Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To see nothing wrong with these workplace smoking rules

82 replies

doingthesplitz · 05/09/2013 11:42

Our HR Department has introduced some new rules re smoking breaks eg No smoking break within one hour of clocking in (we are on flexi) or for half an hour before clocking out; one morning smoke break must be taken as part of your normal coffee break; smoking breaks should not last more than five minutes and should be kept to an absolute minimum.

Most of us can see where HR are coming from. There were a few staff members who were constantly disappearing for a smoke; would clock in when they arrived in work and immediately go outside for a cigarette; stand outside smoking for twenty minutes in the evening and then come in, clock out and go home; and would take a full coffee break and then immediatly go on a smoking break.

However, some of the smokers are moaning and giving out and saying 'God, next thing we'll start getting told how many times we can go to the loo' etc.
AIBU to think they should just shut up about it. At least now they might be around occasionally to answer their own phones.

OP posts:
Wallison · 06/09/2013 00:23

Anyway, I think the rules sound more than reasonable compared to a lot of firms - surely in most places you just wouldn't be allowed smoking breaks at all? Not that I think that's right, but it seems to be they way things are going.

StarlightMcKenzie · 06/09/2013 00:20

If you were allowed to smoke at your desk, there would be no need to stop working.

Some of the employees became addicted long before the rules stating that you weren't allowed to work and smoke at the same time.

And for some of you judgy types, smoking isn't a choice for most people now, it is an addiction. Addiction is not the same thing as choice.

usualsuspect · 06/09/2013 00:19

I go out for a fag in my lunch break.

that's it.

So not every smoker is a whining addict.

Wallison · 06/09/2013 00:16

I'd say you're not daft but restaurants and train companies banning them are being completely ott. It's just the same as steam off a cup of tea or coffee.

LimitedEditionLady · 06/09/2013 00:14

I have an electronic cig and feel naughty smoking it inside....i push my chair right back away from people even though its doing them no harm in the slightest.ha.I dont think id use it on a train or in a restaurant more because I dont want to do it in front of impressionable people.am i daft?

Wallison · 06/09/2013 00:11

I am imagining specialsubject pounding the keyboard with impotent fists of fury. Everyone wants to put the boot into smokers these days.

Even people who smoke electronic cigs are being targeted; was on a train recently and an announcement came on that electronic cigarettes were not allowed on the train. Have also heard of them being banned in some restaurants. It's water vapour, ffs! Proof if proof were needed that a lot of this anti-smoking stuff is not about fear of catching cancer from someone who has smoked a fag nowhere near you 20 mins before but actually about controlling people's behaviour.

LimitedEditionLady · 06/09/2013 00:08

I smoke and requesting an extra break to smoke at work would be laughed at.If you have an addiction thats your addiction,do it in your own time!!We can only smoke in our own break time and I find I rarely smoke even in them because I am so busy I just wana have a brew and sit down.

Alisvolatpropiis · 06/09/2013 00:00

I smoke.

Don't have/take smoking breaks. I smoke before,at lunch and after. I don't combust with the need for nicotine.

utreas · 05/09/2013 23:57

YANBU I would ban cigarette bans totally,if you want to spend your lunch break smoking then fair enough but otherwise do it before and after work not during.

missingmumxox · 05/09/2013 23:53

as a Smoker and one who nips out, but still I don't think these rules are unreasonable, It is aways remarked that Oh are you back already? I smoke and go only about 1/2 a fag and I do it when I am get stuck...bad habit, my job is problem solving and sometime I just get stuck, I gave up for 7 years and then I used to walk round the block which took longer, outcome the same gave me space to think.

I have worked for 3 bosses who preferred smokers as they "would bloody well organise their work so they can get off" they where all non smokers

I too have found this smokers are aware when they go off they need to be organised, non smokers don't feel bad about going for the weigh in, chat in the post rom, 15 mins in the coffee room, as above, look at bbc news on line, google, Mumsnet :), book a holiday, text, phone family and friends.

just because you are physically at your desk doesn't mean you work more again like another poster I had a boss who used to clock his time in at work from the moment he parked in the carpark and would then read his paper? I would seehim because I would be there but droppping my children off at the nursery I would get in 20 minutes later and he claimed 1/2 every day!!

ShadowSummer · 05/09/2013 21:58

The rules in the OP's workplace sound reasonable to me. Although I am a non-smoker anyway.

My workplace implemented similar rules a few years back because a number of heavy smokers were taking the piss with smoking breaks. So they said that smokers were only allowed one 5 min cigarette break in the morning and one in the afternoon. Plus as many as they could fit into their lunch break.

