Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think this is too much homework for a three year old

119 replies

Waggamamma · 23/10/2013 21:58

I've never posted in aibu before so getting ready to be told I might be unreasonable.

My ds just turned three and was moved into the preschool room at his private nursery which he attends two afternoons a week while I work.

Since moving up I feel they are setting too much 'homework.' In the last three weeks we've been asked to:

  • Bring in an 'animal' (soft toy) for show and tell and learn 5 facts about that animal.
  • Make a model that represents space and talk about it
  • Carve a pumpkin for the halloween competition (and do a costume for the party). At three years old seriously?
  • Learn two pages a4 of songs for the nativity in early dec.

Aibu in thinking this is a bit much for a preschooler who attends nursery ten hours per week? Or am I being a lazy parent? we do our own crafts/baking at home plus swimming lessons and trips out to see friends etc. It's hard to find the time for the nursery stuff too. We're struggling to fit it all in.

I was really happy with the toddler room the change to preschool seems the expect a lot overnight - learning the alphabet etc. He's moving to the preschool attached to our catchment school in January anyway so we can make use of the funded hours.

OP posts:
sturdyoak · 25/10/2013 10:41

Added to this the children with parents who don't or can't support will feel terribly left out by comparison.

sturdyoak · 25/10/2013 10:39

Considering Asking is not unreasonable. Homework at 3 yrs old is. A little booklet of suggested activities is more than sufficient.

And since when is carving a Pumpkin an activity that a 3yr old can do? The parent undoubtedly will do most of this.

ConsideringTheFuture · 25/10/2013 10:34

The full curriculum IS covered in school though. Without fail, in every Primary Year/school I've ever known.

Teachers ask parents to support learning. To practice at home. Is that really so unreasonable?

sturdyoak · 25/10/2013 10:31

ConsideringThatFuture If you really want to lessen social inequality then cover all the curriculum in school / pre-school. The children who have parents who can't or won't support homework will not be in so much in a position of educational disadvantage then.

ConsideringTheFuture · 25/10/2013 10:18

Little robots - I think you've missed my point.

For parents that do interact with their children anyway, the type of homework a 3 year old gets will usually be the same sort of stuff they do. So not much point in moaning about in on principle.

For those that don't bother with much - the 'homework' may be the only motivation they have to do something with the poor kid.

For those that really don't give a shit, nothing will be done regardless of any homework.

I don't see why it's a big deal. My 3 year old is really 'into' shapes ATM. I have numerous note pads and pieces of paper scattered around where he's spent time drawing and colouring in shapes anyway. Drawing a few more on a piece of paper sent by school is no different.

LittleRobots · 25/10/2013 10:10

I do tons and tons of things with my children. That's a bit of a false argument. Why on earth would a child need to be sent home with a worksheet with circles on when there's plenty of real circles you can talk about in the home.

As a teacher I really don't equate worksheets with teaching or learning at such a young age. Its busywork and generally not really advised! There's plenty of playbased activities that provide a lot of scope for learning.

I don't understand why you would think that parents need homework in order to interact with their children. What an odd thought. I'm glad my interactions with my children aren't restricted or limited by homework sent home. I'd honestly look at other pre schools or nursery as I wouldn't agree with their ethos.

ConsideringTheFuture · 25/10/2013 10:04

I struggle to understand some people's horror with 'homework' for young children.

Ds2 (3) spends 15 minutes at the weekend on his school homework. If I didn't TELL him it was 'homework' he wouldn't even realise we were doing anything different!

Honestly, what has happened to people interacting with their young children? Do you (general) not play with and draw/colour with your 3 year olds anyway? Do you not read with them, practice counting or shapes or sing songs? For the most part, things like this is what 3 year olds homework is.

Just because school is there, that doesn't mean you have to rely on them to teach your child everything

KitZacJak · 25/10/2013 10:01

At that age it is basically homework for parents (as if you haven't got enough to do!).

LittleRobots · 25/10/2013 09:55

Gosh how scary. Makes me so pleased looking back that our pre school focused on learning through play! I even chose a school that was very play based for reception (and yes, she's still managing to read basic phonics, count, simple add and take away etc all without homework or formal learning!)

onlyfortonight · 25/10/2013 09:30

...frankly I'd get the 3 yr old to make a Powerpoint presentation for the cuddly animal, make a working replica of the solar system...(remember that Pluto isn't a planet, just a massive meteorite). Carve a selection of winter veg for the 'complete' halloween experience and write a new carol for the nativity play (my 3 yr old agrees with me that old carols are just too retro).

...or I'd ignore all their competitive mother homework ideas.

Speak to the nursery manager...they have really overstepped the mark!

ConsideringTheFuture · 25/10/2013 09:20

I wouldn't even call that homework tbh.

Learning a song, show and tell - both regular things my 3 and 5 year olds are asked to do. Crafty 'suggestions' also come home regularly and requests with ds2 to focus at home on a certain letter (jolly phonics).

Ds2 gets 2 sheets of homework on a Friday to complete. Things like 'copy these shapes', try to draw this letter, choose the odd ones out. It takes 15 minutes ish and he loves it.

sturdyoak · 25/10/2013 09:09

Tanith Yes, about as arrogant and condescending as assuming all parents do not know how to spend their time with their children in a meaningful way. Added to this, private nurseries and pre-schools do provide a service to the parents, as they are paying them.

Tanith · 24/10/2013 23:33

"Hired help"?! What an arrogant and condescending way to refer to a professional entrusted with the care of your child Hmm

breatheslowly · 24/10/2013 23:01

Making playdough at home? No thanks, that is part of what I send DD to nursery for. Same goes for most messy activities. Painting at home generally ends in tears because I won't let DD pour out the whole bottles of paint, then she slips over in a slick of paint on the floor and I have to get a crying child into the bath without getting paint on the carpet. I have little patience for playing with her on the floor, we might do a few jigsaw puzzles or play a game, but I have no desire for this to be imposed on me by the very nursery I pay to do it for me. Don't worry, DD has a good home learning environment (as well as nursery 5 days a week), it might not be the learning environment that an early years practitioner would design, but it seems to work for her.

Lilacroses · 24/10/2013 22:02

Sorry, haven't rtft but YANBU. A 3 year old having homework is ridiculous. What on earth are they trying to prove? Ok, send home a little letter telling everyone what is being planned for the term/week so that parents can talk about it with their child, even possibly a cd of songs to sing along to for FUN but that would be more than enough! This would completely turn me off a nursery.

LifeHuh · 24/10/2013 21:53

Agree,midlands lurker - my DCs are older now but were in childcare just as childminders started to be assessed via Ofsted.
My Dcs were with their childminders for relatively short periods as I worked part time,and I didn't care what they did as long as the DCs were safe and happy.
We did plenty at home.
And DS was completely incomprehensible except to his family at 3 (and for some time after),so the talking about space would have been interesting...

sturdyoak · 24/10/2013 21:39

Maryann it's the generalised blanket approach that is bad. Yes some parents may need extra support. However giving extra homework to 3 year olds will not solve this problem. Toy libraries, parent and child groups, library sessions with free book and toy give always would be much more popular and successful, IMO.

midlandslurker · 24/10/2013 21:08

autumnwinds - I appreciate that it isn't necessarily your point of view,but I wish EYF /Ofsted could actually grasp the fact that parents are paying for a childcare service and not lessons on how to play with their kids and aside from safeguarding issues its got absolutely nothing to do with the"hired help"how parents choose to spend their free time with their DC's.

So bloody what if they spend a day off watching Mr tumble on a loop whilst stuffing a greggs sausage roll down their gob !

I have a lovely child minder and I actually put it in writing (for Ofsted) that I didn't want any assessments/observations done whilst in her care.

As a working parent,my concern was for my DS to be happy and safe in her care, but I certainly would not be parting with my hard earned cash to be set "homework".

