Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think that using peer humiliation as a punishment for a quiet, sensitive child at the start of Year 7 is very bad practice by the school?

461 replies

pippalonglegs · 01/11/2013 13:21

Oh, I need help and advice please. I'm hurting so much for my DS that I can't think about anything else. Please bear with me - it's a story.

Basically, in a drama class the children were split into boys v girls. The boys started giggling and got themselves into a position in which they became helplessly unable to stop laughing. DS commented to his buddy that it was 'as if they were all on drugs'. Teacher (probably stressed) overheard, took exception to the comment and issued a detention. DS came home seeming so sad and withdrawn and was very upset. He told me about the detention and subsequently I emailed the school (Monday), taking great care not to take sides, simply in order to understand what had happened from teacher's point of view. On Tuesday she called me, and left a voicemail in which she said that DS had 'shouted out a completely inappropriate comment'.

I had no contact telephone number so emailed again (Tues) and explained that even prior to this, DS had been struggling with high school transition and was feeling sad to the point of really not wanting to go to school, and might perhaps benefit more from an alternative approach. I asked if we might talk about the detention before it went ahead. She didn't reply on the Tuesday, the Wednesday or the Thursday - in other words, she completely ignored/dismissed my concerns - and instead simply sent him home with a detention slip for the Friday. Of course I was furious, not least because my sensible and genuine concerns had been completely ignored, and I felt I'd been treated as a stupid, interfering parent.

But then the full picture emerged. I happened to be speaking to another parent who told me she had been very shocked to hear what had happened to DS, although initially I didn't fully understand what she meant. Her child gave an account (unprompted by me, I should add) that was identical to DS's. She said that nobody had even heard his comment (which in my opinion merely illustrated a mature understanding of the potential impact of drugs anyway) and that it was only the teacher flying off the handle that caused any interest in it. But - and this is the significant bit - it also transpired from this third party account that DS had been made to stand facing the wall until the end of lesson, and was at that point given the detention. And that was the bit that crushed me. DS is the most gentle, kind and sensitive of boys, has never been in trouble before, and there could have been no need to subject him to that kind of humiliation in front of his peers. Detentions and discipline, yes - but peer humiliation, most definitely no!!!

Suddenly it all made sense. No wonder he had come home from school so upset. And the thing that really distressed me was that he had felt so much shame and humiliation that he hadn't even been able to tell me about it. My heart broke for him. Little wonder that he was unwilling to go back into school to face his peers. Personally, I felt that such a punishment merely lacked a cap with a big 'D' on the front - a punishment more suited to 1913 than 2013.

I set about researching the pathogenic effects and the damage of peer humiliation (which has a profound impact on cognitive development and behaviour in children). Armed with the evidence, I emailed the head teacher with a formal grievance (the substantive points of which were 1. the failure of the teacher to engage with me and 2. the humiliation punishment that was used). That was acknowledged by the head, who said he would appoint his deputy (also the head of pastoral care) to investiagte, and would then meet with me to discuss the matter.

The deputy called me yesterday and Oh. My. God!!!! It has been a long, long time since I've spoken to anybody who was so bloody-minded and unintelligent. In spite of promises by the head, he refused to have a meeting with me, although I asked repeatedly if we could sit down to talk about my complaint. Every time I asked, his parrotted reply was that he 'would not normally meet with a parent to discuss a detention'. It didn't matter how many times I repeated that the detention was the least of my concerns, he wouldn't listen. In the end I even said that I felt like Jeremy Paxman and I said I wanted a straight answer to a straight question - but his reply was the same again!!!

In the end, I said I would redial and speak to the head, which I duly did. Of course, in the intervening minutes, the deputy had skidded down the corridor to forewarn the head and the head was, initially at least, every bit as hostile. We spoke for about ten minutes, most of which was decidedly heated, and I have to say, most (though by no means all) of the anger came from him not me! Clearly, he was unused to being challenged by a parent and he didn't like it at all. I felt his attitude was autocratic, verging on imperialistic - and told him so!! He actually told me that DS wasn't made to stand facing the wall, he was made to stand at the edge of the room, looking away from the class group!! Oh dear. Talk about semantics!!! Paradoxically, his refusal to accept that DS had been made to stand facing the wall seems clearly to indicate that he knew how unacceptable that would have been. I said that kind of ducking and diving, that kind of manipulation was fundamentally dishonest and slippery and wouldn't play out at all well in the press.

At about that point, we had a u-turn and he invited me in to see him on Monday for a cup of tea and a biscuit.

Basically, it would help me to know if anybody else has had a similar experience. I have the meeting next Monday and would really like to know what options I have/don't have. DS is really suffering and has lost a lot of confidence and self-esteem since this incident. I think it's something that he will carry around with him for the rest of his life.

OP posts:
JammieCodger · 01/11/2013 16:44

No-one is saying that teachers' actions should be beyond question; we are saying that in this case the parent is overreacting.

VerySmallSqueak · 01/11/2013 16:38

I also have memories of unfair punishments at school Brodicea.

And my Mum used to call them on it.

For that she still has my complete respect.

I cannot understand where some people on this thread think that a teachers actions are beyond question.

That worries me,and disempowers our children.

TiredDog · 01/11/2013 16:36

shellyf Fri 01-Nov-13 15:34:10
IF this is true you could easily be identified.School staff are often members of mumsnet.If this is brought to the attention of the HT he will not be happy about you posting on an internet forum.Our parents are made aware that posting comments about staff online will be taken very seriously.

Mad as a box of frogs.
If this is for real then I guarantee you are the talk of the staffroom. And you should take note of ShellyF's comment above. In the same way that teachers are not allowed to post online about pupils and parents, it is entirely inappropriate for you to do the same about a member of staff. Particularly when you are mid way through a grievance procedure.

Curioushorse Fri 01-Nov-13 14:56:21
Ha ha ha! Hilarious. OP I'm assuming this is a joke

A few things about how schools work ....
I await your email to go viral on the TES message boards.

Interesting...

Brodicea · 01/11/2013 16:29

I think the teacher has been a bit of a shit and from the sounds of it, very unfair. I have memories of unfair punishments from school that still make me angry!

But, the fact that some people in power are unfair is a life lesson. I think you've taken it too far and are borderline helicopter parenting. You should have spent some time talking to DS about what happened saying, 'hey stuff like this happens all the time, it happened to me at school - teacher sounds like a tool but maybe they were flustered and you were the unlucky one to be made an example of' rather than getting all 'customer services' about it. Sounds like the other kids thought the teacher was an arse too, so they've only undermined themselves by being unfair.

That's my two-penneth.

LoreleisSecret · 01/11/2013 16:27

Your child is going to go through school being very entitled. Knowing he's untouchable to discipline from teachers due to mummy dearest swooping in with her cape and research.

Back off OP, you are doing your son more harm than good. He was in the wrong, get a hobby!

utreas · 01/11/2013 16:23

YABVU and ridiculously melodramatic

noblegiraffe · 01/11/2013 16:21

I don't bawl kids out, larry! A stern talking to is as bad as it gets.

JammieCodger · 01/11/2013 16:20

I wonder if your son was unwilling to tell you what had happened not because he was so traumatised by the event itself, but because he was dreading your response. I'd have been horrified if I'd thought my mother might ring my headteacher and accuse her of being autocratic and dishonest. Have you done this kind of thing before?

Tabliope · 01/11/2013 16:18

I don't have any problem with detentions being given out. You might think they're heavy handed sometimes but mostly it's not worth pursuing.

However, putting all of that aside, what would have annoyed me most is the teacher doesn't seem to have listened to you. She might be busy but it's still rude to ignore you. Likewise, I'm really surprised the deputy didn't want to meet with you. They might not think it would be productive but I think if a parent has requested a meeting it's a surprise not to be granted one. Why not hear you out? At least face to face some understanding of the situation could have been reached. All that's happened and what they've failed to head off is a situation that's got out of control with a parent threatening the press which I think is terribly bad management. They seem to think they're omnipotent and that you, the parent, have to toe the line, which I wouldn't be happy about. Yes, you might be a complete fruit cake but you should have been granted a meeting. Beyond what's happened to your son I'd be questioning that. A head that's hostile in order to put you in your box and cut you dead? To me, that's not a good head.

What has your son said has happened exactly? Was he actually facing a wall? I don't know what I think about this. My issue would be you've got a concern that you wanted to discuss with them and they haven't allowed it. They could have avoided this with a bit of better handling. All they've done is get a parent's back up.

larrygrylls · 01/11/2013 16:18

Noble,

Ok, point taken. I assumed from your first post that you were telling off a sobbing child in front of 29 other children. In private is a different matter.

By the way, from what I read of the OP, her son made a remark about out of control laughter to his mate, he was not laughing at other kids doing a performance. It seems quite a harmless comment to me, I have to say and a slight overreaction from the teacher. Having said that, shit happens, and 11 is a good age to realise it and not whine. If it were one of my children, I would have accepted that they had been unfairly treated but then told them to do the punishment anyway but inwardly know what was fair.

KeemaNaanAndCurryon · 01/11/2013 16:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by Mumsnet for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Replies may also be deleted.

VerySmallSqueak · 01/11/2013 16:15

I am discussing this particular situation as described by the op.

If my child was punished and deserved the punishment I would be right behind the school.

But in the op's situation she wanted a discussion about the situation. That's not teaching the kid to whine.

noblegiraffe · 01/11/2013 16:14

larry the telling off and crying was done in private. Well, outside the classroom at least. And no, they weren't properly upset, I'm not talking sobbing. Crocodile tears only.

Interestingly, I remember a discussion with another teacher about a kid crying being told off. The same kid being a pain in the arse across the school.

larrygrylls · 01/11/2013 16:13

Clearly turning on the tears is a skill more prevalent than I expected! I still could not continue to bawl out a child who was crying. I would still punish them but I would try to calm them first. But that is just me.

