your son has had such a rough time.

ShellyF · 05/11/2013 17:40

Thought Head had invited her in for tea and biscuits:-)

fivefourthreetwoone · 05/11/2013 16:00

Standing against the wall until the end of the thread.

Grin
BadLad · 05/11/2013 12:42

where's op gone???

Standing against the wall until the end of the thread.

cory · 05/11/2013 11:44

And by Yr 7, a child should be quite old enough to realise that the teacher is a person too, that disrupting her lesson and then taunting her with it is humiliating her in public. Far more so than a boy surrounded by his peers and egging them on to laugh at her lesson is likely to be humiliated by being made to turn his face away from them.

cory · 05/11/2013 11:41

I am all for listening to children. But why do we need to listen more to the children who like giggling and disrupting a lesson than to the ones who would like to get on with the class?

To my mind it isn't about mindless respect for adults. It's about intelligent respect for your peers, realising that you are not the only pupil in the class and that your viewpoint is not the only one that matters.

fwiw I have a giggler. The school put him on report last year. I approve whole-heartedly. He needs to learn that other people matter as much as he does, even if they are quiet and well behaved.

Bea · 05/11/2013 00:03

where's op gone???

ForFawkesSakeNoGuyForSolo · 04/11/2013 23:32

ILove he is hoping to go to a 6th form college rather than another school. I'll support whatever he wants as long as he's studying and happy.
I hope things for your Dd continue to improve :)

Biscuits Shelly? Confused

ShellyF · 04/11/2013 19:12

Hope the biscuits were nice.

IloveJudgeJudy · 04/11/2013 14:10

For I think sometimes you just have to be the adult and do something, even if your DS doesn't want you to.

DD was bullied a lot at school (she's now y12 and all is well, on the bullying front, anyway). We didn't know about much of it, as she kept it quiet and also when we did know, she mostly didn't want us to do anything, so we didn't. That was our mistake. She has now suffering some MH problems, leading to attempted suicide Sad. This is being dealt with and she is having some good therapy, but her problems have been traced back to the bullying she suffered. I really, really wish we could turn back the clock. I definitely would complain at the first sign and not leave it. DD thought she could deal with it on her own, but she couldn't.

By the way, if your DS is Y11, he could change schools for Y12? That's what DD has done and it has done her a world of good.

Apologies for the thread derail, it's just that I feel very passionately about this subject.

ForFawkesSakeNoGuyForSolo · 04/11/2013 12:00

My Ds has been bullied since yr 7 and in yr 11 it still continues not just by some of his peers, but by his form teacher! Ds has always asked me not to get involved until recently when another boy (also being bullied by the teacher) decided to lodge a complaint along with his parent/s, but before I got to do it, Ds said that the teacher had quashed the other boys complaint by something he brought up (made the boy feel small), so we felt that it wasn't worth doing without having someone else to back up the allegation. There are three boys that are habitually picked on, made fun of and treated appallingly by this one adult that should know better imo.

I don't like to make waves with anything, but I get more angry with each day of pain that Ds suffers.

I once complained when Ds was stabbed 4 times in the back with a drawing compass, the same teacher as above did nothing about it, so I brought it up with the head of year and despite assuring me that it would be dealt with, it wasn't! one of those stab points was very close to Ds's spinal cord.

I, as a parent have no confidence in the school to protect my son and the teachers smile nicely at parents evening, but do I trust them? no I do not. I just tell Ds to use the teachers to gain knowledge, pass exams and do well in life, that's enough to thumb nose them even if they never know it.
Some teachers I think, take great pleasure in humiliating young people who cannot or will not stand up for themselves and I do think that depending on the type of personality the child has, it can affect them badly, though some kids laugh it off. Some though can't and it stays with them. I don't believe though, in making a mountain out of a molehill and I do think that children have to learn to weather the storm sometimes and if they have a loving family, I'm sure they will come out OK. Ds will not stay on at school though and I find that a bit sad and that is down to his experience at the school, not his lack of interest in learning.

mitchsta · 04/11/2013 11:38

I do think you're overreacting, but I also think he only needed one punishment and if he was made to stand away from the class at the time, he doesn't need the detention too.

I can't tell if your DS is genuinely distressed by this or if you think he's upset but actually he didn't tell you in the first place because he knew how you'd react.

If it's the former, I'd say he needs to learn that these things happen. I was really well-behaved as a child and quite shy and I still remember being made to face the wall aged 6 - a massive overreaction to the situation at the time - especially given my age. I later discovered the teacher was going through a divorce at that time and vented her out on all her pupils, so I'm just glad that for me it was a one-off and I wasn't one of the naughty ones! I still remember it vividly, but it hasn't emotionally scarred me - just made me realise that she was a total cow.

If it's the latter - your DS knew you'd overreact / call the school / insist on meeting the head teacher - then perhaps you need to give him some space to make his own mistakes, accept whatever punishment is given and move on. Like I said, it doesn't sound to me like both punishments were necessary, but I can think of nothing worse than my mum flouncing up to school to negotiate my way out of a detention for me. Worse than the punishment itself if you ask me - and definitely more humiliating.

HandbagCrazy · 04/11/2013 11:11

I hope I'm not posting this too late. When I was in year 7, a bully had a go at me and pushed me over. When I got back up and retaliated, a teacher saw me and I got in trouble. I told my parents and my mother was so incensed by how unfair it was she spoke to the head and came to the school to speak to him about it.
Being told off by the teacher in front of my peers and doing a detention was fine. Forever being that pupil who's mother 'stormed into school to tell off the head teacher' made my life in school a lot harder than it could have been.
You've raised your concerns to the school but asking for him to get different punishments from teachers is going to make him stand out and make his school life hard. If he's already sensitive, having a mum who gets overly involved will make him a target. Let him do his detention and learn on his own

soverylucky · 04/11/2013 10:15

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

VenusDeWillendorf · 04/11/2013 10:10

I think you need a mediator to figure out what you need, and more especially what your DS needs from the school.

You may well have to change schools, if he is so sensitive, he may blossom in a less regimented environment.

Sometimes it's better to have a extra curricular classes where you have vetted the teachers personally and not in the school.

I feel for you, as you are obviously very upset.

I wonder if your DS is picking up your upset?
It's difficult to remember that he is in the school, and you are not, so doing what's best for him is essential.

I hope you get a satisfactory resolution for your DS.

HelloLA · 04/11/2013 09:59

How this would 'play' with the press:

  1. A Beattie Johnson type will be very sympathetic about your plight.
  2. A sadface photo will be taken.
  3. You will be in a Daily Fail hatchet job article about helicopter parents/the parlous lack of parental support for school discipline/the youth of today, tut tut.
Strumpetron · 03/11/2013 23:21

Oh yes poor son having to stand facing a wall because he was being cheeky Hmm how will he ever cope.

The only thing that's going to 'scar him for life' as the OP said is her reaction to the whole thing. Good grief.

fluffypillow · 03/11/2013 23:14

I really feel for you and your Son. The only advice I would give you for when you meet the Head is to keep it relevant and get straight to the point. Try not to get emotional, and make it clear what you expect to happen from here on in.

Also, tell him you are going to follow the meeting up with a letter outlining what was discussed, and what is promised. In my experience, putting it in writting has a much better outcome.

Good luck.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread