Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think this is too much homework for a three year old

119 replies

Waggamamma · 23/10/2013 21:58

I've never posted in aibu before so getting ready to be told I might be unreasonable.

My ds just turned three and was moved into the preschool room at his private nursery which he attends two afternoons a week while I work.

Since moving up I feel they are setting too much 'homework.' In the last three weeks we've been asked to:

  • Bring in an 'animal' (soft toy) for show and tell and learn 5 facts about that animal.
  • Make a model that represents space and talk about it
  • Carve a pumpkin for the halloween competition (and do a costume for the party). At three years old seriously?
  • Learn two pages a4 of songs for the nativity in early dec.

Aibu in thinking this is a bit much for a preschooler who attends nursery ten hours per week? Or am I being a lazy parent? we do our own crafts/baking at home plus swimming lessons and trips out to see friends etc. It's hard to find the time for the nursery stuff too. We're struggling to fit it all in.

I was really happy with the toddler room the change to preschool seems the expect a lot overnight - learning the alphabet etc. He's moving to the preschool attached to our catchment school in January anyway so we can make use of the funded hours.

OP posts:
sturdyoak · 24/10/2013 19:20

The problem is that some parents really don't know how to play with these children or don't know where to start with making playdough or something. So you give them the ingredients to make playdough and a recipe, or lend them a story sack, or give them a treasure basket to explore with their child, or give them a craft project to finish off at home. Hopefully the parents will then realise they can do it, its easy and fun, and things start to improve for children who do not currently benefit from a good home learning environment

Wow that is so clever. I would never have thought of actually playing with my child. Playdough? Reading them stories and giving them actual things to play with. I am so thankful this government has thoughtfully told nurseries to advise on this. There was me letting them sit in a playpen all day, with only a Greggs for company and CBeebies!

How did our parents ever manage without all this helpful advise?

FunkyBoldRibena · 24/10/2013 19:07

Actually I'd ask the head/of the nursery/preschool what sort of knife should you buy your 3 year old for the pumpkin carving that they have asked you to do; as you went into the supermarket with them to buy a knife and they wouldn't let you so you need some guidance as to knife selection for them.

sturdyoak · 24/10/2013 18:25

autumnwinds Nanny State .

Can your get 'Free Nurseries / Pre-Schools' like Free Schools? They don't have to teach the NC do they?

pigletmania · 24/10/2013 18:17

Or telling that a 3 year old needs to learn 5 facts

hettienne · 24/10/2013 18:07

Giving recipes or lending toys/books is very different from sending home a craft project.

autumnwinds · 24/10/2013 18:01

Coming at this from a childminder's perspective.

All the training sessions I've recently been on are really pushing early years childcare staff to 'support the home learning environment', essentially by sending home 'homework' for babies age 0+.

The problem is that some parents really don't know how to play with these children or don't know where to start with making playdough or something. So you give them the ingredients to make playdough and a recipe, or lend them a story sack, or give them a treasure basket to explore with their child, or give them a craft project to finish off at home. Hopefully the parents will then realise they can do it, its easy and fun, and things start to improve for children who do not currently benefit from a good home learning environment.

I'm still very uncertain whether I agree that this is the best way to go about it, and it definitely sounds like the OP's nursery has gone OTT about it. But the push is coming from the government for us to do this...

merrymouse · 24/10/2013 14:58

morethan, I don't think parents don't want to do things with their children. They want to do their own thing with their children - carve a pumpkin at home for their child to enjoy at home, give their child free range with their junk modelling, read books about things that they find interesting.

All these activities strike me as somebody who has never carved a pumpkin, or perhaps thought about appropriate activities for a 3 year old, getting parents to do a whole load of stuff to fill time at school. Why would you want a 3 year old to memorise 5 things about an animal?

sue52 · 24/10/2013 11:51

Any homework is too much homework for a 3 year old.

BionicEmu · 24/10/2013 11:39

DS has just turned 3 and has just moved up into his private day nursery's pre-school room too. He goes 2 full days a week. He's been there 2 weeks and they've not mentioned any form of homework yet, fingers crossed that continues!

teacherlikesapples · 24/10/2013 11:38

I would be making a complaint about this & asking how it fits within the EYFS or anything related to any research of best practice/child development/early childhood education.

Bringing in the toy animal is ok- but having to memorise facts has SO many developmental issues. What about children with EAL/Speech & language or Confidence issues? It is essentially setting them up to fail.

Making a model about space. Ok. Maybe. It is open ended & broad enough to include most children. It just depends on where this interest/project came from- is it driven by the interests of all the children involved? How long is the timeframe for this?

Carving a pumpkin?!? I don't know of a single 3 year old that could carve a pumpkin independently. So this is again- an unreasonable expectation. Especially since it is for a 'competition'. So you are setting some children up to fail. Again.

The song list- perhaps I can understand, if it is framed in a way of "these are the songs we are learning for our end of year concert. You may want to practice these at home."

Anyway. My general feeling about it is that it feels unreasonable and done in a way that goes against good practice/EYFS.

hettienne · 24/10/2013 10:49

Ridiculous. Don't do it.