Ilovegeorgeclooney · 01/11/2013 16:12

Similar issue today. It is half term and our Year 11's have English GCSE exam on Tuesday. For the whole of the past half term I have been running revision sessions on Tuesday/Thursday 3.15-4.30pm. I generally have at least 20 pupils attending. Over the same period of time I have had 18 e-mails( all replied to) and over 20 phone calls from a mother re. her son and how such a quiet, sensitive and quiet boy is struggling. Each week she assures me he will attend, each week he fails to but is happily playing table-tennis with his friends on the table two floors down, each week I phone her to tell her and she makes excuses for him. Initially I would send a pupil, who then misses part of the session they have turned up to, to remind this child. However he would respond with a negative and I no longer do this.

Today, in half-term, I was running a session from 9-12, over 35 pupils turned up. Again this pupil was playing table-tennis. At 9.45 he and his friend turned up, at 10.30 we had a comfort break and he did not return at 10.45. We all worked until just after 12 when we left. As I left the school at 12.30pm his mother stopped me and asked why we were so late finishing. I reported the above and she started shouting at me about her son's sensitivity and how it must be because other pupils were there and why hadn't I personally gone down to collect him/ phoned her.

As a mother I do adore my son but........

TartyMcTart · 01/11/2013 16:12

OP, I think you have completely overreacted BUT I know how it feels when you're sat at home worrying about your kids.

I posted on here once when I was panicking about something that had happened to DS1 at school. Everyone who replied laughed, joked and told me how ridiculous I was being (in a nice way!) and it actually made me feel better knowing I was being completely daft and over the top.

Hope the same goes for you too.

riskit4abiskit · 01/11/2013 16:12

It's parents like you who make teaching hellish.its almost like a drip drip drip of being made to feel weary of the profession;undermined by parents, wasting time dealing with the incident when there are lessons to plan and books to mark, worry about if senior management will take the parents side, kid plays up more on future due to parental attitude, no time to follow up sen concerns etc etc.

I am sure you are lovely op and you sound like a very caring parent but seriously the teacher will be eating out on this story for months.

shellyf · 01/11/2013 16:11

larrygrills

It would surprise you how many children can turn on tears.
For the record I am not an evil punishment giving teacher:-).I work with fantastic primary (4-11) pupils and rarely have to reprimand any of them.
I am also a mum to two young adults who always blamed teachers when they were in trouble at HS.After discussion they generally admitted that perhaps the teacher/s had a point.
Bowing out now as I usually just lurk.
Hope the deputy never finds out he was labelled as unintelligent by OP.

DollyTwat · 01/11/2013 16:11

Both my dc can cry at will. Ages 8 and 11
I can tell its fake, but I'm their mum.

teaand5biscuits · 01/11/2013 16:10

OP a similar thing happened to me when I was your DSs age and I felt really embarrassed, it was the first punishment I ever had in school.
However I didn't do it again and I just used it as a 'guess what mad miss X did' story. Also it didn't have any lasting impact on me, I felt silly at the time but no-one really cared about it in reality and I doubt any of my peers remembered it after a few months.

I think the punishment was a bit extreme but I would of just told your DS that it is one of those things, he knows not to do it again and just made it a funny story to tell his peers if he was still upset about it.

Had my mum gone in the way you have I would of hated her for it because I was shy and quiet and what you did would mean that the head and all the other teachers would know who I was, who my mum was and I would of been paranoid that they would treat me differently or think that I was bad.

My advice to you now would be to calm down and go in on Monday looking mostly at the way your complaint was dealt with and just getting assurances that your DS is okay in school.

noblegiraffe · 01/11/2013 16:10

very, teaching a child to stand up for what's right and wrong is a valuable lesson.

Teaching them to whine and get mum on the case when they get pulled up for misbehaving at school is not a good lesson.

And lots of kids actually go that route. I've had a mum put in a complaint that I was picking on her kid for telling him to do some work instead of staring out of the window. He was in Y11 and a couple of months before his maths GCSE. Hmm

VerySmallSqueak · 01/11/2013 16:09

shellyf they shouldn't automatically ask a parents permission for punishment.

But if a parent asks specifically to discuss a particular punishment over a specific incident then that is quite quite different.

larrygrylls · 01/11/2013 16:09

Noble,

"If a kid is crying simply because they are being told off, then are you really saying I should go soft on them or stop telling them to behave themselves?"

I think that if a child starts really crying (real tears, properly upset), they deserve a sympathetic hearing in private. Of course, at that point, you will continue to explain to them what they have done wrong and that they need to do their detention etc, but at least you have shown them a human face and given them a fair hearing.

Am I wrong to think that?

Minnieisthedevilmouse · 01/11/2013 16:08

Bloody hell. I wonder how you will react when an actual incidence occurs.... This seems trivial beyond belief.

MrsTerryPratchett · 01/11/2013 16:06

larrygrylls I could cry on demand. We are in our 40s and my cousin still talks about it with awe. Very useful skill.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.