3bunnies · 24/10/2013 21:00

And I thought school was bad asking 6yr olds to build medieval villages! Ds does bring home reading books from nursery but that is only because he wants to amd we don't have enough variety at home. He has a home learning book which he can put things in that he does - e.g. a family trip and then tell the other children about but that is it. At his previous one he could bring a picture/collage in on their topic to go on the wall I he never bothered to do one. It isn't compulsory so I would just choose what you want to do. I probably would help with the Christmas lines, so he feels confident on stage, if he is going to the show, that is the sort of thing he might remember, other things I would quietly forget.

Amy106 · 24/10/2013 20:47

OP....power ranger pumpkin?! Grin. Your little one sounds delightful!

junkfoodaddict · 24/10/2013 20:35

I would be demanding to know why he hasn't been given his 8 times tables yet and when he will be given his lime level book! [confued]

Maryann1975 · 24/10/2013 20:30

Sturdyoak, maybe your children are growing up with good parents, but there are thousands of children growing up in this country whose parents do not know the basics of parenting and what to do with a child. These children are not played with at home and generally their days are taken up with cbeebies and a Greggs. You probably wouldn't have to look to far to find parents who don't know how to interact with their children, they exist in every town and cross all social groups. Anything that settings and the government can do for these children has to be a bonus and if that means sending home ideas about what to talk about with your child so be it. Some parents do want to change and do better for their children.

I'm not sure the nursery is expecting a full presentation for the show and tell. Your monkey facts sound fine, probably just what the nursery were hoping for. Learning the song words. I'm sure they are practising the songs at nursery, but I would have appreciated the words to ds nativity songs to help him when he got stuck while singing at home, so sending home the words would have helped me. The model, ask if its compulsory if you are bothered, if not don't do it, I'm sure your child won't miss out, but children get a lot of self confidence from showing things they are proud of.

Talk to your nursery and tell them your concerns, I'm not a believer in homework for primary school children, but I think this is just their attempts at linking home and nursery learning together and trying to work in partnership with parents. They may just have gone a bit OTT and not explained it properly.

autumnwinds · 24/10/2013 20:10

sturdyoak I agree it is incredibly condescending to 99.9% of parents. I'm not presenting it as my point of view or ideas - this is what we got told to do on training! We were given the example of a family support worker going into a family's home, where the social worker had identified they needed more support, with a bag of toys and sitting down on the floor and playing with the child and the toys. The parents had never ever done this and were at first dismissive and then completely shocked and amazed at how their 'out-of-control so-and-so' actually could sit still for more than 10 seconds and do something constructive rather than run around causing mayhem.

wagamamma I didn't want to suggest that you weren't doing these things, far from it! I just wanted to say that this idea of sending kids home with stuff to do from a very young age is being pushed across the early years sector at the moment, and maybe your nursery has just got a bit too keen for it!

I personally think that where there are such serious issues in parenting as this, it should probably remain for social workers to call in more one-one-one support rather than for childminders and nurseries to attempt to 'educate' all parents.

Waggamamma · 24/10/2013 19:58

thanks for all your replies. seems I'm not being unreasonable in thinking it's too much.

For the posters who mentioned parents not playing with their children, I can't comment for others but I do lots with my ds: play trains/cars, various crafts, playdoh, baking, swimming, visit friends with children, day trips and yes he gets to watch cbeebies too Shock .
I think it's just that I like to choose what to do not be told by the nursery. This is a private nursery who we pay almost as much our mortgage each month to provide childcare, not to tell me how to parent.

The show and tell we learned very simple facts 'my monkey us brown, he eats bananas, he lives in the jungle, my grandma bought him for me' so nothing elaborate but it seemed an odd task for the age group.

I've asked him what he wants carved on the pumpkin, the reply was 'a power ranger'...Hmm

he's only there until January otherwise I would be considering if this is the right nursery for him.

OP posts:
midlandslurker · 24/10/2013 19:23

From the original post I understand that this is a private daycare service for which you are paying ?

I pay for childcare for the sole reason of making sure my DS is looked after whilst I'm working and I'd personally be making it quite clear that I'll not be dictated to in regard to how I spend my free time him.

Some parents may appreciate their ideas for activities to do on days off - personally I'd be telling them "thanks,but no thanks".