DS is 3 and goes to an Outstanding state nursery school - so far this term his/our "homework" has been a request from the school to talk to your child about what they do at nursery to help develop their memory and recall. That's it. No craft projects, no memorising anything, no buying anything to take in.

vladthedisorganised · 24/10/2013 10:43

!!???!!!

Blimey! DD is 3.5 and in the preschool room at her nursery as well. They have Show and Tell once a week, where originally they were encouraged to bring in something starting with a particular letter, but lately can be pretty much anything. (DD brought in a stick, a plastic flower and a stamp yesterday, and apparently waffled on about each for ages).

I wonder if the 5 facts are basically asking them to say 5 things, whatever that might be?
So, thinking of DD's approach:

  1. This is a cat.
  2. He has whiskers
  3. He has a long tail
  4. His name is Spot
  5. He isn't a dog, he's a cat. Though there is a dog in the book at home called Spot and Mummy always says do we have to read that again, and she tried to take it to the charity shop but I think she made a mistake so I took it out of the bag and...

Making the model and carving the pumpkin is surely homework for the parents? Why they'd ask you to do this is beyond me. The instruction 'make a model representing space' seems really vague too - they want a full solar system, galaxy, black hole..?

Learning songs I would think would be done within the preschool - as in 'here are the songs we're learning and the children may want to practice at home' - but not push the onus on to the parents.

The only 'homework' I'd expect really might be to reinforce anything they're doing already. DD was asked to look at plants and trees over a weekend and learn the names of some of them, which seemed fair enough to me.

soverylucky · 24/10/2013 09:58

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

sturdyoak · 24/10/2013 09:57

morethanpotatoprints Maybe the parents don't need to be told how to spend their time with their very young DC. Maybe they have (better) plans of their own. Maybe the pre-school should support the parents in this and respect them in the sense that they can think of valuable things to do with their own child themselves.

morethanpotatoprints · 24/10/2013 09:41

I can't understand the problem here and find it very sad that so many parents don't want to do things with their children. It isn't homework ffs and of course suitable for 3 year olds.
If the child only attends for part of the week it is good that a parent can do these things and take them in. Maybe the pumpkin and space model are being done at pre school by those attending full time and on a day when the OPs dc doesn't attend.
It is only the child that will be left out if parents don't support in this way.

merrymouse · 24/10/2013 07:08

This is homework for you, not your child, which is nuts because you are paying them so that you have more free time.

It's also age inappropriate and, given that your child only attends 2 afternoons a week, implies that a lot of the activities are dependent on input of parents - songs learnt at home, 'talks' prepared at home. All very odd.

SatinSandals · 24/10/2013 06:47

One of mine didn't speak at 3 yrs! My eldest didn't join in songs at 3 years.
'A model that represents space' isn't something a 3 yr old would understand so it is parent led and quite difficult for an adult, I am not sure what I would choose.
'Carve a pumpkin' means homework for mum or dad. You can hardly hand the knife and pumpkin to a 3 yr old and let them get on with it!
The costume needs a letter to parents asking them to send in costume.
I can see that competetive parents love it! I can't see much value for the child.

KeatsiePie · 24/10/2013 04:38

Ffs, any homework is too much homework for a three-year-old! I mean yeah I get that some of it is more "fun" projects than actual homework but none of it sounds like fun to me after a day's work.

Good luck with the facts about space, that should go especially well.

GColdtimer · 24/10/2013 00:03

Ffs. Ridiculous. Dd1 has only just started getting proper homework and she is year 3.

Bettercallsaul1 · 24/10/2013 00:01

This really is nuts. Children face demands and tests far too early as it is - to try to introduce homework for three-year-olds is a step too far and should be very firmly resisted.

Suttonmum1 · 24/10/2013 00:00

Very surprised they are celebrating Halloween. Will upset some families. Our school steers clear of making a fuss about it.

Ignore it all. It is homework for you not your child.

AlwaysChasingRainbows · 23/10/2013 23:56

That does sound rather a lot for a just turned 3yo .
My Dn attends a prep nursery for 15 hours a week & she gets 'homework' which is a jotter with her name wrote in that she is encouraged to trace over, she is also just turned 3 .
My Ds 4.11 gets homework at his prep school which I think is brilliant as I get to work with him to help with his letters / numbers etc & he enjoys it , now he is in reception he has two homework books that he has different things to do in & I find it really helps him & seeing the stickers/stars he gets for doing it from his teacher makes him feel grown up .

Their is no harm in it , only takes half n hour .

BackforGood · 23/10/2013 23:55

The words "three-year-old" and "homework" don't belong on the same sentence!

This ^

I think I would also be suggesting the go back and read the EYFS again, and study a few developmental profiles. the very idea of a 3 yr old being able to make a model and then talk about it, is just ridiculous. Have they not grasped the concepts of the children leading the activities ?

pigletmania · 23/10/2013 23:46

If they are under pressure from parents, it should be optional then, so those who don't want todo it, don't have to

Tanith · 23/10/2013 23:38

I know the village preschool staff very well (been picking up and dropping off children for 12 years).

They say they are coming under increasing pressure from parents to set homework and teach more structured lessons. So far they've resisted.