PresidentServalan · 05/09/2013 21:48

I work an average of 11 hours a day (get paid for 7 of those!) - I have the type of job where it's busy when it's busy iyswim - I do sneak out for the occasional fag break (I timed it once, it is less than five minutes from leaving my desk to getting back to it. We are supposed to only smoke during lunchtimes as we have no other set breaks. I have no issue in popping outside for a few mins twice a day when my firm gets an average of an extra 2-3 days a week from me for free!

shrinkingnora · 05/09/2013 16:10

I've worked in a school where staff had to turns blind eye to a kid who snuck out to smoke at break time because he was unteachably foul if he hadn't had any nicotine.

spongebob13 · 05/09/2013 16:06

thing is smokers are an easy target as they are seen NOT at their desk. however where I work those that smoke have a quick smoke ON their breaks as they are conscious of it and the whispers while the non smokers are physically at their desks but sipping coffee and internet browsing for half an hour. its not black and white.

but OP what you posted sounds very very reasonable.

LeoandBoosmum · 05/09/2013 15:57

The smokers' argument is ridiculous... Going for a smoke break is not fundamental, having a wee is! Also, if a person needs the loo frequently then they can get a doctor's note to that end, whereas a smoker will be hard-pressed to find a doctor to give them a doctor's note for smoke breaks. It never ceases to amaze me how smokers get pissed off about these things. They are there to work. Why should non-smokers stay at their desks while colleagues sod off every half an hour for their nicotine fix. I don't smoke, never have, can you tell?! Grin

KellyElly · 05/09/2013 15:35

7 minutes to smoke a cig Shock You were a very slow smoker Grin

Dahlen · 05/09/2013 14:55

limitedperiodonly made a very post I think. None of us are perfect and we all work at different rates. I would much prefer an employee to smoke and work hard around those breaks than employ someone who coasted all day but didn't take any smoking breaks at all.

However, I have no problem with banning smoking on-site completely. A lunch break will ordinarily be long enough for someone to go off-site to smoke, and anyone who can't go that long without one really ought to consider seeking help for an addiction that has reached unmanageable levels.

luxemburgerli · 05/09/2013 14:49

The ones moaning about it are probably the ones who are taking the piss, and leading to the rule in the first place.

I doubt all the smokers feel like that.

zzzzz · 05/09/2013 14:48

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

limitedperiodonly · 05/09/2013 14:47

Stink-breaks and reekers?

I don't smoke. Neither do I feel that hostile towards smokers.

specialsubject · 05/09/2013 14:38

company either bans stink-breaks altogether (you take drugs in your own time) or provides widely separated outdoor shelters, one smoking and one no-smoking. The smoking one should be as far as possible from the building.

all very well to let the non-smokers go out too, but if the building is surrounded by the reekers it is most unpleasant.

surprised this hasn't all gone the way of official coffee breaks.

NiceTabard · 05/09/2013 14:26

Depends on the building. If it takes a couple of mins to get out and round to the smoking area them you're effectively banning it.

Am amazed at all the official coffee breaks! I have only had one job which had a breaks except lunch and that was15 years ago! If a company has lunch plus breaks morning and afternoon them that'sgenerous and enough to smoke IMO.

twistedtoffee · 05/09/2013 14:16

I don't see their issue. They are being asked, where possible, to smoke in their own time and to keep smoking breaks during working hours as short as possible. It sounds as if they've been getting away with murder for ages and have now lost all perspective.

KellyElly · 05/09/2013 14:04

I also think excessive coffee breaks should be banned Grin. The person who takes the most breaks at my work is not even a smoker, possibly a caffeine addict though. He has a tea/coffee break at least every hour for about 10 minutes and turns the TV on in the staff canteen and watches it while he drinks his coffee!!

ShabbyButNotChic · 05/09/2013 13:39

Yanbu and im a smoker. I work in a school so the whole site is non smoking, if you want a smoke you have a wander down the road. Obviously this can only be done at break/lunch time. I dont see why smokers should get extra, but i would also point out that some people are just timewasters, whether they smoke or not. There used to be a teacher where i work who was famous for taking 15mins to make a coffee, leaving her nta to sort the class. Some people just take the piss.

My dad works for a large company, and goes for smoke breaks whenever he likes, but he is also an hour early every day (beat the traffic) and is fantastic at his job. So the big bosses dont care if he pops out for the odd 10mins. He has also been known to do lots of networking in the smoking shelter, at one point he even held a meeting there as all of the bosses smoke! Says it was great...like the old days :)

Swipe left for the next trending thread